Meta tags:
Headings (most frequently used words):
and, law, of, trade, references, rights, consumer, policy, security, the, european, union, contents, history, constitutional, administrative, free, movement, social, market, regulations, public, regulation, see, also, notes, sources, external, links, treaties, executive, institutions, legislature, judiciary, conflict, laws, direct, effect, remedies, judicial, review, human, principles, goods, workers, citizens, establishment, services, capital, protection, labour, companies, investment, competition, commerce, intellectual, property, education, health, banking, monetary, fiscal, electricity, energy, agriculture, forestry, water, transport, buildings, communications, data, media, markets, products, foreign, justice,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (2279), and (1292), for (444), law (443), that (407), #european (385), directive (306), not (281), court (271), was (243), member (240), art (217), rights (205), commission (193), justice (190), states (182), are (177), article (176), this (175), union (173), with (166), from (164), case (161), have (158), see (143), state (139), arts (136), regulation (132), tfeu (125), has (121), which (118), but (115), its (111), there (107), held (101), right (94), treaty (88), under (84), all (81), also (81), other (80), social (80), general (76), their (76), company (76), public (75), council (75), free (73), energy (72), had (72), could (72), policy (69), services (69), can (69), ecr (69), were (66), economic (65), market (65), legal (64), health (64), 2000 (64), articles (63), they (63), human (62), parliament (62), more (60), any (60), would (57), standards (57), requires (56), where (55), international (54), government (54), must (54), national (53), trade (53), such (52), act (51), rules (51), 2007 (50), people (50), because (50), teu (50), movement (50), main (50), should (49), may (48), 2013 (48), only (48), treaties (47), protection (47), europe (46), 2001 (46), principles (45), 2004 (45), 2011 (45), 2009 (44), service (44), edit (44), labour (43), however (43), 2015 (42), common (42), than (42), information (41), 2003 (41), effect (41), german (40), capital (40), workers (40), 2022 (39), citizens (39), central (39), consumer (39), direct (39), while (39), freedom (38), without (38), first (37), directives (36), laws (36), community (36), competition (36), 2010 (36), 2006 (36), who (36), between (36), after (36), charter (35), 2012 (35), system (35), minimum (35), echr (35), 2019 (35), germany (35), most (35), education (34), security (34), transport (34), bank (34), against (34), although (34), over (34), constitutional (33), financial (33), data (33), 2002 (33), principle (33), van (33), time (33), work (33), consumers (33), use (32), sources (32), 2014 (32), yet (32), require (32), been (32), united (31), new (31), 2008 (31), 2005 (31), employment (31), through (31), regulations (30), institutions (30), media (30), judicial (30), into (30), 1966 (30), each (30), gas (30), does (30), companies (30), fundamental (29), monetary (29), legislation (29), tax (29), cases (29), set (29), these (29), within (29), dutch (28), power (28), required (28), courts (28), french (27), higher (27), per (27), legislative (27), procedure (27), review (27), ltd (27), vote (27), based (27), business (27), ensure (27), investment (26), made (26), requirements (26), cfreu (26), france (26), further (26), even (26), 2016 (25), political (25), 1948 (25), unfair (25), products (25), majority (25), agreement (24), development (24), markets (24), property (24), water (24), emissions (24), access (24), one (24), plc (24), out (24), two (24), non (23), agricultural (23), banks (23), private (23), renewable (23), 2018 (23), internet (23), price (23), pay (23), did (23), example (23), contrast (23), years (23), parties (22), opinion (22), commercial (22), working (22), decision (22), being (22), individual (22), take (22), countries (22), when (22), different (21), university (21), 2020 (21), 1994 (21), since (21), basic (21), will (21), some (21), netherlands (21), though (21), generally (21), italy (21), google (21), meant (21), environment (20), insurance (20), stability (20), civil (20), society (20), product (20), treatment (20), practices (20), production (20), equality (20), discrimination (20), enterprise (20), like (20), including (20), 1997 (20), interest (20), same (20), them (20), third (20), give (20), particularly (20), terms (19), contract (19), statute (19), electronic (19), oxford (19), udhr (19), governance (19), ireland (19), those (19), means (19), his (19), prices (19), part (19), justified (19), three (19), governments (19), need (18), british (18), convention (18), area (18), foreign (18), president (18), before (18), eec (18), 1991 (18), craig (18), make (18), measures (18), prevent (18), full (18), requirement (18), entitled (18), fair (18), view (17), code (17), safety (17), budget (17), 1986 (17), corporate (17), equal (17), búrca (17), democracy (17), 1950 (17), gmbh (17), given (17), land (17), protect (17), establishment (17), 1999 (17), high (17), claimed (17), allowed (17), wikipedia (16), 2021 (16), spain (16), authority (16), acts (16), constitution (16), environmental (16), single (16), euro (16), 1995 (16), 1993 (16), rule (16), eur (16), lex (16), million (16), shall (16), necessary (16), way (16), says (16), annex (16), conditions (16), year (16), 1989 (16), requiring (16), functioning (16), belgium (16), elected (16), 1996 (16), position (16), aim (16), claim (16), then (16), both (16), goods (16), italian (15), executive (15), history (15), framework (15), policies (15), fund (15), 1985 (15), coal (15), party (15), home (15), internal (15), kingdom (15), action (15), basis (15), directly (15), icescr (15), duty (15), least (15), climate (15), judges (15), world (15), 1961 (15), belgian (15), 1974 (15), worker (15), contracts (15), voting (15), denmark (15), provisions (15), owned (15), second (15), according (15), among (15), administrative (14), banking (14), democratic (14), communications (14), content (14), every (14), leave (14), own (14), important (14), clear (14), commerce (14), living (14), final (14), found (14), 1992 (14), become (14), costs (14), cannot (14), crisis (14), care (14), austria (14), include (14), restrictions (14), undertakings (14), provision (14), needed (14), employees (14), effective (14), citizen (14), claims (14), itself (14), limited (14), corporations (14), clean (14), applies (14), about (13), available (13), profit (13), republic (13), agreements (13), having (13), person (13), economy (13), group (13), practice (13), systems (13), order (13), liability (13), electricity (13), performance (13), rome (13), isbn (13), board (13), unless (13), rejected (13), paid (13), food (13), oil (13), 1979 (13), bargaining (13), money (13), rather (13), developed (13), fiscal (13), allow (13), whether (13), duties (13), risk (13), applied (13), often (13), still (13), body (13), issues (12), subject (12), mechanism (12), citizenship (12), criminal (12), elections (12), 1990 (12), 1998 (12), 1972 (12), waste (12), buildings (12), life (12), four (12), members (12), press (12), report (12), everyone (12), bring (12), limits (12), payments (12), damage (12), investors (12), supply (12), improvement (12), powers (12), share (12), dominant (12), collective (12), securities (12), employee (12), refer (12), 1988 (12), activity (12), regarded (12), another (12), well (12), breach (12), said (12), decisions (12), called (12), create (12), manufacturers (12), authorities (12), ecb (12), text (11), apply (11), committee (11), vehicle (11), journal (11), copyright (11), staff (11), bodies (11), patent (11), supreme (11), fact (11), gend (11), loos (11), universal (11), preliminary (11), lisbon (11), december (11), 2017 (11), iccpr (11), sets (11), quality (11), management (11), change (11), equally (11), post (11), shares (11), many (11), long (11), outside (11), minister (11), created (11), less (11), failed (11), implement (11), far (11), accession (11), adopted (11), votes (11), fossil (11), around (11), usually (11), imports (11), debt (11), privacy (10), using (10), control (10), objective (10), association (10), process (10), eurozone (10), integration (10), commissioners (10), level (10), protected (10), obligations (10), microsoft (10), trading (10), vehicles (10), good (10), proposed (10), doi (10), europa (10), july (10), persons (10), days (10), billion (10), changes (10), specific (10), disproportionate (10), 147 (10), 101 (10), compensation (10), agriculture (10), now (10), conflicts (10), spa (10), proportionate (10), corporation (10), beyond (10), argued (10), 263 (10), 294 (10), 1963 (10), race (10), unlawful (10), number (10), portugal (10), fined (10), abuse (10), instance (10), receive (10), ownership (10), provide (10), benefits (10), greenhouse (10), comply (10), limit (10), increasingly (10), questions (10), binding (10), cent (10), actions (10), conduct (9), september (9), references (9), ordinary (9), value (9), customs (9), defence (9), list (9), wage (9), country (9), damages (9), structure (9), intellectual (9), office (9), others (9), costa (9), move (9), consultation (9), maastricht (9), existing (9), 978 (9), five (9), brexit (9), our (9), upon (9), able (9), facebook (9), der (9), various (9), holding (9), regulatory (9), passenger (9), com (9), subsidies (9), competence (9), following (9), plan (9), communication (9), proposals (9), 282 (9), interpreted (9), led (9), support (9), progress (9), retirement (9), voice (9), 288 (9), 112 (9), shareholder (9), scope (9), merely (9), might (9), interpret (9), reference (9), luxembourg (9), aid (9), exist (9), thought (9), providers (9), operating (9), rail (9), failure (9), therefore (9), selling (9), similarly (9), follow (9), concern (9), ministers (9), search (8), october (8), june (8), status (8), healthcare (8), cooperation (8), currency (8), military (8), independent (8), secretary (8), judiciary (8), 1973 (8), women (8), election (8), interpretation (8), theory (8), measure (8), making (8), war (8), family (8), anti (8), fraud (8), corp (8), term (8), ruling (8), consent (8), merger (8), edn (8), cambridge (8), barnard (8), greater (8), resources (8), age (8), she (8), personal (8), uksc (8), provided (8), enough (8), respect (8), competitive (8), adequate (8), road (8), emission (8), s2cid (8), what (8), 1964 (8), serious (8), neutral (8), choice (8), gdp (8), large (8), 106 (8), occupational (8), 1976 (8), involvement (8), codified (8), weeks (8), week (8), concept (8), possible (8), 415 (8), rwe (8), primary (8), paris (8), applicable (8), appeal (8), nationals (8), wages (8), her (8), reasoned (8), 267 (8), wide (8), seek (8), pre (8), referendum (8), promote (8), sweden (8), establishing (8), toxic (8), commissioner (8), networks (8), enterprises (8), open (8), advertising (8), 2030 (8), affected (8), hours (8), firms (8), just (8), farm (8), reduce (8), qualified (8), creating (8), barriers (8), fourth (8), standing (8), residence (8), toggle (7), mobile (7), 2025 (7), statements (7), language (7), potentially (7), english (7), czech (7), man (7), global (7), resolution (7), groups (7), special (7), largest (7), external (7), steel (7), tribunal (7), industry (7), school (7), enforcement (7), remedy (7), economics (7), construction (7), evidence (7), deutsches (7), amsterdam (7), restriction (7), pollution (7), end (7), fuels (7), 261 (7), digital (7), primacy (7), maximum (7), 100 (7), fines (7), audiovisual (7), worked (7), radio (7), cjeu (7), assistance (7), line (7), volkswagen (7), ban (7), target (7), simply (7), cap (7), draft (7), prejudice (7), gross (7), lawful (7), despite (7), guarantee (7), goals (7), london (7), mainly (7), appropriate (7), airways (7), themselves (7), account (7), self (7), centros (7), insolvency (7), 1970 (7), used (7), 102 (7), too (7), 157 (7), hungary (7), marshall (7), 281 (7), established (7), contrary (7), des (7), horizontal (7), men (7), kadi (7), belastingen (7), highly (7), greece (7), nations (7), children (7), approach (7), operate (7), someone (7), purpose (7), sought (7), liable (7), count (7), today (7), enable (7), until (7), compared (7), instead (7), remains (7), bound (7), creates (7), months (7), limiting (7), especially (7), participation (7), during (7), agreed (7), registered (6), organization (6), inc (6), page (6), categories (6), containing (6), written (6), march (6), short (6), 1958 (6), block (6), peace (6), strategy (6), structural (6), funds (6), network (6), speed (6), official (6), centre (6), 1984 (6), 1981 (6), communities (6), 1957 (6), agency (6), question (6), representation (6), lawyer (6), jurisdiction (6), judgment (6), administration (6), statutory (6), reform (6), natural (6), trust (6), nationality (6), conflict (6), enel (6), rulings (6), instruments (6), habitats (6), dangerous (6), birds (6), best (6), indirect (6), illegal (6), transparency (6), science (6), something (6), russian (6), engaged (6), back (6), day (6), exchange (6), across (6), november (6), legitimate (6), recital (6), 434 (6), iss (6), request (6), entirely (6), form (6), net (6), previously (6), 000 (6), housing (6), standard (6), followed (6), light (6), forestry (6), rural (6), 151 (6), welfare (6), 107 (6), 379 (6), equivalent (6), shell (6), challenge (6), increasing (6), again (6), student (6), loans (6), students (6), universities (6), 1968 (6), governing (6), fees (6), deutsche (6), 250 (6), very (6), employed (6), works (6), defines (6), application (6), regarding (6), 319 (6), directors (6), transfer (6), ultimate (6), originally (6), hour (6), meaning (6), separate (6), consumption (6), 169 (6), chs (6), few (6), 345 (6), unjustified (6), assets (6), brought (6), intended (6), nor (6), justification (6), cmlr (6), 287 (6), bolzano (6), local (6), probably (6), certain (6), teec (6), secondary (6), peoples (6), minority (6), seen (6), infringed (6), received (6), significant (6), criticised (6), true (6), suggested (6), technical (6), impose (6), unlike (6), reason (6), 1987 (6), solange (6), für (6), consensus (6), strasbourg (6), challenged (6), whole (6), 1956 (6), values (6), poland (6), romania (6), similar (6), legislate (6), proposal (6), funded (6), knowledge (6), citation (6), series (6), giving (6), benefit (6), buy (6), responsibility (6), provider (6), demand (6), user (6), child (6), fall (6), restrict (6), result (6), representatives (6), publicly (6), generation (6), delay (6), flight (6), fuel (6), firm (6), total (6), sold (6), remedies (6), gives (6), raise (6), marketing (6), down (6), hinder (6), negative (6), gave (6), wealth (6), authorisation (6), insolvent (6), establish (6), show (6), affirmed (6), interests (6), investments (6), lived (6), decide (6), judgments (6), signed (6), contents (5), statement (5), statistics (5), agree (5), last (5), unsourced (5), february (5), january (5), 2024 (5), 2023 (5), wayback (5), links (5), retrieved (5), parliamentary (5), bloc (5), declaration (5), portal (5), lists (5), numbers (5), holidays (5), culture (5), enlargement (5), assembly (5), eastern (5), sport (5), regional (5), permanent (5), driving (5), schengen (5), average (5), withdrawal (5), institute (5), auditors (5), institution (5), legislature (5), areas (5), seats (5), points (5), border (5), dispute (5), function (5), tort (5), inspire (5), francovich (5), freely (5), charges (5), harmonisation (5), acting (5), procedures (5), types (5), relationship (5), essential (5), mcgaughey (5), context (5), complete (5), big (5), annual (5), ukhl (5), views (5), avoid (5), how (5), stop (5), taxi (5), uber (5), remuneration (5), abroad (5), regulate (5), known (5), nature (5), speeds (5), city (5), postal (5), railway (5), bus (5), heavy (5), bathing (5), spanish (5), waters (5), timber (5), type (5), asset (5), federal (5), nordrhein (5), westfalen (5), foster (5), 188 (5), 105 (5), 944 (5), advocate (5), jacobs (5), carbon (5), 152 (5), biomass (5), continue (5), defined (5), why (5), forms (5), turn (5), 194 (5), income (5), 134 (5), credit (5), 283 (5), 138 (5), nhs (5), capacity (5), 413 (5), 201 (5), 1978 (5), 225 (5), 1983 (5), original (5), wall (5), 167 (5), 212 (5), turkey (5), hand (5), 555 (5), implementing (5), mean (5), opposed (5), exercise (5), unequal (5), impact (5), transnational (5), 127 (5), aide (5), sociale (5), angonese (5), 196 (5), defrenne (5), sabena (5), former (5), clearly (5), prohibiting (5), towards (5), test (5), taxation (5), expression (5), 144 (5), kücükdeveci (5), swedex (5), 352 (5), eventually (5), transactions (5), charge (5), job (5), dori (5), employer (5), approval (5), individuals (5), deny (5), sell (5), machine (5), archived (5), 402 (5), nederlandse (5), sufficient (5), reduced (5), propose (5), included (5), stated (5), never (5), left (5), membership (5), amazon (5), leading (5), install (5), websites (5), competitors (5), prime (5), activities (5), providing (5), prohibits (5), dignity (5), whose (5), discriminatory (5), regulated (5), break (5), largely (5), boards (5), infrastructure (5), regulator (5), reasonable (5), finally (5), eliminate (5), solar (5), wind (5), wherever (5), air (5), lower (5), violated (5), overriding (5), enabling (5), active (5), purchase (5), place (5), bill (5), businesses (5), producers (5), enforce (5), loss (5), hold (5), reserves (5), buying (5), rates (5), appointed (5), say (5), justify (5), harmonised (5), schools (5), berlin (5), depending (5), competitor (5), bought (5), mergers (5), mandatory (5), version (5), prohibited (5), solidarity (5), concerned (5), managers (5), prevented (5), bottom (5), fields (5), taxes (5), restricted (5), thus (5), importance (5), soviet (5), alcohol (5), addition (5), representing (5), sue (5), senior (5), meps (5), subsection (5), languages (4), additional (4), foundation (4), link (4), lacking (4), style (4), presidents (4), studies (4), house (4), current (4), space (4), mobility (4), supervision (4), registration (4), licence (4), matters (4), asylum (4), legitimacy (4), expense (4), procurement (4), opt (4), initiative (4), offices (4), vice (4), foundations (4), urban (4), territories (4), larger (4), 1962 (4), 1951 (4), ideas (4), judge (4), pluralism (4), drugs (4), animal (4), dassonville (4), paul (4), metock (4), kamer (4), koophandel (4), voor (4), factortame (4), bosman (4), temporary (4), medical (4), devices (4), integrated (4), technology (4), reach (4), brussels (4), online (4), 258 (4), 4th (4), 2nd (4), 3rd (4), michael (4), philosophical (4), want (4), highest (4), put (4), users (4), future (4), longer (4), wishes (4), host (4), inform (4), exempt (4), setting (4), north (4), neutrality (4), controls (4), electric (4), scandal (4), alleged (4), summary (4), 150 (4), drinking (4), bibcode (4), financing (4), 1306 (4), real (4), objectives (4), farmers (4), developing (4), paper (4), storage (4), bioenergy (4), 231 (4), pricing (4), 285 (4), wilson (4), friends (4), earth (4), royal (4), 411 (4), 516 (4), 370 (4), deposit (4), 103 (4), goal (4), ehrr (4), 453 (4), patients (4), department (4), ability (4), substantial (4), england (4), 209 (4), bidar (4), borough (4), ealing (4), problems (4), 252 (4), academic (4), mail (4), brands (4), taken (4), 234 (4), 519 (4), anyone (4), transfers (4), aiming (4), unlimited (4), iii (4), 438 (4), 1345 (4), demir (4), baykara (4), 397 (4), wtd (4), 243 (4), off (4), cover (4), contain (4), 153 (4), parallel (4), banco (4), español (4), faith (4), cause (4), 109 (4), 145 (4), distribution (4), 349 (4), inequality (4), golden (4), residents (4), 251 (4), watts (4), 1980 (4), here (4), 210 (4), 208 (4), little (4), viking (4), chapter (4), 333 (4), 184 (4), ultimately (4), remain (4), 293 (4), 213 (4), 387 (4), creation (4), 110 (4), 265 (4), 1982 (4), introduced (4), mangold (4), helm (4), debate (4), claimant (4), lord (4), outright (4), thirds (4), applying (4), recommendations (4), faccini (4), west (4), 148 (4), referred (4), 271 (4), leaving (4), 334 (4), chose (4), april (4), administratie (4), privatised (4), seat (4), relating (4), funding (4), smaller (4), unclear (4), allegations (4), allowing (4), organisations (4), 1969 (4), deficit (4), consequences (4), balanced (4), bulgaria (4), croatia (4), finland (4), estonia (4), cyprus (4), slovenia (4), malta (4), expressly (4), operators (4), scientific (4), compliance (4), comprehensive (4), results (4), traffic (4), name (4), turnover (4), phone (4), marketplace (4), discriminate (4), android (4), incitement (4), hatred (4), lack (4), sharing (4), transparent (4), preventing (4), enabled (4), actual (4), circumstances (4), quickly (4), travel (4), regulators (4), heads (4), accounts (4), heating (4), run (4), research (4), daily (4), delayed (4), major (4), follows (4), hs2 (4), alliance (4), keep (4), continent (4), hectares (4), 200 (4), receiving (4), supermarkets (4), takes (4), fifth (4), increase (4), owners (4), reasons (4), growing (4), deadline (4), enables (4), responsible (4), allows (4), fully (4), treated (4), spent (4), domestic (4), added (4), determined (4), greek (4), overseen (4), develop (4), hospitals (4), outcomes (4), grand (4), chamber (4), stay (4), shaped (4), always (4), low (4), intel (4), vertical (4), collectively (4), bans (4), includes (4), misleading (4), monopoly (4), employers (4), passport (4), scheme (4), instructions (4), shareholders (4), protecting (4), incorporated (4), stakeholders (4), incompatible (4), controversial (4), reflecting (4), individually (4), prohibition (4), participate (4), competences (4), initially (4), opted (4), won (4), conservative (4), advised (4), proper (4), balance (4), irish (4), failing (4), justifications (4), bonn (4), accepted (4), certificate (4), contravened (4), taking (4), konsumentombudsmannen (4), chocolate (4), schmidberger (4), exports (4), get (4), conflicting (4), refused (4), plaumann (4), reasoning (4), opinions (4), join (4), approve (4), currently (4), hide (4), sidebar (4), topic (3), table (3), contact (3), wikimedia (3), commons (3), license (3), updating (3), august (3), clarification (3), yale (3), norms (3), unilateral (3), religion (3), south (3), programme (3), partnership (3), neighbourhood (3), relations (3), card (3), green (3), cultural (3), migration (3), potential (3), accountability (3), supranational (3), preference (3), referendums (3), acquis (3), agencies (3), unified (3), atomic (3), 1954 (3), 1949 (3), 1967 (3), equity (3), bar (3), chambers (3), trial (3), proportionality (3), litigation (3), legality (3), decree (3), precedent (3), letters (3), estate (3), entertainment (3), unjust (3), enrichment (3), crime (3), duyn (3), und (3), procureur (3), roi (3), marleasing (3), comercial (3), fabrieken (3), equipment (3), substances (3), sea (3), reside (3), promotion (3), 116 (3), clinical (3), roaming (3), certainty (3), freedoms (3), alone (3), nice (3), advocates (3), evolution (3), weiler (3), understanding (3), lawyers (3), gráinne (3), materials (3), hart (3), 440 (3), sanctions (3), dsar (3), exemptions (3), accessible (3), entire (3), ads (3), interference (3), news (3), 162 (3), decided (3), accept (3), distortions (3), unrestricted (3), gdpr (3), informed (3), asociación (3), profesional (3), élite (3), 1535 (3), referring (3), distance (3), recipient (3), amending (3), correspondence (3), broadband (3), encourage (3), mbps (3), vodafone (3), argument (3), retail (3), situation (3), tickets (3), cheaper (3), petrol (3), 181 (3), 126 (3), counting (3), 120 (3), grams (3), 2035 (3), previous (3), 278 (3), dpr (3), force (3), shared (3), essent (3), 2050 (3), present (3), 500 (3), compare (3), landmark (3), forward (3), moving (3), fast (3), hydrocarbons (3), efficiency (3), interconnection (3), affect (3), determine (3), significantly (3), transaction (3), pringle (3), 114 (3), opec (3), 1970s (3), 131 (3), 423 (3), 189 (3), sick (3), prior (3), behind (3), perspective (3), protocol (3), linguistic (3), particular (3), tuition (3), productivity (3), 155 (3), laval (3), 457 (3), 132 (3), 202 (3), telecom (3), akzo (3), chemie (3), continental (3), 358 (3), 395 (3), 211 (3), 224 (3), 249 (3), protects (3), organise (3), ilo (3), manage (3), entity (3), organised (3), solo (3), 374 (3), stichting (3), 513 (3), ucits (3), street (3), historical (3), industrial (3), 552 (3), traditions (3), pfeiffer (3), kreuz (3), arguing (3), gains (3), increases (3), period (3), facts (3), extend (3), deakin (3), 488 (3), verbraucherzentrale (3), nrw (3), 307 (3), 618 (3), crédito (3), camino (3), 244 (3), editorial (3), aimed (3), exit (3), 517 (3), 172 (3), stiglitz (3), 171 (3), maduro (3), 478 (3), physical (3), 361 (3), 123 (3), 384 (3), 137 (3), 372 (3), bedford (3), finanzamt (3), wholly (3), makers (3), arguments (3), federalism (3), überseering (3), nordic (3), clients (3), methods (3), itwf (3), abp (3), gebhard (3), staatssecretaris (3), financiën (3), 456 (3), communist (3), enter (3), resident (3), 1007 (3), passed (3), grzelczyk (3), freistaat (3), bayern (3), 279 (3), 492 (3), cassa (3), risparmio (3), practically (3), dano (3), jobcenter (3), leipzig (3), baden (3), württemberg (3), book (3), listed (3), live (3), 405 (3), 368 (3), reflect (3), accord (3), 142 (3), 170 (3), 173 (3), preussenelektra (3), schleswag (3), 270 (3), pursued (3), namely (3), constant (3), 236 (3), 544 (3), handelsgesellschaft (3), vast (3), widely (3), resolved (3), role (3), 463 (3), read (3), believed (3), otherwise (3), bverfge (3), 366 (3), pension (3), 322 (3), colson (3), von (3), 3325 (3), rely (3), srl (3), gerven (3), 316 (3), grounds (3), sex (3), southampton (3), became (3), express (3), consulting (3), comm (3), penalties (3), imposed (3), dialogue (3), autonomy (3), once (3), 254 (3), 253 (3), 326 (3), 313 (3), 1971 (3), acknowledged (3), hands (3), done (3), elr (3), reimbursement (3), 772 (3), 223 (3), recognised (3), 238 (3), 432 (3), 1960 (3), 273 (3), vienna (3), parti (3), écologiste (3), les (3), verts (3), ministres (3), 1945 (3), pursuant (3), mutual (3), assist (3), monopolies (3), lithuania (3), slovakia (3), latvia (3), needs (3), update (3), politically (3), identifier (3), help (3), events (3), operations (3), replaces (3), placed (3), shopping (3), worldwide (3), app (3), traders (3), sellers (3), alphabet (3), broadcasting (3), programmes (3), either (3), behaviour (3), platform (3), platforms (3), due (3), ensuring (3), denial (3), took (3), web (3), designed (3)
