Meta tags:
Headings (most frequently used words):
and, saint, war, jus, just, traditionalists, revisionists, ancient, christian, bellum, of, theory, contents, origins, criteria, see, also, references, further, reading, external, links, egypt, india, east, asian, greece, rome, views, tradition, ad, in, bello, post, ambrose, augustine, isidore, seville, carolingian, period, peace, truce, god, thomas, aquinas, renaissance, humanists, first, world, contemporary, catholic, doctrine, evangelical, lutheran, churches, russian, orthodox, church,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (548), war (347), and (242), just (176), peace (85), that (85), #theory (74), for (70), military (45), not (44), from (42), jus (40), with (39), was (34), are (34), edit (33), isbn (30), may (29), university (29), #bellum (29), retrieved (28), press (28), who (27), must (27), philosophy (25), ethics (25), international (25), have (25), this (24), law (24), force (23), aquinas (22), church (22), wars (21), christian (21), non (20), catholic (20), their (20), justice (20), right (20), has (20), violence (19), other (19), augustine (19), post (19), saint (19), tradition (18), only (18), century (17), combatants (17), warfare (17), they (17), use (16), political (16), moral (16), god (16), also (16), doctrine (15), defense (15), oxford (15), when (15), bello (15), criteria (15), which (15), been (15), first (15), thomas (14), world (14), religious (14), 978 (14), conduct (13), history (13), cause (13), such (13), doi (13), state (13), but (13), russian (12), all (12), anti (12), cicero (12), some (12), cambridge (12), his (12), medieval (12), can (12), were (12), could (12), view (11), authority (11), principle (11), conflict (11), good (11), against (11), archived (11), 2023 (11), ancient (11), there (11), between (11), people (11), justified (11), last (10), encyclopedia (10), march (10), nuclear (10), action (10), soldiers (10), pacifism (10), new (10), means (10), 2017 (10), revisionists (10), original (10), main (10), legitimate (10), wikipedia (9), april (9), social (9), human (9), one (9), studies (9), after (9), command (9), 2024 (9), unjust (9), traditional (9), resort (9), what (9), ages (9), early (9), wage (9), two (9), would (9), had (9), further (8), states (8), divine (8), evil (8), john (8), david (8), review (8), book (8), journal (8), 2013 (8), stanford (8), more (8), traditionalists (8), public (8), 2015 (8), should (8), egypt (8), orthodox (8), middle (8), enemies (8), isidore (8), roman (8), actions (8), considered (8), necessity (8), attack (8), its (8), about (7), links (7), control (7), day (7), intervention (7), civil (7), list (7), forces (7), women (7), movement (7), modern (7), morality (7), will (7), eds (7), robert (7), including (7), help (7), lazar (7), october (7), limits (7), christians (7), article (7), than (7), rules (7), within (7), government (7), therefore (7), avoid (7), arms (7), waged (7), ambrose (7), air (7), 2026 (6), articles (6), internet (6), united (6), category (6), japan (6), weapons (6), invasion (6), 2014 (6), principles (6), research (6), wrong (6), issn (6), 2007 (6), historical (6), battle (6), necessary (6), 2006 (6), guide (6), seth (6), 2020 (6), september (6), july (6), another (6), seville (6), period (6), security (6), them (6), scholars (6), views (6), well (6), through (6), justify (6), enemy (6), cannot (6), act (6), did (6), before (6), support (6), according (6), armed (6), justifiable (6), themselves (6), part (6), ideas (6), especially (6), toggle (5), text (5), under (5), using (5), page (5), latin (5), february (5), theology (5), israel (5), republic (5), east (5), 2022 (5), party (5), into (5), counter (5), related (5), 1975 (5), aristotle (5), normative (5), life (5), june (5), james (5), online (5), affairs (5), 21st (5), concept (5), origins (5), fight (5), contemporary (5), how (5), science (5), 2019 (5), case (5), com (5), laws (5), 2010 (5), pdf (5), limited (5), lutheran (5), gregory (5), holy (5), religion (5), western (5), even (5), morally (5), while (5), used (5), own (5), does (5), meant (5), proportionality (5), acts (5), towards (5), out (5), fought (5), move (5), intention (5), philosophers (5), nations (5), those (5), offensive (5), always (5), peaceful (5), self (5), truce (5), though (5), righteous (5), training (5), cavalry (5), contents (4), search (4), legal (4), policy (4), terms (4), august (4), reading (4), cs1 (4), national (4), russia (4), 2011 (4), american (4), third (4), violent (4), whole (4), universal (4), politics (4), direct (4), deterrence (4), include (4), churches (4), culture (4), ideology (4), rights (4), virtue (4), plato (4), concepts (4), 1999 (4), michael (4), 2003 (4), theories (4), man (4), america (4), critique (4), hans (4), london (4), york (4), defence (4), any (4), paul (4), routledge (4), offers (4), writings (4), three (4), need (4), 2018 (4), cite (4), 1093 (4), success (4), responsibility (4), protect (4), center (4), 2021 (4), francisco (4), william (4), classical (4), russell (4), frederick (4), motives (4), thinking (4), practice (4), warrior (4), rome (4), conquest (4), see (4), mass (4), however (4), both (4), based (4), rather (4), these (4), take (4), prisoners (4), taken (4), being (4), fighting (4), property (4), objective (4), circumstances (4), innocent (4), then (4), undertaken (4), way (4), system (4), certain (4), establishing (4), since (4), domination (4), warring (4), defensive (4), whether (4), basis (4), developed (4), evangelical (4), group (4), body (4), ensure (4), justly (4), renaissance (4), later (4), europe (4), information (4), carolingian (4), notion (4), order (4), campaign (4), egyptian (4), pharaoh (4), combat (4), special (4), hide (4), sidebar (4), safety (3), organization (3), ibid (3), ignored (3), uses (3), url (3), christianity (3), teaching (3), org (3), peacebuilding (3), kingdom (3), germany (3), canada (3), ukraine (3), protests (3), iraq (3), second (3), specific (3), resisters (3), industrial (3), make (3), love (3), economic (3), sanctions (3), recruitment (3), tactics (3), nonviolence (3), japanese (3), project (3), concert (3), among (3), appeasement (3), imperialism (3), anarcho (3), treaty (3), society (3), psychology (3), education (3), camp (3), pacifist (3), persons (3), methods (3), either (3), elements (3), metaphysics (3), nature (3), smith (3), stoic (3), confucian (3), value (3), work (3), technology (3), land (3), computer (3), applied (3), suffering (3), punishment (3), importance (3), rule (3), equality (3), duty (3), standard (3), our (3), concerning (3), most (3), current (3), terrorism (3), princeton (3), relation (3), spanish (3), today (3), kwon (3), crimes (3), holmes (3), recent (3), form (3), cox (3), rory (3), section (3), learn (3), read (3), annual (3), versus (3), brian (3), 2012 (3), foundations (3), 100 (3), humanitarian (3), conditions (3), development (3), 2001 (3), resource (3), crusades (3), 2009 (3), vitoria (3), ius (3), city (3), viii (3), formation (3), martin (3), luther (3), compendium (3), davidson (3), frowe (3), handbook (3), goetz (3), werner (3), perception (3), ninth (3), chronicles (3), militarisation (3), seems (3), missing (3), delahunty (3), returning (3), rutgers (3), hippo (3), officiis (3), iii (3), thought (3), india (3), iustum (3), broken (3), references (3), itself (3), particular (3), actors (3), leaders (3), responsibilities (3), theorists (3), outside (3), during (3), individuals (3), aggressor (3), treatment (3), whose (3), surrendered (3), threat (3), fair (3), governed (3), harm (3), caused (3), civilians (3), civilian (3), excessive (3), allows (3), prohibited (3), create (3), bombing (3), attacking (3), aircraft (3), grave (3), massive (3), grounds (3), authorities (3), process (3), aim (3), although (3), behalf (3), intentions (3), drew (3), stated (3), off (3), existing (3), slave (3), slaves (3), term (3), present (3), aid (3), permissible (3), lasting (3), still (3), hugo (3), grotius (3), established (3), cold (3), found (3), document (3), respect (3), sacred (3), given (3), emperor (3), men (3), usually (3), serious (3), cases (3), possible (3), important (3), nation (3), community (3), theologians (3), various (3), humanists (3), account (3), nevertheless (3), sin (3), decretum (3), clergy (3), soldier (3), depth (3), many (3), regarded (3), here (3), required (3), conventions (3), greece (3), claimed (3), novel (3), naval (3), space (3), cyber (3), fire (3), units (3), tools (3), subsection (3), languages (2), table (2), statement (2), code (2), contact (2), privacy (2), available (2), creative (2), commons (2), attribution (2), license (2), categories (2), wayback (2), cleanup (2), errors (2), language (2), date (2), unsourced (2), statements (2), short (2), description (2), wikidata (2), https (2), index (2), title (2), yale (2), total (2), calls (2), ceasefire (2), far (2), murderers (2), serve (2), resistance (2), psychological (2), aggression (2), global (2), power (2), draft (2), evasion (2), desertion (2), central (2), bell (2), show (2), promoting (2), enduring (2), festival (2), places (2), named (2), dialogue (2), books (2), art (2), media (2), soviet (2), green (2), antimilitarism (2), anarchism (2), ideologies (2), league (2), freedom (2), democratic (2), congress (2), conference (2), commission (2), socialist (2), common (2), conscientious (2), coalition (2), organizations (2), portal (2), outline (2), reasons (2), animal (2), liberation (2), 1930 (2), utilitarianism (2), morals (2), introduction (2), treatise (2), works (2), taylor (2), anscombe (2), foot (2), kant (2), butler (2), socrates (2), ethicists (2), secular (2), jewish (2), islamic (2), realism (2), cognitivism (2), dilemma (2), ideal (2), naturalism (2), sexual (2), medical (2), machine (2), environmental (2), engineering (2), discourse (2), intelligence (2), role (2), population (2), torture (2), greed (2), free (2), desert (2), conscience (2), compassion (2), autonomy (2), accountability (2), bbc (2), discussion (2), time (2), wikiquote (2), external (2), 2004 (2), 300 (2), debates (2), 1998 (2), perspectives (2), sepúlveda (2), discusses (2), 2005 (2), describing (2), rosicrucian (2), questions (2), volume (2), mark (2), 1992 (2), crawford (2), management (2), via (2), change (2), driscoll (2), thinkers (2), relevance (2), rethinking (2), charles (2), points (2), remove (2), message (2), please (2), improve (2), fall (2), edward (2), zalta (2), edu (2), ryan (2), maintain (2), lab (2), 1146 (2), annurev (2), polisci (2), 060314 (2), 112706 (2), 1017 (2), opinion (2), jstor (2), 1177 (2), brill (2), website (2), easterday (2), exploring (2), 968589 (2), acprof (2), oso (2), 9780199685899 (2), 003 (2), 0001 (2), january (2), sovereignty (2), jonathan (2), murray (2), rothbard (2), lenin (2), vladimir (2), marxists (2), archive (2), genrikh (2), antonovich (2), leer (2), 1869 (2), justwartheory (2), company (2), know (2), gentium (2), army (2), november (2), source (2), 2016 (2), 2000 (2), response (2), catechism (2), randall (2), archbishop (2), canterbury (2), dictionary (2), colet (2), helen (2), 9780199943418 (2), library (2), summa (2), theologica (2), reichberg (2), vii (2), 9781107019904 (2), combatant (2), 211 (2), 220 (2), manchester (2), boda (2), mihaly (2), ordeal (2), etymologies (2), quoted (2), fragment (2), dialog (2), laelius (2), character (2), lockwood (2), thornton (2), philarchive (2), ref (2), 250 (2), 249 (2), livy (2), 2nd (2), publica (2), greek (2), quarterly (2), raymond (2), louis (2), rowman (2), littlefield (2), sikhism (2), sikh (2), mughal (2), britannica (2), orend (2), miller (2), walter (2), english (2), easily (2), additionally (2), associated (2), era (2), led (2), generalized (2), individual (2), participate (2), responsible (2), revisionist (2), start (2), concerns (2), treaties (2), reconstruction (2), added (2), fact (2), battlefield (2), agreements (2), terrorists (2), largely (2), pursuit (2), context (2), treat (2), side (2), biological (2), captured (2), defeat (2), concrete (2), advantage (2), anticipated (2), justification (2), recourse (2), death (2), correct (2), distinction (2), directed (2), targets (2), airborne (2), neutral (2), directs (2), reason (2), needs (2), solely (2), punishing (2), imminent (2), basic (2), options (2), exhausted (2), engagement (2), hostilities (2), starting (2), aims (2), criterion (2), win (2), practical (2), essentially (2), initiated (2), distinctions (2), genuine (2), competent (2), norms (2), enable (2), consensus (2), centuries (2), situations (2), evils (2), evolved (2), christ (2), authorized (2), ethical (2), writes (2), coercive (2), already (2), try (2), impose (2), over (2), owner (2), owned (2), clearly (2), application (2), fatherland (2), deception (2), slavery (2), theorist (2), potential (2), concern (2), sometimes (2), attempt (2), might (2), ultimately (2), sermon (2), criticized (2), set (2), philosopher (2), declared (2), cardinal (2), issued (2), because (2), never (2), country (2), humanist (2), priests (2), same (2), neighbours (2), restoration (2), undesirable (2), gave (2), considers (2), orthodoxy (2), obedience (2), mercy (2), ruler (2), sword (2), earth (2), unfortunately (2), obligation (2), pope (2), following (2), legitimacy (2), decision (2), without (2), clear (2), proof (2), charter (2), council (2), area (2), possession (2), sufficient (2), seek (2), nor (2), citing (2), german (2), british (2), each (2), seeking (2), henry (2), asserted (2), met (2), upon (2), rightful (2), injustice (2), argued (2), extent (2), needed (2), killing (2), sovereign (2), reflected (2), detail (2), contemplated (2), bible (2), heavily (2), gratian (2), dominican (2), friar (2), significant (2), gratiani (2), contributed (2), where (2), version (2), dei (2), informing (2), unbelievers (2), texts (2), charlemagne (2), rulers (2), tours (2), declaration (2), immediately (2), fully (2), became (2), like (2), ultimate (2), goal (2), proper (2), disposition (2), judge (2), redress (2), private (2), core (2), writing (2), understood (2), philosophical (2), craft (2), across (2), coping (2), mechanism (2), held (2), argues (2), obliged (2), believed (2), defeated (2), personal (2), often (2), argue (2), example (2), thus (2), develop (2), chinese (2), dynasty (2), asian (2), dharamyudh (2), ever (2), chariots (2), gods (2), initiating (2), conquer (2), pharaohs (2), ability (2), declare (2), amun (2), guarantee (2), inclined (2), proposing (2), few (2), series (2), horses (2), fiction (2), strength (2), dominance (2), sea (2), martial (2), irregular (2), geneva (2), morale (2), base (2), chain (2), economy (2), conscription (2), ranks (2), engineers (2), staff (2), strategy (2), operational (2), maneuver (2), operation (2), drone (2), aerial (2), infantry (2), artillery (2), armor (2), data (2), gun (2), radar (2), guard (2), general (2), appearance (2), upload (2), file (2), changes (2), log (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, mobile, cookie, statistics, developers, contacts, disclaimers, additional, apply, site, you, agree, registered, trademark, profit, wikimedia, foundation, inc, sharealike, rendered, parsoid, edited, utc, hidden, webarchive, template, periodical, script, unfit, containing, dmy, dates, 2025, matches, php, just_war_theory, oldid, 1371599624, lux, czech, gnd, databases, jammu, kashmir, france, switzerland, sudan, spain, netherlands, costa, rica, countries, convention, elimination, disarmament, taxation, landmines, gaza, libya, sri, lankan, iran, afghanistan, criticism, terror, vietnam, boer, 1812, opposition, aspects, tax, begets, turn, cheek, watching, teach, swords, ploughshares, refusal, walk, nonviolent, complex, lesson, munich, spending, flower, die, department, demilitarisation, escalation, resolution, disobedience, park, ins, bed, slogans, black, association, symbols, songs, plays, news, journalism, museums, nobel, prize, mother, proclamation, monuments, memorials, prizes, civilizations, imagine, piano, films, dances, yutel, cultural, testimony, influence, satyagraha, pacificism, nonkilling, interventionism, isolationism, hippie, finvenkismo, punks, ahimsa, crusade, unity, react, recycle, peaceworker, activists, organisations, greenham, ecopeace, counterculture, objectors, pink, boycott, divestment, advocates, wikiproject, rehabilitation, axiology, 1984, 1981, 1971, 1903, principia, ethica, 1887, genealogy, 1874, 1861, 1843, 1820, 1785, groundwork, 1780, legislation, 1759, sentiments, 1740, 1677, 450, kural, 322, nicomachean, nussbaum, korsgaard, azurmendi, adams, nagel, parfit, singer, hare, macintyre, frankena, mackie, williams, dewey, rawls, bonhoeffer, tillich, barth, moore, nietzsche, sidgwick, kierkegaard, mill, bentham, schopenhauer, hegel, hume, spinoza, valluvar, xunzi, mencius, diogenes, mozi, confucius, taoist, buddhist, kantian, feminist, existentialist, epicurean, aristotelian, schools, pluralism, universalism, skepticism, relativism, rationalism, prescriptivism, quasi, expressivism, emotivism, nihilism, intuitionism, euthyphro, constructivism, observer, subjectivism, axiological, absolutism, meta, uncertain, sentience, terraforming, programming, professional, nursing, meat, eating, marketing, business, bio, artificial, insects, focused, pragmatic, particularism, care, deontology, consequentialism, evolutionary, descriptive, fields, vow, vice, intrinsic, instrumental, utility, trust, sympathy, stewardship, precept, norm, imperative, hierarchy, courage, circle, expansion, agency, loyalty, liberty, immorality, honour, happiness, golden, fidelity, family, values, eudaimonia, etiquette, double, dignity, consent, casuistry, blame, radio, keane, niall, ferguson, catholicism, fieser, dowden, bradley, 37741658, oclc, 2161, 0002, quotations, 10978, arguing, walzer, steinhoff, uwe, covers, basics, controversial, revisited, donovan, oliver, nardin, terry, nájera, luna, myth, prophecy, juan, ginés, crusading, exhortación, ottoman, turks, bulletin, portuguese, mcmahan, jeff, macdonald, roberts, south, bend, 929569, cloverdale, padre, crosse, devonshire, epitaph, astonishing, story, somme, antecedents, washington, 813236, khawaja, irfan, larry, extended, democratiya, 1989, 4008, 6014, gutbrod, applies, 1918, point, fellowship, 911274, reference, answers, heindel, max, updated, 8264, 9260, continuum, fotion, nicholas, evans, editor, edinburgh, reappraisal, elshtain, jean, bethke, nyu, neta, countertenor, 9780691171890, near, churchman, why, 2002, 721, heinonline, ucla, subversion, brunsletter, brough, lango, harry, van, der, linden, albany, annotated, bibliography, suny, blattberg, taking, seriously, benson, richard, showing, position, tidings, editing, edition, uri, nodelman, archives, fall2023, entries, fiala, andrew, authors, cheyney, strongly, framework, flawed, spring, 1094, 2939, benestad, 8132, 1923, 2307, ctt3fgpjc, sagan, scott, valentino, benjamin, 