Meta tags:
description=Family life, formerly a .mac blog, continued and rejigged. Mostly written on Gadigal Wangal land. I welcome any First Nations readers and commenters;

Headings (most frequently used words):

share, this, prize, for, the, at, to, nsw, of, book, club, recent, posts, fiction, literature, award, me, fail, fly, starting, how, end, story, pam, brown, text, thing, on, road, in, dark, yorkshire, with, dalgliesh, remembering, david, malouf, literary, awards, shortlist, 2026, letters, seamus, heaney, third, and, final, progress, report, sean, kelly, fights, good, fight, eliot, weinberger, 19, ways, looking, wang, wei, ian, mcewan, what, we, can, know, carys, davies, clear, subscribe, blog, via, email, comments, top, currently, reading, watching, tags, archives, meta, christina, stead, douglas, stewart, non, kenneth, slessor, poetry, patricia, wrightson, children, ethel, turner, young, people, nick, enright, playwriting, betty, roland, scriptwriting, indigenous, writers, multicultural, uts, glenda, adams, new, writing,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (540), and (234), that (147), for (97), this (90), new (63), opens (60), window (60), was (60), his (59), book (55), with (52), share (50), but (48), about (47), have (41), has (41), are (37), there (37), you (36), from (32), all (32), not (32), may (31), more (31), what (30), when (30), apr (28), can (28), time (28), first (27), books (27), like (27), email (26), read (26), blog (25), how (25), him (25), one (25), poem (25), been (24), which (23), who (23), page (22), feb (21), mar (21), poetry (21), posted (21), #comments (20), oct (20), dec (20), jan (20), 2026 (20), know (20), pinterest (20), tumblr (20), print (20), facebook (20), aug (19), nov (19), jun (19), 2025 (19), had (19), out (19), jul (18), sep (18), brown (17), text (17), years (17), john (17), language (17), they (17), way (17), than (17), end (16), novel (16), friend (16), any (16), think (16), ivar (16), were (16), into (16), she (16), labor (16), her (16), 2018 (15), 2019 (15), david (15), essay (15), link (15), past (15), readers (15), some (15), before (15), people (15), other (14), 2016 (14), 2020 (14), 2021 (14), kelly (14), good (14), almost (14), world (14), will (14), publishing (14), now (13), 2013 (13), 2014 (13), 2015 (13), 2023 (13), 2024 (13), post (13), man (13), land (13), most (13), two (13), ferguson (13), would (13), just (13), them (13), australia (13), 2009 (12), 2010 (12), 2011 (12), 2012 (12), 2017 (12), 2022 (12), club (12), final (12), thing (12), reading (12), wrote (12), much (12), island (12), well (12), say (12), loading (11), pam (11), translation (11), gadigal (11), present (11), here (11), life (11), its (11), then (11), long (11), said (11), doesn (11), albanese (11), theatre (11), press (11), comment (10), reader (10), nations (10), tagged (10), where (10), after (10), right (10), written (10), many (10), year (10), write (9), 2008 (9), things (9), letters (9), heaney (9), quarterly (9), wangal (9), welcome (9), also (9), such (9), our (9), still (9), because (9), old (9), back (9), panel (9), 2007 (8), weinberger (8), ways (8), malouf (8), dark (8), dalgliesh (8), story (8), garner (8), your (8), over (8), part (8), since (8), loved (8), even (8), didn (8), did (8), little (8), mind (8), being (8), always (8), leave (8), character (8), holmes (8), last (8), published (8), own (8), word (8), does (8), only (8), government (8), judging (8), prize (8), small (7), carys (7), davies (7), seamus (7), third (7), posts (7), australian (7), acknowledge (7), elders (7), those (7), very (7), different (7), moment (7), off (7), taken (7), see (7), including (7), words (7), down (7), pages (7), five (7), wrong (7), enough (7), stevenson (7), too (7), interesting (7), their (7), used (7), ken (7), pickled (7), clear (6), ian (6), looking (6), starting (6), sydney (6), lost (6), continent (6), settler (6), heritage (6), alive (6), british (6), eora (6), longer (6), both (6), negative (6), come (6), while (6), why (6), saw (6), find (6), told (6), short (6), country (6), future (6), narrator (6), same (6), give (6), chinese (6), three (6), mostly (6), says (6), onion (6), subscribe (5), account (5), mcewan (5), eliot (5), nsw (5), road (5), recent (5), literature (5), women (5), house (5), belvoir (5), second (5), practice (5), age (5), arthur (5), phillip (5), claimed (5), crown (5), having (5), feel (5), writing (5), these (5), don (5), meeting (5), relationship (5), point (5), perhaps (5), found (5), going (5), through (5), between (5), love (5), knowledge (5), number (5), each (5), central (5), known (5), remember (5), though (5), bridge (5), won (5), home (5), characters (5), person (5), four (5), correspondents (5), correspondence (5), seen (5), personal (5), memory (5), reid (5), often (5), uqp (5), black (5), company (5), woman (5), night (5), kind (5), full (5), probably (5), website (4), report (4), sign (4), fail (4), fly (4), 2006 (4), group (4), wang (4), wei (4), sean (4), literary (4), awards (4), remembering (4), yorkshire (4), writers (4), fiction (4), history (4), children (4), art (4), season (4), helen (4), 2002 (4), currently (4), place (4), jonathan (4), blogging (4), focus (4), coincides (4), elapsed (4), nation (4), seem (4), felt (4), others (4), men (4), made (4), sense (4), towards (4), enjoyed (4), feelings (4), might (4), allowed (4), himself (4), generally (4), take (4), interested (4), north (4), example (4), english (4), whole (4), make (4), links (4), speaker (4), turns (4), meaning (4), attention (4), times (4), change (4), university (4), died (4), case (4), period (4), emotion (4), should (4), seems (4), something (4), never (4), nice (4), party (4), poet (4), question (4), learned (4), ago (4), discussing (4), lot (4), line (4), warm (4), important (4), whose (4), quite (4), bit (4), creative (4), quotes (4), christopher (4), marie (4), decades (4), without (4), wonderful (4), family (4), award (4), ant (4), imprint (4), ultimo (4), allen (4), unwin (4), episode (4), currency (4), sure (4), greg (4), patmore (4), caslin (4), eggs (4), diaries (4), name (3), log (3), wordpress (3), com (3), entries (3), jennifer (3), heat (3), fight (3), shortlist (3), abc (3), griffin (3), divided (3), blacklight (3), dead (3), 100 (3), mary (3), comes (3), whispering (3), search (3), met (3), pretty (3), real (3), true (3), excellent (3), version (3), nothing (3), need (3), stayed (3), clergyman (3), errand (3), could (3), anyone (3), genocide (3), lieutenant (3), intimate (3), certainly (3), beneath (3), learning (3), process (3), giving (3), turn (3), once (3), either (3), picked (3), far (3), next (3), walking (3), under (3), become (3), especially (3), reminded (3), early (3), young (3), names (3), learn (3), events (3), matter (3), announced (3), title (3), hard (3), keep (3), electronic (3), goes (3), truth (3), wasn (3), beyond (3), came (3), evoked (3), mine (3), hundred (3), description (3), state (3), makes (3), student (3), yet (3), shelf (3), tells (3), quest (3), route (3), cévennes (3), france (3), vast (3), together (3), until (3), heard (3), original (3), response (3), gives (3), idea (3), must (3), work (3), occasionally (3), anthony (3), days (3), series (3), answer (3), include (3), keating (3), collective (3), hawke (3), introduced (3), current (3), argues (3), alp (3), catholic (3), childhood (3), natural (3), sounds (3), holding (3), slow (3), addressed (3), mentioned (3), went (3), latin (3), letter (3), sometimes (3), gone (3), poems (3), interview (3), given (3), library (3), micaela (3), sahhar (3), newsouth (3), jaffa (3), gate (3), magabala (3), highly (3), commended (3), shakthidharan (3), grant (3), simon (3), song (3), screen (3), melbourne (3), gift (3), madeleine (3), want (3), single (3), listen (3), missing (3), day (3), big (3), deal (3), hands (3), someone (3), rather (3), image (3), artist (3), bolton (3), curses (3), culture (3), stop (3), perfectly (3), outside (3), opening (3), imagine (3), denis (3), diary (3), decided (3), 1978 (3), yellow (3), notebook (3), required (2), view (2), site (2), content (2), subscribed (2), privacy (2), already (2), join (2), 734 (2), subscribers (2), feed (2), 2004 (2), 2005 (2), archives (2), maiden (2), sentence (2), journal (2), catch (2), winter (2), arundhati (2), roy (2), fights (2), progress (2), rss (2), overland (2), nswpla (2), non (2), proust (2), brooks (2), comics (2), challenge (2), alison (2), croggon (2), graham (2), roland (2), bones (2), mother (2), betty (2), travels (2), top (2), gums (2), monday (2), sto (2), address (2), older (2), nights (2), lasting (2), responses (2), islands (2), difficult (2), alone (2), lessons (2), substantial (2), fact (2), building (2), mission (2), gun (2), climax (2), clearly (2), agreed (2), divergent (2), views (2), completely (2), silly (2), hum (2), sex (2), implausible (2), finally (2), above (2), ever (2), resolution (2), questions (2), dawes (2), patyegarang (2), growing (2), emotional (2), enthusiasm (2), surely (2), around (2), excited (2), scene (2), lies (2), appreciate (2), taste (2), author (2), note (2), further (2), glossary (2), limpets (2), water (2), scalded (2), flingaso (2), flodreks (2), inside (2), saved (2), sitting (2), everything (2), paragraph (2), acted (2), eating (2), slowly (2), away (2), fallen (2), twist (2), kate (2), spare (2), irrelevant (2), humour (2), light (2), against (2), scotland (2), plus (2), simple (2), referred (2), tends (2), runciman (2), nationa (2), gratefully (2), cared (2), beautiful (2), millennia (2), close (2), satisfying (2), span (2), key (2), thinking (2), academics (2), unknown (2), records (2), aren (2), remains (2), climate (2), fading (2), changed (2), extent (2), revelation (2), holiday (2), half (2), becomes (2), chord (2), living (2), sees (2), precious (2), prolonged (2), live (2), loss (2), protect (2), failure (2), effect (2), walked (2), downstream (2), represent (2), following (2), sad (2), exquisitely (2), soon (2), context (2), summary (2), across (2), hadn (2), era (2), academic (2), narrated (2), born (2), inundation (2), robert (2), louis (2), les (2), among (2), hero (2), tracks (2), copy (2), 1960s (2), isn (2), richard (2), trips (2), presented (2), wife (2), points (2), increasingly (2), students (2), seeing (2), produced (2), set (2), britain (2), ice (2), created (2), talking (2), human (2), levy (2), dictionary (2), every (2), another (2), remembered (2), exactly (2), partial (2), attempt (2), hold (2), praise (2), attempts (2), onto (2), classic (2), erudite (2), illuminating (2), judith (2), brett (2), special (2), governments (2), society (2), suggests (2), dangers (2), worth (2), interests (2), concern (2), stands (2), socialism (2), political (2), debate (2), capitalism (2), 101 (2), spot (2), risk (2), calm (2), able (2), believe (2), elevated (2), ending (2), seriously (2), types (2), leaders (2), reason (2), usual (2), whitlam (2), described (2), discussion (2), left (2), tories (2), use (2), doing (2), former (2), prime (2), working (2), class (2), briefly (2), knows (2), fake (2), inevitable (2), call (2), wants (2), issue (2), beautifully (2), relevant (2), months (2), white (2), follow (2), stand (2), flying (2), daily (2), lovely (2), presence (2), marriage (2), holidays (2), feels (2), quote (2), noli (2), replies (2), fascinating (2), job (2), model (2), famous (2), lists (2), readings (2), explains (2), few (2), 800 (2), publication (2), editor (2), faber (2), vanessa (2), turnbull (2), roberts (2), yarn (2), zoe (2), meagher (2), julia (2), darling (2), museums (2), victoria (2), guide (2), aliyah (2), knight (2), fruit (2), box (2), 25a (2), snakeface (2), ange (2), crawford (2), walker (2), normal (2), van (2), powerhouse (2), gather (2), breath (2), stan (2), bundyi (2), schuster (2), murriyang (2), marika (2), indigenous (2), amazon (2), deep (2), flanagan (2), fisk (2), peter (2), lim (2), wright (2), marillier (2), james (2), andrew (2), wells (2), harpercollins (2), publishers (2), uwa (2), cordite (2), tbr (2), martin (2), beside (2), meet (2), atkinson (2), images (2), occasion (2), seven (2), couldn (2), hear (2), shirt (2), touch (2), memories (2), asked (2), putting (2), broadway (2), coming (2), looked (2), late (2), blood (2), bleeding (2), trip (2), somehow (2), door (2), roth (2), feeling (2), spoke (2), poets (2), sentences (2), horror (2), comedy (2), least (2), encounters (2), sets (2), elsewhere (2), audiobooks (2), penned (2), conjured (2), syntax (2), crime (2), enjoy (2), voice (2), qualities (2), detective (2), adam (2), selling (2), popular (2), emerging (2), novels (2), popeye (2), kurt (2), brereton (2), graffiti (2), exclamation (2), let (2), odd (2), gave (2), rant (2), cosy (2), maybe (2), lines (2), feminine (2), start (2), ampersand (2), kylie (2), mole (2), easy (2), plastic (2), hairpin (2), suit (2), squeam (2), power (2), demotics (2), sourpuss (2), ate (2), identity (2), community (2), market (2), realise (2), lover (2), 1972 (2), chapbooks (2), generous (2), initial (2), 1995 (2), formerly (2), mac (2), continued (2), rejigged (2), commenters (2), collapse, bar, manage, subscriptions, create, meta, select, month, mandatory, meanjin, god, becky, manawatu, auē, festival, science, fantasy, phone, photo, memoir, marcel, journals, jeff, sparrow, evelyn, araluen, eileen, chong, editing, doggerel, tags, winds, tony, hillerman, sistren, iolanthe, tui, sutherland, criminal, record, paul, rutman, riot, sally, wainwright, cat, returns, hiroyuki, morita, drive, plow, eamon, flack, watching, rachel, cusk, china, miéville, october, ocean, vuong, losorhymo, flugtag, susan, choi, flashlight, debra, oswald, steinbeck, charley, hearts, london, musings, bluefishcloud, paradisekeen3fb84714, enter, receive, notifications, via, lizards, everywhere, clans, along, macewan, prompted, sea, voyages, vessels, saving, grace, underlying, dread, mutual, trust, affection, reveal, concealed, secret, ass, elements, explosive, delivers, satisfied, astonishingly, everyone, sharply, owners, unlikely, boring, stuff, inexorable, movement, happens, buy, answered, satisfactorily, answers, cut, mustard, realistic, careful, spoilers, difference, improbability, looming, developed, attachment, messenger, eviction, returning, oblivious, receiving, lively, begun, object, blamed, beginning, return, communicate, solitary, undercurrent, idyllic, shadow, forget, blissfully, unaware, warned, placid, obedient, large, strong, kindly, uprooted, judgement, footnotes, absolutely, necessary, faint, immersion, definitely, unsurprisingly, invention, norn, extinct, spoken, orkney, shetland, fictional, includes, italics, purple, heavily, padded, mixture, speech, gestures, wash, socks, filled, lamp, cleaned, quick, swept, brought, drained, soup, tur, snori, skerpin, snyag, flogs, flinter, greut, bunki, gruggy, drawn, incorporated, mimed, wanted, trying, describe, inched, knitting, spinning, carding, wool, quietly, noisily, quickly, shouting, jumping, shivering, coughing, sneezing, crouching, fire, shooing, hens, weeks, dropped, rocks, recovering, hut, halfway, mark, marks, turning, genuine, suspense, brings, delightful, resonance, develops, shares, insistently, settlement, cammeraygal, fictionalised, grenville, explored, ross, gibson, got, recommend, splendidly, canadian, similar, piece, gathering, gloom, extinction, starburst, remote, population, shrunk, cow, domestic, animals, sole, surviving, owned, wealthy, mainlander, 1843, during, clearances, tenants, evicted, profitable, sheep, idealistic, impoverished, member, newly, formed, free, scottish, church, agrees, travelling, prepare, removal, near, fatal, fall, recovers, speak, granta, members, combined, ages, add, passed, sailing, spoilerish, reputedly, masterpiece, headed, document, thanks, ingenious, deciphering, clues, archive, transforms, deeply, concede, ruefully, worked, appropriately, misremembering, keats, earth, specifically, historical, sift, mountains, detailed, documentation, unrecorded, remain, significant, amounted, thinly, disguised, lecturing, guess, camp, happily, wandering, confines, scholarly, engagement, irretrievably, frame, parts, interest, tandem, widely, spoiler, alert, driving, fades, distant, background, opinion, commonplace, affair, vibrates, logically, edge, appreciating, preemptively, mourning, resolving, defend, whether, substantially, unchanged, collapsed, crossing, excluded, humanity, problems, solved, draws, fifty, yards, gleam, western, sky, ruined, town, dear, crossed, bereft, tears, reach, ruin, leads, bottom, standing, village, langogne, semi, hallucinatory, hoping, arriving, surprised, passage, schoolboy, settled, subject, doctorate, eased, hardback, delicate, remnant, contains, descriptions, longing, driver, research, intensified, film, traces, 1870s, antoinette, dans, treasures, journey, foot, eighteen, took, southern, tracking, bible, stopped, villages, tried, exact, slept, open, constantly, remnants, ancient, french, peasantry, hung, rural, fastness, profonde, belle, étoile, donkey, isolation, intertextuality, actual, 1985, minimalist, wikipedia, footsteps, adventures, romantic, biographer, works, physical, environment, geography, specifics, boat, however, engrossed, narrative, thread, concerns, main, hunts, reservoir, data, pieces, picture, dinner, distinguished, aloud, vellum, scroll, tied, bow, retold, becoming, experience, tedious, telling, amount, caring, specialise, overlaps, revolt, studies, needs, regarding, generations, catastrophic, contempt, derangement, 2042, caused, melting, caps, nuclear, international, war, put, global, warming, archipelago, america, domain, lawless, warlords, nigeria, preserver, connectivity, simpler, trove, preserved, podcast, contemplating, death, doubt, regard, critical, genesis, cape, leap, reimagining, regardless, act, intellectual, individual, merely, cannot, twice, octavio, paz, contributed, afterword, furious, professor, writes, general, grateful, mentioning, blogged, seaton, timid, uneducated, comparing, versions, slightly, 701, 762, shambhala, anthology, possibilities, solutions, fun, impressionistic, influence, japanese, taking, specialists, ear, displeasure, empty, mountain, hill, sections, presenting, transliteration, modern, facing, translator, pinyin, looks, nearly, translate, 700, 