Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

court, united, states, legal, supreme, speeches, and, letters, oliver, wendell, holmes, jr, contents, early, life, career, justice, jurisprudential, contributions, retirement, death, honors, legacy, clerks, in, popular, culture, see, also, references, primary, sources, bibliography, external, links, civil, war, lawyer, the, common, law, state, judge, overview, noteworthy, opinions, critique, of, formalism, positivism, explanatory, notes, citations, otis, parker, lochner, new, york, schenck, abrams, silverthorne, lumber, co, buck, bell,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (792), holmes (314), and (314), law (174), his (136), that (127), court (108), oliver (101), #justice (101), wendell (100), was (100), from (88), for (84), with (75), #supreme (70), states (60), united (59), press (59), new (52), not (51), legal (50), university (49), which (45), massachusetts (44), york (43), harvard (40), common (39), edit (36), isbn (35), american (35), cases (34), had (34), life (33), john (29), history (29), but (28), retrieved (27), were (27), opinions (26), buck (25), review (25), war (24), judicial (24), letters (24), this (23), their (23), state (22), who (22), james (22), has (22), judges (21), have (21), bell (20), archived (20), are (20), justices (19), school (19), present (19), howe (19), years (19), one (19), been (19), time (19), all (18), march (18), mark (18), original (18), civil (17), boston (17), washington (17), speech (17), constitution (17), they (17), also (16), william (16), chicago (16), later (16), what (16), more (16), chief (15), thomas (15), edward (15), cambridge (15), 978 (15), december (15), its (15), speeches (15), would (15), when (15), during (15), may (14), internet (14), archive (14), white (14), lincoln (14), jurisprudence (14), henry (14), july (14), book (14), novick (14), battle (14), via (14), sterilization (14), roosevelt (13), other (13), 2020 (13), 1932 (13), 1902 (13), abrams (13), opinion (13), correspondence (13), article (13), death (13), upon (13), articles (12), 2016 (12), great (12), jackson (12), associate (12), george (12), without (12), works (12), company (12), books (12), vol (12), judge (12), dissent (12), dewolfe (12), society (12), pollock (12), into (12), president (12), general (12), view (11), theory (11), 1919 (11), man (11), than (11), collected (11), case (11), only (11), wrote (11), main (11), act (11), could (11), wikipedia (10), citation (10), february (10), service (10), january (10), english (10), library (10), frankfurter (10), 1882 (10), 1881 (10), field (10), wilson (10), list (10), robert (10), natural (10), public (10), oxford (10), work (10), thought (10), biography (10), soldier (10), writings (10), these (10), most (10), schenck (10), him (10), men (10), moral (10), about (9), you (9), september (9), links (9), brown (9), sheldon (9), constitutional (9), amendment (9), philosophy (9), times (9), papers (9), self (9), values (9), free (9), april (9), freedom (9), first (9), see (9), lawyer (9), august (9), after (9), year (9), many (9), made (9), needed (9), any (9), majority (9), became (9), toggle (8), 2021 (8), 2022 (8), people (8), national (8), served (8), 2018 (8), 2010 (8), 1991 (8), stevens (8), 1930 (8), day (8), gray (8), charles (8), stephen (8), richard (8), right (8), albert (8), abraham (8), louis (8), otis (8), 2013 (8), 1927 (8), published (8), alschuler (8), honorable (8), doi (8), america (8), legacy (8), between (8), those (8), two (8), does (8), then (8), did (8), office (8), long (8), before (8), known (8), own (8), personal (8), although (8), through (8), basis (8), intent (8), conduct (7), under (7), theodore (7), 1841 (7), 1993 (7), 1962 (7), 1910 (7), cushing (7), parker (7), sewall (7), rights (7), david (7), succeeded (7), inner (7), 1995 (7), little (7), 2001 (7), october (7), felix (7), england (7), faith (7), belknap (7), frederick (7), often (7), them (7), out (7), however (7), can (7), process (7), three (7), clear (7), cited (7), father (7), such (7), decisions (7), decision (7), experience (7), our (7), even (7), lochner (7), set (7), courts (7), famously (7), early (7), text (6), inc (6), 1911 (6), federal (6), 1935 (6), 1965 (6), 1941 (6), brandeis (6), 1870 (6), 1861 (6), 1864 (6), joseph (6), laws (6), francis (6), preceded (6), fort (6), laski (6), 2000 (6), plunkett (6), lake (6), jstor (6), modern (6), london (6), yankee (6), family (6), hiss (6), series (6), some (6), formalism (6), world (6), true (6), government (6), danger (6), test (6), down (6), because (6), will (6), said (6), friends (6), while (6), should (6), principles (6), must (6), nothing (6), statute (6), harm (6), support (6), defendants (6), subsection (6), search (5), page (5), last (5), wayback (5), november (5), college (5), hall (5), americans (5), arlington (5), cemetery (5), 2017 (5), 1986 (5), marshall (5), 1949 (5), 1939 (5), 1938 (5), 1922 (5), 1916 (5), hughes (5), 1903 (5), story (5), 1789 (5), morton (5), hoar (5), lewis (5), pragmatism (5), system (5), 1961 (5), wright (5), paul (5), benjamin (5), emerson (5), 1899 (5), dissenting (5), 274 (5), 200 (5), fanny (5), external (5), 2019 (5), house (5), 1984 (5), best (5), olympus (5), living (5), 1989 (5), club (5), changed (5), logic (5), volume (5), son (5), facts (5), twenty (5), 2307 (5), path (5), journal (5), biddle (5), 226 (5), sir (5), clerks (5), 2014 (5), 207 (5), june (5), 1917 (5), 457 (5), due (5), interest (5), eugenics (5), chafee (5), until (5), popular (5), formed (5), much (5), views (5), followed (5), well (5), read (5), called (5), believed (5), stated (5), once (5), regiment (5), morality (5), belief (5), itself (5), rules (5), being (5), philosophic (5), person (5), likely (5), following (5), cannot (5), contents (4), available (4), terms (4), foundation (4), use (4), commons (4), written (4), short (4), description (4), appointed (4), hill (4), philosophers (4), 20th (4), century (4), international (4), 2009 (4), 1990 (4), 1969 (4), clark (4), cardozo (4), 1892 (4), 1897 (4), daniel (4), 1790 (4), 2005 (4), 1953 (4), 1946 (4), fred (4), taft (4), fuller (4), 1874 (4), ireland (4), wilkins (4), knowlton (4), lord (4), period (4), lynde (4), willard (4), related (4), realism (4), positivism (4), fundamental (4), franklin (4), horace (4), mary (4), grant (4), liva (4), baker (4), wife (4), essays (4), truth (4), rogat (4), scholar (4), brief (4), bad (4), ideas (4), bibliography (4), 2007 (4), second (4), macmillan (4), wolfe (4), major (4), clare (4), 2nd (4), duty (4), complete (4), help (4), cite (4), bowen (4), quoted (4), material (4), led (4), alger (4), 2023 (4), memorial (4), machine (4), scholars (4), forced (4), 1905 (4), follow (4), individual (4), fact (4), like (4), rejecting (4), pdf (4), decided (4), castletown (4), get (4), months (4), contributions (4), died (4), earlier (4), admired (4), come (4), home (4), fellow (4), felt (4), top (4), against (4), cause (4), held (4), class (4), came (4), expressed (4), talk (4), volunteer (4), race (4), command (4), there (4), having (4), professor (4), end (4), result (4), malice (4), viewed (4), social (4), liability (4), enough (4), her (4), silverthorne (4), lumber (4), writing (4), leaflets (4), experiment (4), opposed (4), expression (4), unanimous (4), contract (4), senator (4), she (4), colonel (4), hide (4), move (4), sidebar (4), policy (3), wikimedia (3), 2026 (3), project (3), gutenberg (3), link (3), wikidata (3), britannica (3), wikisource (3), cs1 (3), date (3), unsourced (3), statements (3), union (3), beacon (3), pudding (3), alumni (3), fame (3), yale (3), 2006 (3), 1994 (3), 1988 (3), connor (3), 1972 (3), 1957 (3), 1971 (3), harlan (3), burton (3), rutledge (3), 1942 (3), reed (3), 1937 (3), 1925 (3), 1914 (3), 1893 (3), 1895 (3), 1888 (3), 1873 (3), strong (3), 1862 (3), 1845 (3), 1872 (3), 1835 (3), 1795 (3), warren (3), evans (3), 1921 (3), howard (3), pierce (3), loring (3), allen (3), wells (3), foster (3), chapman (3), dewey (3), paine (3), winthrop (3), samuel (3), adams (3), susan (3), irving (3), concepts (3), theories (3), german (3), historical (3), ross (3), posner (3), economic (3), lee (3), kent (3), alexander (3), walbridge (3), finding (3), letter (3), jurist (3), edmund (3), city (3), make (3), reading (3), publishing (3), dictionary (3), political (3), 674 (3), yosal (3), stanford (3), 1964 (3), grey (3), both (3), turn (3), 316 (3), 2024 (3), metaphysical (3), menand (3), norton (3), place (3), how (3), congressional (3), quarterly (3), education (3), kellogg (3), frederic (3), 1963 (3), mind (3), 1992 (3), file (3), five (3), eds (3), version (3), oklahoma (3), violence (3), publishers (3), harry (3), selected (3), central (3), selections (3), 1996 (3), einstein (3), palfrey (3), harold (3), congress (3), sources (3), catherine (3), drinker (3), 1944 (3), gould (3), alfred (3), prominent (3), citizens (3), honorary (3), connecticut (3), stamp (3), 1978 (3), s2cid (3), 1918 (3), reprinted (3), science (3), realist (3), better (3), recognize (3), body (3), procedural (3), mentally (3), woman (3), circumstances (3), directed (3), unconstitutional (3), means (3), carrie (3), generations (3), imbeciles (3), zechariah (3), 250 (3), 616 (3), northern (3), securities (3), actions (3), senate (3), committee (3), 220 (3), full (3), measure (3), current (3), included (3), retired (3), references (3), cover (3), play (3), received (3), nomination (3), few (3), magnificent (3), partner (3), close (3), friendships (3), member (3), summer (3), gave (3), based (3), account (3), extensive (3), several (3), established (3), used (3), create (3), publish (3), still (3), wounded (3), widely (3), birthday (3), age (3), retirement (3), bench (3), women (3), speaking (3), similar (3), adopted (3), power (3), combat (3), accepted (3), generation (3), took (3), addresses (3), formal (3), twentieth (3), effort (3), express (3), human (3), himself (3), scholarship (3), summarized (3), voted (3), uphold (3), call (3), good (3), understanding (3), understood (3), saw (3), drawn (3), words (3), sense (3), caused (3), deal (3), duties (3), simply (3), properly (3), argument (3), continued (3), brought (3), rather (3), lectures (3), over (3), community (3), results (3), welfare (3), reasonable (3), believe (3), private (3), parties (3), injury (3), argued (3), fall (3), jurisprudential (3), declared (3), protect (3), though (3), prevent (3), crime (3), upheld (3), asked (3), evidence (3), obtained (3), doctrine (3), doctrines (3), precedent (3), showed (3), unless (3), action (3), administration (3), recent (3), espionage (3), strike (3), specific (3), language (3), privilege (3), write (3), draft (3), upholding (3), supported (3), workers (3), legislatures (3), required (3), part (3), liberty (3), necessarily (3), antitrust (3), considered (3), soon (3), langdell (3), visited (3), intellectual (3), returned (3), career (3), enlisted (3), corps (3), campaign (3), infantry (3), militia (3), amelia (3), wia (3), grandfather (3), nominated (3), tools (3), languages (2), table (2), statement (2), safety (2), contact (2), privacy (2), apply (2), hidden (2), categories (2), librivox (2), incorporating (2), encyclopædia (2), reference (2), maint (2), deprecated (2), archival (2), descent (2), army (2), mattapoisett (2), lawyers (2), hasty (2), faculty (2), inductees (2), deaths (2), pneumonia (2), british (2), academy (2), org (2), israel (2), authority (2), kagan (2), 1981 (2), 1975 (2), rehnquist (2), 1970 (2), 1967 (2), 1958 (2), 1956 (2), 1955 (2), 1945 (2), 1943 (2), 1954 (2), 1940 (2), black (2), roberts (2), stone (2), 1923 (2), 1912 (2), lamar (2), van (2), 1906 (2), 1896 (2), 1909 (2), 1894 (2), 1890 (2), 1889 (2), 1877 (2), bradley (2), 1863 (2), davis (2), 1851 (2), curtis (2), 1865 (2), 1836 (2), 1829 (2), 1826 (2), 1823 (2), 1811 (2), 1807 (2), todd (2), 1804 (2), johnson (2), 1800 (2), 1798 (2), 1796 (2), chase (2), 1793 (2), roger (2), jay (2), individuals (2), refused (2), budd (2), gants (2), liacos (2), hennessey (2), williams (2), ronan (2), qua (2), bernard (2), rugg (2), devens (2), bigelow (2), hubbard (2), putnam (2), dana (2), commonwealth (2), sargent (2), 1775 (2), hutchinson (2), russell (2), graves (2), dudley (2), quincy (2), 1692 (2), sidney (2), unger (2), stanley (2), arthur (2), giovanni (2), josiah (2), herbert (2), mead (2), sanders (2), peirce (2), rational (2), question (2), utilitarianism (2), canon (2), 1934 (2), plato (2), kant (2), hart (2), comparative (2), studies (2), woodrow (2), thayer (2), beecher (2), stowe (2), sherman (2), peabody (2), simon (2), morse (2), andrew (2), hopkins (2), patrick (2), ralph (2), waldo (2), jonathan (2), cushman (2), cooper (2), carnegie (2), phillips (2), anthony (2), marcus (2), interview (2), digital (2), suite (2), aid (2), 1878 (2), shapell (2), manuscript (2), visit (2), domain (2), wikiquote (2), garden (2), eight (2), reviewed (2), farrar (2), straus (2), giroux (2), literature (2), patriotic (2), gore (2), catharine (2), urofsky (2), melvin (2), writes (2), spectator (2), yet (2), 2012 (2), pohlman (2), revised (2), updated (2), edition (2), ann (2), claflin (2), experimental (2), 374 (2), 19963 (2), fredericksburg (2), nation (2), martin (2), basic (2), hate (2), greatest (2), academic (2), routledge (2), proving (2), dies (2), healy (2), lives (2), 1931 (2), 1326500 (2), davies (2), hoeflich (2), lawbook (2), exchange (2), ltd (2), reflections (2), biographies (2), cohen (2), budiansky (2), division (2), 2025 (2), vanguard (2), aichele (2), gary (2), shriver (2), given (2), 67554 (2), essential (2), 34966 (2), incompatibility (2), occasional (2), introduction (2), corham (2), editor (2), geoffrey (2), cumberlege (2), representative (2), 1920 (2), google (2), reader (2), sheehan (2), primary (2), occasionally (2), window (2), spoke (2), chauncey (2), largest (2), firms (2), tony (2), murray (2), 375 (2), including (2), cincinnati (2), devise (2), below (2), kiselewski (2), edu (2), morris (2), 1229467 (2), contemporary (2), volumes (2), seat (2), jeffrey (2), rosen (2), 1997 (2), southern (2), 442 (2), role (2), politics (2), vintage (2), racial (2), unlimited (2), pleases (2), past (2), 197 (2), vaccination (2), 113 (2), roe (2), wade (2), 2015 (2), 584 (2), abuse (2), error (2), 473 (2), equal (2), handicapped (2), various (2), involuntary (2), lombardo (2), 1890079 (2), 1327107 (2), 630 (2), 370 (2), 371 (2), relationship (2), judiciary (2), 478 (2), 1322028 (2), mass (2), county (2), mcauliffe (2), mayor (2), bedford (2), affair (2), irish (2), innocent (2), illinois (2), acting (2), attorney (2), brothers (2), citations (2), younger (2), explanatory (2), notes (2), prediction (2), fictionalized (2), 1950 (2), calhern (2), repeated (2), film (2), starred (2), small (2), dorothy (2), culture (2), name (2), rose (2), chairman (2), firm (2), secretaries (2), another (2), special (2), donated (2), somewhat (2), accounts (2), scholarly (2), coherent (2), left (2), permanent (2), honored (2), estate (2), civilized (2), officer (2), uniform (2), battles (2), beside (2), coast (2), dean (2), bar (2), association (2), suggested (2), oldest (2), record (2), newly (2), issued (2), honors (2), closest (2), corresponded (2), regularly (2), usually (2), especially (2), britain (2), cast (2), style (2), contributed (2), nominate (2), shared (2), far (2), overcome (2), evil (2), here (2), away (2), address (2), conflict (2), rough (2), spanish (2), every (2), respect (2), scientific (2), differences (2), why (2), anyone (2), divided (2), gathered (2), less (2), clubs (2), third (2), frequently (2), seem (2), toward (2), mysterious (2), certain (2), degree (2), talks (2), thousand (2), beginning (2), subsequent (2), insistence (2), way (2), contempt (2), sister (2), form (2), outside (2), development (2), practice (2), morals (2), single (2), learning (2), insisted (2), same (2), word (2), take (2), thinking (2), 458 (2), mathematical (2), taking (2), propositions (2), decide (2), done (2), determined (2), rejected (2), carried (2), deciding (2), arose (2), evolving (2), evolved (2), kind (2), instead (2), omnipresence (2), sky (2), infinite (2), abstract (2), prophecies (2), pretentious (2), mean (2), concerning (2), perspective (2), particular (2), necessary (2), where (2), force (2), bear (2), consult (2), consequences (2), imposed (2), standard (2), reflected (2), standards (2), workman (2), street (2), prudence (2), foresee (2), bodily (2), dealt (2), concerned (2), whose (2), lifelong (2), consciously (2), unconsciously (2), deduced (2), departure (2), critique (2), provided (2), requirements (2), procedures (2), proposition (2), already (2), broad (2), claimed (2), virginia (2), violating (2), arguments (2), struck (2), ruled (2), fourth (2), obtain (2), influenced (2), relied (2), formulation (2), advocacy (2), protected (2), competition (2), market (2), rate (2), dissented (2), socialists (2), russia (2), efforts (2), charged (2), sedition (2), convictions (2), sentences (2), precedents (2), neither (2), threatened (2), nor (2), prosecution (2), went (2), democracy (2), russian (2), defeated (2), showing (2), circulated (2), attempts (2), purely (2), posed (2), legislature (2), falsely (2), shouting (2), fire (2), theatre (2), causing (2), panic (2), tendency (2), defer (2), employes (2), fourteenth (2), advocates (2), laissez (2), faire (2), constitutionality (2), contracts (2), capital (2), void (2), interfere (2), considerable (2), allowed (2), admitted (2), calling (2), noteworthy (2), briefly (2), pithy (2), oath (2), privileges (2), centuries (2), embodies (2), annexation (2), appoint (2), successor (2), vacancy (2), senior (2), opponent (2), imperialism (2), expected (2), lodge (2), frisbie (2), overview (2), policeman (2), want (2), knowledge (2), give (2), added (2), extended (2), hayes (2), professorship (2), largely (2), republican (2), governor (2), council (2), happiness (2), won (2), universal (2), your (2), evolves (2), share (2), founders (2), idealism (2), actual (2), criminal (2), print (2), remains (2), important (2), idealist (2), spring (2), whom (2), sociological (2), poetry (2), friend (2), cousin (2), bowditch (2), dixwell (2), 1929 (2), never (2), grew (2), aged (2), shouted (2), unit (2), returning (2), sixth (2), aide (2), camp (2), particularly (2), rank (2), abbott (2), lieutenant (2), chancellorsville (2), antietam (2), ball (2), bluff (2), wilderness (2), peninsula (2), abolitionist (2), phi (2), born (2), parents (2), mother (2), leading (2), figure (2), maxim (2), tenure (2), brevet (2), appearance (2), upload (2), changes (2), log (2), donate (2), menu (2), add, topic, mobile, cookie, statistics, developers, code, contacts, disclaimers, additional, using, site, agree, registered, trademark, non, profit, organization, creative, attribution, sharealike, license, rendered, parsoid, edited, utc, category, encyclopaedia, errors, webarchive, template, mdy, dates, different, officers, republicans, corresponding, fellows, burials, writers, eugenicists, 19th, births, https, index, php, title, oliver_wendell_holmes_jr, oldid, 