Meta tags:
description=What? [Please note that the code is still a WIP, but it works for testing.] As we are looking at changing tab behaviour in the editor (for list and code blocks), we need to strengthen other types of navigation. There s two existing mechanisms: Block navigation mode: press Escape. Regions: press (Shift+)Ctrl+` or Ctrl+Alt+N/P, both of which I find hard to remember. Proposal: additional regions with easier to remember shortcuts. The additional regions would be: The block toolbar Navigation mode Potentially before/after inserter for the selected block In addition to that, offer easier to remember shortcuts: Escape already enters Navigation mode, but does nothing further. Let it be used to enter the next region. Shift+Escape should reverse cycle through the regions, so from the selected block, it enters the block toolbar, from there the interface header, and so on. The (Shift+)Escape combination is a good indicator that it can be used to cycle through the regions, just like (Shift+)Tab can be used to cycle through tabbable elements. But Ella, won t Escape clash with existing behaviour? When a block is selected and focussed, we already use it for Navigation mode, which is now baked in the regions. In other places, it can be used for closing popovers and modals, but that s fine. First the popover or modal must be closed before you can continue cycling through the regions. It makes perfect sense to me. The main regions can be seen as the roundabout on which (Shift+)Escape can be used to navigate. (Shift+)Tab (default) or Arrow keys (navigation mode, toolbars) can be used to navigate more granularly. Why? We need a solid method to navigate the editor because (Shift+)Tab may no longer work when a block is focussed. A single unified way that is easy to remember will benefit all users greatly. How? Testing Instructions Select a block. Test Escape and Shift+Escape shortcuts. Screenshots or screencast;

Headings (most frequently used words):

commented, oct, 2022, ellatrix, 20, alexstine, 24, 25, better, regions, and, shortcut, 45157, footer, you, edited, 21, 26, conversation, what, why, how, testing, instructions, screenshots, or, screencast, are, sure, want, to, change, the, base, github, actions, bot, left, comment, navigation,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
build (356), block (303), css (290), library (266), blocks (258), the (198), rtl (145), style (141), editor (132), this (84), and (71), min (66), for (60), index (60), escape (55), not (53), that (52), mode (51), you (41), #navigation (41), with (39), all (34), can (32), screen (32), 2022 (31), link (31), post (31), something (30), focus (29), oct (29), ctrl (28), theme (28), ellatrix (26), use (26), key (26), edit (25), tab (24), but (24), code (23), because (23), list (23), toolbar (23), shift (23), sorry (22), wrong (22), went (21), reactions (21), copy (21), regions (21), comments (20), does (20), are (20), alt (20), commented (20), reader (20), browse (20), have (19), windows (19), from (18), will (18), github (17), press (17), what (16), just (16), used (16), one (15), alexstine (15), should (15), how (15), author (15), view (15), another (14), content (14), work (14), would (14), using (14), why (14), switch (14), when (13), navigate (13), way (13), more (13), shortcuts (13), site (13), other (12), f10 (12), keys (12), title (12), shortcut (12), member (12), back (12), pagination (12), change (11), keyboard (11), open (11), image (11), etc (11), through (11), which (11), readers (11), about (10), cannot (10), applied (10), pull (10), accessibility (10), comment (10), think (10), find (10), browser (10), region (10), could (10), text (10), template (10), query (10), out (9), changes (9), issues (9), review (9), already (9), sign (9), now (9), there (9), contributor (9), default (9), going (9), dom (9), mac (9), nvda (9), jaws (9), widgets (9), has (8), close (8), don (8), before (8), users (8), they (8), any (8), gutenberg (8), move (8), cmd (8), applications (8), some (8), modes (8), application (8), better (8), form (8), 126 (8), columns (8), suggestions (7), while (7), request (7), only (7), a11y (7), forward (7), was (7), after (7), cycle (7), toolbars (7), still (7), get (7), much (7), works (7), based (7), 100 (7), sure (7), remember (7), currently (7), jump (7), button (7), file (7), suggestion (6), need (6), example (6), media (6), longer (6), alternatives (6), let (6), always (6), sense (6), hard (6), trying (6), role (6), modal (6), reusable (6), video (6), table (6), social (6), separator (6), search (6), pullquote (6), latest (6), group (6), gallery (6), embed (6), avatar (6), audio (6), contact (5), closed (5), were (5), may (5), well (5), improve (5), start (5), here (5), allow (5), try (5), maybe (5), people (5), same (5), common (5), things (5), too (5), usage (5), easy (5), makes (5), our (5), easier (5), everyone (5), also (5), then (5), next (5), question (5), switching (5), aria (5), sent (5), quote (5), links (5), virtual (5), commits (5), size (5), react (5), elements (5), base (5), refresh (4), your (4), security (4), terms (4), merge (4), been (4), must (4), existing (4), merging (4), writing (4), flow (4), account (4), insert (4), preformatted (4), know (4), right (4), where (4), thing (4), first (4), either (4), keep (4), position (4), inside (4), field (4), formatting (4), pressing (4), believe (4), different (4), https (4), function (4), see (4), modals (4), menus (4), okay (4), around (4), depending (4), really (4), working (4), make (4), doesn (4), thanks (4), discussions (4), clash (4), behavior (4), web (4), characters (4), two (4), those (4), old (4), event (4), good (4), input (4), html (4), classic (4), 174 (4), part (4), spacer (4), 116 (4), logo (4), rss (4), 121 (4), numbers (4), featured (4), excerpt (4), paragraph (4), page (4), posts (4), 108 (4), cover (4), categories (4), buttons (4), archives (4), actions (4), 45157 (4), time (3), multi (3), line (3), batch (3), single (3), projects (3), markup (3), labels (3), marcozehe (3), conversation (3), free (3), indent (3), mentioned (3), looking (3), lists (3), character (3), whether (3), positioned (3), agreed (3), multiple (3), most (3), appears (3), above (3), tricky (3), like (3), com (3), means (3), backwards (3), both (3), modifiers (3), native (3), tabs (3), options (3), pressed (3), exactly (3), modifier (3), without (3), adding (3), than (3), even (3), though (3), requested (3), might (3), many (3), types (3), project (3), look (3), certain (3), force (3), agree (3), dialog (3), want (3), situation (3), navigational (3), community (3), developers (3), fine (3), problems (3), solution (3), introduce (3), case (3), arrow (3), cursor (3), into (3), related (3), tree (3), reason (3), however (3), vendors (3), shortcode (3), nux (3), 571 (3), format (3), date (3), data (3), customize (3), components (3), 235 (3), 406 (3), 213 (3), 282 (3), 122 (3), 175 (3), directory (3), selected (3), unicode (3), trunk (3), branch (3), refname (3), wordpress (3), repository (3), signed (2), window (2), session (2), reload (2), action (2), blog (2), api (2), pricing (2), docs (2), privacy (2), footer (2), outdated (2), order (2), add (2), commit (2), per (2), none (2), yet (2), these (2), milestone (2), needs (2), feedback (2), selection (2), splitting (2), deletion (2), feature (2), impact (2), corresponding (2), least (2), kevin940726 (2), adamziel (2), tellthemachines (2), noisysocks (2), talldan (2), draganescu (2), ajitbohra (2), giving (2), test (2), yes (2), dynamic (2), such (2), tabbable (2), future (2), hence (2), put (2), wondering (2), closest (2), cycles (2), leave (2), inline (2), fix (2), give (2), hands (2), edge (2), closer (2), itself (2), correct (2), specifically (2), word (2), lot (2), editors (2), until (2), mean (2), voiceover (2), ways (2), apple (2), moving (2), seems (2), due (2), suggested (2), super (2), wrapped (2), little (2), closing (2), very (2), helps (2), cause (2), greatly (2), once (2), space (2), guess (2), left (2), forwards (2), macos (2), navigating (2), combination (2), act (2), emoji (2), quickly (2), mind (2), consistency (2), slightly (2), addition (2), having (2), problem (2), hope (2), continue (2), positioning (2), removed (2), likely (2), equal (2), fact (2), new (2), email (2), others (2), main (2), slack (2), idea (2), desktop (2), client (2), teams (2), mention (2), translate (2), plainly (2), proper (2), sites (2), comes (2), entering (2), probably (2), user (2), picture (2), apps (2), suggest (2), getting (2), 29526 (2), following (2), yeah (2), considered (2), added (2), great (2), systems (2), essentially (2), point (2), important (2), trust (2), worried (2), optimise (2), provide (2), saying (2), hurt (2), removing (2), differently (2), control (2), down (2), current (2), found (2), sometimes (2), ever (2), popovers (2), contains (2), grid (2), placed (2), bug (2), org (2), articles (2), further (2), called (2), system (2), please (2), nasty (2), 256 (2), i18n (2), preferences (2), 835 (2), 507 (2), serialization (2), parser (2), 478 (2), reset (2), 162 (2), verse (2), 166 (2), 101 (2), 253 (2), tag (2), cloud (2), 190 (2), 494 (2), 322 (2), 184 (2), tagline (2), 203 (2), 490 (2), 464 (2), 194 (2), 234 (2), 146 (2), 114 (2), 165 (2), 202 (2), 132 (2), read (2), 439 (2), 167 (2), 135 (2), 103 (2), 153 (2), 315 (2), 493 (2), 363 (2), 395 (2), nextpage (2), submenu (2), 115 (2), 431 (2), 284 (2), 880 (2), heading (2), 394 (2), freeform (2), 300 (2), 410 (2), 293 (2), 125 (2), 124 (2), 239 (2), calendar (2), 332 (2), 337 (2), 482 (2), 161 (2), 150 (2), 378 (2), styles (2), filename (2), 532 (2), edited (2), testing (2), focussed (2), behaviour (2), enters (2), nothing (2), additional (2), show (2), hidden (2), bidirectional (2), wants (2), load (2), tags (2), branches (2), issue (2), insights (2), requests (2), source (2), plan (2), manage (2), packages (2), capture (2), nov (2), perform, training, status, inc, queued, pending, reviews, marked, resolved, create, valid, applying, deleted, lines, supported, viewing, subset, invalid, made, participants, successfully, development, assigned, assignees, approving, required, reviewers, join, 45404, envision, improving, within, accessing, upload, include, specific, roving, tabindex, pattern, fair, figure, dynamically, chooses, tests, polish, alternative, separate, less, direction, backward, possible, c12e439, unreasonable, kind, clunky, constantly, adjusting, app, annoying, proof, away, approach, sigh, support, ht204436, feel, kept, displaying, harder, delete, backspace, generally, unless, fault, anyone, struggling, task, ones, conflicts, sidebar, own, conditions, goes, creative, crowded, browsers, option, similar, natively, solely, previous, course, neither, long, globe, dual, purpose, viewer, symbols, three, worse, often, forget, number, end, few, focussing, context, stuck, onwards, fits, care, consider, matter, accessed, matters, opinion, visual, appear, apologies, confused, includes, alias, stop, enhancements, usetabnav, 41645, pushing, blind, rarely, receive, education, sighted, painful, watched, myself, graduated, who, barely, check, their, incredibly, simple, odds, against, known, disagree, place, run, educational, program, basics, stuff, marco, able, tagging, help, explain, finer, points, provides, best, bar, whole, call, variation, alone, wrote, uses, knowledge, coming, stated, trickier, follow, perfectly, caps, lock, followed, hopefully, explains, bit, happened, unpredictable, gets, predictable, decide, editing, puts, typing, dialogs, knowing, confusing, effect, quite, respected, trouble, directly, responsible, echoing, reaction, skorasaurus, reacted, heart, tie, necessary, towards, maintain, slippery, slope, designing, devs, making, ensuring, experience, did, wake, day, say, come, level, independence, online, document, real, quick, said, between, letters, headings, fields, operate, almost, answers, actually, anyway, far, takes, menu, had, weird, shouldn, understand, hundreds, google, slides, answer, unable, inserted, receives, 43729, automatically, rely, switched, supposed, causes, becomes, useless, treegrid, expect, understanding, careful, roles, hijacking, every, pretty, hand, clue, occurring, dequeuniversity, screenreaders, webaim, reading, rather, unique, normally, remains, difference, intercept, enables, prevent, modification, over, sending, normal, events, distinct, talked, sends, allows, relies, bare, logic, behind, non, existent, elaborate, thoughts, usable, remove, together, step, supporting, especially, since, accessible, job, showing, parent, child, 45135, tried, refactor, handled, received, agreement, push, 44883, prs, exploring, global, reviewed, mamaduka, compressed, wordcount, 268, warning, viewport, inert, polyfill, url, 644, token, engine, server, side, render, rich, redux, routine, runtime, entry, 696, priority, queue, 933, primitives, persistence, plugins, 728, 732, 963, notices, utils, keycodes, 527, shallow, 448, entities, hooks, 868, experiments, 537, element, 547, 546, 324, ready, deprecated, 653, controls, core, compose, spec, 722, 719, 694, 691, 251, 609, 611, 673, 674, 409, 288, 289, 204, 226, 223, 278, 211, 221, 325, 326, 584, 586, 176, 281, 279, 443, 295, 296, 703, 705, 505, 263, 266, 462, 463, 212, 630, 627, 329, 327, 950, 948, 346, 254, 613, 612, 636, 637, 839, 840, 231, 209, 222, 123, 991, 990, 475, blob, autop, fetch, annotations, 982, unchanged, 109, 111, 192, 198, 199, 867, 169, total, bot, owners, label, 392e595, screenshots, screencast, select, instructions, solid, method, unified, benefit, seen, roundabout, granularly, places, popover, cycling, perfect, baked, ella, won, indicator, reverse, interface, header, enter, offer, potentially, inserter, proposal, mechanisms, changing, strengthen, note, wip, interpreted, compiled, below, reveals, learn, files, changed, checks, 343, timeline, become, choose, bottom, clicking, occasionally, send, emails, statement, service, password, address, pick, username, its, maintainers, 831, star, fork, notifications, public, message, organization, results, collections, trending, topics, repositories, readme, fund, sponsors, resources, customer, stories, studies, devsecops, devops, automation, compare, enterprise, solutions, skills, documentation, features, explore, collaborate, outside, track, write, copilot, instant, dev, environments, codespaces, vulnerabilities, host, automate, workflow, product, toggle, skip, wayback, machine, http, archive, 20221101012819, timestamps, fail, success, 2023, 2021, dec,

Text of the page (random words):