761, nature, deer, park, translating, nerd, spades, wittier, directions, revert, birth, teh, strange, possible, turmoil, endless, unique, graded, contribute, improvement, permanent, sadly, insiders, rises, baseball, discussions, philosophical, tangential, argument, abandoned, socialist, objective, catering, business, reply, relation, formulation, meant, opposition, belief, ameliorative, capacities, reduce, inequality, advance, common, michael, wesley, correct, facts, contribution, brief, enlightening, blind, establishing, consistent, tone, breaks, calmness, admits, recovered, artistic, commonly, fitting, technocrat, bureaucrat, montaigne, swerve, discusses, writer, ella, ferrante, particularly, lately, politicians, technocrats, bureaucrats, leadership, ingredients, imagination, courage, boldness, haunts, saying, great, instincts, artists, remarkable, historically, mythologising, effectively, choose, dominate, deregulated, economy, proud, laments, heroes, medicare, franklin, river, high, court, rights, judgment, striding, failures, predecessors, moving, glittering, driven, inevitably, harked, longest, approval, successive, elections, garnered, critics, freudenberg, legendary, speechwriter, gough, bob, action, decline, system, impressive, degree, unity, vigorous, refining, policy, outsourced, arguments, greens, dismissed, hostility, disarray, coalition, useful, fighting, phrase, raison, être, adviser, ministers, likes, refrain, familiarity, nicknames, frames, tension, ideals, beliefs, pragmatism, stay, convincingly, mistake, adopt, strategy, reforms, order, moved, fast, cropper, assertion, largely, formula, futility, glad, wail, timidity, worse, perfidy, instead, thoughtful, starts, definite, paid, essays, subtitle, mealy, mouthed, statements, ongoing, gaza, genocidal, rhetoric, emanating, pentagon, ahead, vandalism, fossil, fuel, companies, wing, advisers, responding, horrific, killing, jews, bondi, protest, punctuated, walk, beach, windy, darkness, face, pricked, sand, particles, awabakal, miss, contact, movingly, constant, parenthood, illness, striking, endeavours, mention, ceremonial, occasions, social, opinions, intimately, speaks, afraid, viral, leaves, savour, message, epitomises, biblical, jesus, resurrection, tangere, practising, imagery, stories, heart, creativity, gaudens, gaudeo, celebrate, translated, aeneid, timere, pass, laptop, offering, excuse, handwriting, wobbly, result, stroke, communication, sent, wheeled, operating, generously, graduate, asking, track, translators, spectacular, refusing, requests, offence, respond, struggles, avoid, commodification, reluctant, interviews, intensely, previous, ones, ask, chain, apologising, lateness, gifts, excuses, lectures, honours, received, encloses, complains, hasn, cheerfully, resigned, hind, legs, attend, event, honoured, steal, limelight, explain, nobel, finished, gathered, 599, winners, ceremony, 18th, choice, luke, patterson, savage, lucy, nelson, summit, wait, uts, glenda, adams, ela, pinar, guest, jeanine, leane, ellen, neerven, eds, shapeshifting, daniel, nour, affirm, dodge, sandals, advice, zeynab, gamieldien, behaviours, randa, abdel, fattah, discipline, thuy, sarah, ayoub, chan, farz, edraki, ita, hanssens, multicultural, marjorie, nunga, williams, imanka, nurna, laakinha, nitjaarta, kirli, saunders, joan, mla26, iwp, eclipse, natalie, harkin, wakefield, apron, sorrow, sovereign, tea, rärriwuy, gurramu, merrkiyawuy, ganambarr, stubbs, literacy, foundation, yalaŋbara, aunty, fay, muir, krystal, napoli, glenn, shea, samantha, strauss, films, picking, scabs, apple, cider, vinegar, shaun, curio, pictures, mgm, studios, narrow, penny, kitty, duncan, pop, entertainment, correspondent, jada, alberts, bunya, productions, mystery, origin, mirrah, foulkes, michôd, bear, christy, udging, jenevieve, chang, pauline

Text of the page (random words):
or clear enjoyed this one as a satisfying holiday read for some the world building amounted to thinly disguised lecturing about climate change others felt there wasn t enough of it and i guess i m in that camp i would happily have stayed in that future wandering beyond the confines of university scholarly life where my engagement as a reader was fading by the end of the first part and died irretrievably when the narrator and time frame changed that was where others felt the book finally came alive i think there were two people out of five who were there for both parts my interest had died to such an extent that i had to be reminded of the key revelation in the second part i think the key thing that worked for others and not for me is announced in the book s title appropriately enough the title is hard to remember i keep misremembering it as all we can know or all that you know and i keep thinking of keats that is all ye know on earth and all ye