Meta tags:
description= 8 posts published by Jonathan Jarrett during August 2016;
Headings (most frequently used words):
the, and, in, medieval, of, early, leeds, world, archives, history, imc, report, for, 2015, part, century, byzantine, frontiers, islamic, networks, ii, monthly, august, 2016, debunking, book, review, dealings, with, jerusalem, before, eleventh, remains, modern, cesma, field, trip, to, shrewsbury, another, gathering, byzantinists, birmingham, seminar, ccxxxix, fragments, father, 539, texts, politics, long, 10th, western, kingdom, 641, re, formed, coinage, renewed, meaning, using, imitating, disposing, coins, far, beyond, imperial, 733, vi, iberia, 814, neighbours, iv, tracing, aristocratic, three, kingdoms, 233, provinces, syria, west, 325, byzantium, context, environment, economy, power, crisis, renewal, 401, europe, lecture, recent, comments, see, something, wrong, blogroll, currently, reading, institutions, tourism, pictures, personal, webpages, resources, email, subscription, rss, feed,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (709), and (332), that (162), was (139), this (101), but (93), for (88), with (70), which (63), one (62), have (60), not (52), about (46), from (46), there (44), medieval (43), had (43), #history (40), more (40), were (39), all (38), than (36), they (35), are (35), century (34), his (34), what (34), been (32), their (31), out (30), some (30), early (29), them (29), people (29), can (29), much (29), #august (27), byzantine (27), how (27), who (27), here (26), now (25), may (25), very (25), only (24), then (24), other (23), you (23), really (23), could (23), 2016 (22), because (22), middle (21), might (21), also (21), when (21), coins (20), into (20), these (20), december (19), july (19), october (19), ages (19), where (19), still (19), like (19), january (18), march (18), september (18), would (18), just (18), jerusalem (18), june (17), 2015 (17), two (17), see (17), better (17), such (17), seems (17), its (17), between (17), february (16), april (16), 2014 (16), think (16), has (16), time (16), work (16), 2007 (15), november (15), 2009 (15), 2012 (15), book (15), professor (15), christian (15), church (15), even (15), before (15), comments (14), tenth (14), 2008 (14), 2010 (14), 2011 (14), posted (14), paper (14), made (14), being (14), least (14), point (14), make (14), europe (13), 2013 (13), charlemagne (13), any (13), authors (13), pretty (13), over (13), 2019 (12), 2020 (12), 2022 (12), 2023 (12), part (12), know (12), way (12), modern (12), things (12), after (12), set (12), most (12), coin (12), well (12), louis (12), power (11), world (11), another (11), find (11), though (11), area (11), should (11), get (11), question (11), evidence (11), blog (10), new (10), 2018 (10), 2021 (10), day (10), through (10), john (10), something (10), knowing (10), while (10), looking (10), found (10), good (10), come (10), probably (10), own (10), far (10), put (10), indeed (10), first (10), session (10), age (9), archaeology (9), herodotus (9), example (9), period (9), certainly (9), public (9), western (9), case (9), although (9), coinage (9), byzantium (9), use (9), hard (9), local (9), emperor (9), don (9), back (9), papers (9), took (9), perhaps (9), often (9), did (9), long (9), umayyad (9), pilgrims (9), already (8), 2024 (8), online (8), global (8), text (8), city (8), india (8), churches (8), research (8), wrong (8), sources (8), able (8), both (8), discussion (8), lot (8), around (8), greek (8), simple (8), too (8), lastly (8), christ (8), need (8), went (8), rulers (8), few (8), end (8), usually (8), sense (8), survey (8), someone (8), spain (8), charles (8), france (7), late (7), carolingian (7), rome (7), medievalist (7), oxford (7), leeds (7), institute (7), edd (7), historian (7), whose (7), using (7), done (7), down (7), level (7), peter (7), wikimedia (7), commons (7), known (7), apparently (7), king (7), centuries (7), year (7), empire (7), barber (7), anna (7), law (7), vol (7), yet (7), right (7), gold (7), mediterranean (7), interests (7), different (7), quite (7), off (7), constantinople (7), seem (7), less (7), got (7), holy (7), same (7), mayke (7), scale (7), will (7), she (7), written (7), questions (7), sepulchre (7), cases (7), sign (6), com (6), 2026 (6), project (6), home (6), image (6), collection (6), political (6), jonathan (6), jarrett (6), abbey (6), castle (6), west (6), seen (6), historical (6), robert (6), going (6), contact (6), man (6), state (6), bruce (6), tagged (6), without (6), course (6), context (6), tell (6), him (6), title (6), cotton (6), islamic (6), memory (6), why (6), rather (6), imperial (6), copper (6), fact (6), politics (6), armenia (6), little (6), ways (6), thought (6), eastern (6), mainly (6), sometimes (6), human (6), doing (6), enough (6), post (6), mark (6), pious (6), climate (6), carolingians (6), reynolds (6), three (6), old (6), since (6), partly (6), visigothic (6), popular (6), email (5), comment (5), report (5), latin (5), gallery (5), studies (5), antique (5), full (5), venice (5), china (5), below (5), reading (5), last (5), stuff (5), earlier (5), leave (5), actual (5), recent (5), knowledge (5), 600789 (5), 799461 (5), many (5), again (5), came (5), once (5), actually (5), via (5), therefore (5), source (5), doesn (5), does (5), against (5), either (5), answer (5), texts (5), those (5), notes (5), conference (5), coming (5), picked (5), redford (5), keane (5), dixon (5), birmingham (5), africa (5), conquest (5), desert (5), show (5), her (5), justinian (5), didn (5), sessions (5), short (5), idea (5), money (5), saint (5), said (5), mostly (5), place (5), want (5), military (5), various (5), despite (5), best (5), clear (5), land (5), kind (5), read (5), interesting (5), caravanserai (5), backlog (5), photos (5), field (5), imc (5), ellenblum (5), corisande (5), frontiers (5), however (5), patriarchs (5), support (5), themselves (5), almost (5), ying (5), manzano (5), andalus (5), say (5), kingdom (5), write (4), corner (4), posts (4), address (4), 2025 (4), words (4), translation (4), art (4), reference (4), making (4), resources (4), del (4), images (4), rebecca (4), daniel (4), sicily (4), itself (4), cambridge (4), institutions (4), catalunya (4), nothing (4), interest (4), histories (4), always (4), dipl (4), seminar (4), scott (4), domain (4), contexts (4), abbot (4), story (4), given (4), wonder (4), supposed (4), fourth (4), obviously (4), father (4), speaking (4), canon (4), later (4), ancient (4), photo (4), vassilopolou (4), mongols (4), mike (4), crescent (4), abstain (4), started (4), programme (4), under (4), peculiar (4), picture (4), seventh (4), areas (4), stage (4), syracuse (4), authority (4), struck (4), thessaloniki (4), fine (4), trying (4), whom (4), tried (4), half (4), eleventh (4), silver (4), remember (4), guess (4), especially (4), international (4), suppose (4), postgraduate (4), central (4), shall (4), try (4), clearly (4), getting (4), congress (4), syria (4), beyond (4), difficult (4), whole (4), reign (4), our (4), understand (4), large (4), largely (4), fair (4), perspective (4), places (4), nonetheless (4), latter (4), great (4), anything (4), mosques (4), settlements (4), each (4), whereas (4), frontier (4), bit (4), morris (4), review (4), years (4), caliph (4), fun (4), jlascar (4), argument (4), kings (4), wilk (4), koziol (4), fraser (4), opinion (4), ron (4), stapley (4), rayner (4), required (3), reader (3), content (3), subscribe (3), join (3), subscribers (3), 2006 (3), archives (3), web (3), library (3), monastery (3), 840 (3), writing (3), material (3), historians (3), iberian (3), index (3), dark (3), museum (3), monarchy (3), information (3), michael (3), darley (3), academic (3), priory (3), south (3), paris (3), nice (3), istanbul (3), wester (3), antiquity (3), currently (3), viking (3), lost (3), word (3), general (3), anglo (3), isn (3), correct (3), appropriate (3), simon (3), orosius (3), josephus (3), transmission (3), look (3), thus (3), route (3), stories (3), pointed (3), neither (3), original (3), person (3), obvious (3), truth (3), foreign (3), brief (3), paulicians (3), maroula (3), perisanidi (3), maria (3), james (3), conferences (3), equality (3), hamilton (3), leone (3), changing (3), arab (3), final (3), symposium (3), asking (3), theme (3), everyone (3), centre (3), ottoman (3), showing (3), tunisia (3), sites (3), certain (3), together (3), comes (3), production (3), fairly (3), focus (3), follow (3), exactly (3), terms (3), divine (3), islam (3), tea (3), arts (3), arguing (3), kazantzakis (3), country (3), form (3), socialism (3), religious (3), war (3), cannot (3), existed (3), needed (3), none (3), settlement (3), tradition (3), successor (3), states (3), vision (3), beginning (3), neighbours (3), union (3), emperors (3), high (3), remain (3), surprising (3), anyway (3), royal (3), choice (3), colleagues (3), links (3), kesik (3), köprü (3), keynote (3), cultures (3), number (3), konya (3), closer (3), erstwhile (3), event (3), working (3), must (3), continue (3), approach (3), paschasius (3), jong (3), johannes (3), preiser (3), kapeller (3), greece (3), denis (3), genequand (3), change (3), berbers (3), andrew (3), izdebski (3), pay (3), speaker (3), consensus (3), ideas (3), lives (3), landscape (3), society (3), wound (3), lecture (3), particular (3), sphere (3), true (3), second (3), corbie (3), events (3), across (3), useful (3), evening (3), speakers (3), changes (3), lake (3), real (3), problem (3), european (3), continuing (3), further (3), phenomenon (3), single (3), big (3), agree (3), next (3), houses (3), everything (3), buildings (3), palace (3), fascination (3), presence (3), result (3), base (3), alfred (3), studied (3), darby (3), reassessing (3), runciman (3), pilgrimages (3), palestine (3), 2nd (3), edn (3), realise (3), crusades (3), doi (3), british (3), franks (3), looked (3), interested (3), https (3), http (3), www (3), flickr (3), take (3), reasons (3), sacrifice (3), proved (3), frankish (3), involved (3), engaged (3), odd (3), thing (3), rodrigues (3), carvalho (3), clarke (3), lin (3), rosa (3), eduardo (3), scandinavia (3), gerberga (3), moreno (3), diplomas (3), aristocratic (3), aristocracy (3), networks (3), imagine (3), ninth (3), system (3), pierced (3), jewellery (3), chinese (3), francia (3), lotharingia (3), xkcd (3), cover (3), error (3), myth (3), ago (3), debunking (3), collapse (2), view (2), log (2), subscribed (2), privacy (2), wordpress (2), account (2), rss (2), tool (2), plan (2), científicas (2), regnum (2), interactive (2), 614 (2), homepage (2), internet (2), page (2), classical (2), culture (2), album (2), renaissance (2), documents (2), españa (2), fitzwilliam (2), bibliothèque (2), nationale (2), cliopatria (2), group (2), manuscripts (2), cultural (2), bibliography (2), personal (2), york (2), whitby (2), sur (2), mer (2), ravenna (2), siena (2), shrewsbury (2), martin (2), madrid (2), cathedral (2), marca (2), hispanica (2), trips (2), seven (2), geneva (2), carlisle (2), saints (2), castles (2), pictures (2), university (2), rethinking (2), kenneth (2), gladly (2), romànic (2), dame (2), eleanor (2), hull (2), coffee (2), island (2), sword (2), among (2), ruins (2), extra (2), recall (2), mistakes (2), necessary (2), wet (2), hillforts (2), islay (2), enigmatic (2), corcoran (2), intellectual (2), ihr (2), seminars (2), examples (2), shards (2), urban (2), used (2), citation (2), having (2), talking (2), possible (2), searching (2), concluded (2), start (2), moving (2), showed (2), manuscript (2), venerable (2), alternative (2), fragments (2), transmitted (2), considerable (2), pagan (2), seneca (2), likely (2), cyrus (2), origin (2), books (2), bust (2), roman (2), copy (2), entered (2), enigma (2), simply (2), river (2), ganges (2), missed (2), mentions (2), fifth (2), called (2), ought (2), unlike (2), somehow (2), control (2), jackson (2), london (2), volume (2), classic (2), makes (2), season (2), deal (2), term (2), returned (2), turks (2), sex (2), nafsika (2), saxby (2), vrij (2), hill (2), egypt (2), catherine (2), carl (2), bulgaria (2), kelley (2), numismatics (2), twelfth (2), bernard (2), ben (2), michel (2), 339 (2), sidi (2), jdidi (2), north (2), dualist (2), gender (2), somewhat (2), value (2), study (2), closed (2), gone (2), laid (2), cultivation (2), unknown (2), coast (2), points (2), current (2), grown (2), economic (2), wine (2), rural (2), hand (2), portrait (2), mint (2), constantinopolitan (2), sufficiently (2), outright (2), explanation (2), readers (2), anomaly (2), curious (2), round (2), ethic (2), riven (2), community (2), help (2), cut (2), exile (2), generally (2), noted (2), demetrius (2), exposed (2), bulgarians (2), plans (2), mount (2), mission (2), easily (2), situation (2), observed (2), date (2), rule (2), felt (2), suggested (2), easy (2), six (2), hundred (2), civil (2), divided (2), fragmentation (2), tells (2), finally (2), path (2), trebizond (2), heraclius (2), viii (2), lunch (2), give (2), happened (2), basically (2), close (2), constantine (2), never (2), solidus (2), wife (2), sort (2), agreement (2), popes (2), trouble (2), eighty (2), eight (2), marriages (2), consistently (2), status (2), territory (2), capital (2), main (2), choose (2), reason (2), piece (2), four (2), elibelinde (2), symbols (2), became (2), seljuk (2), speak (2), identity (2), blurred (2), illustrations (2), bridge (2), began (2), occasioned (2), document (2), officials (2), nur (2), din (2), ibn (2), established (2), dated (2), mongol (2), thirteenth (2), yes (2), patronage (2), above (2), sultanate (2), near (2), fell (2), reporting (2), annual (2), whether (2), hope (2), stress (2), times (2), myself (2), ran (2), anyone (2), advanced (2), life (2), sleep (2), experienced (2), realised (2), contains (2), thirteen (2), umayyads (2), ronnie (2), radbertus (2), whittow (2), libya (2), einhard (2), fenwick (2), marsham (2), adam (2), referred (2), citing (2), countryside (2), turnhout (2), available (2), english (2), 1967 (2), philadelphia (2), ideal (2), der (2), reform (2), origins (2), non (2), vidi (2), decline (2), 814 (2), wala (2), east (2), expect (2), ended (2), era (2), died (2), crowd (2), audience (2), literary (2), fashion (2), strikes (2), teaching (2), sharp (2), shows (2), whatever (2), epitaphium (2), food (2), program (2), marked (2), ecological (2), admit (2), visible (2), else (2), van (2), room (2), every (2), produce (2), entirely (2), trend (2), ask (2), difference (2), fit (2), tiny (2), revival (2), default (2), comparator (2), include (2), pollen (2), patterns (2), expansion (2), profile (2), meanwhile (2), ecology (2), 1000 (2), persians (2), environmental (2), veikou (2), url (2), publications (2), afraid (2), environment (2), former (2), advertised (2), unable (2), tripolitania (2), possibilities (2), overall (2), palaces (2), variety (2), complex (2), fortified (2), changed (2), architecture (2), jebel (2), borderlands (2), usual (2), notional (2), range (2), shown (2), 10th (2), 233 (2), during (2), begin (2), pilgrimage (2), saxons (2), mccormick (2), dan (2), others (2), grabois (2), bruxelles (2), 1980 (2), wilkinson (2), wanted (2), statement (2), stroud (2), caliphate (2), locis (2), sanctis (2), spanish (2), 3406 (2), rbph (2), revue (2), belge (2), philologie (2), histoire (2), council (2), suffered (2), bet (2), enemy (2), relics (2), org (2), php (2), curid (2), 451 (2), disputes (2), sounds (2), meaning (2), cross (2), becomes (2), gets (2), heart (2), belief (2), let (2), unclear (2), position (2), recognition (2), provided (2), tomb (2), related (2), thinking (2), distant (2), limited (2), supposedly (2), link (2), sparked (2), dealings (2), renato (2), silva (2), paulo (2), henrique (2), pachá (2), northumbria (2), nicola (2), mateusz (2), maastricht (2), karen (2), torres (2), horst (2), geoffrey (2), mcnair (2), florent (2), audy (2), roberts (2), charters (2), mind (2), 923 (2), running (2), crusafont (2), visigoths (2), 1988 (2), jaume (2), visigoda (2), garcía (2), problems (2), held (2), 987 (2), kingdoms (2), hunting (2), reverse (2), attempt (2), señor (2), nobles (2), break (2), normal (2), feel (2), northumbrian (2), moderating (2), order (2), dispute (2), importance (2), lieutenants (2), muslim (2), provoked (2), peninsula (2), survival (2), school (2), hear (2), iberia (2), double (2), currency (2), dead (2), wearing (2), bullion (2), pecked (2), except (2), leading (2), unlucky (2), pieces (2), lößlein (2), archbishops (2), awful (2), bad (2), misapprehensions (2), american (2), doubt (2), usa (2), patriotic (2), evident (2), america (2), worrisome (2), prejudices (2), britain (2), blair (2), subjective (2), verdict (2), judgements (2), job (2), vicious (2), authoritative (2), contents (2), misapprehension (2), controversy (2), list (2), myths (2), exploded (2), reasonable (2), bear (2), website, name, loading, bar, manage, subscriptions, site, 897, feed, 958, enter, your, receive, notifications, subscription, 2017, william, whitaker, fontes, academy, labyrinth, illustrated, isidore, digital, monumenta, germaniae, historica, deer, datini, telma, chartes, originales, antérieures, 1121, conservées, tattúínárdøla, saga, gall, special, characters, html, revistas, consejo, superior, investigaciones, edición, electrónica, francorum, maps, regesta, imperii, martha, carlin, paul, halsall, sourcebooks, openedition, open, humanities, press, palæography, exercises, monastic, matrix, medievaleuropeonline, calendar, calculator, powerpoint, presentation, inscriptions, kornbluth, photography, archive, mediaeval, palaeography, imareal, server, primary, histeria, història, paisatge, gmail, faq, glossa, dictionary, portal, emap, ireland, department, medals, gallica, collaborative, hincmar, christianization, rise, catalogue, digitized, castros, asturias, treasures, kells, evaluating, beowulf, basics, drout, association, computing, archim, nationales, ryan, lavelle, rose, walker, nathaniel, lane, taylor, kıvılcım, yavuz, luca, zavagno, domink, waßenhoven, david, roffe, domesday, inquest, melleno, phd, alaric, hall, webpages, minster, white, ladies, shifnal, mary, villefranche, vienna, cloisters, taormina, skipton, florence, sarratt, hertfordshire, rye, sussex, roquebrune, cap, penrhosfeilw, train, naples, maldon, essex, sutton, hoo, suffolk, ely, cambridgeshire, lleida, lichfield, surrounds, lausanne, lastingham, kirkstall, iffley, halifax, glastonbury, town, gairloch, sands, ross, scotland, dudley, dolwyddelan, dolbadarn, cuxham, watlington, oxfordshire, claverley, chillon, castercliff, hillfort, castelmola, brixworth, bridgnorth, bolton, beddgelert, beaulieu, appleby, pendragon, ankara, tourism, krea, upinder, singh, thurston, manuel, fernández, götz, premodern, societies, mills, anthony, grafton, conversion, hudson, sally, crumplin, essays, honour, bartlett, francesc, monsalvatje, fossas, vallfogona, álvaro, carvajal, castro, bajo, máscara, antoni, pladevall, font, romànica, bages, metal, fort, sketchpad, heroic, geeky, senchus, pallia, nosas, muhlberger, geek, maresme, magistra, mater, lingwë, musings, fish, knighthood, learning, atheists, hispania, los, vikingos, lerne, teche, gemæcca, colleen, morgan, clio, clas, merdin, tales, enchanted, cathalaunia, abans, castells, catalans, pontifex, minimus, blogenspiel, beachcombing, bizarre, bàsicament, archaeodeath, antiquarian, attic, saxon, african, aardvarchaeology, blogroll, perfect, anxious, happy, acknowledge, correction, please, mail, yer, count, ermengol, urgell, cathalaunis, 