Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

argument, from, in, brain, vat, contents, intuitive, version, uses, philosophical, debates, fiction, see, also, references, external, links, biology, externalism, incoherence, reconstructions, of, putnam, the, disjunctive,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (171), brain (68), and (47), vat (44), that (41), biv (38), from (34), #argument (34), not (27), putnam (24), are (22), this (21), philosophy (20), with (19), retrieved (17), edit (16), original (15), archived (14), one (13), for (13), which (13), false (13), thought (12), brains (12), have (12), philosophical (11), 2021 (11), embodied (11), then (11), externalism (9), brueckner (9), out (9), doi (9), experiment (9), episode (9), utterances (9), since (9), statement (8), simulation (8), cambridge (8), has (8), mind (8), english (8), reference (8), would (8), earth (8), wikipedia (7), was (7), issn (7), world (7), pdf (7), cannot (7), speaking (7), theory (7), encyclopedia (6), september (6), fiction (6), philosophers (6), new (6), october (6), jstor (6), consciousness (6), star (6), but (6), causal (6), its (6), version (6), may (5), page (5), links (5), human (5), against (5), evil (5), skepticism (5), isbn (5), university (5), truth (5), history (5), they (5), march (5), november (5), 2023 (5), information (5), reality (5), also (5), series (5), being (5), language (5), only (5), knowledge (5), what (5), however (5), say (5), debates (5), contents (4), search (4), view (4), you (4), non (4), commons (4), science (4), hypothesis (4), demon (4), robert (4), content (4), external (4), january (4), case (4), machine (4), anthony (4), hilary (4), 2014 (4), when (4), cognition (4), current (4), body (4), matrix (4), trek (4), see (4), into (4), possible (4), two (4), fallout (4), main (4), true (4), these (4), object (4), disquotational (4), principle (4), incoherence (4), relationship (4), can (4), scenario (4), refer (4), twin (4), cats (4), could (4), will (4), receives (4), similar (4), person (4), biology (4), whether (4), hide (4), move (4), sidebar (4), toggle (3), terms (3), wikimedia (3), use (3), wikidata (3), 2015 (3), literature (3), semantic (3), here (3), skeptical (3), william (3), solipsism (3), types (3), where (3), 1981 (3), 978 (3), press (3), reason (3), tony (3), stanford (3), related (3), believe (3), york (3), 2307 (3), our (3), 2025 (3), february (3), s2cid (3), transcendental (3), routledge (3), controversies (3), representation (3), 180 (3), 2017 (3), descartes (3), metaphysics (3), references (3), isolated (3), first (3), upload (3), next (3), expansion (3), pack (3), article (3), reconstructions (3), follows (3), either (3), sense (3), premises (3), further (3), because (3), imply (3), yet (3), like (3), self (3), does (3), monkey (3), same (3), thoughts (3), things (3), their (3), found (3), says (3), vats (3), thus (3), according (3), stimuli (3), account (3), there (3), those (3), beliefs (3), know (3), meaning (3), definition (3), carrying (3), sentence (3), such (3), computer (3), tools (3), languages (2), table (2), mobile (2), code (2), contact (2), about (2), privacy (2), policy (2), available (2), july (2), 2026 (2), categories (2), articles (2), internet (2), link (2), pages (2), broken (2), short (2), description (2), different (2), experiments (2), hypothetical (2), technology (2), aenesidemus (2), montaigne (2), cicero (2), responses (2), problem (2), dream (2), scenarios (2), concepts (2), peter (2), david (2), pierre (2), metrodorus (2), skeptics (2), radical (2), neuronal (2), control (2), daniel (2), dennett (2), 52129776 (2), oclc (2), must (2), had (2), some (2), donovan (2), colossus (2), warfield (2), ted (2), 2108437 (2), knowing (2), 2026572 (2), journal (2), 1007 (2), studies (2), wright (2), crispin (2), 1093 (2), aristotelian (2), proceedings (2), 2016 (2), 2012 (2), issues (2), rupert (2), mcginn (2), colin (2), kriegel (2), uriah (2), 2019 (2), experience (2), april (2), singularity (2), virtual (2), 2181388 (2), 2004 (2), harman (2), gilbert (2), red (2), man (2), adapted (2), again (2), way (2), tron (2), legacy (2), generation (2), film (2), lies (2), who (2), lost (2), influential (2), suggested (2), impressions (2), though (2), metalinguistic (2), putnamian (2), conclusion (2), his (2), employing (2), contains (2), tokens (2), disjunctive (2), issue (2), taken (2), approaches (2), demonstrate (2), through (2), refuting (2), connected (2), referring (2), therefore (2), identical (2), another (2), people (2), pure (2), outside (2), even (2), objects (2), connection (2), referred (2), been (2), loophole (2), real (2), remains (2), following (2), hamlet (2), etc (2), environment (2), representing (2), several (2), including (2), experiences (2), jar (2), disembodied (2), were (2), many (2), contemporary (2), rené (2), zhuangzi (2), impulses (2), skull (2), most (2), walking (2), believes (2), raising (2), other (2), uses (2), actual (2), interaction (2), meaningless (2), intuitive (2), considered (2), stories (2), events (2), appearance (2), file (2), changes (2), read (2), log (2), create (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, cookie, statistics, developers, conduct, legal, safety, contacts, disclaimers, text, under, additional, apply, using, site, agree, registered, trademark, profit, organization, foundation, inc, creative, attribution, sharealike, license, rendered, parsoid, last, edited, utc, hidden, category, anchors, dmy, dates, themes, https, org, index, php, title, brain_in_a_vat, oldid, 1366026447, treatise, nature, discourse, method, essays, mathematicians, dogmatists, outlines, pyrrhonism, academica, barhaspatya, sutras, relativism, contextualism, epistemic, closure, process, reliabilism, hand, cogito, ergo, sum, wax, regress, induction, criterion, münchhausen, trilemma, five, minute, ignoramus, ignorabimus, suspension, judgment, epoché, cartesian, doubt, aporia, acatalepsy, unger, drummond, gottlob, ernst, schulze, hume, humean, bayle, uriel, costa, francisco, sanches, charron, renaissance, nicholas, autrecourt, scholasticism, benson, mates, fogelin, richard, popkin, chillingworth, favorinus, sextus, empiricus, agrippa, timon, pyrrho, elis, pyrrhonists, simon, foucher, dio, alexandria, gaius, aurelius, cotta, philo, larissa, aeschines, neapolis, charmadas, clitomachus, aristanax, stratonicea, hagnon, tarsus, carneades, hegesinus, evander, telecles, lacydes, diocles, cnidus, arcesilaus, academic, nausiphanes, anaxarchus, chios, atomist, xeniades, xenophanes, pre, socratic, charvaka, ajñana, jayarāśi, bhaṭṭa, sanjaya, belatthiputta, indian, scientific, jewish, religious, pseudoskepticism, moral, local, architecture, cell, robot, adaptive, flight, living, networks, microelectrode, arrays, 1996, harper, magazine, teaser, chapter, 222, discussion, inverse, fieser, james, dowden, bradley, eds, 37741658, 2161, 0002, 429049174, 1095, 5054, zalta, edward, media, photo, monsterhunter, 2013, 2022, turns, jeremy, sitting, glass, water, hooked, eeg, led, kind, clearance, sale, set, leftovers, 2018, monsterhuntermoviereviews, com, 1958, 1995, 545, 0031, 8205, 525, phenomenological, research, minds, 1986, 167, 0022, 362x, 148, pritchard, duncan, engaging, wittgenstein, cavell, occasion, sensitive, semantics, heil, john, 2001, blackwell, publishers, 412, 9780470998656, 404, companion, analytic, tymoczko, thomas, 1989, 295, 170928278, 4320079, bf00372698, 294, defense, 1992, december, 4545146, 0066, 7374, society, proof, goldberg, sanford, 9781107706965, 1017, cbo9781107706965, 002, chen, jiaming, lin, zhang, 269, 44259404, 1673, 3436, 255, frontiers, china, shapiro, lawrence, sufficiency, objective, 1988, 219, british, academy, kirk, 1997, relations, communication, cosmelli, diego, spring, 2011, 170332029, 5840, philtopics201139119, 163, topics, brainbound, versus, enactive, views, thompson, evan, 142, 126, break, why, extended, embedded, heylighen, francis, cogburn, jon, silcox, mark, 579, 2020, 143774123, 2210, 5433, s13347, 013, 0137, 561, vatism, value, bouwsma, 1949, 151, 149, review, genius, june, klein, chalmers, oxford, pressnew, 176, 518106, oso, 9780195181067, 003, 0009, 132, explore, 1973, princeton, wirehead, transhumanism, technological, pill, organoid, intelligence, neurally, controlled, animat, uploading, metaverse, internalism, project, avicenna, floating, borg, boltzmann, wire, 1979, tales, unexpected, 1961, roald, dahl, mary, black, mirror, white, christmas, part, whisperer, darkness, written, american, dad, vacation, goo, transcendence, total, recall, thirteenth, floor, strange, days, steins, gate, diaries, spock, source, soma, sid, meier, alpha, centauri, ship, bottle, saints, row, robocop, repo, men, psycho, pass, worlds, dwarf, time, lobotomy, corporation, overture, dlc, kavanozdaki, adam, inner, light, inception, ghost, shell, doctor, anchor, gangers, futurama, flashes, before, your, eyes, automatron, vegas, old, blues, point, lookout, existenz, dark, cold, lazarus, city, children, chappie, caprica, brainstorm, novel, morbius, 