Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

numerical, relativity, of, contents, overview, history, recent, developments, see, also, notes, external, links, foundations, in, theory, early, results, maturation, the, field, excision, punctures, 2005, breakthrough, annus, mirabilis, lazarus, project, adaptive, mesh, refinement,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (202), and (64), black (61), numerical (53), #relativity (52), doi (36), bibcode (35), holes (35), hole (28), s2cid (28), arxiv (28), 1103 (27), phys (27), rev (26), equations (25), that (24), with (22), for (22), gravitational (22), this (18), from (18), edit (18), field (18), was (13), binary (13), physrevd (13), physrevlett (13), excision (13), einstein (13), first (13), computational (12), pmid (12), lett (12), problem (12), one (12), coordinate (12), general (11), initial (11), two (11), data (10), 2005 (10), time (10), also (10), results (10), has (10), other (9), mesh (9), refinement (9), singularity (9), conditions (9), can (9), move (9), solutions (9), theory (9), wikipedia (8), lousto (8), campanelli (8), spacetime (8), horizon (8), were (8), adm (8), using (7), which (7), david (7), evolutions (7), baker (7), radiation (7), evolution (7), spacetimes (7), published (7), technique (7), known (7), study (7), not (7), solution (7), are (7), science (6), stars (6), simulations (6), wave (6), three (6), dimensional (6), adaptive (6), collapse (6), lazarus (6), physical (6), simulation (6), have (6), been (6), merger (6), method (6), used (6), into (6), event (6), more (6), techniques (6), problems (6), inside (6), these (6), methods (6), about (5), page (5), physics (5), dynamics (5), quantum (5), rotating (5), neutron (5), effects (5), puncture (5), 1088 (5), university (5), project (5), accurate (5), collision (5), piran (5), research (5), waves (5), most (5), any (5), work (5), form (5), solve (5), all (5), numerically (5), years (5), because (5), early (5), many (5), history (5), contents (4), search (4), may (4), articles (4), short (4), mathematics (4), retrieved (4), mechanics (4), article (4), links (4), zlochower (4), spin (4), james (4), richard (4), john (4), joan (4), 2004 (4), fixed (4), 0264 (4), 9381 (4), 2003 (4), choptuik (4), takahashi (4), orbiting (4), lindquist (4), energy (4), bernd (4), seidel (4), gauge (4), 1995 (4), smarr (4), 2024 (4), computers (4), applied (4), post (4), well (4), through (4), dimensions (4), such (4), fields (4), single (4), developed (4), attempts (4), punctures (4), some (4), out (4), special (4), annus (4), mirabilis (4), outside (4), calculations (4), static (4), their (4), like (4), space (4), hide (4), sidebar (4), toggle (3), view (3), statistics (3), code (3), fluid (3), systems (3), technical (3), review (3), yosef (3), carlos (3), manuela (3), hyperbolic (3), foundations (3), multiple (3), relativistic (3), fiske (3), van (3), meter (3), choi (3), dae (3), centrella (3), evolving (3), class (3), grav (3), 2001 (3), thesis (3), cambridge (3), critical (3), scalar (3), axisymmetry (3), frontiers (3), remnant (3), astro (3), merging (3), york (3), 131 (3), brugmann (3), peter (3), long (3), term (3), alcubierre (3), miguel (3), new (3), formalism (3), 270 (3), larry (3), misner (3), der (3), albert (3), astrophysical (3), allow (3), its (3), mass (3), recent (3), original (3), but (3), become (3), emitted (3), than (3), after (3), supercomputers (3), group (3), ability (3), propagate (3), does (3), could (3), each (3), part (3), free (3), stability (3), late (3), while (3), changes (3), associated (3), solving (3), described (3), case (3), paper (3), symmetry (3), what (3), areas (3), attention (3), tools (3), main (3), languages (2), table (2), contact (2), privacy (2), policy (2), available (2), under (2), terms (2), foundation (2), use (2), commons (2), categories (2), video (2), specifically (2), clarification (2), description (2), different (2), wikidata (2), org (2), electromagnetics (2), structure (2), introduction (2), concepts (2), external (2), merritt (2), 2007 (2), mergers (2), 064030 (2), ian (2), shoemaker (2), deirdre (2), laguna (2), pablo (2), matzner (2), 2009 (2), 041101 (2), 102 (2), 231102 (2), 024034 (2), shapiro (2), stuart (2), extraction (2), 104036 (2), 124025 (2), 2004phrvd (2), schnetter (2), erik (2), scott (2), symmetric (2), inhomogeneous (2), cosmologies (2), steven (2), pretorius (2), massless (2), 044007 (2), 2003phrvd (2), coalescence (2), spinning (2), 027505 (2), 2002 (2), 124012 (2), 2002phrvd (2), forms (2), 121103 (2), approach (2), 044001 (2), koppitz (2), michael (2), 2006 (2), 111102 (2), 2006phrvl (2), binaries (2), without (2), 111101 (2), bowen (2), 2047 (2), brill (2), 471 (2), simple (2), 3606 (2), 121101 (2), moving (2), 2003cqgra (2), 211101 (2), edward (2), 084023 (2), 304 (2), classical (2), gravity (2), cook (2), 1998 (2), 2512 (2), masso (2), 600 (2), 104006 (2), anninos (2), suen (2), 2059 (2), 5238 (2), 941 (2), pdf (2), geometry (2), stark (2), 891 (2), cylindrical (2), 1085 (2), eppley (2), 1975 (2), oclc (2), 1977 (2), generated (2), 302 (2), ann (2), hahn (2), 1964 (2), arnowitt (2), deser (2), gravitation (2), current (2), 1915 (2), 2000 (2), gw150914 (2), notes (2), newtonian (2), see (2), papers (2), mathematical (2), extended (2), galaxy (2), process (2), rest (2), developments (2), amr (2), appears (2), 1980s (2), now (2), addition (2), propagation (2), events (2), schwarzschild (2), insight (2), relatively (2), radiated (2), momentum (2), computed (2), second (2), grand (2), challenge (2), lived (2), full (2), before (2), around (2), led (2), orbit (2), researchers (2), demonstrated (2), system (2), thus (2), earlier (2), since (2), matter (2), computation (2), 100 (2), breakthrough (2), contains (2), then (2), prescription (2), required (2), position (2), course (2), several (2), including (2), stable (2), 1990s (2), surrounding (2), simply (2), evolved (2), should (2), still (2), obtain (2), imposing (2), boundary (2), careful (2), example (2), characteristic (2), coordinates (2), followed (2), powerful (2), various (2), groups (2), nonlinear (2), based (2), maturation (2), documented (2), focused (2), closed (2), exact (2), attempt (2), they (2), lack (2), memory (2), tsvi (2), few (2), set (2), constrained (2), decomposition (2), formulated (2), related (2), value (2), cosmological (2), partial (2), differential (2), often (2), specialization (2), scientific (2), analysis (2), paid (2), evolve (2), phenomena (2), stationary (2), dynamical (2), overview (2), appearance (2), upload (2), file (2), read (2), log (2), create (2), account (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, mobile, cookie, statement, developers, conduct, legal, safety, contacts, disclaimers, text, additional, apply, site, you, agree, registered, trademark, non, profit, organization, wikimedia, inc, creative, attribution, sharealike, license, rendered, parsoid, last, edited, september, 2026, utc, hidden, containing, clips, marked, weasel, worded, phrases, july, 2025, needing, march, 2014, https, index, php, title, numerical_relativity, oldid, 1375775298, category, transportation, semiotics, engineering, materials, finance, archaeology, economics, sociology, politics, social, lexicology, semantics, linguistics, thermodynamics, particle, optics, geophysics, aerodynamics, biofluids, astrophysics, aeroacoustics, molecular, electronic, chemistry, phylogenetics, neuroscience, genomics, cognition, biological, anatomy, biology, basic, tutorial, caltech, section, applications, includes, discussion, krishnan, badri, flips, precession, 119334687, 2007phrvd, 75f4030c, 0612076, healy, herrmann, frank, hinder, superkicks, encounters, 9897187, 19257409, 2009phrvl, 102d1101h, 0807, 3292, maximum, recoil, 29246347, 17677894, 2007phrvl, 98w1102c, 0702133, 2008, 96426196, 2008phrvd, 77b4034l, 0711, 1165, etienne, zachariah, liu, yuk, tung, baumgarte, thomas, star, 104021, 119110932, 044024, 2009phrvd, 79d4024e, 0812, 2245, zone, 119402841, 2005phrvd, 71j4036f, 0503100, imbiriba, breno, brown, olson, kevin, 119376660, 70l4025i, 0403048, hawley, hawke, 1488, 52322605, 014, 2004cqgra, 1465s, 0310042, 