Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

the, of, 2010, thursday, june, march, 2009, 2008, friday, sunday, february, on, evolution, proper, study, mankind, tuesday, 29, 24, 11, 04, august, 09, 01, 12, september, 26, 06, wednesday, 20, about, me, some, my, published, articles, links, previous, posts, archives, thoughts, templeton, foundation, biological, innovation, oh, what, lovely, molecule, torture, inc, is, belief, all, it, cracked, up, to, be, disgust, happy, 200th, darwin, gracious, giving, and, helping, hands, two, feet, good, scientific, happenings, south, coast,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (647), and (375), that (200), this (110), for (106), with (88), #disgust (76), have (62), not (58), are (57), has (55), they (55), but (54), moral (53), more (50), from (48), their (47), group (47), out (46), was (45), templeton (44), you (44), human (43), new (41), these (41), science (40), about (38), also (38), which (37), some (33), such (33), all (31), will (30), other (30), been (29), one (29), when (29), what (28), just (27), can (26), who (26), there (25), than (25), were (25), behaviour (24), could (23), would (23), how (22), much (22), people (22), oxytocin (22), scientist (21), social (21), response (21), nature (20), then (20), whether (20), only (20), research (20), money (20), into (19), coyne (19), may (18), evolutionary (18), even (18), religion (18), 2008 (17), evolution (17), while (17), groups (17), humans (16), many (16), case (16), variation (16), our (16), those (16), effects (15), psychology (15), get (15), interrogation (15), between (15), his (15), core (15), work (15), two (14), its (14), think (14), march (13), 2006 (13), torture (13), world (13), time (13), genetic (13), really (13), reward (13), related (13), suggest (13), like (13), monkeys (13), see (13), over (13), say (13), 2009 (12), foundation (12), dan (12), jones (12), comments (12), big (12), through (12), altruism (12), another (12), chimpanzees (12), should (12), does (12), haidt (12), three (12), good (11), love (11), don (11), here (11), study (11), why (11), members (11), colleagues (11), both (11), issue (11), cultural (11), writers (11), funding (11), 2007 (10), your (10), posted (10), history (10), among (10), line (10), yet (10), prosocial (10), others (10), studies (10), now (10), them (10), after (10), same (10), levels (10), myers (10), accommodationist (10), 2010 (9), february (9), scientific (9), make (9), brain (9), beyond (9), published (9), well (9), where (9), researchers (9), show (9), species (9), short (9), little (9), towards (9), option (9), capuchins (9), being (9), toy (9), experimenter (9), self (9), accept (9), evaluation (9), associated (9), system (9), kleinman (9), pap (9), helping (8), darwin (8), anyone (8), bit (8), often (8), idea (8), first (8), look (8), indeed (8), any (8), experiments (8), things (8), point (8), selection (8), perhaps (8), disgusting (8), contamination (8), elicitors (8), contact (8), rozin (8), community (8), support (8), intelligence (8), population (8), giving (7), cognitive (7), november (7), natural (7), walking (7), part (7), course (7), filler (7), university (7), changes (7), years (7), rather (7), ideas (7), particularly (7), large (7), way (7), similar (7), reach (7), selfish (7), partner (7), had (7), different (7), unfairness (7), less (7), seems (7), doesn (7), though (7), bodily (7), distaste (7), simple (7), animals (7), issues (7), fairness (7), techniques (7), questions (7), players (7), markets (7), accommodationism (7), june (6), previous (6), richard (6), biology (6), theory (6), personal (6), going (6), prospect (6), psychologist (6), bad (6), evolvability (6), interested (6), various (6), question (6), might (6), based (6), argue (6), leading (6), genes (6), developmental (6), small (6), produce (6), feeling (6), suggested (6), found (6), hold (6), too (6), paper (6), effect (6), sense (6), shown (6), given (6), using (6), although (6), take (6), details (6), trying (6), experiment (6), condition (6), conditions (6), words (6), own (6), call (6), under (6), variety (6), instance (6), long (6), need (6), psychologists (6), most (6), talk (6), treatment (6), emotion (6), seen (6), something (6), evidence (6), cause (6), greater (6), oral (6), emotions (6), used (6), simply (6), program (6), interrogator (6), information (6), each (6), pool (6), august (5), reason (5), want (5), protect (5), against (5), light (5), website (5), hand (5), along (5), taken (5), feature (5), recently (5), themselves (5), debates (5), produced (5), individual (5), forms (5), online (5), off (5), article (5), factors (5), help (5), feelings (5), hypothesis (5), findings (5), reported (5), results (5), room (5), involved (5), subject (5), rewards (5), known (5), individuals (5), annex (5), around (5), cases (5), didn (5), few (5), reaching (5), second (5), someone (5), use (5), understand (5), story (5), understanding (5), interests (5), result (5), disagreement (5), complex (5), rights (5), willing (5), least (5), domain (5), fear (5), isn (5), anger (5), subjects (5), did (5), role (5), chapman (5), example (5), basic (5), economic (5), output (5), religious (5), written (5), stress (5), write (5), high (5), hormone (5), games (5), cortisol (5), received (5), player (5), morals (5), organisation (5), oil (5), september (4), october (4), feet (4), belief (4), dawkins (4), gene (4), daily (4), end (4), within (4), view (4), complete (4), man (4), know (4), proper (4), food (4), events (4), life (4), upright (4), trees (4), orangutans (4), clearly (4), evolved (4), piece (4), because (4), apes (4), single (4), generation (4), needs (4), film (4), arguing (4), recent (4), thursday (4), frequently (4), actions (4), bias (4), ways (4), altruistic (4), number (4), likely (4), cost (4), young (4), children (4), position (4), described (4), waal (4), led (4), nothing (4), unrelated (4), perspective (4), set (4), face (4), authors (4), monkey (4), grid (4), very (4), comes (4), similarly (4), today (4), word (4), put (4), approach (4), mean (4), mind (4), important (4), field (4), genuine (4), john (4), respond (4), revulsion (4), away (4), ourselves (4), extreme (4), driven (4), views (4), far (4), emotional (4), certain (4), drink (4), taste (4), heart (4), built (4), evolve (4), domains (4), stimuli (4), receiving (4), true (4), autonomy (4), norms (4), divinity (4), societies (4), low (4), arguments (4), success (4), beliefs (4), knowledge (4), fundamental (4), none (4), whom (4), parochial (4), post (4), greed (4), pretty (4), writing (4), churn (4), positive (4), unethical (4), south (3), hands (3), 200th (3), molecule (3), biological (3), innovation (3), philosophy (3), edge (3), letters (3), 2005 (3), makes (3), ask (3), better (3), choices (3), p36 (3), exactly (3), magazine (3), immoral (3), future (3), mankind (3), annual (3), region (3), free (3), eat (3), week (3), got (3), sound (3), possibility (3), move (3), onto (3), bipedalism (3), bipedality (3), shows (3), increasingly (3), sort (3), tell (3), academic (3), term (3), keep (3), mammals (3), including (3), old (3), argues (3), million (3), split (3), great (3), video (3), watched (3), behave (3), drive (3), empathy (3), turn (3), activation (3), tend (3), feel (3), non (3), benefits (3), rewarding (3), indifferent (3), familiar (3), solely (3), gain (3), object (3), chimpanzee (3), benefit (3), suggests (3), looked (3), capuchin (3), provide (3), made (3), concern (3), paired (3), member (3), sensitive (3), inequity (3), current (3), came (3), doing (3), barnes (3), data (3), situation (3), figure (3), pass (3), held (3), times (3), run (3), provided (3), seem (3), potential (3), regard (3), tomasello (3), henrich (3), situations (3), doubt (3), greatest (3), reaction (3), emergence (3), racist (3), right (3), genetically (3), wrong (3), steven (3), worst (3), crucial (3), typically (3), culture (3), sorts (3), deep (3), child (3), poor (3), front (3), distance (3), ethnic (3), terms (3), cockroaches (3), force (3), find (3), complexity (3), development (3), follows (3), experienced (3), draws (3), claim (3), sweater (3), merely (3), sexual (3), morality (3), disgusted (3), responses (3), whereas (3), image (3), otherwise (3), matter (3), serve (3), morally (3), body (3), guardian (3), transgressions (3), won (3), compared (3), facial (3), game (3), agree (3), paul (3), jonathan (3), model (3), behavioural (3), direct (3), acts (3), abstract (3), routes (3), trigger (3), activate (3), finally (3), represent (3), according (3), ethic (3), justice (3), focused (3), mapping (3), detainees (3), blood (3), down (3), legal (3), coercive (3), physical (3), consequences (3), art (3), administered (3), army (3), fact (3), methods (3), manual (3), communication (3), military (3), effectiveness (3), however (3), toward (3), conflict (3), prisoner (3), capture (3), defend (3), check (3), trust (3), mothers (3), stressed (3), vocalisations (3), key (3), quite (3), minutes (3), showed (3), extent (3), capacity (3), scale (3), emerged (3), played (3), person (3), either (3), contribute (3), cents (3), placebo (3), passed (3), organisms (3), variants (3), beneficial (3), anything (3), inherently (3), wrote (3), must (3), toe (3), party (3), compatibility (3), integrity (3), accepting (3), senator (3), drilling (3), funds (3), wagner (3), reconciliation (3), compatible (3), scientists (3), institutions (3), rosenbaum (3), january (2), april (2), happenings (2), coast (2), gracious (2), happy (2), cracked (2), inc (2), lovely (2), thoughts (2), posts (2), expression (2), adventures (2), links (2), exploring (2), p28 (2), p42 (2), delusion (2), depths (2), 768 (2), 447 (2), global (2), emerging (2), web (2), name (2), spite (2), catch (2), sun (2), control (2), since (2), articles (2), brighton (2), united (2), kingdom (2), alexander (2), essay (2), playing (2), host (2), living (2), detailed (2), left (2), side (2), plants (2), importance (2), chris (2), counter (2), intuitive (2), observations (2), locomotor (2), wild (2), branches (2), walk (2), goes (2), controversial (2), record (2), knuckle (2), ancestry (2), argument (2), points (2), latter (2), fossils (2), needed (2), suspect (2), theoretical (2), open (2), tree (2), expert (2), origin (2), account (2), spine (2), lumbar (2), ancient (2), ape (2), before (2), signs (2), arisen (2), processes (2), arboreal (2), style (2), says (2), primate (2), music (2), primates (2), live (2), regarding (2), drives (2), provides (2), motivational (2), fuel (2), warm (2), glow (2), areas (2), aside (2), explore (2), demonstrated (2), intrinsically (2), conflicting (2), welfare (2), silk (2), choose (2), benefitted (2), extra (2), jensen (2), suggesting (2), motivated (2), later (2), complicated (2), cannot (2), regardless (2), concerns (2), analysis (2), brown (2), noted (2), insights (2), apply (2), choosing (2), token (2), previously (2), partners (2), pick (2), random (2), unless (2), nasty (2), contrast (2), chance (2), stronger (2), general (2), prosociality (2), relationship (2), therefore (2), strangers (2), order (2), variant (2), generated (2), grape (2), again (2), modulating (2), failed (2), relatives (2), still (2), sociality (2), operations (2), dependent (2), particular (2), team (2), sat (2), main (2), difference (2), extend (2), arm (2), easily (2), repeatedly (2), enabled (2), above (2), dropped (2), pay (2), whose (2), desires (2), ability (2), cebus (2), apella (2), proc (2), sci (2), warneken (2), hare (2), infants (2), doi (2), royal (2), friday (2), hiding (2), year (2), birthday (2), anniversary (2), inspired (2), magazines (2), together (2), century (2), excesses (2), nazi (2), 1970s (2), 1990s (2), misguided (2), pinker (2), innate (2), blank (2), slate (2), picked (2), intellectual (2), initially (2), lead (2), transmission (2), read (2), wilson (2), david (2), anthropologists (2), thinking (2), hope (2), editorial (2), condemnation (2), visceral (2), fellow (2), possibly (2), baby (2), thought (2), lacking (2), generally (2), wisdom (2), repugnance (2), ends (2), physically (2), emotionally (2), rats (2), attitudes (2), sex (2), shaping (2), gay (2), source (2), treated (2), historically (2), developmentally (2), coat (2), tails (2), fluids (2), shit (2), itself (2), cognitively (2), start (2), aversion (2), tastes (2), having (2), lemonade (2), clean (2), probably (2), contaminated (2), notion (2), cockroach (2), directed (2), gets (2), nor (2), notions (2), transference (2), drinks (2), putting (2), hitler (2), recall (2), faeces (2), strong (2), wonder (2), experiencing (2), verbal (2), metaphor (2), elicit (2), physiological (2), looking (2), nazis (2), address (2), clips (2), viewed (2), sherman (2), report (2), rates (2), leads (2), following (2), create (2), practically (2), type (2), looks (2), matters (2), place (2), opted (2), incorporation (2), expanded (2), communities (2), purity (2), captured (2), mouth (2), images (2), designed (2), depicted (2), bitter (2), expressions (2), includes (2), involves (2), nose (2), raising (2), lips (2), manner (2), consistent (2), characteristic (2), reject (2), entirely (2), fincher (2), describe (2), below (2), bottom (2), elements (2), feed (2), common (2), engage (2), neither (2), processed (2), purely (2), directly (2), functions (2), concepts (2), leave (2), measures (2), violations (2), shweder (2), spiritual (2), ethical (2), contempt (2), cad (2), triad (2), measure (2), activated (2), full (2), blown (2), commendable (2), mention (2), 1997 (2), harris (2), 1999 (2), london (2), princeton (2), press (2), origins (2), explanations (2), psychol (2), health (2), humanity (2), represents (2), elicitor (2), lines (2), sunday (2), atheists (2), christopher (2), hitchens (2), always (2), developed (2), armstrong (2), parallel (2), specific (2), traditions (2), form (2), comment (2), became (2), standard (2), practice (2), katani (2), four (2), khalid (2), sheikh (2), mohammed (2), opinion (2), neuroscientists (2), obvious (2), psychological (2), mental (2), touch (2), cidt (2), historical (2), lack (2), interrogations (2), former (2), moment (2), reform (2), reviewed (2), efficacy (2), enduring (2), experimental (2), material (2), actually (2), approaches (2), available (2), absence (2), gaining (2), michael (2), return (2), real (2), terrorist (2), security (2), budget (2), generations (2), government (2), reflects (2), nation (2), wars (2), especially (2), operational (2), higher (2), quality (2), begin (2), challenges (2), college (2), appearance (2), enemy (2), convinced (2), already (2), assertion (2), trauma (2), answers (2), ego (2), essentially (2), increase (2), bond (2), george (2), oxygen (2), haemoglobin (2), deepest (2), past (2), anxiety (2), tactile (2), means (2), essential (2), mice (2), profound (2), seltzer (2), boost (2), alone (2), affect (2), females (2), degree (2), release (2), kids (2), soothing (2), comprised (2), final (2), expected (2), controls (2), comforting (2), males (2), cooperation (2), cast (2), percentage (2), process (2), inter (2), competition (2), biologists (2), famous (2), dairy (2), farming (2), populations (2), lactose (2), mechanisms (2), promote (2), every (2), contributions (2), measured (2), ride (2), share (2), paying (2), per (2), hate (2), shot (2), selfishly (2), acted (2), moved (2), highly (2), rules (2), meant (2), contributing (2), significant (2), starting (2), weeks (2), back (2), affects (2), thus (2), selective (2), pressures (2), phenotypes (2), modern (2), phenotypic (2), organismal (2), determine (2), blog (2), jerry (2), association (2), possible (2), scope (2), required (2), combination (2), observation (2), apart (2), interest (2), automatically (2), everything (2), calls (2), essays (2), try (2), believe (2), unethically (2), aimed (2), reconciling (2), disagree (2), evident (2), wouldn (2), publication (2), follow (2), hard (2), exists (2), company (2), sums (2), biologist (2), bend (2), supports (2), grant (2), topic (2), keltner (2), activities (2), bribe (2), fellowship (2), genetics (2), predetermined (2), industry (2), truth (2), larger (2), across (2), positively (2), covaries (2), size (2), punishment (2), cambridge (2), ron (2), dreher (2), archives, panda, thumb, intersection, loom, pharyngula, neurophilosopher, mixing, memory, evolutionblog, evolgen, butterflies, wheels, arts, afarensis, ethics, beginning, 2002, reviews, p14, 438, maze, p34, genome, neander, code, p44, superimmune, neanderthal, p35, blame, mouse, p38, 771, conquered, killer, instincts, 512, 515, 451, engines, p40, limb, exclusive, p32, cyber, p24, running, p580, 583, july, stonehenge, smithsonian, advances, p29, jan, remix, 780, 783, 457, intentional, 666, 669, dawn, statesman, dig, dive, unpicking, cash, lottery, click, visit, profile, east, sussex, location, pope, 1733, thyself, presume, god, scan, fourth, festival, lots, offer, browse, programme, highlights, pages, page, multiple, personalities, patterns, museum, ubiquity, symmetry, talks, worth, checking, marcus, sautoy, fortey, phillip, ball, oliver, morton, frith, rita, carter, wednesday, defining, relates, globe, ground, suspended, occasionally, stabilising, holding, braches, overhead, assisted, suggestion, precursor, experts, fossil, earliest, features, ancestor, chimps, gorillas, retained, trait, commitment, abandoned, arrive, consensus, existing, rivalries, prior, commitments, unlikely, eyes, provocative, unable, cover, space, constraints, aaron, spinal, harvard, fascination, proposed, older, simpler, allow, studying, spines, extinct, filer, claims, documented, series, typical, astonishingly, vertebrae, lived, ago, tale, owner, biped, savannahs, mutations, homeotic, orchestrate, affecting, entire, cascades, speculates, mutation, causing, posture, bipedal, orangutan, derivative, innovative, vestige, harbinger, book, expounding, describing, locomotion, cool, gibbons, showing, parkour, antics, mixed, welcome, jungle, guns, roses, adds, www, uprightape, net, morotopithecus, bishopi, arose, altruistically, remain, unclear, connectedness, rewarded, circuits, goof, subjective, empathic, systematic, acting, gratifying, tendencies, thrown, early, joan, keith, picture, achieved, effort, access, helper, fruits, literally, act, prospects, motive, frans, distantly, african, nonetheless, closely, presented, choice, colour, coded, tokens, selecting, visible, separate, equal, outcomes, benefitting, suppose, consistently, prosical, chose, significantly, relative, disappeared, unknown, increased, closeness, closer, empathetic, family, friends, acquaintances, exchange, gestures, affiliation, kindness, limits, asymmetric, apple, inferior, apparently, fond, fruit, comparable, efforts, factor, preference, exceed, closest, kind, overall, kinder, kin, jennifer, indicate, underlying, context, ran, connected, separated, grasp, grasping, empty, subdivided, half, flapped, limply, stared, intently, glanced, bothered, manoeuvre, suitable, irrespective, changed, slightly, separating, removed, combined, repeated, trials, six, handed, analysed, actively, staring, tried, helped, somewhat, stuck, offs, care, bring, admittedly, contrasts, propose, lineage, incorporate, overcoming, centred, hill, langer, martinez, santos, epub, ahead, print, leimgruber, greenberg, 