Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

begging, the, question, contents, history, definition, related, fallacies, vernacular, see, also, notes, references,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (262), #question (80), and (52), that (51), for (33), #begging (30), logic (26), fallacy (26), not (26), argument (25), from (23), which (21), are (20), this (19), conclusion (19), one (18), petitio (17), language (15), fallacies (15), beg (15), because (15), has (15), isbn (14), but (14), aristotle (14), may (13), retrieved (13), reasoning (13), original (13), with (12), point (12), other (11), premise (11), circular (11), press (11), edit (11), principii (11), example (10), usage (10), more (10), self (10), proposition (9), premises (9), university (9), dictionary (9), such (9), same (9), wool (9), statement (8), wikipedia (8), 2024 (8), reason (8), proof (8), philosophy (8), out (8), false (8), new (8), english (8), than (8), 978 (8), also (8), explanatory (8), was (7), form (7), what (7), can (7), issue (7), some (7), opium (7), dialectical (7), thing (7), then (7), asking (7), text (6), non (6), use (6), articles (6), informal (6), definition (6), formal (6), history (6), here (6), common (6), oxford (6), modern (6), cambridge (6), november (6), lccn (6), does (6), meaning (6), itself (6), sleep (6), when (6), prior (6), claim (6), questioner (6), terms (5), page (5), short (5), march (5), greek (5), latin (5), different (5), truth (5), philosophical (5), classical (5), ignoratio (5), elenchi (5), true (5), accessed (5), book (5), means (5), where (5), sentence (5), begs (5), must (5), why (5), known (5), analytics (5), related (5), identical (5), assuming (5), contents (4), search (4), view (4), containing (4), description (4), error (4), logical (4), law (4), context (4), evidence (4), illicit (4), welton (4), 1905 (4), york (4), company (4), there (4), april (4), world (4), morris (4), will (4), how (4), mean (4), obvious (4), questions (4), encyclopedia (4), equivalent (4), have (4), its (4), soporific (4), committed (4), pointing (4), his (4), sophistical (4), only (4), word (4), type (4), sometimes (4), attempt (4), often (4), simply (4), main (4), into (4), called (4), answerer (4), phrase (4), debate (4), thesis (4), nylon (4), hide (4), move (4), sidebar (4), legal (3), about (3), pages (3), ancient (3), 2019 (3), wikidata (3), critical (3), thinking (3), changes (3), portal (3), rules (3), inference (3), mathematical (3), topics (3), deductive (3), antecedent (3), natural (3), man (3), special (3), two (3), errors (3), cause (3), ambiguity (3), correlative (3), complex (3), loaded (3), james (3), problem (3), 1998 (3), times (3), take (3), william (3), john (3), being (3), open (3), through (3), 2005 (3), life (3), herrick (3), gibson (3), 1908 (3), american (3), online (3), advanced (3), learner (3), edition (3), however (3), always (3), even (3), who (3), fowler (3), dowden (3), bradley (3), 2003 (3), 2012 (3), internet (3), considered (3), cannot (3), prove (3), power (3), could (3), engel (3), requires (3), without (3), logically (3), refutations (3), another (3), expression (3), while (3), log (3), 2025 (3), october (3), ways (3), free (3), see (3), confused (3), used (3), all (3), vernacular (3), fails (3), might (3), valid (3), been (3), dress (3), wearing (3), presupposes (3), reasoner (3), persuasive (3), rather (3), anything (3), should (3), first (3), making (3), between (3), induces (3), would (3), asked (3), things (3), ἀρχῇ (3), discusses (3), initial (3), sweaters (3), better (3), content (3), tools (3), languages (2), toggle (2), table (2), contact (2), privacy (2), policy (2), under (2), you (2), inc (2), attribution (2), categories (2), displaying (2), descriptions (2), redirect (2), targets (2), link (2), french (2), clarification (2), january (2), ignorance (2), cognitive (2), title (2), outline (2), category (2), symbols (2), paradoxes (2), set (2), theory (2), necessity (2), name (2), induction (2), linguistic (2), paradox (2), consequent (2), propositions (2), foundations (2), argumentation (2), logics (2), syntax (2), semantics (2), science (2), major (2), make (2), opinion (2), four (2), great (2), argumentum (2), arguments (2), relevance (2), novelty (2), reductio (2), invented (2), slippery (2), slope (2), single (2), post (2), hoc (2), questionable (2), quoting (2), accident (2), denying (2), scotsman (2), relation (2), semantic (2), conflation (2), equivalence (2), equivocation (2), existential (2), negative (2), affirmative (2), syllogistic (2), affirming (2), london (2), vol (2), scott (2), macmillan (2), 1912 (2), scientific (2), july (2), june (2), 2009 (2), safire (2), system (2), connected (2), principles (2), arthur (2), publishing (2), martin (2), 2002 (2), problems (2), kilpatrick (2), assumes (2), 1997 (2), news (2), kahane (2), cavender (2), contemporary (2), rhetoric (2), everyday (2), paul (2), 2000 (2), many (2), 1966 (2), guide (2), follett (2), davies (2), ernest (2), 1915 (2), introduction (2), references (2), 2008 (2), houghton (2), mifflin (2), clear (2), whether (2), heritage (2), assumption (2), demonstration (2), think (2), intelligently (2), begins (2), conception (2), defined (2), beginning (2), 1989 (2), davis (2), walton (2), 1988 (2), invalid (2), any (2), suny (2), wellington (2), zealand (2), therefore (2), concede (2), 291 (2), elements (2), pitfalls (2), trap (2), answers (2), malade (2), imaginaire (2), est (2), assumed (2), thomas (2), schreiber (2), state (2), epistemic (2), cases (2), evident (2), belief (2), order (2), justification (2), regard (2), obligates (2), action (2), him (2), positio (2), obligatum (2), peto (2), 2010 (2), principia (2), college (2), 2023 (2), merriam (2), webster (2), school (2), notes (2), propaganda (2), relations (2), regress (2), apologetics (2), sequence (2), term (2), explain (2), situation (2), avoid (2), several (2), look (2), unanswered (2), personal (2), delivery (2), place (2), something (2), support (2), position (2), allow (2), established (2), mary (2), fallacious (2), closely (2), individual (2), doubts (2), circulus (2), probando (2), usually (2), uses (2), wherein (2), step (2), community (2), words (2), origin (2), fact (2), placed (2), structure (2), device (2), less (2), opioid (2), whose (2), learn (2), refers (2), quality (2), granted (2), literally (2), realize (2), apparent (2), request (2), just (2), falsely (2), thought (2), certain (2), reflection (2), knowledge (2), sense (2), taken (2), they (2), version (2), stylized (2), included (2), ἀρχῆς (2), party (2), αἰτεῖν (2), jackets (2), fall (2), attire (2), made (2), assume (2), appearance (2), upload (2), file (2), links (2), read (2), article (2), create (2), account (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, mobile, cookie, statistics, developers, code, conduct, safety, contacts, disclaimers, available, additional, apply, using, site, agree, registered, trademark, profit, organization, wikimedia, foundation, creative, commons, sharealike, license, rendered, parsoid, last, edited, august, 2026, utc, hidden, via, module, annotated, needing, 1453, dmy, dates, inertia, barriers, https, org, index, php, begging_the_question, oldid, 1369168292, wikiproject, logicians, boolean, algebra, lists, validity, substitution, reference, probability, sufficiency, entailment, dichotomy, closure, deduction, antinomy, contradiction, analytic, synthetic, abduction, metamathematics, metalogic, theories, computational, computer, fields, straw, pleading, wrongs, right, red, herring, rationalization, psychologist, motte, bailey, naturalistic, moralistic, invincible, entitled, cliché, populum, moderation, silence, incredulity, anecdote, sealioning, nauseam, chronological, snobbery, tradition, nature, etymology, wealth, poverty, ipse, dixit, accomplishment, authority, whataboutism, quoque, tone, poisoning, well, bulverism, stalinum, hitlerum, association, appeal, motive, hominem, genetic, wisdom, repugnance, stirring, spite, parade, horribles, loyalty, island, mentality, group, favoritism, ridicule, pity, flattery, fear, children, emotion, wishful, baculum, consequences, assertion, stone, legality, appeals, texas, sharpshooter, regression, inverse, gambler, correlation, implies, causation, cum, furtive, animistic, syntactic, sorites, moving, goalposts, precision, accent, muhammad, wang, overwhelming, exception, slothful, analogy, double, counting, conjunction, base, rate, mcnamara, cherry, picking, sampling, bias, anecdotal, faulty, generalization, converse, secundum, quid, ecological, division, composition, transference, suppressed, perfect, solution, dilemma, based, compound, leading, map, territory, reification, loki, wager, moral, undistributed, middle, minor, exclusive, quantifier, shift, conversion, quantificational, masked, disjunct, propositional, list, incident, method, clive, tutorial, manual, schiller, ferdinand, canning, social, please, mill, stuart, parker, 