Meta tags:
description= In search of disinterested science;
Headings (most frequently used words):
science, share, this, about, to, the, from, uncritical, skeptical, and, of, recent, hiv, aids, blunder, skepticism, medicine, in, search, disinterested, meta, archives, categories, comments, posts, subscribe, my, new, blog, at, substack, organized, so, called, skeptics, groups, follow, loch, ness, monster, its, real, important, significance, banality, evil, modern, medical, practices, missed, opportunities, for, mainstream, research, self, correct, is,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (483), and (281), #science (178), that (155), for (109), new (82), about (81), scientific (71), share (71), not (64), opens (60), window (60), hiv (58), had (57), was (53), with (51), are (50), from (49), research (46), aids (46), what (40), been (39), how (38), more (35), but (34), has (31), this (28), were (28), scientists (27), society (27), who (27), wrong (26), like (25), loch (25), ness (25), medical (23), their (23), there (23), medicine (22), some (22), one (22), have (21), well (21), those (21), velikovsky (21), other (20), posted (20), pinterest (20), reddit (20), tumblr (20), linkedin (20), facebook (20), all (20), quite (20), which (20), even (19), would (19), many (19), can (19), consensus (19), henry (18), bauer (18), 2017 (17), why (17), evidence (17), matters (17), monster (16), grant (16), university (16), than (16), 2021 (16), truth (16), interest (15), change (15), when (15), called (15), people (15), several (15), public (15), among (14), fact (14), out (14), 2014 (14), journal (14), exploration (14), belief (14), may (14), also (14), dogmatism (14), human (13), book (13), into (13), published (13), case (13), they (13), example (13), facts (13), media (13), practices (13), mainstream (13), only (12), see (12), much (12), first (12), because (12), comments (12), topics (12), skeptics (12), global (12), any (12), official (12), most (12), funds (11), press (11), grants (11), researchers (11), time (11), history (11), such (11), should (11), court (11), drugs (11), 2018 (11), com (10), now (10), loading (10), 2012 (10), something (10), including (10), groups (10), its (10), mcfarland (10), learning (10), theory (10), drug (10), 2020 (10), 2013 (10), view (9), tagged (9), culture (9), june (9), 2015 (9), could (9), things (9), over (9), then (9), pseudo (9), policy (9), books (9), needed (9), sse (9), does (9), individuals (9), climate (9), based (9), blood (9), blog (8), funding (8), national (8), sciences (8), data (8), chemistry (8), enough (8), still (8), often (8), without (8), social (8), particular (8), after (8), these (8), general (8), study (8), views (8), unwarranted (8), beliefs (8), july (8), august (8), organized (8), january (8), fraud (7), nih (7), began (7), our (7), nsf (7), years (7), great (7), best (7), universities (7), particularly (7), taken (7), them (7), self (7), proper (7), state (7), led (7), point (7), part (7), will (7), training (7), skeptical (7), illinois (7), you (7), interdisciplinary (7), political (7), warming (7), contemporary (7), reality (7), cause (7), having (7), significance (7), important (7), likely (7), 2007 (7), positive (7), present (7), become (7), march (7), vaccines (7), pressure (7), april (7), https (7), already (6), increasing (6), age (6), discovery (6), seemed (6), increased (6), number (6), institutions (6), too (6), made (6), long (6), available (6), pundits (6), find (6), truzzi (6), interested (6), learned (6), knowledge (6), affair (6), technology (6), found (6), dogmatic (6), claims (6), real (6), obvious (6), majority (6), 1987 (6), actions (6), further (6), rather (6), specific (6), through (6), chapter (6), against (6), february (6), robert (6), october (6), day (6), cancer (6), truths (6), risk (6), evil (6), authorities (6), modern (6), recognized (6), aluminum (6), substack (6), 2019 (6), wordpress (5), skepticism (5), leave (5), faculty (5), career (5), early (5), 1970s (5), phd (5), graduate (5), flying (5), yet (5), year (5), least (5), necessary (5), became (5), costs (5), members (5), federal (5), brought (5), support (5), during (5), since (5), make (5), academic (5), health (5), average (5), far (5), activity (5), resistance (5), politics (5), making (5), controversy (5), dean (5), changed (5), world (5), war (5), come (5), ufos (5), ignored (5), dismissed (5), investigation (5), another (5), few (5), later (5), came (5), community (5), good (5), did (5), understanding (5), large (5), widely (5), understand (5), know (5), posts (5), csicop (5), nowadays (5), controversies (5), theories (5), causes (5), numbers (5), recognize (5), interests (5), within (5), articles (5), misleading (5), controversial (5), being (5), mistaken (5), increasingly (5), checking (5), background (5), while (5), peter (5), duesberg (5), virus (5), cdc (5), mortality (5), gallo (5), statistical (5), pervasive (5), hpv (5), harmful (5), prescribing (5), november (5), december (5), september (5), subscribe (4), comment (4), conflicts (4), cited (4), michael (4), fundamental (4), rate (4), off (4), insights (4), american (4), job (4), students (4), doing (4), 1960s (4), high (4), naturally (4), money (4), 1980s (4), soon (4), founded (4), paid (4), academics (4), publications (4), carried (4), physical (4), summer (4), certain (4), administration (4), use (4), effect (4), perhaps (4), treated (4), established (4), philosophy (4), certainly (4), easy (4), san (4), francisco (4), way (4), highly (4), sea (4), department (4), arts (4), uncritical (4), places (4), 1986 (4), mystery (4), beyond (4), think (4), trust (4), fixed (4), psychic (4), phenomena (4), substantive (4), sheer (4), group (4), two (4), marcello (4), discussions (4), indeed (4), virginia (4), failed (4), significant (4), sometimes (4), sts (4), illustrated (4), claim (4), details (4), everyone (4), nature (4), never (4), look (4), popular (4), earth (4), set (4), wanted (4), ignores (4), etc (4), trying (4), scientism (4), search (4), ever (4), monsters (4), minority (4), remains (4), different (4), living (4), origin (4), life (4), steady (4), accepted (4), competent (4), missed (4), factor (4), seeking (4), though (4), pertinent (4), 2006 (4), experts (4), granted (4), gay (4), recent (4), test (4), result (4), episode (4), uncategorized (4), flaws (4), john (4), authors (4), correlation (4), smith (4), statistics (4), patients (4), used (4), cholesterol (4), soul (4), carbon (4), dioxide (4), henryhbauer (4), 2016 (4), report (3), log (3), sign (3), entries (3), growth (3), competition (3), academy (3), century (3), ways (3), bringing (3), down (3), work (3), continually (3), journals (3), page (3), charges (3), commercial (3), publishers (3), access (3), researcher (3), salary (3), non (3), funded (3), practice (3), doubt (3), side (3), physicists (3), eventually (3), sociology (3), personal (3), almost (3), teaching (3), before (3), amounts (3), just (3), possible (3), asked (3), stock (3), kentucky (3), mid (3), late (3), every (3), applicants (3), themselves (3), dozen (3), name (3), united (3), states (3), fringe (3), 2002 (3), under (3), above (3), objects (3), denigrated (3), authoritative (3), engineers (3), scholars (3), sufficient (3), warrant (3), learn (3), review (3), deal (3), center (3), trustworthiness (3), between (3), want (3), looking (3), potential (3), full (3), tech (3), strong (3), technical (3), reading (3), couple (3), increases (3), very (3), information (3), together (3), disciplines (3), studies (3), earlier (3), included (3), unorthodox (3), criticisms (3), famously (3), struck (3), obviously (3), same (3), continuing (3), pseudoscience (3), england (3), english (3), opinion (3), noticed (3), overwhelming (3), journalists (3), examples (3), iconic (3), paranormal (3), dominant (3), monopolize (3), stifle (3), genuine (3), policies (3), suppression (3), his (3), said (3), variety (3), little (3), decades (3), written (3), surely (3), lack (3), shared (3), activists (3), typically (3), whole (3), danger (3), faith (3), respected (3), colleagues (3), problem (3), factual (3), crucial (3), happen (3), chance (3), reason (3), where (3), followed (3), successful (3), animals (3), correcting (3), demographic (3), characteristics (3), tests (3), questioning (3), persistence (3), failings (3), points (3), becomes (3), hodgkinson (3), always (3), past (3), york (3), country (3), especially (3), taking (3), entrenched (3), peer (3), misled (3), infection (3), fig (3), brundage (3), burke (3), dvm (3), infections (3), service (3), immunodeficiency (3), greene (3), failure (3), needs (3), need (3), officially (3), last (3), abuse (3), anyone (3), sources (3), ages (3), greatest (3), older (3), ensure (3), acceptance (3), correct (3), skyhorse (3), harm (3), administering (3), statins (3), levels (3), companies (3), means (3), believes (3), banality (3), nessie (3), joe (3), scarborough (3), eugenics (3), christopher (3), exley (3), expert (3), follow (3), gwup (3), edgar (3), wunder (3), worth (3), rss (3), oliver (3), sam (3), bacon (3), fake (3), get (2), site (2), collapse (2), subscriptions (2), subscribed (2), account (2), join (2), previous (2), phds (2), 1978 (2), 2001 (2), principal (2), investigators (2), levitt (2), future (2), base (2), plan (2), overhead (2), draws (2), proceedings (2), usa (2), analyses (2), recreational (2), leading (2), turned (2), market (2), collapsed (2), program (2), attract (2), went (2), end (2), project (2), relevant (2), fuel (2), cells (2), whose (2), unscrupulous (2), behavior (2), clear (2), itself (2), affected (2), trusted (2), societies (2), fees (2), tens (2), newly (2), professional (2), course (2), publication (2), benefits (2), administrative (2), actual (2), postdoctoral (2), percentage (2), psychologists (2), sociologists (2), economics (2), routinely (2), basis (2), three (2), appropriate (2), 70s (2), cultural (2), regarded (2), industry (2), might (2), observe (2), analyzing (2), foundation (2), 1966 (2), appointed (2), director (2), twice (2), four (2), times (2), refused (2), news (2), purposes (2), mathematicians (2), jobs (2), programs (2), designed (2), academe (2), production (2), demand (2), half (2), success (2), applications (2), decline (2), continued (2), institutes (2), source (2), biological (2), individual (2), major (2), liberal (2), colleges (2), 1950 (2), 1960 (2), professor (2), help (2), observed (2), consequences (2), ample (2), reprinted (2), immanuel (2), wipf (2), 1988 (2), 1984 (2), literature (2), winter (2), inquirer (2), enigma (2), sense (2), principle (2), literacy (2), method (2), worlds (2), collision (2), unidentified (2), saucers (2), believed (2), founding (2), read (2), manuscript (2), emerged (2), separate (2), sociologist (2), unorthodoxies (2), various (2), subjects (2), created (2), recently (2), projects (2), humanities (2), engineering (2), departments (2), courses (2), fields (2), allow (2), vpi (2), known (2), wider (2), changes (2), following (2), resulted (2), sound (2), historians (2), philosophers (2), centers (2), intellectual (2), works (2), both (2), getting (2), interesting (2), scenario (2), accomplished (2), nonsense (2), arrogantly (2), unscientifically (2), words (2), humanists (2), heard (2), inferred (2), myths (2), producing (2), effects (2), events (2), reported (2), red (2), direction (2), eminently (2), journalism (2), accumulates (2), fairly (2), reports (2), difficult (2), widespread (2), infatuation (2), apparently (2), shape (2), bigfoot (2), automatically (2), meant (2), makes (2), special (2), post (2), overlooked (2), writers (2), series (2), pale (2), denialism (2), committee (2), amateur (2), prominent (2), includes (2), criticized (2), existence (2), perfectly (2), natural (2), creatures (2), halton (2), arp (2), generally (2), explain (2), fusion (2), originally (2), nuclear (2), transformations (2), temperatures (2), energy (2), redshifts (2), freely (2), exactly (2), required (2), don (2), across (2), 1990s (2), taught (2), checked (2), actually (2), contrary (2), massive (2), damage (2), own (2), take (2), worse (2), earn (2), fascination (2), offered (2), gold (2), acknowledged (2), nothing (2), favored (2), paradigm (2), big (2), him (2), despite (2), analyzed (2), really (2), claimed (2), frustration (2), bond (2), corollary (2), commonly (2), opinions (2), defend (2), others (2), amount (2), effort (2), reaching (2), outside (2), here (2), blind (2), held (2), simply (2), picked (2), random (2), analogous (2), experience (2), insight (2), chemist (2), cosmopolitan (2), firmly (2), believe (2), existing (2), unknown (2), 2003 (2), iii (2), scientifically (2), disinformation (2), lied (2), historical (2), skeptic (2), physicians (2), dissenters (2), force (2), question (2), matter (2), officialdom (2), around (2), once (2), correction (2), opportunities (2), crankish (2), unique (2), investigative (2), crewdson (2), farber (2), shenton (2), realizing (2), cases (2), supposedly (2), earliest (2), men (2), los (2), angeles (2), assertion (2), army (2), teenagers (2), according (2), determined (2), mis (2), familiarity (2), consensuses (2), largely (2), described (2), comprehensive (2), illustrating (2), 900 (2), blunder (2), 1996 (2), 1985 (2), 1981 (2), cochrane (2), immunodeficiency (2), corps (2), donald (2), visintine (2), peterson (2), redfield (2), young (2), mary (2), gardner (2), military (2), acquired (2), 1989 (2), gøtzsche (2), kendrick (2), ravnskov (2), jama (2), epidemic (2), proportion (2), testing (2), gathering (2), say (2), doctors (2), mds (2), story (2), lesson (2), sorely (2), task (2), elementary (2), familiar (2), lessons (2), kaposi (2), sarcoma (2), stronger (2), needles (2), instances (2), finding (2), younger (2), females (2), males (2), disease (2), mistakenly (2), association (2), common (2), healthy (2), she (2), mistake (2), heckler (2), interference (2), incompetent (2), documented (2), politically (2), republican (2), gone (2), ideological (2), prescription (2), jeremy (2), trial (2), intentioned (2), dozens (2), perpetrated (2), statistically (2), pharmaceutical (2), rely (2), although (2), misguided (2), beneficial (2), body (2), direct (2), inevitably (2), insurance (2), namely (2), bring (2), happens (2), neither (2), fallibility (2), intention (2), analysis (2), fallible (2), immortal (2), description (2), turtles (2), unbiased (2), independent (2), network (2), less (2), importance (2), audience (2), offering (2), insightful (2), mass (2), lies (2), humankind (2), damaging (2), tell (2), gerhard (2), mayer (2), radin (2), issue (2), anomalistik (2), zeitschrift (2), seriously (2), resigned (2), issues (2), acs (2), blogging (2), hope (2), disagree (2), place (2), 2023 (2), predatory (2), feed (2), started, design, bar, manage, reader, content, privacy, subscribers, overproduction, paraview, 166, shaffer, distribution, aamc, school, r01, jonathan, biomedical, 114, 6498, 6503, jocelyn, kaiser, averages, reduce, payments, fire, fatal, attractions, troubles, doctorates, pay, entirely, unforeseeable, changing, economy, mentioned, pleasantly, personally, tail, collared, five, 1969, million, dollar, promise, fad, stakes, encourage, corner, cutting, outright, cheating, faking, hindsight, corrupted, willingly, greedily, visibly, dishonest, troubling, noticeably, flowed, obtain, traditionally, underwritten, membership, edited, remuneration, printing, postage, levy, dollars, per, periodicals, staff, editors, legitimate, second, class, status, displayed, header, footer, borne, siphoned, indirect, justifying, preferred, term, placed, greater, obligations, libraries, facilities, tasks, add, wages, tuition, defray, added, burdens, private, undesirable, arousing, enhancing, jealousy, determination, chemists, biologists, lobbying, 1957, seven, anthropology, hindered, additional, month, responsibilities, months, round, receive, getters, meet, meetings, desirable, locations, fun, games, socially, boisterous, traveling, sample, topless, bars, performance, norm, breaking, counter, musical, gordon, conferences, santa, barbara, using, small, recreation, business, travel, expenses, hair, specialty, enabled, analytical, enjoy, fishing, scuba, diving, caribbean, involved, water, perks, prepared, application, division, rewrote, budget, consulting, duration, costly, total, manager, pointed, requested, usual, faced, expressed, surprise, claiming, graduating, speculated, 2008, economic, crash, owed, lot, ingenious, trading, software, bad, mortgage, bundling, valuing, securities, working, wall, street, positions, presumably, unforeseen, consequence, pushing, wannabe, exceeding, supply, proposals, fallen, sort, main, fell, 1997, obtained, investigator, 2011, alone, ambition, flood, stimulate, transformation, teachers, morphed, 1944, 107, doctorate, granting, 142, 208, 307, 1970, doctoral, 1955, 1967, 165, 192, 1979, moving, australia, associate, spreading, wings, towards, gaining, recognition, excellence, expected, along, given, middle, enormous, infusion, resources, glimpsed, 1950s, stifling, 225, 246, macmillan, 128, 1992, 151, pen, josef, martin, 205, rise, memoirs, unreconstructed, myth, yeti, himalayas, mavericks, process, exchange, experiences, invited, planned, volume, proved, ambitious, again, extraordinarily, fortunate, sent, publisher, establishment, shaken, enhanced, uncertain, comparison, commanded, differences, professed, college, concentrate, degrees, initially, undergraduate, replaced, fledged, gather, informal, coursework, combining, agriculture, components, intended, field, basics, member, obligation, garner, mentor, consuming, thinking, applied, undemanding, intellectually, lucked, perfect, polytechnic, institute, formerly, everywhere, developments, scholarly, role, undergoing, vannevar, bush, dramatic, 1945, worked, manhattan, conscious, makers, planning, bulletin, atomic, president, move, establishing, joint, presaging, integration, actuality, usually, named, acronym, incarnations, zeitgeist, resolved, write, titled, setting, realities, right, altogether, prospects, gloomy, decided, permanent, plausible, convincing, ventured, unceremoniously, utter, declaration, attempting, address, saying, bothered, behaved, respects, psychoanalyst, seller, legends, heavenly, happenings, jupiter, ejected, comet, object, close, planets, bible, parting, walls, jericho, proposal, unsuccessful, reviewers, treats, reviewer, suggested, recruited, team, historian, philosopher, sure, baseless, accumulating, accommodate, fortuitously, happened, shortage, supposed, value, urging, develop, attracting, tangible, animal, publicized, underwater, photographs, flipper, paddle, appendages, indistinct, narrative, indirectly, similarly, dismisses, denigrates, calling, studying, differs, learns, rudyard, kipling, put, poem, flag, erroneous, seems, practicing, conundrum, retracing, evolution, current, disillusionment, synopsis, discussed, critiqued, 200, organization, 1976, predominantly, carl, sagan, publishes, interstellar, apeiron, 