1373191240, lux, snac, nara, open, idref, ddb, deutsche, biographie, librarything, trove, zbmath, cinii, academics, catalonia, poland, sweden, korea, argentina, latvia, netherlands, spain, czech, republic, italy, japan, bnf, data, france, worldcat, fast, gnd, viaf, isni, control, databases, barrett, kavanaugh, gorsuch, sotomayor, alito, breyer, ginsburg, souter, kennedy, scalia, 1987, powell, blackmun, fortas, goldberg, stewart, whittaker, brennan, minton, byrnes, murphy, douglas, sanford, butler, sutherland, clarke, mcreynolds, pitney, devanter, lurton, moody, 1898, mckenna, peckham, shiras, 1891, brewer, blatchford, matthews, 1887, woods, hunt, 1880, miller, swayne, 1858, clifford, 1853, campbell, 1857, 1846, grier, woodbury, nelson, 1842, 1860, 1838, 1852, mckinley, 1837, catron, barbour, 1867, wayne, 1830, 1844, baldwin, mclean, 1828, trimble, 1843, thompson, 1812, duvall, livingston, 1834, moore, 1806, paterson, 1792, 1799, iredell, blair, 1810, 1791, burger, earl, vinson, douglass, melville, morrison, waite, salmon, taney, 1801, ellsworth, indicate, offered, seats, italics, wolohojian, dewar, georges, wendlandt, kafker, cypher, lowy, gaziano, hines, lenk, duffly, botsford, cordy, sosman, spina, cowin, fried, greaney, nolan, lynch, kaplan, braucher, quirico, reardon, jacob, spiegel, kirk, cutter, whittemore, counihan, spalding, dolan, cox, lummus, donahue, sanderson, wait, jenney, carroll, crosby, decourcy, braley, hammond, lathrop, barker, gardner, colburn, soule, endicott, ames, colt, merrick, metcalf, forbes, fletcher, wilde, sedgwick, thatcher, bradbury, dawes, sumner, 1780, sullivan, revolutionary, ropes, trowbridge, saltonstall, remington, davenport, curwin, leverett, hathorne, saffin, walley, cooke, richards, danforth, provincial, tauro, shaw, parsons, addington, stoughton, nicholas, rescher, haack, isaac, levi, hook, roberto, toulmin, talisse, jason, shusterman, mike, sandbothe, orman, quine, rorty, hilary, margolis, clarence, brandom, fish, fine, bernstein, analytic, neo, reinhold, niebuhr, shih, vailati, papini, bois, santayana, royce, protopragmatists, thinkers, schiller, classical, usul, fiqh, reform, interpretation, dharma, virtue, paternalism, libertarian, legalism, moralism, interpretivism, catholic, deontological, ethics, analytical, empire, 1980, concept, pure, 1820, elements, 1748, spirit, 1270, treatise, 355, weber, walzer, waldron, voegelin, stahl, suárez, shang, schmitt, scaevola, savigny, ibn, rushd, renner, reinach, raz, rawls, radbruch, pufendorf, pound, petrażycki, perelman, pashukanis, olivecrona, nussbaum, müller, montesquieu, maistre, luhmann, llewellyn, leoni, kelsen, jhering, jellinek, hägerström, hobbes, hegel, han, haller, habermas, gurvitch, grotius, ghazali, finnis, farabi, ehrlich, dworkin, durkheim, cicero, brożek, bork, bobbio, blackstone, bentham, beccaria, bastiat, austin, aristotle, aquinas, alexy, sociology, norms, analysis, critical, constitutionalism, wilbur, orville, frances, emma, greenleaf, whittier, eli, whitney, walt, whitman, mcneill, whistler, westinghouse, webster, booker, lillian, wald, twain, thoreau, sylvanus, gilbert, stuart, harriet, philip, sousa, tecumseh, augustus, saint, gaudens, walter, edgar, allan, poe, penn, parkman, alice, freeman, palmer, newcomb, lothrop, motley, monroe, maria, mitchell, michelson, matthew, fontaine, maury, mann, madison, macdowell, lyon, lowell, wadsworth, longfellow, lanier, jones, jefferson, elias, nathaniel, hawthorne, hamilton, asa, ulysses, gorgas, gibbs, fulton, farragut, edwards, alva, edison, buchanan, eads, charlotte, peter, fenimore, grover, cleveland, clay, rufus, choate, ellery, channing, carver, luther, burbank, cullen, bryant, brooks, edwin, booth, boone, graham, ward, clara, barton, bancroft, audubon, agassiz, jane, addams, offices, booknotes, addenda, 1818, 1715, findlaw, recalls, famed, audiobooks, quotations, media, doubleday, 217, 238, xvi, chapters, alone, worth, ultimate, hero, blight, sage, willing, servant, unknown, god, vannatta, seth, lexington, prejudice, 8153, 1176, garland, biographical, snyder, brad, salon, foundations, liberalism, rosenberg, 39002, torts, fallon, 1349, 1406, winter, 213, 256, essay

Text of the page (random words):