444, 0892, 6794, s0892679419000431, 411, pattison, 268, 26419464, 0090, 5917, 0090591716669394, 242, nonideal, beyond, revisionism, traditionalism, 0813236513, thom, brooks, 187, 9004228504, jenifer, jennifer, iverson, jens, stahn, carsten, brabandere, eric, 0008, mégret, frédéric, 123, 25660075, 0272, 5037, s0272503700024022, 121, proceedings, asil, meeting, seybolt, 925243, failure, don, hubert, weiss, supplementary, report, centre, buchanan, allen, 0048, 3915, 1111, 1088, 4963, 00051, institutionalizing, 1978, 445, 159493143, s2cid, 004056397803900302, 427, theological, bases, interrelations, priorities, functions, childress, lewrockwell, socialism, wollenberg, erich, light, marxism, incompatibility, рипол, классик, 1ff, 9785458055901, critico, опыт, критико, исторического, исследования, законов, искусства, ведения, войны, opyt, kritiko, istoricheskogo, issledovaniya, zakonov, isskusstva, vedeniya, voyny, eppc, home, publications, rieff, norton, gutman, victor, salas, december, ave, maria, indios, dorling, kindersley, 345, 4053, 4778, saul, bridgeman, 1962, 256, parish, trinity, rectorship, manning, 1908, 1921, dear, reporter, ben, salmon, chapter, copied, knorre, boris, zygmont, aleksei, 3390, rel11010002, religions, militant, piety, return, traditions, alex, iowa, district, missouri, synod, saunders, liberia, editrice, vaticana, 1574551108, mews, stuart, baron, lambeth, 1848, biography, mackenzie, kathleen, dalhousie, 115, 114, classics, ethereal, sec, allmand, christopher, 253, 272, bachrach, 1215, vol, woodbridge, boydell, 217, 218, 359, greenwood, 251, christianitytoday, bitesize, forgiveness, 1980, 150, antiquity, marcia, colish, 1925, 33ff, kaser, goettingen, 1949, 22ff, catalano, torino, 1965, 14ff, harris, 1979, 161, republican, 327, linee, del, sistema, sovrannazionale, romano, das, altroemische, festivals, warde, fowler, xiii, xviii, ithaca, 1968, late, badian, digesta, libro, regolarum, modestinus, origines, philippicae, pro, rege, deiotauro, atticum, provinciis, consularibus, divinatio, caecilium, capelle, wilhelm, gruyter, 358, 9783112318744, perseus, digital, cian, rewriting, greco, roots, 9781134330225, samurai, friday, karl, interreligious, contribution, fenech, mcleod, 9781442236011, syan, hardip, singh, tauris, 252, 9781780762500, militancy, seventeenth, robinson, 9781351924528, comparative, perspective, expanding, 371, 10023, 17848, hdl, isq, sqx009, mchenry, blog, blogs, andersen, rodgers, kerry, lanham, 5381, 5992, 353, 323, schuck, 1994, shooting, stops, 984, 982, 111, guthrie, quinlan, structure, bloomsbury, 0747595571, fellmeth, aaron, horwitz, maurice, 536938, acref, 9780195369380, 001, marcus, tullius, 1913, robarts, toronto, heinemann, translation, constructs, replacing, abbreviated, quick, discouraged, footnotes, style, idem, loc, cit, israeli, palestinian, supreme, emergency, cost, benefit, analysis, distinctive, methodologies, nonreductive, question, criticisms, scope, objections, raised, pacifists, realists, placed, follow, level, collective, pertains, traditionalist, distinct, accountable, breaking, altering, align, different, viewpoints, rest, years, gary, bass, proposed, described, discipline, currently, construction, remediation, trials, reparations, deal, hostile, place, governs, termination, prosecution, criminals, publicly, labelled, idea, decide, labeling, labeled, actual, fault, lies, forfeit, honorable, anyone, bounds, iasiello, forcing, effects, controlled, rape, malum, longer, pose, otherwise, mistreat, intended, proportionate, favor, allowing, limit, unnecessary, destruction, sure, discern, balance, restriction, imposed, corrective, measure, severity, caught, residential, areas, committing, pows, moreover, permitted, injured, presenting, immediate, lethal, shipwrecked, parachuting, disabled, reprisal, once, begun, going, recapturing, things, done, danger, expressed, 1993, said, violation, populations, stipulates, diplomatic, attempted, validly, ruled, regard
Text of the page (random words):
selves a slave owner who owned 100 slaves warring against a slave owner who owned 200 slaves for a more just distribution of slaves clearly the application of the term defensive war or war for the defense of the fatherland in such a case would be historically false and in practice would be sheer deception of the common people of philistines of ignorant people by the astute slaveowners precisely in this way are the present day imperialist bourgeoisie deceiving the peoples by means of national ideology and the term defense of the fatherland in the present war between slave owners for fortifying and strengthening slavery 72 the anarcho capitalist scholar murray rothbard 1926 1995 stated that a just war exists when a people tries to