13685, 13689, 105, natl, acad, usa, melis, hanus, spontaneous, e184, plos, biol, 1301, 1303, 1126, 1121448, 311, precludes, 1013, 1021, 273, soc, brosnan, vonk, povinelli, richardson, lambeth, mascaro, schapiro, 1357, 1359, 1038, nature04243, 437, references, pnas, papers, cave, tora, bora, mountains, somewhere, remote, heard, 12th, 150th, delightful, sesquicentennial, deluge, retrospectives, speculation, celebrate, ever, behind, journals, naturally, biggest, noise, stellar, delighted, able, beings, descent, modification, fell, favour, 20th, understandable, biologically, theories, identity, eugenics, gas, chambers, germany, started, 80s, guise, socio, hit, misread, misunderstood, misrepresented, caricatured, denigrated, telling, rudyard, kipling, spins, yarns, elephants, trunks, leopards, spots, lambasted, sexist, wing, determinist, greedily, reductionist, flat, needless, massively, thorough, rebuttal, charges, flawless, respects, broad, church, internal, disagreements, fully, message, structure, born, rightfully, slain, aid, linguist, noam, chomsky, coming, enthusiastically, drawn, inspiration, climate, neglect, dogmatism, best, mainstream, tooby, leda, cosmides, martin, daly, margo, buss, students, cadre, philosophers, tenets, afraid, interacts, manifest, accounts, exciting, convince, stories, universals, diversity, confronted, wickedness, depravity, apt, news, opportunities, observe, baseness, horrendously, brutal, last, struggled, protection, services, haringey, council, missed, abuse, continuously, suffered, despite, visits, home, earth, mete, defenceless, hardly, unusual, appreciate, incomprehensible, revolting, abhorrence, patently, justified, hearing, tragic, screw, loose, advocated, guide, judgment, express, actiosn, rational, fathom, thoroughly, push, objects, socially, dehumanise, vagrants, primarily, portraying, fat, greedy, greasy, frequent, prelude, pogroms, cleansing, genocide, interracial, potent, knock, marry, infallible, reliable, prejudice, hostility, accordingly, reminds, appear, forcing, filthy, squalid, humiliating, justify, mistreatment, subsequently, reflected, rotting, carcass, dog, shoe, tyres, bike, felling, pioneers, dislike, avoid, qualify, unpacking, imagine, sterilised, cock, roach, dip, glass, tongs, sip, thirsty, dipping, delicious, sweet, tooth, safe, transferred, harmless, reluctant, chocolates, shaped, turds, happen, age, hallmarks, repulsed, consuming, foods, queasy, worn, carefully, laundered, forced, misdemeanours, produces, urge, cleanse, attempt, wash, stain, character, metaphorical, agreement, judgments, involve, offices, element, driving, vexed, venality, irresponsibility, investment, bankers, tag, disapprobation, clues, metaphors, donning, hilter, tends, rate, beat, faster, prompted, gory, drop, happens, getting, mad, revolted, worked, graduate, student, footage, rallies, reactions, monitored, told, strikingly, clenching, throat, muscular, imaging, regions, subserve, scenario, guided, poisonous, harmful, foodstuffs, upon, demanding, primary, totally, gross, piss, puke, snot, puss, decidedly, euphemistic, fire, combine, properties, begins, count, assessing, nice, smells, fresh, provenance, lamentably, include, took, takes, emerge, once, principally, odious, originally, protected, dangerous, concept, enables, selves, corruption, frames, souls, link, colloquialisms, expressing, literal, underlies, trajectory, tested, hannah, toronto, during, judgement, dirtiness, insects, salty, sour, liquids, elicited, unfairly, focus, derives, cross, universal, canonical, wrinkling, caused, raise, wrinkle, levator, labii, muscle, sadness, intriguing, conclusion, rejection, impulse, offensive, interpreting, straightforward, accompanying, commentary, katrina, highlight, problems, tiered, top, nonverbal, tasting, straight, pathway, activates, involving, aversive, substances, principle

Text of the page (random words):