1465, belanger, master, oakland, hern, simon, 1999, dissertation, 0004036, hirschmann, eric, liebling, frans, 14053692, 68d4007c, 0305003, matthew, 1993, universality, scaling, 10053245, 1993phrvl, 1989, experiences, algorithm, evans, finn, hobill, eds, press, 521, 36666, isbn, 119371535, 69b7505b, 0305287, understanding, fate, supermassive, s393, 119011566, 034, 2005cqgra, 22s, 387c, 0411744, s387, modeling, coalescing, 39834308, 65l4012b, 0202469, brügmann, plunge, inspiralling, 39434471, 11580497, 2001phrvl, 87l1103b, 0102037, pragmatic, 11080736, 65d4001b, 0104063, inspiraling, configuration, 23409406, 16605809, 96k1102b, 0511103, marronetti, 5954627, 16605808, 96k1101c, 0511048, 1980, asymmetric, collisions, 2056, 1980phrvd, 2047b, 1963, interaction, geometrostatics, 476, physrev, 1963phrv, 471b, brandt, bruegmann, 1997, construction, 3609, 12024926, 1997phrvl, 3606b, 9703066, letters, 24225193, 16197061, 2005phrvl, 95l1101p, 0507014, smith, kenneth, sperhake, ulrich, via, 3744, 118897417, 313, 3729s, 0301111, 3729, tichy, wolfgang, jansen, nina, 17256720, 15245270, 2004phrvl, 92u1101b, 0312112, diener, pollney, denis, ryoji, 29026273, 67h4023a, 0206072, slicings, avoidance, shocks, 623, 119349361, 607a, 0210050, 607, boosted, 2516, 14432705, 1998phrvl, 2512c, 9711078, bona, stela, 603, 19846364, 10060068, 1995phrvl, 600b, 9412071, 35591865, 2001phrvd, 63j4006a, 0008067, camarda, karen, wai, towns, 2082, 15501717, 10019426, 1995phrvd, 2059a, 9503025, teukolsky, saul, winicour, 947, 121172545, 1126, 1995sci, 941m, 1985, emission, 894, 10032474, 1985phrvl, 891s, 1978, 1978phrvl, 1085p, princeton, 8314225, 569, 84665358, 1111, 1749, 6632, tb37076, 1977nyasa, 569s, acad, sci, texas, austin, 27646162, illustration, body, geometrodynamics, 331, 1016, 0003, 4916, 90223, 1964anphy, 304h, 1962, wiley, 265, 227, witten, 847, 844, sitzungsberichte, königlich, preußischen, akademie, wissenschaften, die, feldgleichungen, gregory, 29142501, 5660886, pmc, 12942, lrr, 2000lrr, 0007085, living, reviews, gottlieb, sigal, khanna, gaurav, 2297, 4687, issn, 3389, fams, 1420155, editorial, advances, 2016, february, ligo, detects, chapel, hill, conference, cactus, framework, flip, expansion, 21st, century, hundreds, leading, wide, spectrum, involving, surprising, predictions, give, speed, 4000, escape, predict, enormous, release, amounting, total, roots, beyond, application, literature, his, studies, dimension, subsequently, standard, tool, compact, objects, astronomical, meantime, gave, best, produced, numerous, angular, latest, state, linear, unequal, final, detailed, predicted, energetic, universe, releasing, fraction, entire, lifetime, extract, combined, approximation, trajectories, perturbations, attempting, previous, integrate, hilbert, describing, software, failure, completed, eliminating, allowed, choosing, appropriate, making, crude, analytic, assumptions, near, crudeness, approximations, obtained, ripples, them, named, 1905, whom, factored, analytical, constructed, generalization, generalized, until, usage, remain, during, proximity, will, tend, force, fact, remained, meant, themselves, became, stretched, twisted, typically, instabilities, stage, over, development, increased, regions, grid, proposed, portion, affect, principle, properties, nothing, influence, able, valid, excises, interior, ingoing, implementation, very, successful, minor, cannot, elliptical, instantly, means, needs, type, velocities, less, light, harmonic, must, continually, adjust, location, region, causality, only, did, alternate, improve, efficiency, respect, devised, avoid, existence, singularities, order, provide, linearized, derived, generally, already, introduced, perturbation, spherically, provides, excellent, test, compared, challenging, features, earliest, simulate, point, progress, impeded, sufficient, power, perform, resolved, realistic, carried, resulting, formation, calculated, nearly, following, there, fairly, probably, due, sufficiently, address, successfully, simulated, head, processing, step, result, exploiting, alliance, computer, technology, would, supported, substantial, size, soon, thereafter, same, wrote, calculation, today, versus, deal, fundamental, treating, constraint, arise, applying, reduced, requirements, allowing, needed, emerged, desire, construct, approximately, necessary, precursor, back, separated, 