Meta tags:
description= Nigel Calder takes the pulse of science, as the author of Magic Universe and Einstein s Universe. He checks predictions of the past half-century, to see how they worked out. And his hand is on the brow of frenzied climatology, as a co-author of The Chilling Stars: A Cosmic View of Climate Change.;
Headings (most frequently used words):
of, the, buy, calder, ve, memorial, meeting, posts, universe, updates, sung, this, song, but, ll, sing, it, again, further, details, advance, notice, obituaries, and, other, notices, newspaper, announcements, nigel, 1931, 2014, gotta, be, driftin, along, stellar, revision, story, life, quantum, computing, forges, ahead, climate, physics, 101, yet, another, trick, cosmic, rays, categories, search, blog, recent, top, currently, rss, links, to, https, calderup, wordpress, com, chilling, stars, magic, einstein, archive, email, subscription, visitors, since, 10, may,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (478), and (172), that (65), for (55), with (51), svensmark (51), cosmic (39), was (37), life (35), #climate (33), from (32), this (31), rays (30), are (29), years (28), cloud (25), what (24), you (24), 2014 (24), #quantum (22), calder (21), new (21), nigel (21), paper (21), not (20), but (20), about (19), sulphuric (19), acid (19), all (19), comments (18), have (18), 2012 (18), million (17), news (17), they (17), would (17), will (17), calderup (16), change (16), supernova (16), time (16), supernovae (16), com (15), may (15), long (15), henrik (15), has (15), there (15), like (14), society (14), when (14), other (13), sun (13), stars (13), space (13), experiment (13), physics (13), universe (13), science (12), how (12), earth (12), computing (12), story (12), meeting (12), aerosols (12), over (12), which (12), sea (12), posted (11), clusters (11), can (11), more (11), too (11), way (11), our (11), wordpress (10), now (10), blog (10), royal (10), permalink (10), very (10), dioxide (10), most (10), one (10), times (10), level (10), many (10), past (10), rate (10), permian (10), comets (9), clouds (9), carbon (9), out (9), memorial (9), nature (9), university (9), theory (9), growth (9), http (9), solar (9), were (9), their (9), its (9), majorana (9), comment (8), ago (8), grow (8), better (8), than (8), some (8), cern (8), hypothesis (8), magic (8), copenhagen (8), enghoff (8), evidence (8), see (8), experimental (8), available (8), end (8), had (8), these (8), into (8), called (8), figure (8), because (8), his (8), galaxy (8), high (8), ibm (8), astronomical (8), event (8), productivity (8), lizzie (8), email (7), since (7), warming (7), stellar (7), results (7), another (7), 1931 (7), uncategorized (7), pedersen (7), condensation (7), nuclei (7), www (7), ion (7), going (7), between (7), number (7), gases (7), before (7), possible (7), here (7), first (7), few (7), during (7), biodiversity (7), take (7), updates (6), why (6), did (6), black (6), molecules (6), who (6), again (6), ray (6), without (6), book (6), chilling (6), https (6), tagged (6), technical (6), pepke (6), institute (6), small (6), much (6), present (6), electrons (6), where (6), water (6), both (6), known (6), shows (6), together (6), year (6), two (6), global (6), world (6), bits (6), atoms (6), far (6), period (6), marine (6), rates (6), june (6), church (6), posts (5), buy (5), matter (5), star (5), still (5), computer (5), big (5), whole (5), 2010 (5), nucleation (5), say (5), action (5), further (5), confirmed (5), trick (5), notices (5), details (5), sulphur (5), physical (5), danish (5), national (5), 2011 (5), 2006 (5), formation (5), experts (5), right (5), experiments (5), additional (5), particles (5), theoretical (5), due (5), made (5), well (5), enough (5), could (5), after (5), then (5), old (5), panel (5), post (5), been (5), work (5), technology (5), press (5), paul (5), same (5), today (5), plate (5), tectonics (5), permo (5), triassic (5), milky (5), late (5), even (5), nearby (5), sketch (5), half (5), family (5), please (5), crawley (5), author (5), view (4), report (4), free (4), history (4), next (4), disappear (4), sky (4), language (4), mars (4), just (4), dying (4), yet (4), 101 (4), revision (4), along (4), obituaries (4), einstein (4), martin (4), jens (4), olaf (4), aarhus (4), observational (4), release (4), role (4), particle (4), atmospheric (4), conditions (4), research (4), arxiv (4), org (4), variation (4), team (4), danes (4), ultraviolet (4), larger (4), also (4), second (4), several (4), down (4), off (4), make (4), blue (4), size (4), should (4), let (4), air (4), last (4), discovery (4), explained (4), ocean (4), intergovernmental (4), delft (4), qubits (4), information (4), coherence (4), practical (4), state (4), london (4), start (4), century (4), january (4), era (4), oxygen (4), extinction (4), bio (4), sometimes (4), left (4), 500 (4), animals (4), short (4), term (4), above (4), leave (4), funeral (4), followed (4), december (4), 2016 (4), get (3), required (3), sign (3), subscribe (3), already (3), address (3), puzzling (3), ice (3), live (3), back (3), image (3), mother (3), human (3), accelerator (3), paradigm (3), shift (3), means (3), personal (3), forges (3), ahead (3), gotta (3), driftin (3), newspaper (3), announcements (3), advance (3), notice (3), sung (3), song (3), sing (3), predictions (3), sky2 (3), letters (3), chemical (3), net (3), 5039 (3), 2007 (3), online (3), ions (3), preprint (3), changes (3), publication (3), until (3), low (3), nearly (3), days (3), isn (3), amazing (3), such (3), activity (3), head (3), cover (3), catalytic (3), trace (3), ozone (3), contradicts (3), models (3), points (3), included (3), promote (3), below (3), comes (3), different (3), mean (3), come (3), extra (3), effect (3), lost (3), large (3), explanation (3), chemistry (3), needed (3), suggestion (3), molecular (3), point (3), theories (3), hand (3), curve (3), through (3), only (3), set (3), primary (3), something (3), need (3), important (3), little (3), brief (3), atmosphere (3), her (3), announced (3), near (3), volcanoes (3), cycle (3), cooling (3), temperatures (3), friis (3), christensen (3), mid (3), match (3), flood (3), pair (3), graphs (3), die (3), want (3), simply (3), qbits (3), steffen (3), fermion (3), forbes (3), ettore (3), decoherence (3), american (3), becomes (3), code (3), within (3), update (3), australia (3), phosphorus (3), energy (3), ambiguities (3), numbers (3), good (3), simple (3), computers (3), therapsid (3), system (3), pleiades (3), photosynthesis (3), mesozoic (3), gorgonopsia (3), fossil (3), evolution (3), pangloss (3), continental (3), drift (3), zone (3), astrobiology (3), include (3), planet (3), least (3), best (3), although (3), rapid (3), place (3), creatures (3), species (3), local (3), photosynthetic (3), affecting (3), dinosaurs (3), ancestors (3), gorgon (3), died (3), ras (3), diversity (3), around (3), changing (3), explain (3), living (3), nothing (3), david (3), writer (3), home (3), july (3), martins (3), bbc (3), started (2), site (2), website (2), write (2), reader (2), content (2), log (2), subscribed (2), account (2), join (2), 150 (2), subscribers (2), create (2), your (2), monsoon (2), sloooow (2), greenland (2), earthquakes (2), wiki (2), seed (2), self (2), population (2), pretty (2), magnetic (2), scale (2), aps (2), missing (2), briefly (2), roll (2), comet (2), confirms (2), falsify (2), pause (2), hoodwinked (2), berkeley (2), editors (2), opinions (2), sausages (2), pig (2), winton (2), prize (2), utopia (2), beats (2), dystopia (2), auroras (2), beginners (2), probe (2), sank (2), titanic (2), rss (2), top (2), currently (2), recent (2), search (2), updating (2), previous (2), tokyo (2), denmark (2), isotopes (2), skyii (2), review (2), dtu (2), seeding (2), aerosol (2), atmos (2), chem (2), phys (2), discuss (2), source (2), basement (2), bondo (2), decreases (2), 2009 (2), abs (2), 1202 (2), 5156v1 (2), response (2), submitted (2), references (2), man (2), continual (2), variations (2), production (2), modulation (2), remnants (2), chain (2), ever (2), political (2), scientific (2), passed (2), 1996 (2), link (2), light (2), vapour (2), gamma (2), result (2), control (2), predict (2), condensable (2), leads (2), finding (2), current (2), induced (2), latest (2), reads (2), liberated (2), pathway (2), reference (2), depending (2), whether (2), relative (2), route (2), night (2), day (2), help (2), form (2), negative (2), keep (2), being (2), used (2), nanometres (2), millionths (2), millimetre (2), anything (2), contrast (2), red (2), illustrate (2), prediction (2), passes (2), expected (2), supply (2), persistent (2), presence (2), influence (2), per (2), maximum (2), continuously (2), reaction (2), doesn (2), rises (2), concentration (2), peak (2), attempts (2), dismiss (2), didn (2), knew (2), understanding (2), order (2), chamber (2), forms (2), colleagues (2), opponents (2), said (2), exploding (2), ends (2), gathering (2), reported (2), indeed (2), really (2), mass (2), become (2), climax (2), met (2), office (2), troposphere (2), north (2), atlantic (2), oscillation (2), isac (2), hadat2 (2), greenhouse (2), european (2), agency (2), niño (2), eigil (2), 2000 (2), those (2), meanwhile (2), decade (2), trend (2), follow (2), effects (2), natural (2), temperature (2), written (2), books (2), subject (2), engaged (2), longer (2), myself (2), based (2), project (2), cause (2), thank (2), people (2), saying (2), others (2), charge (2), army (2), matthias (2), lutchyn (2), leo (2), kouwenhoven (2), eugenie (2), samuel (2), reich (2), alex (2), knapp (2), quest (2), march (2), fermions (2), february (2), towards (2), places (2), particularly (2), techniques (2), led (2), extremely (2), wire (2), own (2), item (2), behaviour (2), devices (2), 250 (2), simultaneously (2), probably (2), told (2), achieved (2), microseconds (2), 100 (2), factor (2), ten (2), increased (2), 000 (2), later (2), errors (2), qubit (2), switches (2), particular (2), soufflé (2), clark (2), south (2), wales (2), striking (2), held (2), beyond (2), seen (2), operation (2), machine (2), centre (2), spooks (2), secret (2), centuries (2), suspect (2), behind (2), digital (2), park (2), sure (2), states (2), give (2), binary (2), billion (2), relays (2), true (2), looked (2), earlier (2), might (2), sum (2), superanoxic (2), soviet (2), academy (2), sciences (2), palaeozoic (2), nutrient (2), exhaustion (2), monthly (2), invertebrates (2), guadalupian (2), record (2), basalt (2), don (2), fret (2), diehards (2), decades (2), never (2), diehard (2), went (2), minor (2), job (2), geology (2), happen (2), previously (2), gives (2), shape (2), speak (2), goldilocks (2), planetary (2), fit (2), nor (2), similar (2), add (2), everything (2), lucky (2), commented (2), 251 (2), consequences (2), green (2), context (2), nutrients (2), read (2), gasping (2), breathe (2), lack (2), microbes (2), recently (2), blame (2), tells (2), animal (2), put (2), cousins (2), findings (2), words (2), normalized (2), invertebrate (2), genera (2), count (2), shown (2), freehand (2), liz (2), part (2), spike (2), 270 (2), 440 (2), published (2), explosions (2), close (2), largely (2), main (2), band (2), things (2), galactic (2), amount (2), icy (2), pooh (2), offer (2), geophysicists (2), depends (2), virtually (2), else (2), exploded (2), directions (2), know (2), esa (2), chapter (2), love (2), added (2), given (2), wife (2), wonderful (2), memory (2), share (2), peacefully (2), beloved (2), friday (2), methodist (2), welcome (2), wearing (2), necessary (2), flowers (2), donations (2), dystonia (2), rh11 (2), 9ba (2), 01293 (2), 552345 (2), enquiries (2), friend (2), independent (2), guardian (2), obituary (2), journalist (2), speakers (2), professor (2), request (2), seat (2), informal (2), reception (2), 6pm (2), tuesday (2), 4pm (2), w1j (2), obq (2), piccadilly (2), burlington (2), house (2), editor (2), 2001 (2), service (2), direction (2), woodfield (2), road (2), parade (2), takes (2), pulse (2), checks (2), worked (2), brow (2), frenzied (2), climatology (2), design, name, loading, collapse, bar, manage, subscriptions, privacy, visitors, enter, receive, notifications, subscription, maps, register, approves, age, origin, artificial, identified, flying, objects, rebels, abdus, salam, devout, ahmadi, rush, hawking, discover, pacific, islands, soil, h2o, tradecraft, propaganda, predictable, co2, thermometer, sprites, fight, witch, west, conundrum, neutrinos, aircraft, organizing, colours, butterflies, positions, sulks, malthus, wisdom, kilgore, trout, remedy, jet, lag, ceramic, superconductors, disappoint, cheer, cryosat, freeze, evolve, planck, fierce, hole, sister, milankovitch, 1974, bomb, amazon, rainforest, tarantula, superstar, silly, season, melting, wishful, thinking, czech, style, mirror, orion, bedrock, monopoles, tongue, misleading, meteor, photo, guided, hurricanes, superatomic, circus, dark, lens, blew, jerusalem, wheat, genome, worse, ivan, terrible, kennelful, pluto, puppies, relativity, graphene, scores, cools, daft, hal, lewis, quits, whoosh, busy, sorting, svensmarks, junior, target, spotted, mustn, attempt, archive, links, pick, pics, falsification, tests, mystery, revisited, categories, entries, making, catalysis, nutshell, summary, relevant, items, acpd, html, 5064, bork, hattori, meusinger, nakagawa, danielache, ueno, johnson, yoshida, isotope, ionising, radiation, vol, 463, 385, original, proceedings, marsh, ulrik, uggerhøj, under, affect, l15101, geophysical, won, publicly, accepted, conversation, sounds, reached, trek, defiance, opposition, mockery, cluster, breakthroughs, themselves, secure, perhaps, confused, dislike, scandals, character, engulf, future, historians, shake, heads, sadly, negligence, fundamental, unnoticed, 