ward off the threat of coercive domination by another people or to overthrow an already existing domination a war is unjust on the other hand when a people try to impose domination on another people or try to retain an already existing coercive rule over them 73 jonathan riley smith writes the consensus among christians on the use of violence has changed radically since the crusades were fought the just war theory prevailing for most of the last two centuries that violence is an evil that can in certain situations be condoned as the lesser of evils is relatively young although it has inherited some elements the criteria of legitimate authority just cause right intention from the older war theory that first evolved around ad 400 it has rejected two premises that underpinned all medieval just wars including crusades first that violence could be employed on behalf of christ s intentions for mankind and could even be directly authorized by him and second that it was a morally neutral force that drew whatever ethical coloring it had from the intentions of the perpetrators 74 criteria edit the just war theory has two sets of criteria the first establishing jus ad bellum the right to go to war and the second establishing jus in bello right conduct within war 75 jus ad bellum edit main article jus ad bellum the just war theory directs jus ad bellum to norms that aim to require certain circumstances to enable the right to go to war 76 competent authority only duly constituted public authorities may wage war a just war must be initiated by a political authority within a political system that allows distinctions of justice dictatorships e g hitler s regime or deceptive military actions e g the 1969 us bombing of cambodia are typically considered as violations of this criterion the importance of this condition is key plainly we cannot have a genuine process of judging a just war within a system that represses the process of genuine justice a just war must be initiated by a political authority within a political system that allows distinctions of justice 77 probability of success according to this principle there must be good grounds for concluding that aims of the just war are achievable 78 this principle emphasizes that mass violence must not be undertaken if it is unlikely to secure the just cause 79 this criterion is to avoid invasion for invasion s sake and links to the proportionality criteria one cannot invade if there is no chance of actually winning however wars are fought with imperfect knowledge so one must simply be able to make a logical case that one can win there is no way to know this in advance these criteria move the conversation from moral and theoretical grounds to practical grounds 80 essentially this is meant to gather coalition building and win approval of other state actors last resort the principle of last resort stipulates that all non violent options must first be exhausted before the use of force can be justified diplomatic options sanctions and other non military methods must be attempted or validly ruled out before the engagement of hostilities further in regard to the amount of harm proportionally the principle of last resort would support using small intervention forces first and then escalating rather than starting a war with massive force such as carpet bombing or nuclear warfare 81 just cause the reason for going to war needs to be just and cannot therefore be solely for recapturing things taken or punishing people who have done wrong innocent life must be in imminent danger and intervention must be to protect life a contemporary view of just cause was expressed in 1993 when the us catholic conference said force may be used only to correct a grave public evil i e aggression or massive violation of the basic human rights of whole populations jus in bello edit main article international humanitarian law once war has begun just war theory jus in bello also directs how combatants are to act or should act distinction just war conduct is governed by the principle of distinction the acts of war should be directed towards enemy combatants and not towards non combatants caught in circumstances that they did not create the prohibited acts include bombing civilian residential areas that include no legitimate military targets committing acts of terrorism or reprisal against civilians or prisoners of war pows and attacking neutral targets moreover combatants are not permitted to attack enemy combatants who have surrendered or who have been captured or who are injured and not presenting an immediate lethal threat or who are parachuting from disabled aircraft and are not airborne forces or who are shipwrecked proportionality just war conduct is governed by the