1950s, although, reasons, precise, rarely, practical, approaches, closely, formulation, procedure, reformulates, addressed, methodologies, charles, stanley, unified, subject, coupled, pdes, publication, those, assume, reduce, complexity, distinct, implemented, inapplicable, facets, however, shared, large, scale, sciences, solid, relativists, mathematicians, draw, among, theories, line, much, formulations, effect, produce, convergence, cases, ways, received, majority, begin, snapshot, neighboring, hypersurfaces, hypersurface, regge, calculus, cauchy, perturbed, models, primary, goal, whose, found, computationally, either, fully, contain, vacuum, equilibrium, divided, requiring, currently, active, branches, uses, analyze, end, employed, algorithms, inspiral, warping, horizons, sub, area, computing, encyclopedia, item, projects, printable, version, download, print, export, switch, legacy, parser, get, shortened, url, cite, information, permanent, link, here, actions, english, talk, oʻzbekcha, ўзбекча, українська, slovenščina, русский, português, հայերեն, فارسی, español, чӑвашла, català, subsection, top, personal, pages, community, portal, learn, help, contribute, random, navigation, jump, content,

Text of the page (random words):
event horizon for the spacetime this result still required imposing and exploiting axisymmetry in the calculations 12 some of the first documented attempts to solve the einstein equations in three dimensions were focused on a single schwarzschild black hole which is described by a static and spherically symmetric solution to the einstein field equations this provides an excellent test case in numerical relativity because it does have a closed form solution so that numerical results can be compared to an exact solution because it is static and because it contains one of the most numerically challenging features of relativity theory a physical singularity one of the earliest groups to attempt to simulate this solution was peter anninos et al in 1995 13 in their paper they point out that progress in three dimensional numerical relativity has been impeded in part by lack of computers with sufficient memory and computational power to perform well resolved calculations of 3d spacetimes maturation of the field edit in the years that followed not only did computers become more powerful but also various research groups developed alternate techniques to improve the efficiency of the calculations with respect to black hole simulations specifically two techniques were devised to avoid problems associated with the existence of physical singularities in the solutions to the equations 1 excision and 2 the puncture method in addition the lazarus group developed techniques for using early results from a short lived simulation solving the nonlinear adm equations in order to provide initial data for a more stable code based on linearized equations derived from perturbation theory more generally adaptive mesh refinement techniques already used in computational fluid dynamics were introduced to the field of numerical relativity excision edit in the excision technique which was first proposed in the late 1990s 14 a portion of a spacetime inside of the event horizon surrounding the singularity of a black hole is simply not evolved in theory this should not affect the solution to the equations outside of the event horizon because of the principle of causality and properties of the event horizon i e nothing physical inside the black hole can influence any of the physics outside the horizon thus if one simply does not solve the equations inside the horizon one should still be able to obtain valid solutions outside one excises the interior by imposing ingoing boundary conditions on a boundary surrounding the singularity but inside the horizon while the implementation of excision has been very successful the technique