min js 933 b build priority queue index min js 1 58 kb build react i18n index min js 696 b build react refresh entry index min js 8 44 kb build react refresh runtime index min js 7 31 kb build redux routine index min js 2 74 kb build reusable blocks index min js 2 21 kb build reusable blocks style rtl css 256 b build reusable blocks style css 256 b build rich text index min js 10 6 kb build server side render index min js 1 77 kb build shortcode index min js 1 53 kb build style engine index min js 1 46 kb build token list index min js 644 b build url index min js 3 61 kb build vendors inert polyfill min js 2 48 kb build vendors react dom min js 38 5 kb build vendors react min js 4 34 kb build viewport index min js 1 08 kb build warning index min js 268 b build widgets index min js 7 21 kb build widgets style rtl css 1 18 kb build widgets style css 1 19 kb build wordcount index min js 1 06 kb compressed size action all reactions sorry something went wrong mamaduka requested a review from alexstine oct 20 2022 alexstine reviewed oct 20 2022 view changes copy link contributor alexstine left a comment ellatrix thanks for exploring this and trying to find a global solution however we must not use escape or shift escape for any reason going forward this has nasty issues for accessibility on windows and i am trying to back us out of this situation not introduce more issues maybe look at using ctrl f6 and ctrl shift f6 related prs if you look at the commits on this pr i tried to refactor how focus was handled i received agreement from another contributor but push back from another 44883 i am trying to get the list view usable so we can remove navigation mode all together 45135 this is a really good step i just cannot see supporting multiple systems especially since the list view is very much accessible and the tree view does a great job of showing me parent child blocks thoughts sorry something went wrong all reactions copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 20 2022 however we must not use escape or shift escape for any reason going forward this has nasty issues for accessibility on windows and i am trying to back us out of this situation not introduce more issues could you elaborate on this we are using escape already and it s super common for web apps to use this shortcut all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link contributor alexstine commented oct 20 2022 ellatrix okay please bare with me the logic behind this is non existent jaws and nvda on windows have the two distinct modes as i ve talked about before one is a mode that sends all keyboard input to the application this is called edit focus mode depending on the screen reader on windows the other mode is called browse virtual mode which allows you to move the screen reader cursor around the screen browse mode however does not move the system focus that is why it we should go for edit focus mode in gutenberg because the editor relies on the system focus as developers we do not have control over the screen reader cursor another reason to keep screen readers sending input to gutenberg as normal keyboard events getting to the point the escape key does something rather unique on windows this key is used to switch in to browse virtual mode from edit focus mode normally when screen readers are in focus edit mode all the keyboard input remains going to the application the escape key is the only difference screen readers intercept the escape event and enables browse virtual mode there is no way to prevent this in gutenberg even with an event modification further reading https webaim org articles jaws https dequeuniversity com screenreaders nvda keyboard shortcuts as you can see the escape key is really the only key we can for sure not use based on screen readers hijacking it s usage if the screen reader were to switch in to browse virtual mode every time we press escape to navigate to another region it would get pretty out of hand quickly as users would have little clue as to why all the mode switching was occurring picture this screen reader focus is placed on a block press shift escape to focus the block toolbar the screen reader will switch to browse virtual mode because of escape usage but then will switch back as it comes in contact with the role toolbar aria can force screen readers in to different modes which is why it is important to be careful with aria roles i do not expect you to ever have a good understanding of this from mac because voiceover does not work this way one more example which is a current bug in nvda only focus a block press escape to focus the next region if the next region contains a button inside a certain aria role nvda will switch to browse mode automatically and will rely on the user to switch it back this is why we switched the list view to be wrapped in role application even though the role treegrid is supposed to force nvda in to edit focus mode so our arrow keys can navigate the tree grid when focus is placed on the options button for the block the mode changes back to browse mode due to the bug this causes our input to no longer be sent to the tree grid and there for it becomes essentially useless related issues list view certain screen readers still switch modes when options button receives focus 43729 unable to edit blocks once they ve been inserted into content while