need to know so what we can know the book is about knowledge specifically historical knowledge the academics of the future can sift through the mountains of detailed electronic and other documentation of our times but what goes unrecorded will remain unknown and if the records of significant truth aren t found then that truth remains unknown i m sailing very close to spoilerish now but the book s central search for a lost poem reputedly a masterpiece turns out to be wrong headed a different document found thanks to ingenious deciphering of clues in the archive transforms the meaning of events as they were known up to that point for some readers perhaps for most this is deeply satisfying it might i concede ruefully be a matter of attention span the book club s five members are all of settler heritage our combined ages add up to many more years than have passed since arthur phillip claimed this continent for the british crown we met on gadigal land and i wrote this blog post on the land of gadigal and wangal of the eora nationa i wrote the blog post on wangal and gadigal land i gratefully acknowledge the elders past and present who have cared for this beautiful country for millennia and welcome any first nations readers of this blog my blogging practice is to focus on the page that coincides with my age currently 79 share this share on x opens in new window x share on facebook opens in new window facebook email a link to a friend opens in new window email print opens in new window print share on tumblr opens in new window tumblr share on pinterest opens in new window pinterest like loading leave a comment posted in book club books page 7x 47 7 tagged david runciman ian mcewan novel carys davies s clear at the book club posted on 29 mar 2026 2 comments carys davies clear granta 2024 before the meeting on a remote island to the north of scotland the population has shrunk to just one man plus a cow and a number of domestic animals the man ivar is the sole surviving speaker of the island s language the island is owned by a wealthy mainlander and this is 1843 during the time of the clearances when tenants all over scotland were evicted to make way for more profitable sheep an idealistic clergyman john ferguson an impoverished member of the newly formed free scottish church agrees to take on the errand of travelling to ivar s island to prepare him for his removal the errand turns out not to be all that simple john ferguson he is always referred to by both names has a near fatal fall ivar tends him and as he recovers they learn to speak each other s language i love this book it s a story well told with genuine suspense what will become of the gun that john ferguson brings with him to the island and an implausible final twist that i found delightful what i especially love is its resonance with australian history as the relationship between the two men develops and ivar shares his knowledge of knowledge of language and place with john ferguson i am reminded insistently of the relationship in the early settlement of sydney between lieutenant dawes and the young cammeraygal women patyegarang as fictionalised by kate grenville in the lieutenant and explored by ross gibson in 26 views of the starburst world links are to my blog posts if you ve got time to spare i recommend the comments on the second one for some splendidly irrelevant canadian humour there is a similar sense of a small piece of light against the gathering gloom of genocide and language extinction it s a short novel and page 78 comes just after the halfway mark perhaps it marks a turning point it s two weeks since john ferguson has been dropped off on the island and fallen from some rocks he is recovering well in ivar s hut and the language lessons are well under way john ferguson mimed what it was he wanted to know and ivar acted out what he was trying to describe and between them they inched towards the right words for say knitting and spinning and carding the wool for eating quietly and for eating noisily for walking quickly and for walking slowly for shouting and for whispering for jumping and for shivering for coughing and sneezing for crouching by the fire and for shooing away the hens in the next paragraph the reader is drawn into the process as words from ivar s language are incorporated into the text still heavily padded with english the whole thing was an excited mixture of speech and gestures in which john ferguson told him how he d been down to the o to wash his socks or that he d stayed inside because it was gruggy out or that he d filled the lamp from the bunki and cleaned out the greut that he d a quick