has two minor problems the first is that one has to be careful about the coordinate conditions while physical effects cannot propagate from inside to outside coordinate effects could for example if the coordinate conditions were elliptical coordinate changes inside could instantly propagate out through the horizon this then means that one needs hyperbolic type coordinate conditions with characteristic velocities less than that of light for the propagation of coordinate effects e g using harmonic coordinates coordinate conditions the second problem is that as the black holes move one must continually adjust the location of the excision region to move with the black hole the excision technique was developed over several years including the development of new gauge conditions that increased stability and work that demonstrated the ability of the excision regions to move through the computational grid 15 16 17 18 19 20 the first stable long term evolution of the orbit and merger of two black holes using this technique was published in 2005 21 punctures edit in the puncture method the solution is factored into an analytical part 22 which contains the singularity of the black hole and a numerically constructed part which is then singularity free this is a generalization of the brill lindquist 23 prescription for initial data of black holes at rest and can be generalized to the bowen york 24 prescription for spinning and moving black hole initial data until 2005 all published usage of the puncture method required that the coordinate position of all punctures remain fixed during the course of the simulation of course black holes in proximity to each other will tend to move under the force of gravity so the fact that the coordinate position of the puncture remained fixed meant that the coordinate systems themselves became stretched or twisted and this typically led to numerical instabilities at some stage of the simulation 2005 s breakthrough annus mirabilis of numerical relativity edit in 2005 a group of researchers demonstrated for the first time the ability to allow punctures to move through the coordinate system thus eliminating some of the earlier problems with the method this allowed accurate long term evolutions of black holes 21 25 26 by choosing appropriate coordinate conditions and making crude analytic assumptions about the fields near the singularity since no physical effects can propagate out of the black hole the crudeness of the approximations does not matter numerical solutions could be obtained to the problem of two black holes orbiting each other as well as accurate computation of gravitational radiation ripples in spacetime emitted by them 2005 was named the annus mirabilis of numerical relativity by whom 100 years after the annus mirabilis papers of special relativity 1905 lazarus project edit the lazarus project 1998 2005 was developed as a post grand challenge technique to extract astrophysical results from short lived full numerical simulations of binary black holes it combined approximation techniques before post newtonian trajectories and after perturbations of single black holes with full numerical simulations attempting to solve einstein s field equations 27 all previous attempts to numerically integrate in supercomputers the hilbert einstein equations describing the gravitational field around binary black holes led to software failure before a single orbit was completed the lazarus project approach in the meantime gave the best insight into the binary black hole problem and produced numerous and relatively accurate results such as the radiated energy and angular momentum emitted in the latest merging state 28 29 the linear momentum radiated by unequal mass holes 30 and the final mass and spin of the remnant black hole 31 the method also computed detailed gravitational waves emitted by the merger process and predicted that the collision of black holes is the most energetic single event in the universe releasing more energy in a fraction of a second in the form of gravitational radiation than an entire galaxy in its lifetime