46f16aab9b, kris, hughes, cxv, search, technical, romans, throw, favourite, learned, equivalent, legends, giving, revelation, danger, electronic, managed, widely, recognised, editors, virtue, enabled, tablet, handy, investigation, opened, minutes, believed, antiquities, illustration, transmitting, 17716, circulating, unrecognised, respectably, christianised, dint, labours, travels, serving, stupidity, excerpted, carried, mental, baggage, passed, filters, denuded, cite, treatise, anger, pagans, gotta, collections, museo, nazionale, roma, palazzo, massimo, terme, 1940, porta, metronia, reliable, buried, phrased, persia, dividing, drowned, soldiers, copied, fifteenth, kicking, somewhere, instead, dropped, plato, virgil, wrestled, framework, precursor, vehicle, revealed, google, quickly, reveals, cluny, benares, nineteenth, tactics, adopted, described, williams, 1907, historic, accounts, travellers, oriental, occidental, pile, unreported, firmly, interlude, fitted, 20th, addressing, fugitive, summer, extremely, elegantly, delivered, explore, kalamazoo, ccxxxix, marriage, palaeologos, heresy, nic, aeig, cbomgs, 154497, 584068, spousal, 422, 443, failure, janet, transl, manchester, 1998, bari, aïcha, abed, khader, fixot, bonifay, sylvestre, roucole, école, française, 2004, basilique, sud, townscapes, heresies, 650, 1450, selected, closing, unconventionally, organisers, answered, gaps, strengths, adherence, reassured, flag, clusters, satisfied, growing, red, sea, nile, suggestion, nubia, network, pieced, roughly, similarly, basic, relocation, northern, oil, industrialised, complexes, cities, increasingly, localising, following, space, looks, citations, indicating, process, replacement, famously, suit, rarely, model, minting, refusal, offered, resistance, circled, message, sadly, followed, death, quarters, export, reality, structures, anonymous, stamenon, 1320, demetrios, sceptre, shield, b6534, representing, component, novels, 1940s, cretan, writer, heal, grass, roots, infused, charity, mutual, overran, conclusion, vital, institutional, messy, 1204, nicæa, epiros, diversified, standardised, previous, armed, degrees, types, claimed, protecting, several, kinds, vie, expression, disputed, heretics, purports, 870s, warning, administration, convert, subvert, foresees, themes, movement, newly, moved, balkans, 970s, forgery, reexamination, ahead, tended, assumed, claims, tephrike, protector, fratricides, recrucified, niko, heterodoxy, arms, analysis, iconography, representations, socio, yannis, stamos, daughter, coinages, head, offer, circumstances, otherwise, shiny, components, road, hisn, kayfa, komnenian, concavity, strange, mixture, mighty, beard, reforms, hyperperon, 1423, 1448, b6492, dashing, handling, literally, correspondence, handout, showcasing, stavraton, discovered, curator, standing, acquired, accessioned, tailpiece, chrysobull, alexios, iii, megas, komnenos, dionysiou, athos, theodora, niece, kantakouzenos, reunify, collapsed, deep, unpopularity, couldn, deliver, troops, price, diplomatic, efforts, genoa, odder, enjoining, marrying, princesses, theological, objection, overrule, consanguinity, juvenility, differing, religions, sects, christianity, palaeologan, arranged, alliance, received, brides, cost, motivation, player, strategy, stupid, hoping, fundamental, deals, churchmen, needing, perform, office, weekly, confronted, pre, gendered, canonists, keep, forgive, phrase, print, yourself, marital, palaeologi, 1258, 1453, appraising, practice, missing, opportune, moment, palaiologos, spectre, volunteered, chair, ever, future, unbeknownst, worked, weaving, featuring, row, personally, convinced, drew, widespread, symbol, locations, sultanates, loudly, crossed, boundaries, fluid, top, outline, restored, entitled, walk, promising, signed, grades, yüksekligi, witness, act, tayā, monkey, gloss, mixing, turkey, turkish, built, stands, 1990, contained, inscription, sultan, rebellion, masters, baghdad
Text of the page (random words):
