Meta tags:
Headings (most frequently used words):
libertarian, libertarianism, perspectives, on, intellectual, property, contents, left, propertarianism, right, ayn, rand, political, parties, see, also, references,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (109), and (60), property (43), #intellectual (34), #libertarian (30), that (27), from (21), for (21), january (19), 2025 (18), libertarianism (18), retrieved (18), rights (14), copyright (14), free (12), patent (11), capitalism (10), right (10), patents (10), are (10), edit (10), this (9), anarchism (9), kinsella (9), 978 (9), isbn (9), other (8), party (8), open (8), pdf (8), their (8), libertarians (8), wikipedia (7), use (7), market (7), left (7), anti (7), books (7), people (7), software (7), against (7), original (7), archived (7), rand (7), would (7), research (7), with (6), law (6), state (6), new (6), works (6), anarcho (6), rothbard (6), association (6), freedom (6), library (6), ayn (6), via (6), google (6), copyrights (6), not (6), can (6), code (5), page (5), public (5), liberty (5), political (5), mises (5), friedman (5), anarchist (5), laws (5), all (5), russia (5), american (5), which (5), who (5), argued (5), contents (4), search (4), terms (4), cs1 (4), russian (4), parties (4), tucker (4), copyleft (4), music (4), movement (4), infringement (4), ideal (4), his (4), stephan (4), institute (4), 933550 (4), man (4), anarchists (4), further (4), oppose (4), also (4), what (4), such (4), only (4), century (4), hide (4), move (4), sidebar (4), perspectives (3), view (3), legal (3), about (3), policy (3), may (3), foundation (3), commons (3), was (3), articles (3), portal (3), government (3), liberalism (3), abolitionism (3), states (3), book (3), mcelroy (3), read (3), philosophical (3), individualist (3), propertarianism (3), classical (3), society (3), work (3), culture (3), knowledge (3), pro (3), instead (3), content (3), through (3), production (3), domain (3), file (3), labor (3), canada (3), york (3), unknown (3), 2008 (3), 2009 (3), tannehill (3), murray (3), power (3), september (3), 2002 (3), long (3), capitalists (3), see (3), resources (3), press (3), too (3), writes (3), its (3), but (3), inventor (3), mind (3), mental (3), physical (3), effort (3), material (3), form (3), thus (3), any (3), since (3), information (3), tools (3), main (3), languages (2), toggle (2), table (2), contact (2), privacy (2), available (2), apply (2), using (2), site (2), you (2), registered (2), organization (2), creative (2), license (2), august (2), categories (2), language (2), maint (2), location (2), missing (2), publisher (2), short (2), description (2), different (2), wikidata (2), activism (2), economics (2), choice (2), science (2), fiction (2), cultural (2), studies (2), related (2), united (2), origins (2), 1980 (2), freed (2), choose (2), anarchy (2), 1973 (2), legislation (2), manifesto (2), objectivism (2), intervention (2), minarchism (2), action (2), issues (2), paul (2), korwin (2), mikke (2), spooner (2), george (2), nozick (2), hoppe (2), wing (2), proudhon (2), green (2), marxism (2), socialism (2), feminism (2), neo (2), natural (2), workers (2), self (2), management (2), voluntary (2), civil (2), concepts (2), internet (2), own (2), good (2), copy (2), aaron (2), peter (2), pirate (2), electronic (2), recording (2), federation (2), theft (2), source (2), positions (2), based (2), commercial (2), system (2), digital (2), program (2), 2024 (2), 2012 (2), 2014 (2), platform (2), 1966 (2), 1st (2), 451 (2), 14795 (2), david (2), father (2), december (2), palmer (2), tom (2), doi (2), wendy (2), morris (2), linda (2), 2022 (2), economy (2), chapter (2), monopoly (2), competition (2), encyclopedia (2), lists (2), favor (2), views (2), liberals (2), link (2), cite (2), benjamin (2), one (2), section (2), current (2), references (2), term (2), takes (2), proposed (2), privilege (2), granted (2), held (2), lead (2), reward (2), unearned (2), support (2), consider (2), had (2), descendants (2), inventors (2), should (2), she (2), wrote (2), every (2), thought (2), into (2), these (2), end (2), minimal (2), role (2), existence (2), could (2), insurance (2), unauthorized (2), invention (2), theoretical (2), argues (2), others (2), arguing (2), there (2), protecting (2), expenditures (2), enough (2), discouraged (2), general (2), because (2), period (2), authors (2), most (2), 19th (2), influenced (2), propertarians (2), appearance (2), upload (2), changes (2), links (2), history (2), article (2), log (2), create (2), account (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, mobile, cookie, statement, statistics, developers, conduct, safety, contacts, disclaimers, text, under, additional, agree, trademark, non, profit, wikimedia, inc, attribution, sharealike, rendered, parsoid, last, edited, 2026, utc, hidden, sources, uses, script, mdy, dates, controversies, within, https, org, index, php, title, libertarian_perspectives_on_intellectual_property, oldid, 1371916724, outline, small, theory, authoritarian, spectrum, economic, constitutionalism, conscientious, objector, center, austro, republicans, democrats, kingdom, country, republicanism, aristotelianism, age, enlightenment, series, 