1875, discovered, found, suggested, produces, amounts, produced, ionization, sources, diameters, appropriate, decline, insufficiency, slower, losses, coagulation, unpredicted, process, possibly, summarize, abstract, forming, performed, collaboration, signatures, abundances, greatly, surpassed, implying, reuse, fashion, concentrations, dozens, raining, ideas, pay, allows, slowly, becoming, charged, producing, reactions, involving, reused, supplies, recall, act, catalysts, horizontal, axis, scaled, each, runs, continued, pessimistic, cease, running, occurs, simulate, show, find, flatly, infant, couldn, clue, persistence, cent, daytime, must, replenished, limelight, drama, commonest, morning, convert, club, ammonia, nevertheless, diminishes, goes, evening, inconsequential, dismay, wrong, support, real, dig, decided, rebuild, cubic, metre, six, prototype, unexpected, sleeve, revealed, elegantly, pointed, blocked, resulting, shortage, starts, paragraph, till, reconfirmed, geneva, coming, supernovas, wide, floating, droplets, seeds, flout, forcing, center, port, reply, lockwood, fröhlich, tropospheric, remained, surface, despite, continuing, increase, flat, contradiction, predicted, lazy, counts, oceans, deg, partly, magnitude, contribution, debatable, upper, roughly, disturbances, removed, upward, measured, balloons, collated, upside, 1991, minimum, fewer, warmer, vary, intensity, having, rebuttal, kinds, scales, millennia, spanning, director, boys, girls, quality, ous, friendly, meticulous, previ, sorry, folks, magazine, prl, 1002, 4033v2, feb, quirky, struck, gold, 10124, solid, case, 10174, pressrelease, 36901, wss, quoted, sites, alexknapp, paves, scalable, opened, special, ability, remember, swaps, sibling, resistant, plagued, promised, industry, netherland, tested, experimentally, field, touch, superconductor, fine, semiconducting, signature, resistance, zero, voltage, product, cosmos, 1937, italian, physicist, adapted, british, dirac, antiparticle, strange, electrically, neutral, exhibit, peculiar, scaling, handling, array, contain, ordinary, entire, capable, performing, millions, computations, existing, withstand, probing, explains, funded, reporter, 1999, nanosecond, improve, threshold, considering, scared, joined, prolonged, researchers, yorktown, height, claimed, sight, device, dogging, experimenters, problem, survive, checked, confirmation, developed, consist, implanted, silicon, using, beam, aimed, precision, sustain, thereby, reducing, risk, transistor, reading, constitutes, unveiling, example, robert, thought, impossible, thing, confidence, members, attempting, widespread, opinion, 20th, reach, requiring, exquisite, delicacy, construction, danger, slightest, external, interference, mismanagement, multiply, parallel, computation, cave, mistimed, australians, front, intentions, wanted, beat, rest, developing, sake, commercial, payoff, bring, founded, federal, funding, participating, teams, universities, queensland, melbourne, spookiness, services, contest, makers, breakers, concepts, pads, supposedly, unbreakable, cipher, powerful, crack, knows, developments, scenes, alan, turing, bletchley, england, war, electron, atom, higher, permitted, laws, considered, once, terms, represents, four, equivalents, three, eight, fifty, represented, compute, them, whereas, electric, electronic, successors, microchips, provide, false, options, expressed, corresponding, fast, exploiting, revolution, spooky, 2002, physicists, equivalent, shannon, offered, pronounced, cue, raised, hopes, operating, section, shadow, looming, reminds, week, happening, breakthrough, predicting, unimaginable, power, discusses, seems, importance, strands, progress, palaeoclimatology, palaeobiology, open, npp, mnras, ipcc, downlaps, cinderella, glory, empirical, issue, except, communist, bloc, immobility, continents, doctrinally, imposed, analagous, doctrine, conceived, insist, causes, compared, impacts, mark, looks, triumph, redfaced, blustering, 1960, department, believed, 