principle of proportionality combatants must make sure that the harm caused to civilians or civilian property is not excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated by an attack on a legitimate military objective this principle is meant to discern the correct balance between the restriction imposed by a corrective measure and the severity of the nature of the prohibited act military necessity just war conduct is governed by the principle of military necessity an attack or action must be intended to help in the defeat of the enemy it must be an attack on a legitimate military objective and the harm caused to civilians or civilian property must be proportionate and not excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated jus in bello allows for military necessity and does not favor a specific justification in allowing for counter attack recourse 82 this principle is meant to limit excessive and unnecessary death and destruction fair treatment of prisoners of war enemy combatants who surrendered or who are captured no longer pose a threat it is therefore wrong to torture them or otherwise mistreat them no means malum in se combatants may not use weapons or other methods of warfare that are considered evil such as mass rape forcing enemy combatants to fight against their own side or using weapons whose effects cannot be controlled e g nuclear biological weapons jus post bellum edit main article jus post bellum in recent years some theorists such as gary bass louis iasiello and brian orend have proposed a third category within the just war theory jus post bellum is described by some scholars as a new discipline or as a new category of international law currently under construction 83 jus post bellum 84 concerns justice after a war including peace treaties reconstruction environmental remediation war crimes trials and war reparations jus post bellum has been added to deal with the fact that some hostile actions may take place outside a traditional battlefield jus post bellum governs the justice of war termination and peace agreements as well as the prosecution of war criminals and publicly labelled terrorists the idea has largely been used to help decide what to do with prisoners taken during battle it is through government labeling and public opinion that people use jus post bellum to justify the pursuit of individuals labeled as terrorists for the safety of the government s state in a modern context the actual fault lies with the aggressor and by being the aggressor they forfeit their rights to honorable treatment by their actions that theory is used to justify the actions taken by anyone fighting in a war to treat prisoners outside the bounds of war 85 86 traditionalists and revisionists edit there are two altering views related to the just war theory that scholars align with which are traditionalists and revisionists the debates between these different viewpoints rest on the moral responsibilities of actors in jus in bello 87 traditionalists edit in the just war theory as it pertains to jus in bello traditionalist scholars view that the two principles jus ad bellum and jus in bello are distinct in which actors in war are morally responsible the traditional view places accountability on leaders who start the war while soldiers are accountable for actions breaking jus in bello 88 revisionists edit revisionist scholars view that moral responsibility in conduct of war is placed on individual soldiers who participate in war even if they follow the rules associated with jus in bello soldiers that participate in unjust wars are morally responsible the revisionist view is based on an individual level rather than on a collective whole 89 87 88 additionally the distinctive methodologies associated with the use of nuclear weapons to wage mass war in the modern era have also led some nonreductive revisionists to question the relevance the just war theory itself 90 such particular criticisms are more limited in scope however than the generalized objections which have been raised by both realists and pacifists 91 92 93 see also edit appeasement christian pacifism cost benefit analysis democratic peace theory deterrence theory peace and conflict studies right of conquest moral equality of combatants supreme emergency peace discourse in the israeli palestinian conflict references edit constructs such as ibid loc cit and idem are discouraged by wikipedia s style guide for footnotes as they are easily broken please improve this article by replacing them with named references quick guide or an abbreviated title march 2026 learn how and when to remove this message cicero marcus tullius miller walter 1913 de officiis with an english translation by walter miller robarts university