1974, utopia, 1979, 1970, war, drugs, theories, alliances, lgbt, internal, debates, immigration, foreign, capital, punishment, autarchy, versus, affirmative, abortion, vanopslagh, seymour, sarwark, milei, massie, madelin, lindner, klaus, jorgensen, johnson, jacobs, hannan, coolidge, cleveland, bernier, politicians, thoreau, szasz, stirner, satoshi, nakamoto, paine, boétie, konkin, hess, emerson, stossel, spencer, simon, paterson, nock, molinari, von, lane, jillette, herbert, hayek, goldwater, brennan, block, bastiat, warren, öcalan, marcuse, kropotkin, hodgskin, guérin, goldman, godwin, fourier, déjacque, cleyre, chomsky, camus, bookchin, bakunin, philosophers, bleeding, heart, agorism, geolibertarianism, egoist, syncretic, syndicalism, mao, spontex, communism, guild, communization, communalism, autonomism, syndicalist, social, queer, pacifist, mutualist, insurrectionary, communist, collectivist, black, voluntaryism, transhumanism, crypto, techno, paternalism, paleo, conservative, consequentialist, christian, fusionism, autarchism, schools, councils, stateless, ownership, refusal, individual, reclamation, individualism, illegalism, contract, federalism, expropriative, decentralization, counter, statism, cyberspace, chokepoint, tpb, afk, boy, steal, film, rip, remix, bad, documentaries, jack, valenti, swartz, sunde, suber, richard, stallman, pamela, samuelson, lawrence, lessig, rick, falkvinge, alexandra, elbakyan, cory, doctorow, students, shadow, sci, hub, piratbyrån, bay, transformative, group, genesis, frontier, anna, archive, industry, america, motion, picture, future, coalition, alliance, australian, screen, organizations, environmentalism, access, movements, video, demand, sound, share, alike, contests, prizes, hardware, model, design, sell, peer, business, models, notice, alternative, compensation, reversed, trolling, debate, biological, bioprospecting, biopiracy, orphan, piracy, monopolies, videos, novel, mashup, aspects, sharing, gripe, vidding, games, films, cosplay, art, fan, fair, troll, censorship, artificial, scarcity, october, 2020, programma, politicheskoy, partii, libertarianskaya, partiya, rossii, программа, политической, партии, либертарианская, партия, россии, 127, 125, wile, anthony, april, daily, bell, famous, solutions, bouillon, hardy, note, externalities, hülsmann, jörg, guido, eds, 157, essays, honor, hans, hermann, 1990, 1515, 9780295803661, 009, harvard, journal, morally, justified, philosophy, objects, 2011, papers, contra, again, 1993, san, francisco, fox, wilkes, 610163, great, problem, solver, november, triangular, steelman, thousand, oaks, california, sage, publications, 750831024, oclc, 2008009151, lccn, 1412965804, 4135, 9781412965811, n220, 250, 249, robert, 1938, hamowy, ronald, roderik, nation, case, discussion, various, matter, four, historical, phases, attorneys, 2023, houston, papinian, reader, critiques, 1893, busy, write, fragmentary, exposition, mckay, iain, edinburgh, 84935, 122, faq, why, ctea, extension, act, moderate, approach, calling, careful, review, existing, accordingly, enforced, violence, basis, intends, repeal, well, provide, sanctions, criminal, administrative, offenses, were, perpetuity, opposite, very, principle, earned, achievement, parasitism, become, cumulative, lien, unborn, generations, ultimately, paralyze, them, happen, producing, automobile, pay, royalties, involved, starting, wheel, apart, impossibility, keeping, records, accidental, status, unreality, claims, limited, implementation, base, product, type, productive, involves, combination, translate, proportion, two, elements, varies, types, lowest, scale, required, perform, unskilled, manual, acknowledge, paramount, values, protect, contribution, purest, origination, subject, establishes, has, brought, idea, founder, herself, significant, influence, prior, department, her, circle, supported, ideas, inventions, privately, owned, data, bank, then, buy, company, guarantee, compensate, losses, suffered, due, stop, opponents, include, observes, inefficient, they, divert, development, filing, lawsuits, patented, easily, practical, relatively, underfunded, moreover, scarce, way, implemented, limiting, neutral, stance, arguments, both, sides, question, neil, schulman, jeffrey, boudewijn, bouckaert, henri, lepage, even, ideological, framework, requires, functions, served, promulgation, enforcement, provided, private, sector, institutions, allowing, contractually, arising, infinite, need, involvement, defining, arbitrary, limits, duration, scope, order, promote, progress, useful, arts, inherently, problematic, saying, standard, judge, much, little, just, actually, hinder, innovation, competitors, indefinitely, area, covered, courts, hold, improvements, infringements, previous, holder, engaging, field, discourages, improvement, entire, assurance, competitor, trespass, 21st, concept, holds, prohibiting, reproducing, trading, copyrighted, exists, minds, cannot, without, owning, publishers, continue, produce, absent, protection, cites, fact, hundreds, thousands, uploaded, onto, day, anyone, world, nearly, written, before, 20th, yet, pre, 1900, still, published, sold, speech, roderick, dating, back, considered, part, broad, opposing, consists, extort, enormously, excess, measure, services, words, giving, certain, years, facts, nature, exact, tribute, wealth, another, strongly, while, distinguished, between, henry, lysander, criticism, socialist, pierre, joseph, have, differing, opinions, validity, whereas, among, more, nuance, ranging, strong, opposition, neutrality, particularly, those, item, projects, printable, version, download, print, export, switch, legacy, parser, get, shortened, url, permanent, here, actions, english, talk, русский, português, español, esperanto, top, personal, special, pages, recent, community, learn, help, contribute, random, events, navigation, jump,