collected and published as the common law in 1881 the common law edit main article the common law book the common law has been continuously in print since 1881 and remains an important contribution to jurisprudence the book also remains controversial for holmes begins by rejecting various kinds of formalism in law in his earlier writings he had rejected utilitarianism 28 as well the views of the german idealist philosophers who believed that the opinions of judges could be harmonized in a purely logical system in the opening paragraphs of the book he famously summarized his own view of the history of the common law the life of the law has not been logic it has been experience the felt necessities of the time the prevalent moral and political theories intuitions of public policy avowed or unconscious even the prejudices which judges share with their fellow men have had a good deal more to do than the syllogism in determining the rules by which men should be governed the law embodies the story of a nation s development through many centuries and it cannot be dealt with as if it contained only the axioms and corollaries of a book of mathematics 6 in the common law holmes wrote that even though the law uses the language of morality it necessarily ends in external standards not dependent on the actual consciousness of the individual 29 or on his moral culpability foreseeability of harm was the key the general basis of criminal liability was knowledge at the time of action of facts from which common experience showed that certain harmful results were likely to follow 30 tort liability similarly was imposed when circumstances were such as would have led a prudent man to perceive danger although not necessarily to foresee the specific harm 31 likewise with respect to contracts the law has nothing to do with the actual state of the parties minds in contract as elsewhere it must go by externals and judge parties by their conduct 32 in the book holmes set forth his view that the only source of law properly speaking was a judicial decision enforced by the state judges decided cases on the facts and then wrote opinions presenting a rationale for their decision the true basis of the decision was often an inarticulate major premise however a judge was obliged to choose between contending legal arguments each posed in absolute terms and the true basis of his decision was sometimes drawn from outside the law when precedents were lacking or were evenly divided citation needed the common law evolves because civilized society evolves and judges share the common preconceptions of the governing class these views endeared holmes to the later advocates of legal realism and made him one of the early founders of law and economics jurisprudence holmes famously contrasted his own scholarship with the abstract doctrines of christopher columbus langdell dean of harvard law school who viewed the common law as a self enclosed set of doctrines holmes viewed langdell s work as akin to the german philosophic idealism he had for so long resisted opposing it with his own scientific materialism 33 albert alschuler however wrote langdell was innocent of the charge of attempting to deduce law from a priori premises 34 state court judge edit we cannot all be descartes or kant but we all want happiness and happiness i am sure from having known many successful men cannot be won simply by being counsel for great corporations and having an income of fifty thousand dollars an intellect great enough to win the prize needs other food beside success the remoter and more general aspects of the law are those which give it universal interest it is through them that you not only become a great master in your calling but connect your subject with the universe and catch an echo of the infinite a glimpse of its unfathomable process a hint of the universal law oliver wendell holmes jr the path of the law 10 harvard law review 457 478 1897 holmes was considered for a federal court judgeship in 1878 by president rutherford b hayes but massachusetts senator george frisbie hoar persuaded hayes to nominate another candidate in the fall of 1882 holmes became a professor at harvard law school accepting an endowed professorship that had been created for him largely through the efforts of louis d brandeis on friday december 8 1882 supreme judicial court of massachusetts associate justice otis lord decided to resign giving outgoing republican governor john davis long a chance to appoint his successor if he could do so before the massachusetts governor s council adjourned at 3 pm holmes s partner george shattuck proposed him for the vacancy holmes quickly agreed and the council not objecting he took the oath of office on december 15 1882 his resignation from his professorship after only a few weeks and without notice was resented by the law school faculty with james bradley thayer finding holmes s conduct selfish and thoughtless 35 on august 2 1899 holmes became chief justice of the massachusetts supreme judicial court following the death of walbridge a field during his service on the massachusetts court holmes continued to develop and apply his views of the common law usually following precedent faithfully he issued few constitutional opinions in these years but carefully developed the principles of free expression as a common law doctrine he