Text of the page (random words):
his is critical during the legislative process 56 the strasbourg seat of the european parliament which meps attend alongside the brussels seats has been criticised for its expense the french president has previously refused to let it be shut down 57 to make new legislation tfeu article 294 defines the ordinary legislative procedure that applies for most eu acts 58 the essence is there are three readings starting with a commission proposal where the parliament must vote by a majority of all meps not just those present to block or suggest changes and the council must vote by qualified majority to approve changes but by unanimity to block commission amendment 59 where the different institutions cannot agree at any stage a conciliation committee is convened representing meps ministers and the commission to try to get agreement on a joint text if this works it will be sent back to the parliament and council to approve by absolute and qualified majority this means legislation can be blocked by a majority in parliament a minority in the council and a majority in the commission it is harder to change eu law than for it to stay the same a different procedure exists for budgets 60 for enhanced cooperation among a sub set of at least member states authorisation must be given by the council 61 member state governments should be informed by the commission at the outset before any proposals start the legislative procedure 62 the eu as a whole can only act within its power set out in the treaties teu articles 4 and 5 state that powers remain with the member states unless they have been conferred although there is a debate about the kompetenz kompetenz question who ultimately has the competence to define the eu s competence many member state courts believe they decide other member state parliaments believe they decide while within the eu the court of justice believes it has the final say judiciary edit v t e eu judiciary sources teu art 19 tfeu arts 251 281 tfeu art 281 and statute of the court c 83 210 rules of procedure of the court of justice see eu law main articles court of justice of the european union and european court of auditors the judiciary of the eu has played an important role in the development of eu law it interprets the treaties and has accelerated economic and political integration 63 today the court of justice of the european union cjeu is the main judicial body within which there is a higher court of justice that deals with cases that contain more public importance and a general court that deals with issues of detail but without general importance and then a separate court of auditors under the treaty on european union article 19 2 there is one judge from each member state in the court of justice and general court 27 on each at present 64 judges should possess the qualifications required for appointment to the highest judicial offices or for the general court the ability required for appointment to high judicial office 65 a president is elected by the judges for three years while teu article 19 3 says the court of justice is the ultimate court to interpret questions of eu law in practice most eu law is applied by member state courts e g the german bundesgerichtshof the belgian cour du travail and formerly the english court of appeal 66 member state courts can refer questions to the cjeu for a preliminary ruling the cjeu s duty is to ensure that in the interpretation and application of the treaties the law is observed although realistically it has the ability to expand and develop the law according to the principles it develops consistently with democratic values examples of landmark and frequently controversial judgments include van gend en loos holding eu law to created a new legal order and citizens could sue for treaty rights 67 mangold v helm establishing equality as a general principle of eu law 68 and kadi v commission confirming international law had to conform with basic principles of eu law 69 until 2016 there was the european union civil service tribunal which dealt with eu institutions staff issues the court of justice of the eu in luxembourg the statute of the court and tfeu require judges are appointed only if they have no political occupation with independence beyond doubt 70 they are selected for renewable six year terms by common accord of governments with the advice of seven eu or member state judges that the council and parliament selects 71 the rules of procedure of the court of justice article 11 says the court is usually organised into chambers of 3 or 5 