1998, earthquake, prediction, tectonics, continental, drift, adequately, topic, thought, phenomenon, ordinary, low, reactions, lenr, ncgt, seeing, cosmology, quasars, paradise, line, magnetic, healing, heterodoxies, distinguishes, alternative, focus, recall, alerted, dissent, proclaim, careerism, institutional, rampant, harmed, threaten, throughout, passionately, vindictive, idealistic, vision, distinguished, distinctly, prevailing, better, accused, espousing, whereas, oddball, hobbies, pursued, fashion, extent, forum, thomas, applauded, original, astrophysics, ideas, fossil, fuels, originated, deep, warm, ponds, surface, cosmos, bang, observational, astronomer, whereupon, telescopes, observations, indicate, earthquakes, predictable, electromagnetic, signals, geology, none, cold, intriguing, incompetently, prevalence, retrospect, insufferably, minor, played, rally, defense, specialized, disturbing, talked, wrote, speculations, benefited, constructive, mutual, criticism, incisive, overwhelmingly, disdain, wage, campaigns, purported, dangers, believing, purport, supporters, defenders, describe, grossly, misnomer, dogmatists, highest, order, unwilling, contemplate, stance, mind, stems, insist, religions, religious, sole, aptly, criticize, quarrels, behave, forming, dogmatically, advocates, friends, urge, maintained, observer, absorb, informed, wade, counterclaims, reasonably, firm, disbelief, looked, detail, characteristically, spot, imagining, remain, stimulus, seek, reliable, family, earning, happening, upon, begun, riffled, unplanned, next, wondered, face, didn, wondering, intelligent, educated, implausible, doubtful, start, fictive, imaginations, cryptozoology, biology, extinct, extant, heretical, relativity, unsound, spread, 2005, 567, 603, erratum, determines, frequency, discriminate, race, 255, morally, reprehensible, warranted, 116, 120, 378, russ, kick, 2009, remixed, guide, distortion, whitewashes, confession, denialist, crank, surgeons, quadrant, ibid, anomalist, refuses, engage, substantively, serve, engagement, disagreeing, arguments, cross, examination, disagreement, identified, clarified, publicly, openly, enable, rest, shed, supported, unlikely, cite, flat, earther, ish, journeys, reached, mine, beginning, era, saw, hand, match, journey, standing, lookout, entered, cities, chancing, recruits, female, male, tested, impossible, pedantic, obsession, check, whether, citation, collating, succession, corrected, ones, participation, suppresses, ruthlessly, indiscriminately, considerable, retired, library, axiomatic, satisfactory, substitute, perpetually, subjecting, nevertheless, incorporating, responses, describing, analyze, frustratedly, website, cites, chiefly, reviewed, detailed, answers, aims, fails, illustrates, brown, inventing, regnery, lauritsen, tables, obscure, connection, five, papers, asklepios, 1993, neville, fourth, estate, pneumocystis, pneumonia, 250, michelle, routledge, 2004, louis, george, conway, charles, hayman, carol, miller, lyle, petersen, timothy, dondero, disadvantaged, adolescents, findings, 266, 1991, 2387, adults, city, area, 232, goldenbaum, lytt, walter, reed, retrovirus, seroprevalence, 263, 1990, 2074, table, herbold, berner, gunzenhauser, voskovitch, redfield, civilian, 317, 131, retroviruses, carcinogens, pathogens, expectations, 1199, 220, syndrome, causation, 755, range, examine, shaped, dilemmas, broad, philosophical, questions, altman, ioannidis, matthews, listed, angell, brody, goldacre, lefanu, leitner, morbidity, weekly, propaganda, profiteering, genocide, industrial, complex, philadelphia, fictions, cover, dark, legacy, incapable, involves, loosely, engaged, recruitment, armed, forces, presumed, antiviral, regions, africa, accumulation, incompatible, contagious, irrelevant, carrying, reporting, dvms, trained, discount, able, transcend, lore, focuses, applying, contrast, covering, holistic, mindset, inadequate, competence, lacking, agency, central, misuse, clearest, policymakers, administrators, advice, acquaintance, incorporated, accepting, administrator, neglects, conundrums, purple, skin, patches, signature, rare, prostitutes, becoming, abusers, clean, exchanged, marriage, pregnancy, factors, primary, debunkings, latter, footnote, promising, rebuttal, eventuated, reminders, 233
Text of the page (random words):