1965, outer, limits, colonel, barham, bliss, avatar, alita, battle, angel, season, agents, poster, 1962, wouldn, die, earliest, reconstruction, define, far, prove, although, achieve, strengthens, justified, metalanguage, belong, arisen, skeptic, demand, proven, combat, various, reconstructed, utilize, principles, others, focus, priori, third, comes, direction, presented, philosopher, attempts, usage, tries, illustrate, basis, defined, assumed, words, automatically, intrinsically, represents, later, become, known, concept, illustrated, establishes, mean, play, back, offers, example, individuals, possess, exact, mental, state, instance, think, referent, twins, possessing, instead, bearing, writes, never, existed, truthfully, within, refers, sometimes, constraint, demonstrably, alternatively, speaker, actually, concludes, necessarily, explored, length, publication, potential, kidnapped, placed, subjected, still, correctly, notion, incorrect, underpinning, formulated, extension, rules, discussed, sections, chance, second, deals, directly, coming, often, ultra, sensors, via, touching, tasting, smelling, receive, input, oftentimes, leads, difference, between, debate, hashed, unresolved, ramifications, discussions, limited, derives, idea, biologically, lacks, renders, neither, nor, equal, counter, argued, made, replicate, inputs, neurophysiologically, neuroanatomically, connections, dis, while, seen, helpful, surrounding, plausibility, conclude, implausible, consequence, closer, than, prior, recently, seriously, affect, autonomy, form, destroy, cognitive, structure, take, away, contrary, allow, more, propositions, insights, perspectives, given, meditations, dreamed, butterfly, maya, illusion, hindu, simplest, simple, runs, gives, exactly, interacting, tell, down, street, eating, ice, cream, latter, might, completely, impossible, rule, oneself, good, grounds, believing, any, contend, certainly, them, drawn, upon, sensation, order, question, really, deceived, all, wider, questions, concerning, perception, perspective, based, describing, spatio, temporal, meaningful, possesses, relation, whatever, denotes, envatted, whose, entire, composed, electric, manipulations, performed, much, place, consider, fail, whom, carry, referential, denote, word, cornerstone, produced, significant, works, inspired, franchise, used, variety, intended, draw, certain, features, conceptions, conceived, turned, modernized, involves, removes, host, suspends, life, sustaining, liquid, supercomputer, provides, normally, appropriate, own, output, continue, perfectly, normal, conscious, without, simulating, electrical, connects, neurons, wires, mad, scientist, redirects, free, item, projects, printable, download, print, export, switch, parser, get, shortened, url, cite, permanent, general, actions, talk, tiếng, việt, oʻzbekcha, ўзбекча, українська, türkçe, tagalog, svenska, српски, srpski, русский, português, polski, norsk, bokmål, nederlands, lietuvių, 한국어, ქართული, 日本語, italiano, íslenska, bahasa, indonesia, հայերեն, hrvatski, עברית, français, suomi, فارسی, euskara, eesti, español, deutsch, dansk, català, বাংলা, العربية, subsection, top, personal, special, recent, community, portal, learn, help, contribute, random, navigation, jump,

Text of the page (random words):
er argued that the hypothetical machine could be made to also replicate those types of inputs argument from externalism edit a second argument deals directly with the stimuli coming into the brain this is often referred to as the account from externalism or ultra externalism 10 in the biv the brain receives stimuli from a machine in an embodied brain however the brain receives the stimuli from the sensors found in the body via touching tasting smelling etc which receive their input from the external environment this argument oftentimes leads to the conclusion that there is a difference between what the biv is representing and what the embodied brain is representing this debate has been hashed out but remains unresolved by several philosophers including uriah kriegel 11 colin mcginn 12 and robert d rupert 13 and has ramifications for philosophy of mind discussions on but not limited to representation consciousness content cognition and embodied cognition 14 argument from incoherence edit a third argument against biv comes from a direction of incoherence which was presented by the philosopher hilary putnam he attempts to demonstrate this through the usage of a transcendental argument in which he tries to illustrate that the thought experiment s incoherence lies on the basis that it is self