on pilgrim traffic entering jerusalem in 1056 despite the city s continuing government by the fatimid caliphate and notional concession to charlemagne of two centuries earlier cf morris sepulchre of christ pp 134 146 8 on that continuing fascination see as well as darby reynolds reassessing the jerusalem pilgrims robert hoyland sarah waidler adomnán s de locis sanctis and the seventh century near east in english historical review vol 129 oxford 2014 pp 787 807 53 799461 1 600789 6 comments posted in anglo saxons byzantium carolingians frontiers islamic crescent tagged alfred the great charlemagne daniel reynolds embassies jerusalem patriarchs pilgrimage leeds imc report for 2015 part 1 posted on 13 august 2016 5 comments it s a bit ridiculous isn t it this backlog but yet it does reduce and as a result i am now into the veritable height of the european medievalist s conference season the international medieval congress at what is now my home base at the university of leeds now in fact on this first day of the congress there was a lot of sorting out of that home aspect so i missed the keynote lectures and the first session of papers but finally arriving during the monday lunchbreak i was able to begin the academic day like this 233 the early islamic world ii provinces and frontiers syria and the west corisande fenwick berbers and borderlands frontier society in north africa anna leone marco nebbia ralf bockmann hafed abdouli moftah haddad and ahmed masud changing landscape in the 8th century to the 10th century the case of the jebel nefiya and tripolitania denis genequand elites in the countryside recent research on the umayyad desert castles i went to this session partly because of knowing corisande partly because of a vague fascination with the umayyad desert palaces that has occasionally shown itself here and mainly because corisande had waved the words frontier and borderlands at us usually guaranteed to catch my interest certainly the area she was looking at challenges our usual ideas of borders since the vast area of africa taken over in the umayyad conquests of the seventh century was so huge as for the presence of the notional occupiers to have to be very sporadic and consequently very concentrated which leaves a distinct archæological profile marked off by garrison architecture mosques a greater range of foodstuffs and most of all coins from military pay and beyond it really very little presence for me this paper was problematised by an assumption that corisande verbalised in questions that new buildings mean new people if there were in fact assimilation of local populations into these fortress settlements going on you could not detect it that way still the extremity of the social division was a point well put ironically the best images i can find from the sites named in this paper are of the christian church at henchir al faouar in tunisia of the other two papers the former was the more peculiar as only one of the authors had in fact been advertised on the program and she had been unable to come so the paper was read by andrew marsham and had a title that was also different from that advertised nonetheless it was interesting the team in question have been carrying out a survey of mosques over much of the old province of tripolitania in what is now libya and were now proceeding to join this up to a survey of settlements oddly the mosques are not all at the settlements which tend to cluster on hilltops in defensively clustered fashion at distances of 5 7 kilometres from each other whereas the mosques could often be in the wilds between them dating all this is the next problem since some of the settlements began in the fourth or fifth centuries and some are ottoman with pretty much everything in between too so the changing landscape had yet to become visible but the possibilities were considerable also the architecture is amazing this is thirteenth century apparently but i don t care it is the fortified granary of qasr kabaw in the jebel nafusa about which you can read slightly more here lastly dr genequand took an overall survey of the various buildings in syria that have been classed as umayyad desert palaces although he tried to avoid both of the words palace and castle because the variety between the 38 such sites is such as to make generalisations like that difficult they are more normally estate centres with areas around them irrigated for intensive farming and produce collection facilities in the complex and while some are luxurious with their own baths and mosque complex and so on and some are fortified and a few are both and they seem to have grown and changed over time they are still probably more like really big desert villas than either palace or castle if you have to find a single word at all one of the erstwhile dams at wadi al qanatir the area around the umayyad palace of umm al walid in jordan image from museum with no frontiers then tea and a chance to see an old colleague kick up some fuss as follows 325 byzantium in context ii environment economy and power crisis and renewal in the byzantine world mark whittow byzantium and global history towards a new determinism adam izdebski the middle byzantine revival from an environmental perspective a return to antique models johannes preiser kapeller topography