y of mankind the proper study of mankind a blog on evolution philosophy and human nature tuesday june 29 2010 thoughts on the templeton foundation it s no secret that many atheists don t much like the john templeton foundation hereafter just templeton and have a pretty low opinion of people who accept templeton funding and financial support this theme cropped up in two recent blog posts one by jerry coyne the other by pz myers and i want to make a few comments about both coyne s post was a response to a new website to be launched by templeton big questions online coyne starts in characteristic style are you one of those indigent freelance writers scrabbling hard to earn a pittance sick of magazines and newspapers that pay you jack well your troubles are over at least if you re willing to churn out accommodationist pap the john templeton foundation through its credential bending director of publications rod dreher has announced that if you re willing to toe the party line templeton has big simoleons for writers the details of the pap writers will have to produce are provided by dreher t he web publication the john templeton foundation will soon launch big questions online will be paying good money for essays we re interested in smart insightful pieces on science religion markets morals and any combination of the four myers post is a long response to an essay by ron rosenbaum who was one of this year s templeton science and religion journalism fellows at the end myers writes i m not going to try to take apart every word in rosenbaum s disjointed agglomeration of poorly thought out nonsense but i will leave you with one little phrase from the article that tells you everything you need to know having recently spent two weeks in cambridge the one in the united kingdom on a templeton cambridge fellowship goodnight ron rosenbaum i don t think i m misreading myers comment when i say that the implication is that anyone who has anything to do with templeton is inherently untrustworthy intellectually and their views can be dismissed simply by virtue of that association coyne s short post admits of two possible readings on one he could be taken to be saying that writing about science religion markets or morals is to inevitably churn out accommodationist pap otherwise it doesn t make sense to cite the scope of the articles templeton are interested in as evidence that putative contributors will be required to do so but that would be crazy talk joseph henrich for example is one of the world s leading anthropologists and uses a combination of ethnographic observation mathematical modelling and experimentation to tease apart the basic factors shaping human behaviour i haven t done justice to his research with this summary check his website out for more details a recent paper of henrich and colleagues published in science was entitled markets religion community size and the evolution of fairness and punishment the abstract reads as follows large scale societies in which strangers regularly engage in mutually beneficial transactions are puzzling the evolutionary mechanisms associated with kinship and reciprocity which underpin much of primate sociality do not readily extend to large unrelated groups theory suggests that the evolution of such societies may have required norms and institutions that sustain fairness in ephemeral exchanges if that is true then engagement in larger scale institutions such as markets and world religions should be associated with greater fairness and larger communities should punish unfairness more using three behavioral experiments administered across 15 diverse populations we show that market integration measured as the percentage of purchased calories positively covaries with fairness while community size positively covaries with punishment participation in a world religion is associated with fairness although not across all measures these results suggest that modern prosociality is not solely the product of an innate psychology but also reflects norms and institutions that have emerged over the course of human history is this accommodationist pap junk research that is of no interest to anyone but the devout wishing to reconcile science with religion of course not would i be producing worthless accommodationist garbage if i wrote a story about this sort of work for say science or nature again of course not so would it automatically become accommodationist pap if i wrote exactly the same thing for big questions online and what does writing about science religion markets and morals have to do with arguments about accommodationism indeed coyne seems to have moved away from principled arguments about accommodationism to simply smearing everything and anyone that has anything to do with templeton though as we ll see below his targeting of people is actually a bit selective and if writing about science religion markets and morals even for templeton is not intrinsically pap worthy then why does coyne say in response to calls for essays on these topics that writers must be willing to churn out accommodationist pap or be willing to toe the party line and finally just what is the templeton party line when it comes to science religion markets and morals i m genuinely interested to hear answers to these reasonable questions of course the real issue here is the templeton foundation what it does and what it s about