there is no intention of offering that audience any genuinely insightful analysis or context or background information media attention span approximates that of twittering one television network asked for an instant interview wanted the best phone contact number even offered me compensation and then never followed up i did talk to one russian and one spanish station or network and i tried to point to what the real significance is of the loch ness animals namely that their existence has been denied by official scientific sources for not much less than a century demonstrating that official science can be wrong quite wrong and while that matters little if at all about loch ness i said it does matter greatly when official science is wrong about such matters of public importance as hiv aids or climate change about which official science does in fact happen to be wrong 3 so far however my bait about those important matters has not been snapped up misunderstandings about science are globally pervasive especially not realizing that it is fallible the consequent unwarranted acceptance of wrong beliefs about hiv and about carbon dioxide demonstrate the need for some institution independent of official science independent of existing scientific organizations and institutions to provide fact checking of contemporary scientific consensuses an impartial unbiased strictly evidence based assessments of official science in other words society sorely needs a science court 4 misconceptions about science can already be seen as a significant reason for flaws in the announced policies of the new biden administration as it places high priority on combating climate change and engaging in a moon shot to cure cancer having not learned any lessons from the failure of the war on cancer or from the fact obvious in great swaths of the geological literature that carbon dioxide is demonstrably not the prime cause of global warming since there is no correlation between global temperatures and carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere 5 neither over the whole life of the earth nor over the last couple of centuries 1 the enigma of loch ness making sense of a mystery university of illinois press 1986 88 wipf stock reprint 2012 genuine facts about nessie the loch ness monster 2 loch ness monsters as cryptid presently unknown sea turtles journal of scientific exploration 34 2020 93 104 3 dogmatism in science and medicine how dominant theories monopolize research and stifle the search for truth mcfarland 2012 the origin persistence and failings of hiv aids theory mcfarland 2007 4 science is not what you think how it has changed why we can t trust it how it can be fixed mcfarland 2017 chapter 12 the case for a science court science court why and what 5 a politically liberal global warming skeptic climate change facts temperature is not determined by carbon dioxide share this share on facebook opens in new window facebook share on linkedin opens in new window linkedin more share on tumblr opens in new window tumblr share on reddit opens in new window reddit share on x opens in new window x share on pinterest opens in new window pinterest like loading posted in consensus fraud in medicine fraud in science global warming media flaws politics and science resistance to discovery science is not truth science policy scientific culture unwarranted dogmatism in science tagged climate change hiv aids loch ness monster nessie science court 17 comments the banality of evil and modern medical practices posted by henry bauer on 2021 01 22 the banality of evil is a phrase famously used by hannah arendt in her description of the trial of adolf eichmann there has been much argument about what exactly she meant for me the insight is that evil is so often unintended that it can result from perfectly well intentioned actions the root of all evil is wrong belief if one believes that the most important thing about a human being is the immortal soul and that the soul will burn in hell for eternity unless it has accepted what the holy roman catholic church believes then obviously one should leave nothing undone in the effort to bring that soul to proper belief even if that amounts to torturing the immortal soul s body even to death if one believes that one s country was defeated and devastated by sabotage perpetrated by jews communists homosexuals gypsies and the like then obviously one should do whatever is necessary to rid the country of those perpe traitors and so on the human tragedy is that we acquire beliefs according to the environment into which we are born and in which we are raised and once belief has been acquired it tends to become increasingly entrenched and increasingly difficult to modify the problem for society is how best to ensure that collective public actions are based on correct rather than on wrong beliefs nowadays that is taken to mean that public actions should be based on science unfortunately the nature of scientific activity is widely and thoroughly misunderstood 1 in particular its fallibility which results inevitably from the fact that science is carried out by fallible human beings that fallibility is well illustrated by the history of medicine where many past practices are now recognized as having been harmful rather than helpful drawing out blood in sizable amounts for example nowadays the excellent