departed from precedent to recognize workers right to organize trade unions and to strike as long as no violence was involved and coercion was not exerted through impermissible means such as secondary boycotts stating in his opinions that fundamental fairness required that workers be allowed to combine to compete on an equal footing with employers 36 he continued to give speeches and to write articles that added to or extended his work on the common law most notably privilege malice and intent 37 in which he presented his view of the pragmatic basis of the common law privileges extended to speech and the press which could be defeated by a showing of malice or of specific intent to harm famously he observed in mcauliffe v mayor of new bedford 1892 that a policeman may have a constitutional right to talk politics but he has no constitutional right to be a policeman 38 he also published an address the path of the law 39 which is best known for its prediction theory of law that t he prophecies of what the courts will do in fact and nothing more pretentious are what i mean by law and for its bad man perspective on the law that i f you really want to know the law and nothing else you must look at it as a bad man who cares only for the material consequences which such knowledge enables him to predict 39 supreme court justice edit overview edit in the year of his ap point ment to the us supreme court soon after the death of associate justice horace gray in july 1902 president theodore roosevelt made known his intention to appoint holmes as gray s successor it was the president s stated desire to fill the vacancy with someone from massachusetts 40 the nomination was supported by senator henry cabot lodge the junior senator from massachusetts but was opposed by its senior senator george frisbie hoar who was also chairman of the senate judiciary committee hoar was a strenuous opponent of imperialism and the legality of the annexation of puerto rico and the philippines was expected to come before the court lodge like roosevelt was a strong supporter of imperialism which holmes was expected to support as well 41 despite hoar s opposition the president moved ahead on the matter on december 2 1902 he formally submitted the nomination and holmes was confirmed by the united states senate on december 4 42 he was sworn into office on december 8 1 on the bench holmes did vote to support the administration s position favoring the annexation of former spanish colonies in the insular cases however he later disappointed roosevelt by dissenting in northern securities co v united states a major antitrust prosecution 43 the majority of the court opposed holmes and sided with roosevelt s belief that northern securities violated the sherman antitrust act 43 holmes s dissent permanently damaged his close relationship with roosevelt 44 holmes was known for his pithy frequently quoted opinions in more than twenty nine years on the supreme court bench he ruled on cases spanning a wide range of federal law he is remembered for prescient opinions on topics as varied as copyright law the law of contempt the antitrust status of professional baseball and the oath required for citizenship holmes like most of his contemporaries viewed the bill of rights as codifying privileges obtained over the centuries in english and american common law and he established that view in numerous opinions for the court he is considered one of the greatest judges in american history and embodies for many the traditions of the common law a eugenicist he wrote the majority opinion in buck v bell upholding forced sterilization 45 tens of thousands of the procedures followed 46 from the departure of william howard taft on february 3 1930 until charles evans hughes became chief justice on february 24 1930 holmes briefly acted as the chief justice and presided over court sessions 47 noteworthy supreme court opinions edit otis v parker edit beginning with his first opinion for the court in otis v parker 1903 holmes exhibited his tendency to defer to legislatures which two years later he did most famously in his dissenting opinion in lochner v new york 1905 in otis v parker the court in an opinion by holmes upheld the constitutionality of a california statute that provided that all contracts for the sales of shares of the capital stock of any corporation or association on margin or to be delivered at a future day shall be void holmes wrote that as a general proposition neither a state legislature nor a state constitution can interfere arbitrarily with private business or transactions but general propositions do not carry us far while the courts must exercise a judgment of their own it by no means is true that every law is void which may seem to the judges who pass upon it excessive unsuited