1851, ratiocinative, inductive, methods, investigation, mercier, charles, court, robert, broadview, 55111, 493, sourcebook, puzzles, unproved, access, rocky, mountain, howard, nancy, cengage, learning, 534, 62604, 515503, worlds, ralph, boyce, black, augusta, klein, 8090, 0139, wilson, adams, cohen, raphael, nagel, corcoran, hackett, 1993, 87220, 144, thesaurus, collins, cobuild, 2018, corbett, philip, september, again, 228, brians, full, 2nd, 2011, harcourt, sorting, exactly, easy, especially, constructions, door, opened, easily, substitute, though, violates, traditional, rule, raise, evade, 2005016513, 0618604999, style, garner, 1995, 101, evading, inviting, mistakenly, believe, proper, basing, much, need, following, classic, examples, reasonable, men, those, 273, 275, 1886, unreported, cir, tenn, patterson, nutter, 95003863, 0195142365, entry, 88030762, 0521379250, handbook, meyer, communication, gruyter, 199, lc88025603, 3110106800, 198, questioning, nolt, eric, rohatyn, dennis, varzi, achille, mcgraw, hill, professional, 205, 0070466494, schaum, indeed, deceptive, premiss, source, ground, lander, sic, douglas, 1992, 207, 0791411575, 206, plausible, conversation, strictly, speaking, ineptitude, thus, deductively, lacks, conviction, since, questioned, encyclopædia, britannica, 1826, quoted, richard, whately, 1994, dover, publications, 30671266, oclc, 486, 28274, 281, quack, wikisource, mihi, docto, doctore, demandatur, causam, rationem, quare, facit, dormire, quoi, respondeo, quia, vertus, dormitiva, cujus, natura, sensus, assoupire, molière, 280, 282, 572, 279, 1887, 145, england, clarendon, ninth, series, 106, 214, hardly, needs, unassailable, importance, places, thoroughly, acceptable, namely, justifying, commits, distinguishing, claims, notorious, crux, antidote, subjectivism, threatens, debilitate, decisions, recognition, takes, training, 2002030968, 0791456590, kretzmann, stump, translations, medieval, texts, 374, sort, relevant, insists, disputation, act, performed, statable, require, respond, affirmatively, god, exists, like, respondent, perform, maintain, way, differ, 87030542, 0521280631, liberman, mark, 2021, center, teaching, excellence, active, interest, media, february, writer, digest, correctly, marsh, david, guardian, harpercollins, 2022, cornell, 248, 2014, archived, public, politics, spin, diallelus, christian, presuppositional, constitute, overlapping, syllogisms, polysyllogism, unjustified, poorly, infinite, failure, mild, indirect, euphemism, treadmill, consequentia, mirabilis, referential, contradictory, constraints, catch, uncertainty, interpretations, possible, data, wiktionary, further, perhaps, leaving, dodging, spending, summer, traveling, around, india, idea, afford, hopewell, success, aren, companies, doing, letter, time, low, letters, kind, future, know, rephrasing, thereof, raises, invites, suggests, leaves, etc, preface, followed, address, appears, debating, permits, attempts, guilty, ought, irrelevant, similar, color, unless, previously, her, outfit, she, pants, instead, trick, components, lack, listener, leads, defective, incorrect, unpersuasive, already, exceptions, reflexive, authors, dub, commonly, circle, every, unbounded, freedom, speech, whole, advantageous, highly, conducive, interests, each, enjoy, liberty, perfectly, unlimited, expressing, sentiments, obscure, concrete, attempting, pass, off, delivered, abstract, bring, forth, expressed, give, very, stated, norman, saxon, eldom, anyone, going, arguer, phraseology, conceals, masquerading, rephrased, immediately, variations, literary, conceal, factors, involved, unstated, essential, controversial, reasons, typically, lead, someone, trade, good, country, patently, isn, unrestricted, commercial, bestow, sections, nation, benefits, result, unimpeded, flow, goods, countries, specific, physiological, processes, omitted, simplicity, contains, activates, central, nervous, inhibitory, receptor, activation, sufficient, induce, receptors, morphine, reading, inducing, causes