1970, practice, sometime, soon, additions, microphysics, unknown, vastly, knowledge, seemed, cocky, pipeline, observations, brought, successes, resisted, umpteen, astronomers, searching, elsewhere, systems, neither, parent, galaxies, unfit, huge, collision, created, disproportionately, moon, provided, orbital, stability, active, relies, astronomically, worlds, threaten, came, range, severe, episodes, snowball, blamed, bursts, location, regions, inhospitable, advanced, itself, closely, related, question, wonder, enhancing, wanting, sound, voltaire, average, hundred, generous, interrupted, chief, victims, warm, including, gigantic, bivalves, rugose, corals, fuller, subtler, persuasive, culminating, lesser, occurred, stage, linked, resurgence, adapt, hyperactive, norma, arm, entered, quiet, fatal, ensue, writes, occurring, quickly, fall, indicator, plumb, middle, downward, pointing, dagger, marks, notes, saw, largest, does, improving, circulation, organisms, simplified, easier, heavy, doomed, symptom, shortfall, weather, circulate, badly, turn, shares, plant, breeders, credit, feeding, growing, plants, covet, bad, course, overlooks, fact, notorious, gas, keeps, alive, geologists, coup, grâce, forget, suggestions, impact, asteroid, greatest, less, sudden, similarly, impressive, eruption, smothered, siberia, noxious, volcanic, rocks, covering, area, belated, regional, scraped, worst, catastrophe, extinct, land, ended, ushered, mammals, trying, clear, death, flourishing, faced, according, reptiles, luckiest, among, mammal, reptile, breath, poor, named, scary, greek, myth, sauroctonus, progressus, metres, relatives, wikipedia, great, fascinating, particulars, use, significance, choose, follows, entirely, arbitrary, brings, axes, labelled, simpler, vertical, bars, indicating, groups, telling, changed, broad, correspondence, surprising, floods, margins, extensive, varied, habitats, obviously, conspicuous, declining, strong, wiggles, remove, broader, taller, reckoning, stress, sketches, operations, convey, data, drawn, precisely, superimposed, comparison, highly, befits, professional, journal, non, expert, eyes, illustrations, enlisted, aid, graph, relatively, strongly, influenced, trilobites, ancient, lobsters, caption, evidently, combination, astrophysical, argument, draws, total, fluctuating, recession, ftp, ftp2, pub, mnras_svensmark2012, pdf, text, via, concern, uppermost, timescales, smaller, briefer, major, controlled, vicinity, destruction, copyrighted, reproduced, acknowledgement, implication, determine, inherently, reaching, tried, diagram, amusing, stands, popular, geoscientists, drastic, alternations, hot, increases, intricate, ways, driven, govern, presented, caution, consideration, feelings, fields, unfolds, meshes, clockwork, anyone, wishes, any, piece, correlation, necessarily, causality, mega, says, mutually, supportive, coincidences, arise, events, neighbourhood, geological, records, converge, gets, bringing, exceptionally, lived, falls, convincingly, astrophysics, equally, concise, cool, increasing, explanations, rampant, faltered, senses, word, taking, victory, pioneers, battle, against, eminent, makes, feel, younger, shredding, textbooks, tuzo, wilson, dan, mckenzie, jason, morgan, merrily, mountain, building, varying, depth, fragments, lithosphere, various, globe, 219, 2117, thrive, giant, figures, equations, effort, variable, frequency, ruled, fortunes, throughout, appearing, publishes, entitled, visible, naked, eye, seven, sisters, famous, surviving, formed, born, massive, siblings, generated, catalogue, calculated, needing, precise, armed, digs, deep, histories, nasa, hubble, jackpot, webmasters, deal, incoming, etc, visit, daily, containing, parts, plural, finished, meant, hope, outline, anyway, watch, writing, prevented, finishing, though, idle, stroke, became, full, carer, apart, dealing, warding, spam, april, explanatory, diagrams, pete, seeger, sang, cancer, exciting, worried, celebrated, diamond, wedding, pictured, received, message, queen, elizabeth, texts, mentioned, check, gentle, telegraph, monday, announcement, appear, ritchie, aged, devoted, husband, adored, brilliant, dad, sarah, penny, simon, jonathan, kate, steadfast, loving, father, law
Text of the page (random words):
omment uncategorized permalink posted by calderup obituaries and other notices 28 06 2014 nigel calder prolific journalist and author who did much to educate the public in the understanding of science the independent 27 june 2014 nigel calder 1931 2014 the global warming policy foundation 27 june 2014 sad news nigel calder 1931 2014 tallbloke s talkshop 27 june 2014 nigel calder bishop hill 28 june 2014 nigel calder obituary the guardian 1 july 2014 scientist with a social conscience letter from john pilgrim tothe independent 3 july 2014 a friend has passed away nir shaviv at sciencebits 1 august 2014 1 comment uncategorized permalink posted by calderup newspaper announcements nigel calder 1931 2014 28 06 2014 calder nigel david ritchie science writer died peacefully at home on 25 june 2014 aged 82 after a wonderful life most beloved and devoted husband to his true love lizzie for 60 years adored and brilliant dad to sarah penny simon jonathan and kate steadfast and loving father in law to nick charlotte jacqui and giuseppe proud and