intention to base medical practices on sound scientific knowledge has sadly gone wrong in several ways as a result of beliefs that turn out to be wrong one pervasive reason is that statistical associations are taken as indicating cause and effect an error that is warned against in even the most elementary introductions to statistical analysis several pertinent stories are analyzed in jeremy greene s magisterial prescribing by numbers 2 one story has to do with blood pressure life insurance companies required physical examinations their accumulated data revealed that on average mortality increased with increasing blood pressure now mortality increases with age and it happens also that every relevant study has shown that blood pressure too increases naturally with age in otherwise healthy people the association of blood pressure with mortality is an artefact illustrating the common principle in statistics that when two things a and b are each correlated with a third factor c then a and b will also show a correlation with one another even though neither causes the other 3 the misinterpretation of life insurance statistics has resulted in contemporary medical practice based on a wrong belief namely that it is beneficial is to bring everyone s blood pressure to a level that is normal only for people in their twenties this mistake becomes particularly harmful since the means used to lower blood pressure almost invariably involve administering drugs though lip service is always paid to advising appropriate diet and exercise as the first resort that drug companies are permitted to advertise direct to consumers among developed countries only in the usa and new zealand means that such practices become so taken for granted as to be virtually unquestionable another mistaken belief is that high levels of cholesterol in the blood constitute cardiovascular disease and increased risk of stroke and heart attack the corollary misguided belief is that bringing cholesterol levels down by administering statin drugs is beneficial even though statins hinder the body s production of coenzyme q10 which is a necessary component of the energy producing mechanisms of all cells inevitably therefore statins induce in muscular weakness which is officially but quite mistakenly described as a side effect it is a direct effect many well documented books and articles have debunked the cholesterol theory for example kendrick 2007 and ravnskov 2000 in 4 without effecting any change in standard practice although many individuals ignore or defy their doctor s prescribing of statins not only do modern american medical practices rely on misleading incompetent statistical analyses they are based fundamentally on the wrong belief that preventive medicine can be successfully practiced by administering of drugs this becomes increasingly harmful when those drugs continue to be prescribed as people get older and the steadily cumulating danger from drug side effects outweigh any possible benefit from reducing risk of one or another ailment 5 drug based treatments are particularly well entrenched because the pharmaceutical industry is hugely profitable in large part because of the profligate prescribing of drugs stimulated by pervasive advertising the greatest immediate improvement in prescribing practices would result if the food and drug administration and other regulatory authorities would demand statistically competent and honest protocols for clinical trials including that outcomes not be assessed as significant at p 0 05 but in terms of nnt and nnh numbers of patients needed to be treated for 1 successful outcome compared to numbers of patients needed to be treated to observe 1 undesired adverse event 6 that would prevent much harm for example that now perpetrated by hpv vaccines which are responsible for the greatest number of officially reported averse events as well as many horrifying anecdotes 7 while there is no actual proof that hpv causes any cancer at all hpv having been found guilty only because a few strains out of many dozens are often statistically associated with some cancers well intentioned physicians are doing harm because of wrong beliefs even as dozens of books 4 have exposed the misdeeds and their causes is it not an evil to persuade people to ingest things that do harm without any compensating good 1 science is not what you think how it has changed why we can t trust it how it can be fixed mcfarland 2017 2 jeremy greene prescribing by numbers johns hopkins university press 2007 3 seeking immortality challenging the drug based medical paradigm j ournal of scientific exploration 26 2012 867 80 4 what s wrong with present day medicine 5 when is enough enough stopping medicines in older people best practices journal 27 april 2010 6 9 rushabh j dagli akanksha