of toronto london heinemann fellmeth aaron x horwitz maurice 2009 bellum iustum guide to latin in international law oxford university press doi 10 1093 acref 9780195369380 001 0001 isbn 978 0 19 536938 0 retrieved 27 february 2022 1 2 guthrie charles quinlan michael 2007 iii the structure of the tradition just war the just war tradition ethics in modern warfare bloomsbury pp 11 15 isbn 978 0747595571 schuck michael j 26 october 1994 when the shooting stops missing elements in just war theory the christian century 111 30 982 984 orend brian 1999 kant s just war theory journal of the history of philosophy 37 2 323 353 andersen rodgers david crawford kerry f 2023 human security theory and action peace and security in the 21st century 2nd ed lanham md rowman littlefield isbn 978 1 5381 5992 7 mchenry robert 22 march 2010 william james on peace and war blogs britannica com britannica blog archived from the original on 31 october 2015 retrieved 6 august 2017 just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy retrieved 30 october 2016 lazar seth 2017 just war theory revisionists versus traditionalists annual review of political science 20 1 37 54 doi 10 1146 annurev polisci 060314 112706 lazar seth 2020 war the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy metaphysics research lab stanford university retrieved 13 june 2023 1 2 cox rory 2017 expanding the history of the just war the ethics of war in ancient egypt international studies quarterly 61 2 371 doi 10 1093 isq sqx009 hdl 10023 17848 paul robinson 2017 just war in comparative perspective routledge isbn 9781351924528 syan hardip singh 2013 sikh militancy in the seventeenth century religious violence in mughal and early modern india london new york i b tauris pp 3 4 252 isbn 9781780762500 retrieved 15 september 2019 louis e fenech w h mcleod 2014 historical dictionary of sikhism rowman littlefield pp 99 100 isbn 9781442236011 kwon david 2023 a confucian contribution to the catholic just war tradition journal of interreligious studies friday karl f 2004 samurai warfare and the state in early medieval japan routledge pp 21 22 isbn 9781134330225 gregory raymond the greco roman roots of the western just war tradition routledge 2010 rory cox the ethics of war up to thomas aquinas in eds lazar frowe the oxford handbook of ethics of war oxford 2018 cian o driscoll rewriting the just war tradition just war in classical greek political thought and practice international studies quarterly 2015 aristotle politics book 7 perseus digital library capelle wilhelm 2020 history of greek philosophy de gruyter p 358 isbn 9783112318744 livy 9 1 10 cicero divinatio in caecilium 63 de provinciis consularibus 4 ad atticum vii 14 3 ix 19 1 pro rege deiotauro 13 de officiis i 36 philippicae xi 37 xiii 35 de re publica ii 31 iii 35 isidore of seville origines xviii 1 2 modestinus libro i regolarum digesta i 3 40 e badian roman imperialism in the late republic ithaca 1968 2nd ed p 11 william warde fowler the roman festivals of the period of the republic london 1925 pp 33ff m kaser das altroemische ius goettingen 1949 pp 22ff p catalano linee del sistema sovrannazionale romano torino 1965 pp 14ff w v harris war and imperialism in republican rome 327 70 b c oxford 1979 pp 161 ff livy 1 32 31 8 3 36 3 9 cicero de officiis 3 17 69 marcia l colish the stoic tradition from antiquity to the early middle ages brill 1980 p 150 delahunty robert j the returning warrior and the limits of just war theory rutgers journal of law religion 15 2013 p 249 christians and war augustine of hippo and the just war theory archived from the original on 28 november 2006 forgiveness what is a just war bitesize bbc 27 september 2024 archived from the original on 13 march 2023 retrieved 11 may 2020 delahunty robert j the returning warrior and the limits of just war theory rutgers journal of law religion 15 2013 pp 249 250 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ibid robert l holmes september 2001 a time for war christianitytoday com retrieved 25 april 2015 1 2 city of god archived from the original on 25 july 2013 retrieved 25 april 2015 city of god 22 6 quoted in lockwood thornton cicero s philosophy of just war philarchive retrieved 28 july 2023 the text seems from a missing fragment of cicero s dialog on the republic by the laelius character augustine political and social philosophy 3 c war and peace the just war delahunty robert j the returning warrior and the limits of just war theory rutgers journal of law religion 15 2013 pp 250 251 goetz hans werner 2021 holy wars religious wars the perception of religious motives of warfare against non christian enemies in ninth century chronicles in early medieval militarisation pp 211 220 ref russe...
|