the big sticking point for writers such as coyne and myers seems to be not merely the fact that many folk at templeton hold religious beliefs but that they argue for a compatibility between science and religion that coyne myers and many others do not accept richard dawkins has criticised the organisation for trying to ride on the coat tails of science but i get the impression that the issue is really much deeper that templeton poses a threat to the conduct of science and the integrity of researchers who benefit from their funding on the edge website coyne wrote i absolutely agree that the templeton foundation corrupts science it does this in two ways first it involves us in a dialogue that is designed to have a predetermined result the reconciliation of science and religion but when doing our own research we are not committed to a specific outcome thus if you re one of the many scientists who doesn t think that such a reconciliation is possible at least not without mendacity self delusion or cognitive dissonance then it is unethical to take money from the foundation that is like taking money to attend a conference aimed at reconciling evolution with intelligent design even if you do not think that they re compatible iders think that they are second it leads as george johnson has noted to the appearance of a conflict of interest even if the beneficiary is convinced that none exists even if a us senator is predetermined by his own opinions to vote in favor of say drilling for oil in alaska it is nevertheless illegal and unethical for him to take personal money from the oil industry and it looks bad to take campaign money from the oil industry scientists should be purer than senators because it is our business to promulgate the truth and all we have is our reputations as unsullied truth seekers i am appalled at the templeton foundation dangling large sums of money in front of scientists why so much money this can only serve i think to bend those people motivated by the prospect of gaining a million plus dollars toward the will of the foundation you d have to be a bit of a moron to fail to see why someone might hold these concerns but i think they may be a bit over blown and i ll try to explain why the first point that anyone who doesn t believe in a fundamental compatibility of scientific knowledge and religious belief is behaving unethically if they accept money from the templeton seems to go a bit far for a number of reasons first not everyone who receives templeton funding does so in relation to work that is aimed at establishing this compatibility jonathan haidt of the university of virginia for instance is a leading social and cultural psychologist and one of his research interests is in the long neglected positive emotions hadit has received templeton funding into positive psychology but the published work that has arisen from this has nothing to do with reconciling science and religion or even arguing for accommodationism second even if you disagree with templeton about accommodationism or the fundamental harmony between science and religion it does not strike me as unethical to work with templeton here s a parallel jerry coyne like me has written for science magazine and the official line of its publisher the american association for the advancement of science is accommodationist yet that didn t prevent either coyne or me for writing for them and quite rightly the purist attitude evident in refusing to accept money from someone with whom you do not entirely agree with is commendable to a degree but i think it needs to be kept in perspective i wouldn t write for a racist publication or organisation for instance my ethical stance against racism would make me an unethical hypocrite if i did yet does it follow from that example that i shouldn t write for anyone with whom i disagree on some point whether it be foreign policy or domestic politics obviously not otherwise i wouldn t write for anybody similarly if you only maintained friendships with people with whom you agreed 100 you d probably be pretty lonely so it clearly matters what the disagreement is about a disagreement about whether some races are inherently superior to others is very deep moral disagreement one that cannot be glossed over while conversation focuses on other things but is a disagreement of whether science and religion can be reconciled a similarly profound moral issue as opposed to an intellectual epistemological issue is it the case that if someone believes in accommodationism and you don t then that person s is like the racist beyond the moral pale and should therefore be avoided this seems a little hard to swallow but i d be interested in arguments to show i m wrong coyne s second point that accepting templeton funding creates the