, effect, explains, involves, variable, rhetorical, later, earlier, hysteron, proteron, restates, simultaneously, taking, believed, properly, quæsiti, gregory, advice, resolving, brief, realizes, refuse, reputable, hand, conceded, concession, produce, refutation, turn, tables, opponent, oneself, exchange, worse, mistake, caught, inadvertently, failed, detect, utterances, did, knowingly, reveals, himself, ontologically, mistaken, tactical, psychological, misjudgment, guise, covering, universal, divided, exhaustive, parts, principle, facts, others, solely, abilities, humans, primarily, noncognitive, reality, successful, resolution, firm, grasp, correct, powers, liable, find, distinction, forms, nondemonstrative, rests, appropriate, become, trained, dialectician, metaphysics, epistemology, apodictic, hugh, tredennick, trans, consists, widest, failing, demonstrate, required, happen, argue, equally, unknown, establish, utilizing, consequents, proceeds, now, none, these, clearly, convertible, applies, egging, proving, evidently, employing, either, predicates, belong, subject, predicate, belongs, subjects, comes, xvi, 64b28, 65a26, archêi, aiteîsthai, αἰτεῖσθαι, translated, 16th, century, interpreted, arose, older, basis, principium, genitive, beseeching, petition, postulating, starting, exchanges, scoring, important, precisely, matter, actual, adopted, too, close, undertakes, defend, ask, trivial, uninteresting, 64b, 65a, 57b, 59b, needed, descends, intended, tied, viii, formalized, defending, asserts, attacking, refute, yes, deducing, inconsistency, responses, bust, contained, early, discussion, strongly, prompt, distinct, study, criticized, diluting, higher, analysis, observes, intrinsically, giving, weak, superiority, essentialist, occurs, historically, fault, speaker, demonstrated, come, refer, supporting, makes, calling, founded, unproven, item, projects, printable, download, pdf, print, export, switch, legacy, parser, get, shortened, url, cite, information, permanent, general, actions, talk, українська, türkçe, tagalog, svenska, српски, srpski, slovenčina, simple, română, português, polski, pälzisch, occitan, lietuvių, 한국어, 日本語, italiano, íslenska, bahasa, indonesia, magyar, hrvatski, עברית, français, فارسی, euskara, español, deutsch, dansk, čeština, کوردی, العربية, top, recent, help, contribute, random, current, events, navigation, jump,

Text of the page (random words):
alent or a covering universal or divided up into exhaustive parts would be more persuasive to the answerer rather the questioner falsely thought that a non self explanatory fact about the world was an explanatory first principle for aristotle that certain facts are self explanatory while others are not is not a reflection solely of the cognitive abilities of humans it is primarily a reflection of the structure of noncognitive reality in short a successful resolution of such a fallacy requires a firm grasp of the correct explanatory powers of things without a knowledge of which things are self explanatory and which are not the reasoner is liable to find a question begging argument persuasive 13 scott gregory schreiber aristotle on false reasoning language and the world in the sophistical refutations thomas fowler believed that petitio principii would be more properly called petitio quæsiti which is literally begging the question 14 definition edit to beg the question also called petitio principii is to attempt to support a claim with a premise that itself restates or presupposes the claim 15 it is an attempt to prove a proposition while simultaneously taking the proposition for granted when the fallacy involves only a single variable it is sometimes called a hysteron proteron 16 17 18 greek for later earlier a rhetorical device as in the statement opium induces sleep because it has a soporific quality 19 reading this sentence the only thing one can learn is a new word soporific that refers to a more common action inducing sleep it does not explain why opium causes that effect a sentence that explains why opium often induces sleep or the same why opium has soporific quality is opium often induces sleep because it contains morphine an opioid which activates μ opioid receptors in the central nervous system a type of inhibitory receptor whose activation is often sufficient to induce sleep where the specific