refuting 15 this relationship is further defined through a theory of reference that suggested reference can not be assumed and words are not automatically intrinsically connected with what it represents this theory of reference would later become known as semantic externalism this concept is further illustrated when putnam establishes a scenario in which a monkey types out hamlet by chance however this does not mean that the monkey is referring to the play because the monkey has no knowledge of hamlet and therefore can not refer back to it 16 he then offers the twin earth example to demonstrate that two identical individuals one on the earth and another on a twin earth may possess the exact same mental state and thoughts yet refer to two different things 17 for instance when people think of cats the referent of their thoughts would be the cats that are found on earth however people s twins on twin earth though possessing the same thoughts would instead be referring not to earth s cats but to twin earth s cats bearing this in mind he writes that a pure brain in a vat i e one that has never existed outside of the simulation could not even truthfully say that it was a brain in a vat this is because the biv when it says brain and vat can only refer to objects within the simulation not to things outside the simulation it does not have a relationship with putnam refers to this relationship as a causal connection which is sometimes referred to as a causal constraint 18 2 therefore what it says is demonstrably false alternatively if the speaker is not actually a biv then the statement is also false he concludes then that the statement i m a biv is necessarily false and self refuting 17 this argument has been explored at length in philosophical literature since its publication a potential loophole in putnam s reference theory is that a brain on earth that is kidnapped placed into a vat and subjected to a simulation could still refer to brains and vats which are real in the sense of putnam and thus correctly say it is a brain in a vat according to putnamian reference theory 19 however the notion that the pure biv is incorrect and the reference theory underpinning it remains influential in the philosophy of mind language and metaphysics 20 21 anthony l brueckner has formulated an extension of putnam s argument which rules out this loophole by employing a disquotational principle it will be discussed in the following two sections reconstructions of putnam s argument edit an issue that has arisen with putnam s argument is that his premises only imply the metalinguistic statement my utterances of i am a biv are false but a skeptic may demand the object language statement i am a biv to be proven 22 23 to combat this issue various philosophers have reconstructed putnam s argument some like anthony l brueckner and crispin wright have taken approaches that utilize disquotational principles 22 18 others like ted a warfield have taken approaches that focus on the concepts of self knowledge and priori 23 the disjunctive argument edit one of the earliest but influential reconstructions of putnam s transcendental argument was suggested by anthony l brueckner brueckner s reconstruction is as follows 1 either i am a biv speaking vat english or i am a non biv speaking english 2 if i am a biv speaking vat english then my utterances of i am a biv are true if i have sense impressions as of being a biv 3 if i am a biv speaking vat english then i do not have sense impressions as of being a biv 4 if i am a biv speaking vat english then my utterances of i am a biv are false 2 3 5 if i am a non biv speaking english then my utterances of i am a biv are true if i am a biv 6 if i am a non biv speaking english then my utterances of i am a biv are false 5 7 my utterances of i am a biv are false 1 4 6 22 though these premises further define putnam s argument they do not so far prove i am not a biv because although the premises imply the metalinguistic statement my utterances i am a biv are false they do not yet imply the object language statement i am not a biv to achieve the putnamian conclusion brueckner strengthens his argument by employing the disquotational principle my utterances of i am not a biv are true if i am not a biv this statement is justified since the metalanguage that contains the tokens for the disquotational principle also contains the object language tokens to which the utterances i am not a biv belong 22 a poster for the film the brain that wouldn t die 1962 in fiction edit main article isolated brain in