ecology and byzantine power un early medieval eastern anatolia and armenia 750 1000 myrto veikou a concerted discourse interplay between environment and human agency in the area of smyrna modern izmir in the 13th century ce this session had gathered a much bigger crowd than would fit into the tiny room it had been allocated to which is a lesson about the revival of interest in byzantium more generally in medieval studies i think mark coming very visibly from his involvement with the global middle ages project accordingly set out a manifesto for a new medieval european history in which the continuing byzantine empire was the default comparator not the weird remnant a sign of what should have happened everywhere this would he then further defined need to include the perspective that in the middle bzyantine period prosperity became rural rather than urban a phenomenon that we also see in other places and which mark bravely suggested might have something to with climate the obvious point of reference here was ronnie ellenblum s work which mark hoped one might be less deterministic than but mainly i wonder how once you have scaled up to the level of climate one can make any single place central to a hypothesis however big it was 1 the other papers tried to make such connections more explicit nonetheless dr izdebski comparing coin circulation and pollen patterns across central greece the only place where adequate survey evidence exists he said and determining two very similar looking phases of expansion in the fourth to sixth centuries and the first half of the second millennium but the coins and the pollen don t agree about when the latter was and neither make a great deal of sense next to the supposed climate profile dr preiser kapeller meanwhile ran us very summarily through the history of armenia from the seventh to tenth centuries and concluded that while the fragile local ecology would impact the two surviving noble houses grip on power in the area after the year 1000 up till that point military conquest by persians and arabs was a far better explanation of how the area wound up with only two such houses from fourteen than was anything environmental the point of ms veikou s paper lastly was mainly to put the url of her project before us a project that as far that url now shows had by then already wound up and has produced no further publications since it did so no points from me for that i m afraid the tenth century church of akdamar island in the salt lake van in armenia from which lake johannes s climate evidence was largely coming and fair enough i found the three actual papers in this session a paradoxical combination and this came out in discussion all three speakers were attracted by the idea that large scale survey that factored in changes in the ecological sphere alongside more material evidence of human usage could tell us something but when approached on what had to admit either that the data was not yet collected as in cappadocia where much is visible but very little dated or interpreted or that when it had been it had made sense only on a regional basis and not compared well with anywhere else or the global pattern as at lake van or miletus in greece the effect was to leave the audience and indeed one at least of the speakers much more sceptical that this was a useful approach than they had been when we all entered the room as if ellenblum s book like the first velvet underground album has made every one of its readers determined to have a go too and then discover that trying to be less erratic and offhand than lou reed somehow doesn t produce better rock and roll i suppose the real point for us to work on here is the junction between macro scale and micro scale pictures if at a local level one can entirely escape what is apparently the global trend one has to ask what difference the global trend really made to people a problem that we have of course been seeing with generating concern about the current global ecological situation since well as long as i can remember really presumably there was then food as my conference program is pretty much marked up with receptions for the evening so there wouldn t have been time later between the food and the wine however came one final academic event for the day 401 early medieval europe lecture the modern state of the abbey church of corbie from wikimedia commons the annual early medieval europe lecture was this year given by none other than professor mayke de jong speaking with the title carolingian cultures of dialogue and debate so as you might expect i went mayke was speaking about a difficult text on which she has been working for a long time the epitaphium arsenii of paschasius radbertus this is an anonymised critique of the policies of the carolingian emperor louis the pious written in the