physiological processes are omitted for simplicity a less obvious example from fallacies and pitfalls of language the language trap by s morris engel free trade will be good for this country the reason is patently clear isn t it obvious that unrestricted commercial relations will bestow on all sections of this nation the benefits which result when there is an unimpeded flow of goods between countries 20 this form of the fallacy may not be immediately obvious linguistic variations in syntax sentence structure and the literary device may conceal it as may other factors involved in an argument s delivery it may take the form of an unstated premise which is essential but not identical to the conclusion or is controversial or questionable for the same reasons that typically might lead someone to question the conclusion 21 s eldom is anyone going to simply place the conclusion word for word into the premises rather an arguer might use phraseology that conceals the fact that the conclusion is masquerading as a premise the conclusion is rephrased to look different and is then placed in the premises paul herrick 2 for example one can obscure the fallacy by first making a statement in concrete terms then attempting to pass off an identical statement delivered in abstract terms as evidence for the original 19 one could also bring forth a proposition expressed in words of saxon origin and give as a reason for it the very same proposition stated in words of norman origin 22 as here to allow every man an unbounded freedom of speech must always be on the whole advantageous to the state for it is highly conducive to the interests of the community that each individual should enjoy a liberty perfectly unlimited of expressing his sentiments 23 when the fallacy of begging the question is committed in more than one step some authors dub it circulus in probando reasoning in a circle 16 24 or more commonly circular reasoning begging the question is usually not considered a formal fallacy an argument that is defective because it uses an incorrect deductive step rather it is usually a type of informal fallacy that is logically valid but unpersuasive in that it fails to prove anything other than what is already assumed 25 26 27 there are some exceptions wherein it may be considered a formal fallacy such as in non reflexive logics related fallacies edit main articles circular reasoning complex question and ignoratio elenchi closely connected with begging the question is the fallacy of circular reasoning circulus in probando a fallacy in which the reasoner begins with the conclusion 28 the individual components of a circular argument can be logically valid because if the premises are true the conclusion must be true and does not lack relevance however circular reasoning is not persuasive because a listener who doubts the conclusion also doubts the premise that leads to it 29 begging the question is similar to the complex question also known as trick question or fallacy of many questions a question that to be valid requires the truth of another question that has not been established for example which color dress is mary wearing may be fallacious because it presupposes that mary is wearing a dress unless it has previously been established that her outfit is a dress the question is fallacious because she could be wearing pants instead 30 31 another related fallacy is ignoratio elenchi or irrelevant conclusion an argument that fails to address the issue in question but appears to do so an example might be a situation where a and b are debating whether the law permits a to do something if a attempts to support his position with an argument that the law ought to allow him to do the thing in question then he is guilty of ignoratio elenchi 32 vernacular edit in vernacular english 33 34 35 36 begging the question or equivalent rephrasing thereof is sometimes used in place of raises the question invites the question suggests the question leaves unanswered the question etc such preface is then followed with the question as in 37 38 personal letter delivery is at an all time low which begs the question are open letters the only kind the future will know 38 hopewell s success begs the question why aren t more companies doing the same 39 spending the summer traveling around india is a great idea but it does beg the