fiction agents of s h i e l d season 4 alita battle angel avatar bliss the brain of colonel barham a 1965 episode of the tv series the outer limits the brain of morbius brain novel brainstorm caprica chappie the city of lost children cold lazarus the colossus of new york 24 dark star donovan s brain existenz fallout series point lookout an expansion pack for fallout 3 old world blues an expansion pack for fallout new vegas automatron an expansion pack for fallout 4 flashes before your eyes an episode of lost futurama gangers broken anchor in doctor who ghost in the shell inception the inner light an episode of star trek the next generation kavanozdaki adam tr lies of p in the overture dlc lobotomy corporation the man with two brains the matrix film series out of time an episode of red dwarf possible worlds psycho pass repo men robocop saints row iv ship in a bottle an episode of star trek the next generation sid meier s alpha centauri soma source code spock s brain an episode of star trek the original series the star diaries steins gate 0 strange days the thirteenth floor total recall transcendence tron tron legacy upload tv series the vacation goo an episode of american dad where am i written by daniel dennett the whisperer in darkness white christmas part ii an episode of black mirror william and mary by roald dahl adapted into the first episode of way out in 1961 adapted again for tales of the unexpected in 1979 world on a wire see also edit boltzmann brain borg star trek dream argument evil demon experience machine floating man avicenna thought experiment human brain project internalism and externalism isolated brain metaverse mind uploading neurally controlled animat organoid intelligence red pill simulation hypothesis skeptical hypothesis solipsism technological singularity transhumanism wirehead science fiction references edit harman gilbert 1973 thought princeton nj p 5 1 2 3 putnam hilary 1981 brains in a vat pdf reason truth and history cambridge university of cambridge archived from the original pdf on 6 october 2021 retrieved 21 april 2015 brueckner tony 29 october 2004 brains in a vat stanford encyclopedia of philosophy retrieved 7 march 2025 chalmers david j 1 september 2004 the matrix as metaphysics philosophers explore the matrix oxford university pressnew york ny pp 132 176 doi 10 1093 oso 9780195181067 003 0009 isbn 978 0 19 518106 7 retrieved 20 november 2023 klein peter 2 june 2015 skepticism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy archived from the original on 31 january 2016 retrieved 7 january 2017 bouwsma o k 1949 descartes evil genius pdf the philosophical review 58 2 149 151 doi 10 2307 2181388 jstor 2181388 archived pdf from the original on 31 may 2023 retrieved 2 march 2021 cogburn jon silcox mark 2014 against brain in a vatism on the value of virtual reality philosophy technology 27 4 561 579 doi 10 1007 s13347 013 0137 4 issn 2210 5433 s2cid 143774123 archived from the original on 5 november 2023 retrieved 8 november 2020 heylighen francis 2012 a brain in a vat cannot break out why the singularity must be extended embedded and embodied journal of consciousness studies 19 1 2 126 142 archived from the original on 15 april 2019 retrieved 7 february 2017 thompson evan cosmelli diego spring 2011 brain in a vat or body in a world brainbound versus enactive views of experience philosophical topics 39 1 163 180 doi 10 5840 philtopics201139119 s2cid 170332029 archived from the original on 22 july 2019 retrieved 7 february 2017 kirk robert 1997 consciousness information and external relations communication and cognition 30 3 4 kriegel uriah 2014 current controversies in philosophy of mind routledge pp 180 95 mcginn colin 1988 consciousness and content proceedings of the british academy 76 219 39 rupert robert 2014 the sufficiency of objective representation current controversies in philosophy of mind routledge pp 180 95 shapiro lawrence 2014 when is cognition embodied current controversies in philosophy of mind routledge pp 73 90 chen jiaming lin zhang 2012 on the issues of transcendental argument frontiers of philosophy in china 7 2 255 269 issn 1673 3436 jstor 44259404 archived from the original on 10 october 2021 retrieved 10 october 2021 brueckner tony 2016 putnam on brains in a vat in goldberg sanford c ed the brain in a vat cambridge cambridge university press pp 19 26 doi 10 1017 cbo9781107706965 002 isbn 9781107706965 archived from the original on 5 november 2023 retrieved 23 september 2021 1 2 putnam hilary 1981 reason truth and history cambridge