amused grandfather of hannah nicholas robbie daisy poppy david and izzy funeral friday 4 july 2014 at 2pm at st paul s methodist church crawley rh10 8er all welcome followed by a private cremation wearing of black not necessary no flowers please donations if desired to the dystonia society or rnli c o the martins funeral directors crawley rh11 9ba 01293 552345 to whom all enquiries should be made memorial gathering to be held later this year with minor variations the above announcement will appear in the times and the telegraph on monday 30 june 2014 leave a comment uncategorized permalink posted by calderup i ve gotta be driftin along 27 06 2014 posted by nigel s family the additional texts mentioned by nigel below will be added in the next few days please check back for these updates if gentle reader you have a particular memory of nigel to share please comment on this post as pete seeger sang in so long it s been good to know you cancer experts have given me a short time to live we all have to die of something and i ve had a particularly exciting life so i m not at all worried about it what s more after 60 years together my wife lizzie and i have recently celebrated our diamond wedding with our wonderful family pictured above and even received a personal message from queen elizabeth until today this blog has been largely idle since 2012 when lizzie had a stroke and i became her full time carer apart from dealing with comments and warding off spam i ve added nothing since a post in april 2012 about henrik svensmark s paper on supernovae and life by the way lizzie did explanatory diagrams for that post then i started writing a book based on henrik s paper to be called supernova but lack of time has prevented me from finishing it even though lizzie is now much better so i m going to start a new part of the blog would be books containing what parts of the book already written chapter by chapter as new posts the plural comes about because when supernova was finished i meant to write another book called the physics of love now i hope to add at least an outline of that book too we ll see anyway watch this space meanwhile to all of you who have read and commented on my blog and still visit it daily let me offer a big thank you my family will take over as webmasters to deal with incoming comments obituaries etc 22 comments uncategorized permalink posted by calderup a stellar revision of the story of life 24 04 2012 climate change news and comments and the svensmark hypothesis svensmark s cosmic jackpot visible to the naked eye as the seven sisters the pleiades are the most famous of many surviving clusters of stars that formed together at the same time the pleiades were born during the time of the dinosaurs and the most massive of the siblings would have exploded over a period of 40 million years their supernova remnants generated cosmic rays from the catalogue of known star clusters henrik svensmark has calculated the variation in cosmic rays over the past 500 million years without needing to know the precise shape of the milky way galaxy armed with that astronomical history he digs deep into the histories of the climate and of life on earth image esa nasa hubble today the royal astronomical society in london publishes online henrik svensmark s latest paper entitled evidence of nearby supernovae affecting life on earth after years of effort svensmark shows how the variable frequency of stellar explosions not far from our planet has ruled over the changing fortunes of living things throughout the past half billion years appearing in monthly notices of the royal astronomical society it s a giant of a paper with 22 figures 30 equations and about 15 000 words see the ras press release at http www ras org uk news and press 219 news 2012 2117 did exploding stars help life on earth to thrive by taking me back to when i reported the victory of the pioneers of plate tectonics in their battle against the most eminent geophysicists of the day it makes me feel 40 years younger shredding the textbooks tuzo wilson dan mckenzie and jason morgan merrily explained earthquakes volcanoes mountain building and even the varying depth of the ocean simply by the drift of fragments of the lithosphere in various directions around the globe in svensmark s new paper an equally concise theory that cosmic rays from exploded stars cool the world by increasing the cloud cover leads to amazing explanations not least for why evolution sometimes was rampant and sometimes faltered in both senses of the word this is a stellar revision of the story of life here are the main results the long term diversity of