Text of the page (random words):
intellectual property as part of their broad criticism of capitalism and anti capitalism 1 benjamin tucker a 19th century american individualist anarchist opposing intellectual property argued that the patent monopoly consists in protecting inventors against competition for a period long enough to extort from the people a reward enormously in excess of the labor measure of their services in other words in giving certain people a right of property for a term of years in laws and facts of nature and the power to exact tribute from others for the use of this natural wealth which should be open to all 2 lysander spooner another 19th century american individualist anarchist or left libertarian who also influenced propertarians right libertarians argued strongly for patents 3 while henry george distinguished between patents and copyrights 3 into the 21st century roderick t long argues that the concept of intellectual property is not libertarian he holds that prohibiting people from using reproducing and trading copyrighted material is an infringement of freedom of speech and freedom of the press and that since information exists in people s minds and other people s property one cannot own information without owning other people arguing that authors and publishers would continue to produce absent copyright protection he cites the fact that hundreds of thousands of articles are uploaded onto the internet by their authors every day available to anyone in the world for free and that nearly all works written before the 20th century are in the public domain yet pre 1900 works are still published and sold 4 5 propertarianism right libertarianism edit anarcho capitalists oppose the existence of even a minimal state this ideological framework requires that any functions served by intellectual property law promulgation and enforcement be provided through private sector institutions murray rothbard argued for allowing contractually arising infinite copyright terms and against the need for any government role in protecting intellectual property 6 rothbard states that government s involvement in defining arbitrary limits on the duration and scope of intellectual property in order to promote the progress of science and useful arts is inherently problematic saying by what standard do you judge that research expenditures are too much too little or just about enough 7 thus he argued that intellectual property laws can actually hinder innovation since competitors can be indefinitely discouraged from further research expenditures in the general area covered by the patent because the courts may hold their improvements as infringements on the previous patent and the patent holder is discouraged from engaging in further research in this field because the privilege discourages improvement of their invention for the entire period of the patent with the assurance that no competitor can trespass on their domain 7 morris and linda tannehill proposed that ideas in the form of inventions could be registered in a privately owned data bank the inventor could then buy insurance against the theft and unauthorized commercial use of the invention and the insurance company would guarantee to not only compensate the inventor for any losses suffered due to such infringement but to stop such unauthorized use 8 opponents to intellectual property rights include wendy mcelroy 9 tom g palmer 10 henri lepage boudewijn bouckaert jeffrey tucker and stephan kinsella 11 kinsella observes in against intellectual property that patents may be inefficient since they divert resources from research and development to patent filing and lawsuits he writes that theoretical research can not be patented as easily as practical research and thus theoretical research is relatively underfunded moreover he argues that property rights can only apply to resources that are scarce which intellectual property is not kinsella also states that the only way that intellectual property rights can be implemented is by limiting others physical property rights 12 david d friedman takes a neutral stance on intellectual property arguing that there are good arguments on both sides of that question 13 j neil schulman instead argued in favor of intellectual property 3 ayn rand edit ayn rand the founder of objectivism who herself was not a libertarian but who had a significant influence on rothbard prior to his department from her philosophical studies circle and other right libertarians supported copyrights and patents 14 in capitalism the unknown ideal she wrote patents and