flinter around swept up the flogs of snyag and brought in the skerpin or that he d picked some snori he d found growing in the for scalded the flodreks and drained them and saved the flingaso to make soup and for a little while now had been sitting in the tur going through everything he d written down so far on the pages of his glossary i so appreciate carys davies good judgement in not giving us footnotes they are absolutely not necessary we are allowed to have a faint taste of learning the language by immersion an interested reader as i definitely am can turn to the author s note to find that unsurprisingly ivar s language is not carys davies invention it is a version of norn now extinct but once spoken on the islands of orkney and shetland and on ivar s fictional island which lies further north than either of those the author s note includes a glossary including all the words in italics purple on page 78 flodreks for example are limpets and flingaso is water in which limpets have been scalded beneath this excited learning to communicate and in the process learning about ivar s solitary way of life there is a dark undercurrent over this idyllic scene there lies the shadow of john ferguson s mission john ferguson has allowed himself to forget about it for now and ivar is blissfully unaware of it john ferguson has been warned that ivar generally placid and obedient was also large and strong and might not take kindly to being uprooted perhaps anyone on the receiving end of so much lively enthusiasm would have begun to feel that they were in some way the object of it all and surely ivar could not be blamed for starting to think at around this time that john ferguson might be beginning to return his feelings just as with genocide looming in sydney lieutenant dawes and patyegarang developed an intimate relationship so here ivar has a growing emotional attachment to the messenger of his eviction and at this point in the novel who can say if he s right about john ferguson returning his feelings certainly not the oblivious clergyman after the meeting astonishingly while everyone agreed that the writing was excellent there were sharply divergent views about this book the most negative version was that the book is completely silly nothing made sense why did the owners need ivar off the island why had he stayed there in the first place how unlikely is it that a clergyman would have taken on such an errand how boring is all that stuff about language how ho hum is the inexorable movement towards the two men having sex how implausible is the sex when it finally happens and above all who would ever buy the final resolution all of these questions could be answered satisfactorily by those of us who enjoyed the book but our answers cut very little mustard mind you i don t think anyone saw the final resolution as completely realistic see how careful i m being about spoilers the difference is that some of us didn t mind and even enjoyed the improbability the most negative didn t feel as others of us did an underlying dread as the two men are building mutual trust and affection we know that the moment will come when john ferguson will have to reveal his true mission and we know there is a concealed gun ivar has a secret ass well so the elements were in place for an explosive climax the book delivers that climax but clearly not in ways that satisfied all readers i was pretty much alone in having loved the language lessons but i think the world of the island felt real and substantial to us all was in fact the book s saving grace even for the mn we read this book along with ian macewan s what we can know which also prompted very different responses both books have islands and difficult sea voyages in small vessels i am a man of settler heritage who has been alive for almost a third of the time that has elapsed since arthur phillip claimed this continent for the british crown the book club met on gadigal land and i wrote this blog post on the land of gadigal and wangal of the eora nation where the nights are lasting longer and small lizards seem to be everywhere i acknowledge the elders past and present of all those clans and welcome any first nations readers of the blog my blogging practice is to focus on the page that coincides with my age which was 78 when i wrote that part of this blog post share this share on x opens in new window x share on facebook opens in new window facebook email a link to a friend opens in new window email print opens in new window print share on tumblr opens in new window tumblr share on pinterest opens in new window pinterest like loading 2 comments posted in book club