life in the sea depends on the sea level set by plate tectonics and the local supernova rate set by the astrophysics and on virtually nothing else the long term primary productivity of life in the sea the net growth of photosynthetic microbes depends on the supernova rate and on virtually nothing else exceptionally close supernovae account for short lived falls in sea level during the past 500 million years long known to geophysicists but never convincingly explained as the geological and astronomical records converge the match between climate and supernova rates gets better and better with high rates bringing icy times presented with due caution as well as with consideration for the feelings of experts in several fields of research a story unfolds in which everything meshes like well made clockwork anyone who wishes to pooh pooh any piece of it by saying correlation is not necessarily causality should offer some other mega theory that says why several mutually supportive coincidences arise between events in our galactic neighbourhood and living conditions on the earth an amusing point is that svensmark stands the currently popular carbon dioxide story on its head some geoscientists want to blame the drastic alternations of hot and icy conditions during the past 500 million years on increases and decreases in carbon dioxide which they explain in intricate ways for svensmark the changes driven by the stars govern the amount of carbon dioxide in the air climate and life control co 2 not the other way around by implication supernovae also determine the amount of oxygen available for animals like you and me to breathe so the inherently simple cosmic ray cloud hypothesis now has far reaching consequences which i ve tried to sum up in this diagram cosmic rays in action the main findings in the new svensmark paper concern the uppermost stellar band the green band of living things and on the right atmospheric chemistry although solar modulation of galactic cosmic rays is important to us on short timescales its effects are smaller and briefer than the major long term changes controlled by the rate of formation of big stars in our vicinity and their self destruction as supernovae although copyrighted this figure may be reproduced with due acknowledgement in the context of henrik svensmark s work by way of explanation the text of evidence of nearby supernovae affecting life on earth is available via ftp ftp2 space dtu dk pub svensmark mnras_svensmark2012 pdf the paper is highly technical as befits a professional journal so to non expert eyes even the illustrations may be a little puzzling so i ve enlisted the aid of liz calder to explain the way one of the most striking graphs svensmark s figure 20 was put together that graph shows how over the past 440 million years the changing rates of supernova explosions relatively close to the earth have strongly influenced the biodiversity of marine invertebrate animals from trilobites of ancient times to lobsters of today svensmark s published caption ends evidently marine biodiversity is largely explained by a combination of sea level and astrophysical activity to follow his argument you need to see how figure 20 draws on information in figure 19 that tells of the total diversity of the sea creatures in the fossil record fluctuating between times of rapid evolution and times of recession the count is by genera which are groups of similar animals here it s shown freehand by liz in sketch a sketch b is from another part of figure 19 telling how the long term global sea level changed during the same period the broad correspondence isn t surprising because a high sea level floods continental margins and gives the marine invertebrates more extensive and varied habitats but it obviously isn t the whole story for a start there s a conspicuous spike in diversity about 270 million years ago that contradicts the declining sea level svensmark knew that there was a strong peak in the supernova rate around that time so he looked to see what would happen to the wiggles over the whole 440 million years if he normalized the biodiversity to remove the influence of sea level that simple operation is shown in sketch c where the 270 million year spike becomes broader and taller sketch d shows svensmark s reckoning of the changing rates of nearby supernovae during the same period let me stress that these are all freehand sketches to explain the operations not to convey the data in the published paper the graphs as in c and d are drawn precisely and superimposed for comparison this is svensmark s figure 20 with axes re labelled with simpler words for the