question of how we can afford it 40 sometimes it is further confused with dodging the question an attempt to avoid it or perhaps more often begging the question is simply used to mean leaving the question unanswered 11 see also edit look up begging the question in wiktionary the free dictionary wikidata has data related to begging the question philosophy portal ambiguity type of uncertainty of meaning where several interpretations are possible catch 22 logic situation in which one cannot avoid a problem because of contradictory constraints circular definition self referential description of meaning consequentia mirabilis euphemism treadmill mild or indirect word or expression pages displaying short descriptions of redirect targets infinite regress failure to explain fallacies of definition ways in which a term may be poorly defined loaded question question containing an unjustified assumption open question argument philosophical argument polysyllogism sequence of propositions which constitute a sequence of overlapping syllogisms presuppositional apologetics school of christian apologetics regress argument diallelus spin propaganda form of propaganda in public relations and politics notes edit dowden bradley 27 march 2003 fallacies internet encyclopedia of philosophy archived from the original on 9 october 2014 retrieved 5 april 2012 1 2 herrick 2000 248 beg the question cornell law school retrieved 31 may 2025 beg the question the american heritage dictionary of the english language harpercollins 2022 retrieved 10 november 2024 beg the question merriam webster merriam webster inc 2024 retrieved 10 november 2024 beg the question oxford learner s dictionary oxford university press 2024 retrieved 10 november 2024 beg the question cambridge advanced learner s dictionary cambridge university press 2024 retrieved 10 november 2024 marsh david 24 may 2010 begging the question the guardian retrieved 17 march 2023 begging the question how to use it correctly writer s digest active interest media 27 february 2023 retrieved 21 october 2025 how to use it begs the question center for teaching excellence principia college principia college 18 march 2021 retrieved 21 october 2025 1 2 liberman mark 29 april 2010 begging the question we have answers language log retrieved 12 january 2012 kretzmann n stump e 1988 logic and the philosophy of language the cambridge translations of medieval philosophical texts vol 1 cambridge university press p 374 isbn 978 0521280631 lccn 87030542 one sort of petitio is common and another is dialectical but common petitio is not relevant here a dialectical petitio is an expression that insists that in the disputation some act must be performed with regard to the statable thing at issue for example i require peto you to respond affirmatively to god exists and the like and petitio obligates the respondent to perform an action with regard to the obligatum while positio obligates him only to maintain the obligatum and in this way petitio and positio differ 1 2 schreiber s g 2003 aristotle on false reasoning language and the world in the sophistical refutations suny series in ancient greek philosophy state university of new york press pp 99 106 214 isbn 978 0791456590 lccn 2002030968 it hardly needs pointing out that such circular arguments are logically unassailable the importance of the prior analytics introduction to the fallacy is that it places the error in a thoroughly epistemic context for aristotle some reasoning of the form p because p is acceptable namely in cases where p is self justifying in other cases the same logical reasoning commits the error of begging the question distinguishing self evident from non self evident claims is a notorious crux in the history of philosophy aristotle s antidote to the subjectivism that threatens always to debilitate such decisions is his belief in a natural order of epistemic justification and the recognition that it takes special dialectical training to make that natural order also known to us fowler thomas 1887 the elements of deductive logic ninth edition p 145 oxford england clarendon press welton 1905 279 petitio principii is therefore committed when a proposition which requires proof is assumed without proof 1 2 davies 1915 572 welton 1905 280 282 in molière s le malade imaginaire a quack answers the question of why