to its ostensible end or based upon conceptions of morality with which they disagree considerable latitude must be allowed for differences of view if the state thinks that an admitted evil cannot be prevented except by prohibiting a calling or transaction not in itself necessarily objectionable the courts cannot interfere unless they can see that it is a clear unmistakable infringement of rights secured by the fundamental law 48 lochner v new york edit main article lochner v new york in his dissenting opinion in lochner v new york 1905 holmes supported labor not out of sympathy for workers but because of his tendency to defer to legislatures in lochner the court struck down a new york statute that prohibited employees spelled employes at the time from being required or permitted to work in a bakery more than sixty hours a week the majority found that the statute interferes with the right of contract between the employer and employes and that the right of contract though not explicit in the constitution is part of the liberty of the individual protected by the fourteenth amendment under which no state may deprive any person of life liberty or property without due process of law in his brief dissent holmes said that the majority had reached its decision on the basis of the economic theory of laissez faire but that the constitution does not prevent the states from interfering with the liberty to contract the fourteenth amendment holmes wrote does not enact mr herbert spencer s social statics which advocates laissez faire schenck v united states edit main article schenck v united states in a series of opinions surrounding the world war i espionage act of 1917 and the sedition act of 1918 holmes held that the freedom of expression guaranteed by federal and state constitutions simply declared a common law privilege for speech and the press even when those expressions caused injury but that the privilege could be defeated by a showing of malice or intent to do harm holmes came to write three unanimous opinions for the supreme court that arose from prosecutions under the 1917 espionage act because in an earlier case baltzer v united states he had circulated a powerfully expressed dissent when the majority had voted to uphold a conviction of immigrant socialists who had circulated a petition criticizing the draft apparently learning that he was likely to publish this dissent the government perhaps alerted by justice louis d brandeis newly appointed by president woodrow wilson abandoned the case and it was dismissed by the court the chief justice then asked holmes to write opinions that could be unanimous upholding convictions in three similar cases where there were jury findings that speeches or leaflets were published with an intent to obstruct the draft a crime under the 1917 law although there was no evidence that the attempts had succeeded holmes in schenck v united states 1919 held for a unanimous court that an attempt purely by language could be prosecuted if the expression in the circumstances in which it was uttered posed a clear and present danger that the legislature had properly forbidden in his opinion for the court holmes famously declared that the first amendment would not protect a person falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic abrams v united states edit main article abrams v united states later in 1919 however in abrams v united states holmes dissented in support of freedom of speech the wilson administration was vigorously prosecuting those suspected of sympathies with the recent russian revolution as well as opponents of the war against germany the defendants in this case were socialists and anarchists recent immigrants from russia who opposed the apparent efforts of the united states to intervene in the russian civil war they were charged with violating the sedition act of 1918 which was an amendment to the espionage act of 1917 that made criticisms of the government or the war effort a crime abrams and his co defendants were charged with distributing leaflets one in english and one in yiddish that called for a general strike to protest the u s intervention in russia a majority of the court voted to uphold the convictions and sentences of ten and twenty years to be followed by deportation while holmes dissented the majority claimed to be following the precedents already set in schenck and the other cases in which holmes had written for the court but holmes insisted that the defendants leaflets neither threatened to cause any harm nor showed a specific intent to hinder the war effort 49 holmes condemned the wilson administration s prosecution and its insistence on draconian sentences for the defendants in passionate language even if i am technically wrong regarding the defendants intent and en...