using a screen reader 29526 comment sorry this is so hard to understand but you are going to have to trust me that this is not a good idea just because other applications use it does not make it right i could list hundreds of problems with google docs slides etc probably not the answer you were looking for but hope it helps thanks all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 20 2022 so we shouldn t be using escape ever how do you suggest we close modals popovers etc all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link contributor alexstine commented oct 20 2022 ellatrix ah you found the only use for escape in applications using escape inside a modal is okay because the screen reader is already likely in browse mode anyway as far as menus go sometimes depending on the markup escape on first press does not work with screen readers because of the mode switching sometimes it takes 1 escape press to switch to browse mode and 1 escape press to close the menu i agree it doesn t make sense because in browse mode keys are not sent to the application but escape seems to have always had some weird behavior this way all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 20 2022 i don t get it if they key down event is not sent to the application in browse mode how can the modal be closed on escape all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 20 2022 i m worried that we start to optimise too much for screen readers while we do provide alternatives to use from what you re saying it doesn t hurt allow the usage of escape it s just that you cannot use it on windows in that case you can still use the old shortcuts to navigate regions i m not removing those all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 20 2022 in fact this pr is actually adding two other ways to get to navigation mode with the current region shortcuts all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link contributor alexstine commented oct 20 2022 ellatrix answers i don t get it if they key down event is not sent to the application in browse mode how can the modal be closed on escape yeah i believe it is considered to be a navigational key and that is why it works just like tab tab key really does not act that differently between the different modes the letters on the keyboard do they could be used to jump to headings links lists edit fields etc the arrow keys move the screen reader cursor in browse mode but allow the application control in edit focus mode some keys operate almost the same way in either mode and some do not i m worried that we start to optimise too much for screen readers while we do provide alternatives to use from what you re saying it doesn t hurt allow the usage of escape it s just that you cannot use it on windows in that case you can still use the old shortcuts to navigate regions i m not removing those agreed to a point but designing around accessibility and screen readers is something that should be more important then it currently is as devs we should be making things easy to use for everyone and ensuring everyone has the same experience trust me i did not wake up one day and say i want all the problems that come with a screen reader just to have some level of independence online if we document escape key as a working solution we ll find out real quick what types of problems those introduce for screen reader users for other alternatives i ll quote what you said regions press shift ctrl or ctrl alt n p both of which i find hard to remember it is the edge of a slippery slope you find those hard to remember but because escape would not work well on windows they are okay for the screen reader users another thing to think about is how this might tie in with the list view i just do not find the block navigation 100 necessary any longer and it would be great to working towards something everyone can use without having to maintain two systems that do essentially the same thing list view and navigation mode thanks ️ 1 skorasaurus reacted with heart emoji all reactions ️ 1 reaction sorry something went wrong alexstine added accessibility a11y changes that impact accessibility and need corresponding review e g markup changes needs accessibility feedback a11y keyboard focus labels oct 21 2022 copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 21 2022 yeah i believe it is considered to be a navigational key and that is why it works this is where i m not following so escape does work in browse mode in windows so then it is fine all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link contributor alexstine commented oct 21 2022 ellatrix this is where i m not following so escape does work in browse mode in windows so then it is fine not exactly escape is a multi function key in windows depending on the screen reader jaws for example has the most trouble with this because it is directly responsible for switching modes this is one of the developers of jaws echoing the same 29526 comment the ctrl