cambridge university press pp 14 18 19 isbn 978 0 52129776 9 1 2 wright crispin 1992 on putnam s proof that we are not brains in a vat proceedings of the aristotelian society 92 67 94 doi 10 1093 aristotelian 92 1 67 issn 0066 7374 jstor 4545146 archived from the original on 17 december 2025 retrieved 19 september 2021 tymoczko thomas 1989 in defense of putnam s brains philosophical studies 57 3 294 295 doi 10 1007 bf00372698 jstor 4320079 s2cid 170928278 archived from the original on 6 february 2021 retrieved 17 march 2021 heil john 2001 a companion to analytic philosophy blackwell publishers pp 404 412 isbn 9780470998656 pritchard duncan putnam on radical skepticism wittgenstein cavell and occasion sensitive semantics pdf engaging putnam 1 2 archived pdf from the original on 5 november 2023 retrieved 17 march 2021 1 2 3 4 brueckner anthony l 1986 brains in a vat the journal of philosophy 83 3 148 167 doi 10 2307 2026572 issn 0022 362x jstor 2026572 archived from the original on 30 september 2025 retrieved 10 october 2021 1 2 warfield ted a 1995 knowing the world and knowing our minds philosophy and phenomenological research 55 3 525 545 doi 10 2307 2108437 issn 0031 8205 jstor 2108437 archived from the original on 13 january 2026 retrieved 10 october 2021 the colossus of new york 1958 monsterhuntermoviereviews com monsterhunter 27 september 2013 archived from the original on 17 january 2022 retrieved 11 march 2018 it turns out that jeremy s brain was sitting in a glass case of water hooked up to an eeg machine which led me to believe that they must have had some kind of clearance sale on set leftovers from donovan s brain with photo external links edit wikimedia commons has media related to brain in a vat philosophy brueckner tony skepticism and content externalism in zalta edward n ed stanford encyclopedia of philosophy issn 1095 5054 oclc 429049174 fieser james dowden bradley eds brain in a vat internet encyclopedia of philosophy issn 2161 0002 oclc 37741658 inverse brain in a vat putnam s discussion of the brains in a vat in chapter one of reason truth and history cambridge cambridge university press 1981 p 222 isbn 978 0 52129776 9 where am i by daniel dennett brain in a vat brain teaser harper s magazine 1996 science adaptive flight control with living neuronal networks on microelectrode arrays architecture for neuronal cell control of a mobile robot v t e philosophical skepticism types local moral pseudoskepticism radical religious jewish skeptics scientific solipsism philosophers indian sanjaya belatthiputta jayarāśi bhaṭṭa ajñana charvaka pre socratic xenophanes xeniades atomist metrodorus of chios anaxarchus nausiphanes academic skeptics arcesilaus diocles of cnidus lacydes telecles and evander hegesinus carneades hagnon of tarsus metrodorus of stratonicea aristanax clitomachus charmadas aeschines of neapolis philo of larissa cicero gaius aurelius cotta dio of alexandria simon foucher pyrrhonists pyrrho of elis timon agrippa sextus empiricus aenesidemus favorinus william chillingworth richard popkin robert fogelin benson mates scholasticism nicholas of autrecourt renaissance montaigne pierre charron francisco sanches uriel da costa pierre bayle humean david hume gottlob ernst schulze william drummond peter unger concepts acatalepsy aporia cartesian doubt epoché suspension of judgment ignoramus et ignorabimus skeptical scenarios brain in a vat dream argument evil demon five minute hypothesis münchhausen trilemma problem of the criterion problem of induction regress argument simulation hypothesis wax argument responses cogito ergo sum here is one hand semantic externalism process reliabilism epistemic closure contextualism relativism literature barhaspatya sutras academica cicero outlines of pyrrhonism against the dogmatists against the mathematicians essays montaigne discourse on the method a treatise of human nature aenesidemus retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title brain_in_a_vat oldid 1366026447 categories hypothetical technology science fiction themes thought experiments in philosophy hidden categories articles with short description short description is different from wikidata use dmy dates from september 2015 pages with broken anchors commons category link is on wikidata articles with internet encyclopedia of philosophy links this page was last edited on 25 july 2026 at 21 15 utc page was rendered with parsoid text is available under the creative commons attribution sharealike 4 0 license additional terms may apply by using this site you agree to...