sharma polypharmacy a global risk factor for elderly people journal of international oral health 6 6 2014 i ii 6 how not to measure the efficacy of drugs 7 mary holland kim mack rosenberg eileen iorio t he hpv vaccine on trial seeking justice for a generation betrayed skyhorse 2018 documentary sacrificial virgins share this share on facebook opens in new window facebook share on linkedin opens in new window linkedin more share on tumblr opens in new window tumblr share on reddit opens in new window reddit share on x opens in new window x share on pinterest opens in new window pinterest like loading posted in consensus fraud in medicine medical practices prescription drugs science is not truth scientific culture scientists are human unwarranted dogmatism in science tagged blood pressure and mortality cholesterol not harmful hpv vaccines harmful 1 comment the hiv aids blunder missed opportunities for mainstream research to self correct posted by henry bauer on 2021 01 20 quite a number of specific mis steps conspired to the acceptance and continuance of hiv aids theory they illustrate much of what has gone wrong with science it is subject to interference by commercial political and ideological influences it is comprised of a variety of institutions that do not interact usefully or reliably above all science has no overarching watchdog to ensure that theories change appropriately as evidence accumulates 1 the first and crucial mistake was when the secretary of health and human services margaret heckler held a press conference at which robert gallo claimed to have discovered the probable cause of aids illustrated by this sad episode is political interference and the pervasive ignorance of how science works gallo had not yet published anything insiders regarded him as incompetent and untrustworthy investigative journalism later 2002 fully documented that he is an unscrupulous charlatan 1 heckler s background was as a lawyer and a politically active republican activists had been campaigning vigorously for the republican administration to do something about aids this official endorsement of gallo s claim acted as a signal that anyone who wanted research support from the national institutes of health nih would likely be successful by proposing to work on hiv virologists in particular were hungry for funding after their failure to discover cancer causing viruses in the war on cancer 2 2 an important contributing factor was statistical incompetence at the centers for disease control cdc mistakenly taking gay rather than drug abuse as the most meaningful association with aids 3 the cdc should also have been aware that aids like symptoms had been quite common among addicts during the 1960 70s epidemic of so called recreational drug use 4 initiated the misleading young previously healthy gay men characterization based on 5 cases aged 29 36 average 32 6 5 its task force on kaposi s sarcoma had found the average age of aids victims to be 35 when cochrane 6 re examined the medical records 20 years later she found that the average age of the first 25 aids patients in san francisco had been 38 this mattered crucially the greatest risk for sexual infections is among people 30 lifestyle ailments are increasingly likely at older ages more compatible with a decade or two of what used to be called dissolute living cdc researchers as early as 1987 failed to recognize the significance of their finding that among job corps members at ages about 17 and younger females are more likely to test hiv positive than males 7 3 the army hiv research office also failed to recognize the significance of their finding that at ages about 17 and younger females are more likely to test hiv positive than males 8 4 duesberg had published comprehensive debunkings of hiv in 1987 9 and 1989 10 the latter has a footnote promising a rebuttal from gallo that never eventuated despite several reminders 11 233 5 as the years went by more and more conundrums emerged whose significance was missed the purple skin patches of kaposi s sarcoma had been the iconic signature of aids yet after half a dozen years they had become rare among aids patients the correlation between drug abuse and aids became stronger and stronger prostitutes who did not use drugs were not at risk of becoming hiv positive drug abusers who used clean needles would more likely to test hiv positive than those who exchanged needles marriage and pregnancy are risk factors for testing hiv positive many further instances with primary sources cited also for the points above see the case against hiv lessons the clearest general lesson is that policymakers and administrators should not take far reaching actions on matters of science or medicine without advice from individuals who have at least an elementary acquaint...
|