does opium cause sleep with because of its soporific power in the original mihi a docto doctore demandatur causam et rationem quare opium facit dormire a quoi respondeo quia est in eo vertus dormitiva cujus est natura sensus assoupire le malade imaginaire in french wikisource 1 2 welton 1905 281 engel s morris 1994 fallacies and pitfalls of language the language trap s morris engel new york dover publications isbn 0 486 28274 0 oclc 30671266 kahane and cavender 2005 60 gibson 1908 291 richard whately elements of logic 1826 quoted in gibson 1908 291 bradley dowden fallacies in internet encyclopedia of philosophy fallacy encyclopædia britannica strictly speaking petitio principii is not a fallacy of reasoning but an ineptitude in argumentation thus the argument from p as a premise to p as conclusion is not deductively invalid but lacks any power of conviction since no one who questioned the conclusion could concede the premise walton douglas 1992 plausible argument in everyday conversation suny press pp 206 207 isbn 978 0791411575 wellington is in new zealand therefore wellington is in new zealand the reason petitio principii is considered a fallacy is not that the inference is invalid because any statement is indeed equivalent to itself but that the argument can be deceptive a statement cannot prove itself a premiss sic must have a different source of reason ground or evidence for its truth from that of the conclusion lander university petitio principii dowden bradley 27 march 2003 fallacies internet encyclopedia of philosophy retrieved 5 april 2012 nolt john eric rohatyn dennis varzi achille 1998 schaum s outline of theory and problems of logic mcgraw hill professional p 205 isbn 978 0070466494 meyer m 1988 questions and questioning foundations of communication w de gruyter pp 198 199 isbn 978 3110106800 lccn lc88025603 walton d n 1989 informal logic a handbook for critical argument cambridge university press pp 36 37 isbn 978 0521379250 lccn 88030762 h w fowler a dictionary of modern english usage entry for ignoratio elenchi garner b a 1995 dictionary of modern legal usage oxford dictionary of modern legal usage oxford university press p 101 isbn 978 0195142365 lccn 95003863 begging the question does not mean evading the issue or inviting the obvious questions as some mistakenly believe the proper meaning of begging the question is basing a conclusion on an assumption that is as much in need of proof or demonstration as the conclusion itself the formal name for this logical fallacy is petitio principii following are two classic examples reasonable men are those who think and reason intelligently patterson v nutter 7 a 273 275 me 1886 this statement begs the question what does it mean to think and reason intelligently life begins at conception fn conception is defined as the beginning of life davis v davis unreported opinion cir tenn eq 1989 the proof or the definition is circular houghton mifflin company 2005 the american heritage guide to contemporary usage and style houghton mifflin harcourt p 56 isbn 978 0618604999 lccn 2005016513 sorting out exactly what beg the question means however is not always easy especially in constructions such as beg the question of whether and beg the question of how where the door is opened to more than one question but we can easily substitute evade the question or even raise the question and the sentence will be clear even though it violates the traditional usage rule brians common errors in english usage online edition full text of book 2nd edition november 2008 william james company accessed 1 july 2011 follett 1966 228 kilpatrick 1997 martin 2002 71 safire 1998 corbett philip b 25 september 2008 begging the question again new york times 1 2 beg the question retrieved 3 november 2018 beg the question collins cobuild advanced english dictionary online accessed on 2019 05 13 beg the question cambridge advanced learner s dictionary thesaurus online accessed on 2019 05 13 references edit cohen morris raphael ernest nagel and john corcoran an introduction to logic hackett publishing 1993 isbn 0 87220 144 9 davies arthur ernest a text book of logic r g adams and company 1915 follett wilson modern american usage a guide macmillan 1966 isbn 0 8090 0139 x gibson william ralph boyce and augusta klein the problem of logic a and c black 1908 herri...