judges each a grand chamber of 15 more senior judges sit on questions of difficulty or importance or those requested by member states 72 the court s president and vice president are elected by other judges for renewable 3 year terms by secret ballot judges can only be dismissed if all other judges and advocates general unanimously agree advocates general are appointed by the court to give reasoned submissions on cases especially involving new points of law unlike judges on the court they write opinions as themselves rather than collectively and often with a command of prose and reason and while not binding are often followed in practice 73 in addition each judge has secretaries or referendaires who research and write unlike the uk where judges always write their own opinions referendaires often assist drafting the judgments in the court of justice the court s translation directorate will translate every final judgment into the 24 official languages of the european union the three main kinds of judgments the court of justice gives following 1 preliminary rulings requested by the courts of member states 74 2 enforcement actions brought by the commission or member states against the eu a member state or any other party that is alleged to violate eu law 75 and 3 other direct actions where the eu or member state is involved as a party to the dispute and gives final rulings 76 the rules of procedure of the court of justice modelled on the international court of justice begin with submission of written cases to the court followed by a short oral hearing in each case a judge is designated to actively manage the hearing called a rapporteur and draft the judgment probably with help from referendaires the court always deliberates and votes before the final opinion is written and published cases in the general court can be appealed to the court of justice on points of law while there is no formal appeal procedure from the court of justice in practice its actions are subject to scrutiny by both the supreme courts of member states and the european court of human rights even if the final balance of power is unresolved conflict of laws edit v t e eu law primacy cases van gend en loos v ned belastingen 1963 costa v enel 1964 amm delle finanze v simmenthal spa 1978 macarthys v smith 1979 3 all er 325 r factortame ltd v secretary of state for transport 1990 r hs2 action alliance ltd v ss for transport 2014 uksc 3 solange i 1970 solange ii 1987 3 cmlr 225 case k 18 04 2005 case k 3 21 2021 see law of the european union main articles primacy of european union law and conflict of laws since its founding the eu has operated among an increasing plurality of member state and globalising legal systems 77 this has meant both the european court of justice and the supreme courts of the states have had to develop principles to resolve conflicts of laws between different systems within the eu itself the court of justice s view is that if union law conflicts with a provision of state law then union law has primacy in the first major case in 1964 costa v enel a milanese lawyer and former shareholder of an energy company named mr costa refused to pay his electricity bill to enel as a protest against the nationalization of the italian energy corporations 78 he claimed the italian nationalisation law conflicted with the treaty of rome f and requested a reference be made to both the italian constitutional court and the court of justice under tfeu article 267 79 the italian constitutional court gave an opinion that because the nationalisation law was from 1962 and the treaty was in force from 1958 costa had no claim by contrast the court of justice held that ultimately the treaty of rome in no way prevented energy nationalisation and in any case under the treaty provisions only the commission could have brought a claim not mr costa however in principle mr costa was entitled to plead that the treaty conflicted with national law and the court would have a duty to consider his claim to make a reference if there would be no appeal against its decision the court of justice repeating its view in van gend en loos 80 said member states have limited their sovereign rights albeit within limited fields and have thus created a body of law which binds both their nationals and themselves 81 on the basis of reciprocity 81 eu law would not be overridden by domestic legal provisions however framed without the legal basis of the community itself being called into question this meant any subsequent unilateral act of the member state inapplicable 82 similarly in amministrazione delle finanze dello stato v simmenthal spa a company simmenthal spa claimed that a public health inspection fee under an italian law of 1970 for importing beef from france to italy was contrary to two regulations from 1964 and 1968 in accordance with the principle of the precedence of community law said the court of justice the directly applicable measures of the institutions such as the regulations in the case render automatically inapplicable any conflicting provision of current national law this was necessary to prevent a corresponding denial of treaty obligations undertaken unconditionally and irrevocably