copyrights are the legal implementation of the base of all property rights a man s right to the product of his mind every type of productive work involves a combination of mental and of physical effort of thought and of physical action to translate that thought into a material form the proportion of these two elements varies in different types of work at the lowest end of the scale the mental effort required to perform unskilled manual labor is minimal at the other end what the patent and copyright laws acknowledge is the paramount role of mental effort in the production of material values these laws protect the mind s contribution in its purest form the origination of an idea the subject of patents and copyrights is intellectual property thus the law establishes the property right of a mind to that which it has brought in existence 14 rand held that patent should be granted for limited terms only 15 she wrote if it were held in perpetuity it would lead to the opposite of the very principle on which it is based it would lead not to the earned reward of achievement but to the unearned support of parasitism it would become a cumulative lien on the production of unborn generations which would ultimately paralyze them consider what would happen if in producing an automobile we had to pay royalties to the descendants of all the inventors involved starting with the inventor of the wheel and on up apart from the impossibility of keeping such records consider the accidental status of such descendants and the unreality of their unearned claims 15 libertarian political parties edit the libertarian party of canada takes a moderate approach to patents and copyrights calling for a careful review of existing and proposed legislation 16 the libertarian party of russia writes in its platform that intellectual property is a privilege granted by the state accordingly intellectual property rights are enforced by the state through violence on this basis it writes in its program that it intends to repeal the section of the civil code of russia as well as the articles of the code of the russian federation on administrative offenses and criminal code of russia that provide for sanctions for infringement of intellectual property rights 17 see also edit libertarianism portal copyleft copyright term extension act ctea references edit mckay iain ed 2008 section b why do anarchists oppose the current system an anarchist faq edinburgh ak press isbn 978 1 84935 122 5 archived from the original on december 8 2024 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books tucker benjamin 1893 instead of a book by a man too busy to write one a fragmentary exposition of philosophical anarchism new york p 13 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books cite book cs1 maint location missing publisher link 1 2 3 kinsella stephan ed 2023 the anti ip reader free market critiques of intellectual property houston papinian press retrieved january 17 2025 in classical liberals and anarchists on intellectual property kinsella lists anarchists classical liberals anarcho capitalists and american libertarians and their positions on intellectual property in pro ip anarchists and anti ip patent attorneys kinsella lists further anarcho capitalists in favor of intellectual property for further discussion of the views of various libertarians on this matter see his anti ip resources the four historical phases of ip abolitionism and the origins of libertarian ip abolitionism long roderik t september 14 2002 the libertarian case against intellectual property rights libertarian nation archived from the original on september 14 2002 retrieved january 17 2025 steelman aaron 2008 intellectual property in hamowy ronald ed nozick robert 1938 2002 the encyclopedia of libertarianism thousand oaks california sage publications pp 249 250 doi 10 4135 9781412965811 n220 isbn 978 1412965804 lccn 2008009151 oclc 750831024 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books rothbard murray 2009 chapter 3 triangular intervention man economy and state with power and market mises institute isbn 978 1 933550 27 5 archived from the original on september 29 2022 retrieved january 17 2025 1 2 rothbard murray 2009 chapter 10 monopoly and competition man economy and state with power and market mises institute isbn 978 1 933550 27 5 archived from the original on november 27 2022 retrieved january 17 2025 tannehill morris tannehill linda 1993 property the great problem solver the market for liberty san francisco fox wilkes pp 58 59 isbn 978 1 610163 95 8 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books mcelroy wendy 2011 contra copyright again pdf libertarian papers 3 12 retrieved january 17 2025 palmer tom g 1990 are patents and copyrights morally justified the philosophy of property rights and ideal objects pdf harvard journal of law and public policy 13 3 doi 10 1515 9780295803661 009 retrieved january 17 2025 bouillon hardy 2009 a note on intellectual property and externalities in hülsmann jörg guido kinsella stephan eds property freedom and society essays in honor of hans hermann hoppe pdf mises institute p 157 isbn 978 1 933550 52 7 retrieved january 17 2025 kinsella stephan 2008 against intellectual