form of a dialoguic account of the life of one of his relatives abbot wala of corbie as he ended his earthly career 2 just explaining what it is isn t simple therefore but mayke is one of three people who have recently written about it all coming into the field as she explained with different historiographical demons to slay 3 the particular one she tackled here was the idea that the early middle ages was an era in which there was no public sphere and the ancient tradition of speaking truth to power died off in which rulers were influenced not by the voices of the crowd but a closed circle of advisors texts like the epitaphium show that this is not true at least if mayke s right that its much more polemical second book was intended for an audience beyond the monastery at corbie where it was written the whole text rests on the idea that it was not just all right but morally necessary to try to correct the emperor about his mistakes after all and that this could be done by this kind of literary device mayke had other examples of people rewriting events in literary fashion to put their view across but it now strikes me after teaching it for a term again that another obvious one of these texts is einhard s vita karoli because whatever its date and purpose was it s certainly using praise of charlemagne in the reign of his successor to do something the whole lecture was full of wry wit and sharp observations about the way that people s intellectual traditions have constructed their opinions and she was quite right that if we as scholars of the early middle ages want to get our field away from the old idea of the dark ages we need better to understand why people find it useful to put it there 4 but her final point that the carolingian religious sphere was a public one that included laymen shows how far our categories are crumbling as we better understand what authors like paschasius were doing with their texts and so that wound up the first day of the imc of 2015 and i will alternate the reports on the remaining three with shorter and more discursive content but i will by my blogger s pledge get it done and then continue onwards 1 ellenblum s work referred to here is r ellenblum the collapse of the eastern mediterranean climate change and the decline of the east 950 1072 cambridge 2012 to which at some point i am also going to have to pay attention i suppose on issues of scale it always seems worth my citing julio escalona the early middle ages a scale based approach in idem andrew reynolds edd scale and scale change in the early middle ages exploring landscape local society and the world beyond the medieval countryside 6 turnhout 2011 pp 9 29 2 it is available in a deprecated but still unique translation for the english speaker as allen cabaniss trans charlemagne s cousins contemporary lives of adalard and wala syracuse ny 1967 3 referring to m de jong the penitential state authority and atonement in the age of louis the pious 814 840 cambridge 2010 but also to courtney m booker past convictions the penance of louis the pious and the decline of the carolingians philadelphia pa 2009 and some unnamed work by steffen patzold that i don t know but which might be or be referred to in his consensus concordia unitas überlegungen zu einem politisch religiösen ideal der karolingerzeit in nikolaus staubach ed exemplaris imago ideale in mittelalter und früher neuzeit tradition reform innovation 15 frankfurt 2012 pp 31 56 non vidi 4 mayke cited among other things ian wood the modern origins of the early middle ages oxford 2013 and i might add with my original cautions as linked kathleen davis periodization and sovereignty how ideas of feudalism and secularization govern the politics of time philadelphia pa 2006 53 799461 1 600789 5 comments posted in archaeology byzantium carolingians frontiers institutions islamic crescent tagged adam izdebski andrew marsham anna leone armenia berbers climate change conferences corisande fenwick denis genequand einhard greece johannes preiser kapeller leeds libya louis the pious mark whittow mayke de jong medieval warm period paschasius radbertus ronnie ellenblum settlement archaeology syria tunisia umayyads gallery medieval remains in modern leeds posted on 13 august 2016 this gallery contains 4 photos today just a very short photo post the backlog is now in some sense advanced to only thirteen months behind as i approach the international medieval congress of the year before the one just gone but the imc 2015 was continue reading 4 comments gallery cesma field trip to shrewsbury posted on 11 august 2016 this gallery contains 25 photos i should apologise for the blip in posts subscribers must just have experienced i put one post together in the depths of sleep deprivation before i realised that this one should have come first ...
|