by member states that could imperil the very foundations of the eu 83 but despite the views of the court of justice the national courts of member states have not accepted the same analysis citation needed generally speaking while all member states recognise that eu law takes primacy over national law where this agreed in the treaties they do not accept that the court of justice has the final say on foundational constitutional questions affecting democracy and human rights the view of the german constitutional court from the solange i and solange ii decisions is that if the eu does not comply with its basic constitutional rights and principles particularly democracy the rule of law and the social state principles 84 then it cannot override german law 85 however as the nicknames of the judgments go so long as the eu works towards the democratisation of its institutions and has a framework that protects fundamental human rights it would not review eu legislation for compatibility with german constitutional principles 86 most other member states have expressed similar reservations this suggests the eu s legitimacy rests on the ultimate authority of member states its factual commitment to human rights and the democratic will of the people citation needed the eu complies with international law and the european convention on human rights so long as international law institutions like the united nations themselves comply with basic human rights 87 as opposed to the member states the relation of eu law and international law is debated particularly relating to the european convention on human rights and the united nations all individual eu member states are party to both organisations through international treaties the treaty on european union article 6 2 required the eu to accede to the echr but would not affect the union s competences as defined in the treaties this was thought necessary before the treaty of lisbon to ensure that the eu gave adequate protection to human rights overseen by the external european court of human rights in strasbourg however in opinion 2 13 after a request by the commission to review their plan to accede the court of justice in luxembourg produced five main reasons why it felt that the accession agreement as it stood was incompatible with the treaties 88 in summary these were it 1 undermined the cjeu s autonomy 2 allowed for a parallel dispute resolution mechanism among member states when the treaties said the cjeu should be the sole arbiter 3 the co respondent system allowing the eu and member states to be sued together allowed the ecthr to illegitimately interpret eu law and allocate responsibility between the eu and member states 4 did not allow the court of justice to decide if an issue of law was already dealt with before the echr heard a case and 5 the ecthr was illegitimately being given power of judicial review over common foreign and security policy the reasoning was regarded by a majority of commentators as thinly veiled attempt of the court of justice to clutch onto its own power 89 but it has meant the commission is redrafting a new accession agreement under teu articles 3 5 21 34 and 42 the eu must also respect the principles of the united nations charter after the september 11 attacks on the world trade center in new york city the un security council adopted a resolution to freeze the assets of suspected terrorists linked to osama bin laden this included a saudi national mr kadi sweden froze his assets pursuant to an eu regulation which gave effect to the un security council resolution in kadi v commission mr kadi claimed there was no evidence that he was connected to terrorism and he had not had a fair trial a fundamental human right 90 the opinion of ag maduro recalled aharon barak of the supreme court of israel that it is when the cannons roar that we especially need the laws the court of justice held that even un member cannot contravene the principles that form part of the very community legal order 91 in effect the eu has developed a rule that within the boundaries of certain jus cogens principles other courts may take primacy the content of those core principles remains open to ongoing judicial dialogue among the senior courts in the union citation needed administrative law edit see also administrative law and united states administrative law the european court of human rights in strasbourg europe s highest human rights authority uses the flag of europe but is not part of the eu all eu member states are in the european convention and the eu treaties require it to join but the court of justice has delayed 92 while constitutional law concerns the european union s governance structure administrative law binds eu institutions and member state governments to follow the law both member states and the commission have a general legal right or standing locus standi to bring claims against eu institutions and other member states for breach of the treaties from the eu s foundation the court of justice also held that the treaties allowed citizens or corporations to bring claims against eu and member state institutions for violation of the treaties and regulations if they were properly ...
|