adaptive mesh refinement edit adaptive mesh refinement amr as a numerical method has roots that go well beyond its first application in the field of numerical relativity mesh refinement first appears in the numerical relativity literature in the 1980s through the work of choptuik in his studies of critical collapse of scalar fields 32 33 the original work was in one dimension but it was subsequently extended to two dimensions 34 in two dimensions amr has also been applied to the study of inhomogeneous cosmologies 35 36 and to the study of schwarzschild black holes 37 the technique has now become a standard tool in numerical relativity and has been used to study the merger of black holes and other compact objects in addition to the propagation of gravitational radiation generated by such astronomical events 38 39 recent developments edit in the 21st century hundreds of research papers have been published leading to a wide spectrum of mathematical relativity gravitational wave and astrophysical results for the orbiting black hole problem this technique extended to astrophysical binary systems involving neutron stars and black holes 40 and multiple black holes 41 one of the most surprising predictions is that the merger of two black holes can give the remnant hole a speed of up to 4000 km s that can allow it to escape from any known galaxy 42 43 the simulations also predict an enormous release of gravitational energy in this merger process amounting up to 8 of its total rest mass 44 see also edit mathematics of general relativity post newtonian expansion spin flip cactus framework chapel hill conference notes edit gw150914 ligo detects gravitational waves black holes org retrieved 16 february 2016 field scott e gottlieb sigal khanna gaurav 2024 05 14 editorial advances in computational relativity frontiers in applied mathematics and statistics 10 frontiers doi 10 3389 fams 2024 1420155 issn 2297 4687 cook gregory b 2000 11 14 initial data for numerical relativity living reviews in relativity 3 1 5 arxiv gr qc 0007085 bibcode 2000lrr 3 5c doi 10 12942 lrr 2000 5 pmc 5660886 pmid 29142501 einstein albert 1915 die feldgleichungen der gravitation sitzungsberichte der königlich preußischen akademie der wissenschaften 844 847 arnowitt r deser s misner c w 1962 the dynamics of general relativity in witten l ed gravitation an introduction to current research new york wiley pp 227 265 hahn s g lindquist r w 1964 the two body problem in geometrodynamics ann phys 29 2 304 331 bibcode 1964anphy 29 304h doi 10 1016 0003 4916 64 90223 4 smarr larry 1975 the structure of general relativity with a numerical illustration the collision of two black holes ph d thesis university of texas at austin oclc 27646162 retrieved 2024 03 07 smarr larry 1977 spacetimes generated by computers black holes with gravitational radiation ann n y acad sci 302 569 bibcode 1977nyasa 302 569s doi 10 1111 j 1749 6632 1977 tb37076 x s2cid 84665358 eppley k r 1975 numerical evolution of the collision of two black holes ph d thesis princeton university oclc 8314225 retrieved 2024 03 07 piran t 1978 cylindrical general relativistic collapse phys rev lett 41 16 1085 1088 bibcode 1978phrvl 41 1085p doi 10 1103 physrevlett 41 1085 stark r f piran t 1985 gravitational wave emission from rotating gravitational collapse phys rev lett 55 8 891 894 bibcode 1985phrvl 55 891s doi 10 1103 physrevlett 55 891 pmid 10032474 matzner richard a seidel h e shapiro stuart l smarr l suen w m teukolsky saul a winicour j 1995 geometry of a black hole collision pdf science 270 5238 941 947 bibcode 1995sci 270 941m doi 10 1126 science 270 5238 941 s2cid 121172545 anninos peter camarda karen masso joan seidel edward suen wai mo towns john 1995 three dimensional numerical relativity the evolution of black holes phys rev d 52 4 2059 2082 arxiv gr qc 9503025 bibcode 1995phrvd 52 2059a doi 10 1103 physrevd 52 2059 pmid 10019426 s2cid 15501717 alcubierre miguel brugmann bernd 2001 simple excision of a black hole in 3 1 numerical relativity phys rev d 63 10 104006 arxiv gr qc 0008067 bibcode 2001phrvd 63j4006a doi 10 1103 