ras press release biodiversity the normalized marine invertebrate genera count is in blue with vertical bars indicating possible errors the supernova rates are in black there are many fascinating particulars that i might use to illustrate the significance of svensmark s findings to choose the gorgon s story that follows is not entirely arbitrary because this brings in another of those top results about supernovae and bio productivity the great dying at the end of the permian out of breath poor gorgon gasping for some supernovae named after scary creatures of greek myth the gorgonopsia of the late permian period included this fossil species sauroctonus progressus 3 metres long like many of its therapsid cousins near relatives of our own ancestors it died out during the permo triassic event source http en wikipedia org wiki gorgonopsia luckiest among our ancestors was a mammal like reptile or therapsid that scraped through the permo triassic event the worst catastrophe in the history of animal life the climax was 251 million years ago at the end of the permian period nearly all animal species in the sea went extinct along with most on land the event ended the era of old life the palaeozoic and ushered in the mesozoic era when our ancestors would become small mammals trying to keep clear of the dinosaurs so what put to death our previously flourishing gorgon faced cousins of the late permian according to henrik svensmark the galaxy let the reptiles down forget old suggestions by myself included that the impact of a comet or asteroid was to blame like the one that did for the dinosaurs at the end of the mesozoic the greatest dying was less sudden than that similarly the impressive evidence for an eruption 250 million years ago a flood basalt event that smothered siberia with noxious volcanic rocks covering an area half the size of australia tells of only a belated regional coup de grâce it s more to the point that oxygen was in short supply geologists speak of a superanoxic ocean and there was far more carbon dioxide in the air than there is now well there you go some people will say we told you co 2 is bad for you that of course overlooks the fact that the notorious gas keeps us alive the recently increased co 2 shares with the plant breeders the credit for feeding the growing human population plants and photosynthetic microbes covet co 2 to grow so in the late permian its high concentration was a symptom of a big shortfall in life s productivity due to few supernovae ice free conditions and a lack of weather to circulate the nutrients and as photosynthesis is also badly needed to turn h 2 o into o 2 the doomed animals were left gasping for oxygen with little more than half of what we re lucky to breathe today when svensmark comments briefly on the permo triassic event in his new paper evidence of nearby supernovae affecting life on earth he does so in the context of the finding that high rates of nearby supernovae promote life s productivity by chilling the planet and so improving the circulation of nutrients needed by the photosynthetic organisms here s a sketch from figure 22 in the paper simplified to make it easier to read heavy carbon 13 c is an indicator of how much photosynthesis was going on plumb in the middle is a downward pointing green dagger that marks the permo triassic event and in the local supernova rate black curve svensmark notes that the late permian saw the largest fall in the local supernova rate seen in the past 500 million years this was when the solar system had left the hyperactive norma arm of the milky way galaxy behind it and entered the quiet space beyond fatal consequences would ensue for marine life svensmark writes if a rapid warming led to nutrient exhaustion occurring too quickly for species to adapt one size doesn t fit all and a fuller story of late permian biodiversity becomes subtler and even more persuasive about 6 million years before the culminating mass extinction of 251 million years ago a lesser one occurred at the end of the guadalupian stage this earlier extinction was linked with a brief resurgence in the supernova rate and a global cooling that interrupted the mid permian warming in contrast with the end of the permian bio productivity was high the chief victims of this die off were warm water creatures including gigantic bivalves and rugose corals why it s tagged as astrobiology so what you may wonder is the most life enhancing supernova rate without wanting to sound like voltaire s dr pangloss it s probably not very far from the average rate for the past few hundred million years nor very different from what we...
|