property pdf mises institute isbn 978 1 933550 32 9 archived from the original pdf on december 16 2014 retrieved january 17 2025 wile anthony april 8 2012 david d friedman on his famous father anarcho capitalism and free market solutions the daily bell retrieved january 17 2025 1 2 rand ayn 1966 capitalism the unknown ideal 1st ed new york new american library p 125 isbn 978 0 451 14795 0 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books 1 2 rand ayn 1966 capitalism the unknown ideal 1st ed new york new american library p 127 isbn 978 0 451 14795 0 retrieved january 17 2025 via google books platform of the libertarian party of canada libertarian party of canada 2012 archived from the original on january 11 2014 retrieved january 17 2025 programma politicheskoy partii libertarianskaya partiya rossii программа политической партии либертарианская партия россии program of the political party libertarian party of russia pdf in russian libertarian party of russia october 31 2020 archived pdf from the original on august 30 2024 retrieved january 17 2025 v t e intellectual property activism issues artificial scarcity censorship by copyright copyright infringement copyright troll digital rights management fair use fan labor art cosplay fiction films games vidding gripe site legal aspects of file sharing mashup digital music novel videos monopolies of knowledge music piracy orphan works biopiracy bioprospecting patents biological software software patent debate trolling public domain concepts all rights reversed alternative compensation system anti copyright notice business models for open source software copyleft commercial use of copyleft works commons based peer production electronic sell through free content free software license libertarian positions open content open design movement open music model open patent open source hardware software prizes instead of patents contests share alike sound recording copyright video on demand movements access to knowledge movement anti copyright cultural environmentalism free culture movement free software movement organizations pro copyright australian screen association copyright alliance federation against copyright theft future of music coalition motion picture association recording industry association of america pro copyleft anna s archive creative commons electronic frontier foundation free software foundation library genesis open rights group organization for transformative works the anarchist library the pirate bay piratbyrån pirate party public knowledge sci hub shadow library students for free culture z library people cory doctorow alexandra elbakyan rick falkvinge lawrence lessig pamela samuelson richard stallman peter suber peter sunde aaron swartz jack valenti documentaries good copy bad copy rip a remix manifesto steal this film the internet s own boy tpb afk books chokepoint capitalism code and other laws of cyberspace free culture v t e libertarianism concepts anti statism civil libertarianism counter economics decentralization expropriative anarchism federalism anarchist free association marxism and anarchism freedom of association freedom of choice freedom of contract illegalism individualism individual reclamation liberty refusal of work self ownership stateless society voluntary association voluntary society workers councils workers self management schools right libertarianism anarcho capitalism autarchism fusionism christian consequentialist conservative feminism natural rights neo paleo paternalism techno crypto transhumanism minarchism neo classical liberalism propertarianism voluntaryism left libertarianism anarchism black collectivist communist feminism green individualist insurrectionary mutualist pacifist philosophical queer social syndicalist autonomism communalism communization libertarian socialism guild socialism libertarian communism libertarian marxism mao spontex syndicalism syncretic egoist anarchism geolibertarianism green libertarianism market anarchism agorism bleeding heart libertarianism philosophers left wing bakunin bookchin camus chomsky cleyre déjacque fourier godwin goldman guérin hodgskin kropotkin marcuse öcalan proudhon warren tucker right wing bastiat block brennan d friedman m friedman r friedman goldwater hayek herbert hoppe jillette kinsella korwin mikke lane von mises de molinari nock nozick paterson read rothbard simon spencer stossel other emerson george hess konkin de la boétie mcelroy paine satoshi nakamoto spooner stirner szasz thoreau politicians bernier cleveland coolidge hannan jacobs johnson jorgensen klaus lindner korwin mikke madelin massie milei paul sr paul jr sarwark seymour vanopslagh wu issues abortion affirmative action anarchism and capitalism anarcho capitalism and minarchism autarchy versus anarchy capital punishment foreign intervention immigration intellectual property internal debates lgbt rights objectivism political alliances political parties theories of law war on drugs works the market for liberty 1970 for a new liberty the libertarian manifesto 1973 law legislation and liberty 1973 1979 anarchy state and utopia 1974 freed to choose 1980 book freed to choose 1980 tv series origins age of enlightenment anarchism aristotelianism repu...
|