physrevd 63 104006 s2cid 35591865 bona c masso j seidel e stela j 1995 new formalism for numerical relativity phys rev lett 75 4 600 603 arxiv gr qc 9412071 bibcode 1995phrvl 75 600b doi 10 1103 physrevlett 75 600 pmid 10060068 s2cid 19846364 cook g b et al 1998 boosted three dimensional black hole evolutions with singularity excision phys rev lett 80 12 2512 2516 arxiv gr qc 9711078 bibcode 1998phrvl 80 2512c doi 10 1103 physrevlett 80 2512 s2cid 14432705 alcubierre miguel 2003 hyperbolic slicings of spacetime singularity avoidance and gauge shocks classical and quantum gravity 20 4 607 623 arxiv gr qc 0210050 bibcode 2003cqgra 20 607a doi 10 1088 0264 9381 20 4 304 s2cid 119349361 alcubierre miguel brugmann bernd diener peter koppitz michael pollney denis seidel edward takahashi ryoji 2003 gauge conditions for long term numerical black hole evolutions without excision phys rev d 67 8 084023 arxiv gr qc 0206072 bibcode 2003phrvd 67h4023a doi 10 1103 physrevd 67 084023 s2cid 29026273 brugmann bernd tichy wolfgang jansen nina 2004 numerical simulation of orbiting black holes phys rev lett 92 21 211101 arxiv gr qc 0312112 bibcode 2004phrvl 92u1101b doi 10 1103 physrevlett 92 211101 pmid 15245270 s2cid 17256720 shoemaker deirdre smith kenneth sperhake ulrich laguna pablo schnetter erik fiske david 2003 moving black holes via singularity excision class quantum grav 20 16 3729 3744 arxiv gr qc 0301111 bibcode 2003cqgra 20 3729s doi 10 1088 0264 9381 20 16 313 s2cid 118897417 1 2 pretorius f 2005 evolution of binary black hole spacetimes phys rev lett 95 12 121101 arxiv gr qc 0507014 bibcode 2005phrvl 95l1101p doi 10 1103 physrevlett 95 121101 pmid 16197061 s2cid 24225193 brandt steven bruegmann bernd 1997 a simple construction of initial data for multiple black holes physical review letters 78 19 3606 3609 arxiv gr qc 9703066 bibcode 1997phrvl 78 3606b doi 10 1103 physrevlett 78 3606 s2cid 12024926 brill d lindquist r 1963 interaction energy in geometrostatics phys rev 131 1 471 476 bibcode 1963phrv 131 471b doi 10 1103 physrev 131 471 bowen j york j w 1980 time asymmetric initial data for black holes and black hole collisions phys rev d 21 8 2047 2056 bibcode 1980phrvd 21 2047b doi 10 1103 physrevd 21 2047 campanelli m lousto c o marronetti p zlochower y 2006 accurate evolutions of orbiting black hole binaries without excision phys rev lett 96 11 111101 arxiv gr qc 0511048 bibcode 2006phrvl 96k1101c doi 10 1103 physrevlett 96 111101 pmid 16605808 s2cid 5954627 baker john g centrella joan choi dae il koppitz michael van meter james 2006 gravitational wave extraction from an inspiraling configuration of merging black holes phys rev lett 96 11 111102 arxiv gr qc 0511103 bibcode 2006phrvl 96k1102b doi 10 1103 physrevlett 96 111102 pmid 16605809 s2cid 23409406 baker j campanelli m lousto c o 2002 the lazarus project a pragmatic approach to binary black hole evolutions phys rev d 65 4 044001 arxiv gr qc 0104063 bibcode 2002phrvd 65d4001b doi 10 1103 physrevd 65 044001 s2cid 11080736 baker j brügmann b campanelli m lousto c o takahashi r 2001 plunge wave forms from inspiralling binary black holes phys rev lett 87 12 121103 arxiv gr qc 0102037 bibcode 2001phrvl 87l1103b doi 10 1103 physrevlett 87 121103 pmid 11580497 s2cid 39434471 baker j campanelli m lousto c o takahashi r 2002 modeling gravitational radiation from coalescing binary black holes phys rev d 65 12 124012 arxiv astro ph 0202469 bibcode 2002phrvd 65l4012b doi 10 1103 physrevd 65 124012 s2cid 39834308 campanelli manuela 2005 understanding the fate of merging supermassive black holes class quantum grav 22 10 s387 s393 arxiv astro ph 0411744 bibcode 2005cqgra 22s 387c doi 10 1088 0264 9381 22 10 034 s2cid 119011566 baker j campanelli m lousto c o takahashi r 2004 coalescence remnant of spinning binary black holes phys rev d 69 2 027505 arxiv astro ph 0305287 bibcode 2004phrvd 69b7505b doi 10 1103 physrevd 69 027505 s2cid 119371535 choptuik m w 1989 experiences with an adaptive mesh refinement algorithm in numerical relativity in evans c finn l hobill d eds frontiers in numerical relativity cambrid...