f6 and ctrl shift f6 shortcuts are used in many browser based applications and f6 shift f6 is used in many windows mac apps for navigation i suggest this shortcut because it does not have any effect on screen reader mode switching and it is getting to be quite a well respected navigational shortcut in the screen reader community let me put it this way if there was another key other than the escape key that could close menus and dialogs we d probably use it not knowing as a screen reader user if escape will switch modes or close the modal you are currently in is a confusing situation picture this example start jaws on windows open a dialog with a form inside of it if you are typing in to the form this is in edit focus mode of the screen reader that way keyboard characters get sent to the form field if i decide i do not want to be in the dialog any longer i press escape because i am currently editing a form field this puts my screen reader in to browse mode because that is what escape does another escape key press will close the dialog escape is a multi function key and behavior is unpredictable just know that in windows screen readers it will always switch modes but the order in which something gets closed or a mode switch is not predictable if everyone could agree on a better keyboard shortcut to always close modals menus etc i think it would have happened already hopefully this explains a bit more all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 24 2022 how do you go back to entering edit focus mode after pressing escape and going to browse mode all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link member author ellatrix commented oct 24 2022 another question you mention that ctrl f6 is used for browser based applications why are we currently using alt f6 if we were to use ctrl f6 would this translate to cmd f6 on mac and why can t we plainly use f6 does that clash with browser shortcuts all reactions sorry something went wrong copy link contributor alexstine commented oct 24 2022 ellatrix how do you go back to entering edit focus mode after pressing escape and going to browse mode nvda nvda modifier space nvda modifier by default is caps lock and insert the mode can also switch if it comes in contact with proper aria role but this behavior is tricky and not always followed jaws to my knowledge there is not a way to force jaws back in to focus mode without coming in contact with the stated proper aria role it is a slightly trickier screen reader with dynamic sites or sites that do not follow a11y perfectly you can always switch to browse mode in jaws with escape but not back to focus mode another question you mention that ctrl f6 is used for browser based applications why are we currently using alt f6 if we were to use ctrl f6 would this translate to cmd f6 on mac and why can t we plainly use f6 does that clash with browser shortcuts so f6 does clash with browser behavior i am not sure if it does or not on mac but best guess would be yes by default f6 will move the focus around the toolbar tabs bar main content etc where are we currently using alt f6 i think slack used ctrl f6 but i think the whole idea is just to call some variation of f6 a navigation shortcut in slack desktop client f6 alone is used because it is a native application they wrote i think teams uses ctrl f6 on the web and the desktop client for consistency i see no problem with using alt f6 if that is easier tagging marcozehe to help explain some finer points if time provides why certain keys can cause mode switch in nvda jaws and others do not using escape as a region navigation key i know the basics of how this stuff works marco might be able to give us a look at why it works this way your next question might likely be if switching from modes is so easy why am i pushing back so hard on it because blind people rarely receive equal education to sighted people in the us it is a painful fact but i watched it myself i graduated with many who barely new how to check their email so when i start these types of discussions i do so to try to make things incredibly simple with odds that are against us others on the project have been known to disagree but i do not think it is our place to run an educational program for screen reader users at least not for just using gutenberg if that makes sense all for giving back but that to me is the wrong way to go about it thanks all reactions sorry something went wrong alexstine requested a review from marcozehe oct 24 2022 alexstin...

Images from subpage: "web.archive.org/web/20221101012819/https://resources.github.... " Verify

Images from subpage: "web.archive.org/web/20221101012819/https://resources.github.... " Verify

Images from subpage: "web.archive.org/web/20221101012819/https://github.com/custom... " Verify

Images from subpage: "web.archive.org/web/20221101012819/https://resources.github.... " Verify

Images from subpage: "web.archive.org/web/20221101012819/https://github.com/sponso... " Verify