books page 7x 47 7 tagged carys davies novel older posts search for subscribe to blog via email enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email email address subscribe join 734 other subscribers recent comments jonathan on starting how to end a sto whispering gums on starting how to end a sto jonathan on pam brown s text th paradisekeen3fb84714 on pam brown s text th bluefishcloud on pam brown s text th monday musings on au on remembering david malouf whispering gums on remembering david malouf top posts about hearts in london 1 john steinbeck s travels with charley and the book group mother mary comes to me arundhati roy and the book club debra oswald s 100 years of betty and the book club susan choi s flashlight at the book club losorhymo 3 flugtag ocean vuong s time is a mother the book group and china miéville s october the book group in second place with rachel cusk currently reading watching belvoir drive your plow over the bones of the dead eamon flack 2026 the cat returns hiroyuki morita 2002 riot women sally wainwright 2025 criminal record season 2 paul rutman 2026 the lost continent tui t sutherland 2019 how to end a story helen garner 2025 blacklight j m dalgliesh 2018 divided house j m dalgliesh 2018 griffin sistren iolanthe 2025 dark winds season 4 graham roland 2026 from a novel by tony hillerman tags abc alison croggon art australian women writers challenge children s literature comics david brooks david malouf doggerel editing eileen chong evelyn araluen first nations history jeff sparrow jennifer maiden journals marcel proust memoir non fiction novel nswpla overland pam brown phone photo poetry quarterly essay science fiction fantasy sydney writers festival translation may 2026 m t w t f s s 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 apr rss posts rss comments recent posts starting how to end a story pam brown s text thing on the road in dark yorkshire with j m dalgliesh remembering david malouf nsw literary awards shortlist 2026 the letters of seamus heaney third and final progress report sean kelly fights the good fight eliot weinberger s 19 ways of looking at wang wei ian mcewan s what we can know at the book club carys davies s clear at the book club becky manawatu s auē journal catch up 34 heat 21 arundhati roy s god of small things and the book group journal catch up 33 meanjin winter 2025 jennifer maiden s mandatory sentence archives archives select month apr 2026 7 mar 2026 11 feb 2026 4 jan 2026 11 dec 2025 9 nov 2025 18 oct 2025 10 sep 2025 6 aug 2025 11 jul 2025 7 jun 2025 9 may 2025 10 apr 2025 8 mar 2025 3 feb 2025 9 jan 2025 12 dec 2024 7 nov 2024 14 oct 2024 7 sep 2024 10 aug 2024 7 jul 2024 8 jun 2024 4 may 2024 12 apr 2024 8 mar 2024 8 feb 2024 7 jan 2024 7 dec 2023 8 nov 2023 16 oct 2023 6 sep 2023 4 aug 2023 11 jul 2023 9 jun 2023 5 may 2023 13 apr 2023 6 mar 2023 9 feb 2023 8 jan 2023 10 dec 2022 8 nov 2022 18 oct 2022 5 sep 2022 9 aug 2022 6 jul 2022 10 jun 2022 4 may 2022 8 apr 2022 7 mar 2022 9 feb 2022 3 jan 2022 7 dec 2021 13 nov 2021 25 oct 2021 10 sep 2021 9 aug 2021 9 jul 2021 8 jun 2021 10 may 2021 13 apr 2021 16 mar 2021 9 feb 2021 7 jan 2021 9 dec 2020 9 nov 2020 19 oct 2020 12 sep 2020 10 aug 2020 7 jul 2020 8 jun 2020 8 may 2020 7 apr 2020 11 mar 2020 9 feb 2020 7 jan 2020 8 dec 2019 8 nov 2019 14 oct 2019 7 sep 2019 9 aug 2019 6 jul 2019 10 jun 2019 7 may 2019 11 apr 2019 11 mar 2019 12 feb 2019 7 jan 2019 9 dec 2018 10 nov 2018 18 oct 2018 4 sep 2018 5 aug 2018 4 jul 2018 4 jun 2018 8 may 2018 7 apr 2018 11 mar 2018 5 feb 2018 6 jan 2018 6 dec 2017 5 nov 2017 16 oct 2017 8 sep 2017 8 aug 2017 7 jul 2017 6 jun 2017 4 may 2017 9 apr 2017 9 mar 2017 8 feb 2017 3 jan 2017 8 dec 2016 7 nov 2016 14 oct 2016 6 sep 2016 5 aug 2016 11 jul 2016 8 jun 2016 4 may 2016 12 apr 2016 6 mar 2016 12 feb 2016 5 jan 2016 7 dec 2015 7 nov 2015 13 oct 2015 8 sep 2015 9 aug 2015 7 jul 2015 3 jun 2015 3 may 2015 11 apr 2015 13 mar 2015 5 feb 2015 6 jan 2015 9 dec 2014 12 nov 2014 14 oct 2014 6 sep 2014 6 aug 2014 4 jul 2014 8 jun 2014 4 may 2014 11 apr 2014 9 mar 2014 12 feb 2014 7 jan 2014 9 dec 2013 11 nov 2013 16 oct 2013 12 sep 2013 8 aug 2013 9 jul 2013 8 jun 2013 9 may 2013 13 apr 2013 7 mar 2013 5 feb 2013 5 jan 2013 12 dec 2012 10 nov 2012 16 oct 2012 14 sep 2012 13 aug 2012 9 jul 2012 18 jun 2012 15 may 2012 15 apr 2012 10 mar 2012 10 feb 2012 8 jan 2012 12 dec 2011 10 nov 2011 17 oct 2011 10 sep 2011 11 aug 2011 5 jul 2011 10 jun 2011 8 may 2011 22 apr 2011 14 mar 2011 12 feb 2011 12 jan 2011 15 dec 2010 11 nov 2010 19 oct 2010 16 sep 2010 19 aug 2010 20 jul 2010 10 jun 2010 14 may 2010 25 apr 2010 17 mar 201...