perception of conflict of interests even where none really exists also seems to be less significant in practice in the case of the oil company and the senator the oil company wants to pursue drilling and the senator is advocating drilling but this one to one mapping of interests is not always or perhaps even frequently evident when it comes to templeton funding it s not like templeton has a single goal of arguing for accommodationism and only funds people who argue likewise haidt s work on the positive emotions for instance is not a call for accommodationism nor is it offered as proof of spiritual realities it s just basic psychological research the final point about the temptations created by the prospect of large sums of money calls into question the integrity of those who accept it yet i m not really sure that coyne or myers want to go on the record and question the research and motivations of people such as haidt or dacher keltner another researcher in positive psychology or evolutionary biologist david sloan wilson who have received templeton funding or researchers such as herb gintis a leading game theorist and behavioural economist and michael gazzaniga one of the world s most famous neuroscientists who have participated in templeton projects i accept that the quality of their work and their fame is no guarantee that they do not bend their views to get templeton money or that they don t hold bizarre views in other domains but i ve seen no evidence to support either assertion of course if templeton was an inherently immoral organisation then there would be cause for censure of these academics but what evidence supports such an argument i want to return to the issue of the scope of templeton s funding interests which i ve already suggested go beyond simply giving people money to spout an accommodationist position the organisation funds research into many areas that are part of standard academic research for instance the highly respected evolutionary biologist gunter wagner of yale university was awarded a grant to study genetics and the origins of organismal complexity a topic that should be right up myers and coyne s street and mine too as you can see in this article this sort of work is essential for understanding the topic of evolvability a central issue in evolutionary developmental biology wagner s published work which i heartily commend to you has nothing to do with promoting a reconciliation between science and religion it s just good science and we should be grateful that it s being funded would coyne be prepared to say that wagner or haidt or keltner has in some way acted unethically or been corrupted by accepting this grant has science lost out or gained by the availability of templeton funding in this case and if this case is beyond reproach then why the blanket dismissal and ridicule of all templeton related activities what about behavioural geneticist robert plomin of kings college london receiving money to look into the genetics of high cognitive abilities or paul zak receiving funding to study the effects of oxytocin on social behaviour are all these researchers obligated to churn out accommodationist pap because they ve received money from templeton and if not then why does that logic apply to writers contributing to the big questions online so i come back to the starting point why does coyne suggest that doing anything related to the templeton s activities automatically imply that you have to write accommodationist pap or toe a part line why does myers think that the mere fact that someone has had something to do with templeton mean that they can be written off i understand that neither of these writers likes the idea of science and religion being compatible in a deep sense i e not just that one mind can hold both scientific and religious beliefs but i struggle to see how this translates into such vitriol against templeton and its affiliates remember coyne described the templeton fellowships as a bribe coyne did later say he didn t really mean bribe though it s it not quite clear what he meant other than to smear the organisation and russell blackford called chris mooney a disgusting traitor for accepting one such fellowship i must be missing something perhaps coyne and myers will suggest i m a mental defective who simply can t see what s really going on or perhaps they know things i don t about how corrupting templeton is on researchers writers and science at large i hope however that if they reply they can refrain from the obvious temptation to attack me at my deepest integrity by suggesting that i m simply auditioning for templeton money we need the debates to get beyond the ad hominems i m also an atheist who doesn t believe that science and religion are fundamentally compat...