Meta tags:
Headings (most frequently used words):
and, theory, language, the, homo, of, hypothesis, origin, speech, communication, history, early, tool, in, evolution, sapiens, contents, approaches, hypotheses, for, cognitive, development, linguistic, structures, evolutionary, timeline, see, also, references, further, reading, external, links, speculations, problems, reliability, deception, resiliency, grammar, production, humanistic, chomsky, single, step, romulus, remus, gestural, use, associated, sound, mirror, neurons, origins, putting, down, baby, from, where, to, what, grammaticalization, progression, model, self, domesticated, ape, mind, number, representation, lexical, phonological, principle, pidgins, creoles, primate, ardipithecus, ramidus, archaic, descended, larynx, phonemic, diversity, religion, mythology, historical, experiments, research, mother, tongues, obligatory, reciprocal, altruism, gossip, grooming, ritual, coevolution, erectus, heidelbergensis, neanderthalensis, size, exaggeration,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (1037), and (538), #language (451), that (230), from (161), human (146), evolution (136), for (135), doi (122), this (118), with (116), have (113), isbn (98), are (91), theory (89), #speech (85), pmid (83), humans (82), 978 (80), not (74), press (70), origin (64), university (62), vocal (61), communication (60), s2cid (60), homo (59), they (57), pdf (56), their (56), edit (53), evolutionary (52), use (51), social (51), may (49), was (49), such (49), other (48), archived (45), origins (44), modern (43), new (43), bibcode (43), one (43), brain (42), retrieved (41), oxford (41), words (40), original (40), languages (39), knight (39), which (39), linguistics (37), hypothesis (37), eds (37), issn (36), science (35), tool (35), cognitive (35), development (34), linguistic (34), would (34), all (33), evidence (33), been (33), some (32), these (32), early (31), cambridge (31), pmc (31), mind (30), animal (30), but (30), more (30), journal (29), stone (29), chris (29), years (29), articles (28), time (28), when (28), can (28), first (27), its (27), also (27), primate (26), evolved (26), emergence (26), were (26), selection (25), grammar (25), what (25), has (25), 2014 (24), york (24), larynx (24), had (24), calls (24), children (24), system (23), ago (23), only (23), number (22), species (22), sound (22), symbolic (22), 000 (22), between (22), 2021 (21), january (21), 2007 (21), october (21), sounds (21), out (21), into (21), nature (20), culture (20), sciences (20), africa (20), chomsky (20), gesture (20), another (20), chimpanzees (20), could (20), however (20), 2023 (19), different (19), history (19), 1016 (19), word (19), needed (19), 2005 (19), 2012 (19), similar (19), two (19), study (19), syntax (19), primates (19), using (18), model (18), cognition (18), apes (18), sapiens (18), june (18), michael (18), production (18), society (18), must (18), developed (18), according (18), than (18), any (18), ape (17), 2006 (17), fitch (17), auditory (17), who (17), signals (17), part (17), being (17), non (16), september (16), biology (16), psychology (16), research (16), while (16), systems (16), animals (16), february (16), neanderthals (16), 2009 (16), see (16), recursive (16), gestural (16), gestures (16), sign (16), used (16), even (16), about (15), theories (15), cultural (15), behavioral (15), tools (15), self (15), 2008 (15), how (15), phonological (15), scholars (15), example (15), august (14), 2017 (14), functional (14), motor (14), well (14), earliest (14), call (14), ramidus (14), current (14), 1998 (14), monkeys (14), over (14), 2011 (14), nonhuman (14), song (14), during (14), very (14), does (14), contact (13), states (13), biological (13), comparative (13), anthropology (13), age (13), based (13), hurford (13), 2000 (13), 521 (13), form (13), meaning (13), order (13), many (13), ritual (13), each (13), most (13), kind (13), there (13), necessary (13), wikipedia (12), theoretical (12), natural (12), thought (12), john (12), world (12), people (12), approaches (12), april (12), london (12), botha (12), diversity (12), associated (12), without (12), main (12), grooming (12), through (12), change (12), because (12), ability (12), idea (12), much (12), within (12), view (11), march (11), complex (11), recent (11), principle (11), problem (11), effect (11), altruism (11), academy (11), mother (11), list (11), long (11), general (11), heidelbergensis (11), anatomically (11), 2016 (11), studdert (11), kennedy (11), james (11), 2002 (11), 2010 (11), further (11), 1126 (11), july (11), descent (11), tract (11), 1038 (11), 2003 (11), size (11), lower (11), possible (11), where (11), lexical (11), information (11), single (11), structures (11), found (11), same (11), might (11), those (11), thus (11), mirror (11), cannot (11), page (10), statements (10), december (10), made (10), memory (10), acquisition (10), religion (10), behavior (10), reciprocal (10), simple (10), architecture (10), illustration (10), analysis (10), specific (10), deception (10), archaic (10), erectus (10), david (10), body (10), function (10), point (10), then (10), around (10), mothers (10), hominin (10), rudolf (10), 2013 (10), phonemic (10), proceedings (10), intentional (10), making (10), question (10), manual (10), grammaticalization (10), left (10), citation (10), genetic (10), work (10), reliability (10), later (10), wild (10), historical (10), emerged (10), argues (10), learn (10), listeners (10), generation (10), like (10), trust (10), november (9), paleolithic (9), group (9), art (9), neuroscience (9), related (9), intelligence (9), elements (9), features (9), monkey (9), ancestors (9), chimpanzee (9), million (9), anatomical (9), bases (9), make (9), way (9), why (9), hyoid (9), skull (9), 2019 (9), after (9), mutation (9), gossip (9), approach (9), explain (9), themselves (9), communicate (9), suggests (9), terms (8), unsourced (8), 2024 (8), national (8), great (8), shift (8), learning (8), tongue (8), relationship (8), proto (8), cave (8), middle (8), archaeological (8), fire (8), acheulean (8), processing (8), studies (8), vocalization (8), richard (8), robert (8), lieberman (8), usage (8), power (8), facts (8), 2001 (8), supports (8), royal (8), scientific (8), 2004 (8), structure (8), 1007 (8), vocalizations (8), spoken (8), stream (8), able (8), down (8), complexity (8), ochre (8), cheap (8), base (8), stage (8), speak (8), them (8), phonemes (8), capable (8), researchers (8), level (8), proposed (8), important (8), signal (8), intrinsically (8), toggle (7), search (7), under (7), needing (7), 2022 (7), wayback (7), international (7), coevolution (7), mental (7), physical (7), effects (7), reading (7), perception (7), processes (7), symbols (7), prehistoric (7), hand (7), foxp2 (7), others (7), life (7), ardipithecus (7), tongues (7), 1086 (7), neural (7), 1993 (7), review (7), mimicry (7), abstract (7), hdl (7), abilities (7), man (7), 1371 (7), southern (7), recursion (7), rumbaugh (7), understand (7), questions (7), learned (7), full (7), period (7), 1996 (7), cradle (7), old (7), reliable (7), müller (7), century (7), article (7), both (7), his (7), although (7), speakers (7), occurred (7), increased (7), remains (7), infants (7), greater (7), rather (7), less (7), since (7), fact (7), known (7), required (7), resulted (7), led (7), morphology (7), infant (7), changes (7), certain (7), among (7), tus (7), pfs (7), data (6), citations (6), specifically (6), multiple (6), control (6), consciousness (6), adult (6), digital (6), interaction (6), criticism (6), modernity (6), expression (6), display (6), areas (6), costly (6), kin (6), state (6), school (6), books (6), linguists (6), cairn (6), music (6), mark (6), timeline (6), bone (6), prehistory (6), individual (6), talking (6), habilis (6), common (6), machine (6), klein (6), free (6), tomasello (6), mit (6), steven (6), singing (6), philip (6), springer (6), instead (6), became (6), longer (6), babies (6), 160 (6), everett (6), daniel (6), 1999 (6), trends (6), against (6), 335 (6), plos (6), american (6), case (6), capacities (6), 1073 (6), pnas (6), capability (6), behaviour (6), numbers (6), intonation (6), smith (6), area (6), philosophical (6), sequences (6), andrew (6), 200 (6), called (6), boeckx (6), noam (6), saussure (6), rappaport (6), experiments (6), conditions (6), should (6), outside (6), given (6), exaggeration (6), turn (6), despite (6), producing (6), responsible (6), unique (6), still (6), argue (6), neanderthal (6), suggest (6), seem (6), movements (6), due (6), reference (6), will (6), pidgins (6), creoles (6), derived (6), often (6), become (6), feature (6), create (6), false (6), high (6), whom (6), allowed (6), move (6), means (6), therefore (6), neurons (6), critics (6), least (6), across (6), darwinian (6), topic (5), last (5), clarification (5), 2018 (5), phrases (5), 2015 (5), links (5), potentially (5), short (5), problems (5), portal (5), determinism (5), philosophy (5), role (5), emotional (5), sex (5), sexual (5), computer (5), factors (5), process (5), domain (5), facial (5), strategy (5), gene (5), rock (5), blombos (5), bow (5), core (5), technology (5), points (5), food (5), domestication (5), founder (5), birds (5), models (5), ergaster (5), red (5), neanderthalensis (5), mithen (5), grammatical (5), 63964 (5), ancient (5), imitation (5), until (5), our (5), pre (5), began (5), invention (5), dunbar (5), ian (5), paris (5), book (5), either (5), babel (5), expansion (5), transition (5), lowered (5), pone (5), 119 (5), 1098 (5), descended (5), potential (5), 1017 (5), three (5), distinct (5), jean (5), palaeolithic (5), 1987 (5), phonology (5), peter (5), alarm (5), 1994 (5), 167 (5), direct (5), ones (5), child (5), faculty (5), did (5), evolve (5), basic (5), chicago (5), 135 (5), stages (5), temporal (5), 1093 (5), object (5), revealed (5), interactions (5), cortex (5), term (5), voice (5), 107 (5), play (5), precursor (5), help (5), hemisphere (5), events (5), vocabulary (5), novel (5), prefrontal (5), shared (5), patterns (5), construction (5), 211 (5), signalling (5), 111 (5), solution (5), darwin (5), 954586 (5), creation (5), communicative (5), subject (5), own (5), said (5), probably (5), regions (5), compared (5), males (5), especially (5), whose (5), initially (5), oral (5), support (5), accepted (5), vocalisations (5), here (5), suggested (5), once (5), bonobos (5), authors (5), young (5), approximately (5), chimps (5), produce (5), fixed (5), few (5), units (5), yet (5), completely (5), existence (5), focus (5), acquire (5), before (5), finches (5), domesticated (5), today (5), community (5), evolving (5), established (5), baby (5), scenario (5), likely (5), pfc (5), hypotheses (5), levels (5), fake (5), consider (5), subsection (5), contents (4), additional (4), you (4), references (4), 2020 (4), marked (4), issues (4), psychological (4), training (4), topics (4), health (4), differences (4), male (4), mating (4), activity (4), universals (4), foundations (4), visual (4), task (4), response (4), controlled (4), rules (4), recognition (4), synthesis (4), revolution (4), category (4), dictionary (4), method (4), range (4), grave (4), dolmen (4), shaped (4), circle (4), painting (4), bird (4), technique (4), spear (4), hunting (4), involved (4), developmental (4), theorists (4), african (4), bipedalism (4), australopithecus (4), hominins (4), speaking (4), together (4), extended (4), 674 (4), toward (4), took (4), eventually (4), something (4), tecumseh (4), robin (4), camilla (4), talk (4), corballis (4), cangelosi (4), angelo (4), applied (4), 104 (4), 262 (4), serial (4), atkinson (4), ohala (4), anatomy (4), america (4), 244 (4), apparatus (4), 205 (4), penguin (4), earlier (4), watts (4), formation (4), 101 (4), neandertal (4), 159 (4), 981 (4), 256 (4), hypoglossal (4), canal (4), constraints (4), design (4), mechanisms (4), handbook (4), 121 (4), referential (4), christopher (4), acoustic (4), times (4), vervet (4), savage (4), sue (4), philippe (4), via (4), 174 (4), mechanism (4), 222 (4), simon (4), second (4), metaphors (4), mean (4), metaphor (4), maggie (4), tallerman (4), 102 (4), 226 (4), knowledge (4), dorsal (4), fmri (4), working (4), hearing (4), transactions (4), 123 (4), broca (4), right (4), law (4), ideas (4), romulus (4), remus (4), consequences (4), generative (4), cedric (4), berwick (4), durkheim (4), special (4), 193 (4), forms (4), zahavi (4), published (4), roy (4), context (4), 147 (4), machiavellian (4), account (4), purpose (4), articulate (4), ulbæk (4), psycholinguistics (4), begin (4), god (4), particular (4), selective (4), laryngeal (4), initial (4), giving (4), low (4), resulting (4), ask (4), relatively (4), section (4), message (4), needs (4), fossil (4), capacity (4), efficient (4), similarities (4), little (4), close (4), possibly (4), seen (4), result (4), limited (4), significantly (4), failed (4), growth (4), include (4), including (4), difficult (4), corresponding (4), develop (4), generations (4), nouns (4), verbs (4), items (4), linked (4), put (4), simply (4), meanings (4), suddenly (4), things (4), considered (4), environment (4), sentence (4), methods (4), just (4), pathways (4), highly (4), brains (4), sequence (4), survival (4), emotions (4), creativity (4), say (4), back (4), intonations (4), putting (4), lip (4), functions (4), express (4), distress (4), parents (4), individuals (4), developing (4), automatically (4), gesturing (4), particularly (4), hands (4), various (4), reason (4), entire (4), appearance (4), linguist (4), humanistic (4), relatives (4), pooh (4), continuity (4), hide (4), sidebar (4), statement (3), safety (3), organization (3), 2026 (3), categories (3), vague (3), weasel (3), worded (3), date (3), dated (3), description (3), wikidata (3), united (3), darwinism (3), functionalism (3), dual (3), sense (3), emotion (3), ethology (3), biolinguistics (3), academic (3), crime (3), female (3), mate (3), attachment (3), driving (3), aspects (3), media (3), contagion (3), moral (3), eye (3), computational (3), affect (3), choice (3), signaling (3), parent (3), offspring (3), fitness (3), evolutionarily (3), stable (3), institutions (3), altaic (3), north (3), universal (3), internal (3), concepts (3), symbolism (3), box (3), megalithic (3), barrow (3), burial (3), material (3), enclosure (3), house (3), megalith (3), standing (3), stick (3), saw (3), axe (3), lithic (3), storage (3), cooking (3), aquatic (3), muscles (3), antecessor (3), deer (3), look (3), external (3), stephen (3), puzzle (3), story (3), harvard (3), uniquely (3), wiley (3), mathematics (3), 179 (3), 78157 (3), 002 (3), routledge (3), jane (3), now (3), name (3), place (3), series (3), perhaps (3), originally (3), humanity (3), dan (3), lewis (3), crystal (3), 1997 (3), mouth (3), symbol (3), martin (3), 1995 (3), 1989 (3), tower (3), 6069 (3), 657 (3), 2012sci (3), comment (3), ding (3), 11858 (3), 001m (3), 0000 (3), 346 (3), advances (3), mccarthy (3), matsuzawa (3), 201 (3), cat (3), panthera (3), tracts (3), skulls (3), pattern (3), variation (3), introduction (3), 007 (3), ecology (3), pleistocene (3), access (3), populations (3), boer (3), bart (3), louis (3), 146 (3), 1002 (3), 139 (3), 656 (3), conference (3), rome (3), hominid (3), 473 (3), living (3), implications (3), basis (3), 137 (3), pirahã (3), scientist (3), 188 (3), 169 (3), lawrence (3), blackwell (3), 001 (3), zuberbühler (3), klaus (3), semantic (3), 1980 (3), semantics (3), campbell (3), charles (3), 203 (3), infinity (3), beyond (3), extent (3), 1986 (3), duane (3), comprehension (3), jstor (3), kirby (3), bengalese (3), finch (3), 1006 (3), comes (3), heine (3), bernd (3), kuteva (3), tania (3), kathleen (3), gibson (3), 954111 (3), live (3), 155 (3), 175 (3), 0036 (3), 8075 (3), mice (3), lateralization (3), 202 (3), pierre (3), thomas (3), 161 (3), buchsbaum (3), bradley (3), 1162 (3), 0093 (3), 934x (3), christoph (3), rstb (3), empirical (3), nina (3), 128 (3), 3389 (3), 186 (3), capabilities (3), rapid (3), responses (3), rhythmic (3), cite (3), rule (3), outcomes (3), component (3), imagination (3), enabled (3), simultaneously (3), fallacy (3), inquiry (3), claude (3), course (3), prague (3), rational (3), arnauld (3), perspective (3), searle (3), ulrich (3), frey (3), charlotte (3), störmer (3), kai (3), novus (3), berlin (3), conventional (3), 340 (3), 227 (3), crucial (3), interpreting (3), wives (3), tales (3), 129 (3), 130 (3), 1988 (3), 1163 (3), medieval (3), muslim (3), discourse (3), 1861 (3), relation (3), california (3), 223 (3), 149 (3), cost (3), honest (3), shows (3), communicating (3), wow (3), phenomenon (3), interest (3), gradually (3), late (3), remained (3), 19th (3), increasingly (3), johann (3), situation (3), psammetichus (3), raised (3), shepherd (3), concluded (3), phrygian (3), supposed (3), having (3), subsequently (3), upon (3), mythology (3), numerous (3), necessarily (3), take (3), allowing (3), originated (3), advantage (3), lowering (3), nothing (3), consistent (3), occurs (3), objection (3), females (3), displays (3), adaptation (3), whole (3), substantial (3), fully (3), remove (3), rest (3), archaeologists (3), pigments (3), record (3), finding (3), largely (3), universally (3), final (3), sophistication (3), present (3), depend (3), users (3), planning (3), utterances (3), hmmmmm (3), structural (3), developments (3), significant (3), 183 (3), observation (3), argued (3), approaching (3), leopard (3), scientists (3), field (3), insights (3), find (3), rudimentary (3), creole (3), movement (3), syntactic (3), groups (3), pidgin (3), innovations (3), exist (3), songs (3), combining (3), contrast (3), occur (3), set (3), rise (3), open (3), wherein (3), existing (3), essential (3), large (3), messages (3), distinction (3), difference (3), regard (3), sometimes (3), seems (3), arbitrary (3), property (3), representation (3), moreover (3), show (3), intentions (3), notably (3), replaced (3), innate (3), immediately (3), test (3), frequently (3), juliet (3), generally (3), primarily (3), indicates (3), 145 (3), convey (3), concrete (3), equally (3), event (3), ever (3), types (3), unlike (3), abandoned (3), expressive (3), argument (3), neuron (3), link (3), participants (3), indeed (3), understanding (3), favor (3), reliance (3), cries (3), located (3), 100 (3), perform (3), step (3), likes (3), apples (3), technologies (3), appeared (3), stochastic (3), structuralism (3), diachronic (3), anthropologist (3), involves (3), attempts (3), cued (3), standpoint (3), patently (3), socially (3), carry (3), unreliable (3), collective (3), hard (3), anthropologists (3), obligatory (3), offer (3), relevant (3), interests (3), conventionalist (3), revelationist (3), speculations (3), discontinuity (3), mostly (3), add (2), table (2), mobile (2), statistics (2), privacy (2), policy (2), text (2), available (2), agree (2), inc (2), creative (2), ambiguous (2), maintenance (2), cs1 (2), errors (2), ignored (2), incomplete (2), containing (2), https (2), org (2), index (2), authority (2), psychologists (2), standard (2), versus (2), positions (2), trivers (2), inheritance (2), population (2), missing (2), heritability (2), navigation (2), sociobiology (2), primatology (2), genetics (2), neuropsychology (2), medicine (2), cross (2), subjects (2), schizophrenia (2), gender (2), division (2), aggression (2), romantic (2), bond (2), desire (2), concealed (2), depression (2), internet (2), neuronal (2), education (2), deprivation (2), maternal (2), representations (2), musicology (2), naïve (2), color (2), vision (2), parallel (2), folk (2), taxonomy (2), unconscious (2), competition (2), conflict (2), products (2), adaptations (2), acquired (2), characteristics (2), cognitivism (2), institute (2), russian (2), moscow (2), etymological (2), sergei (2), starostin (2), kortlandt (2), murray (2), dolgopolsky (2), indo (2), caucasian (2), uralic (2), families (2), mass (2), comparison (2), reconstruction (2), glottochronology (2), sites (2), unchambered (2), tor (2), ring (2), tomb (2), goods (2), mound (2), round (2), drug (2), flute (2), british (2), gwion (2), paintings (2), stones (2), wine (2), ware (2), pottery (2), track (2), timber (2), extant (2), water (2), dwellings (2), shelter (2), neolithic (2), row (2), quern (2), plough (2), canoe (2), industry (2), mining (2), clovis (2), toolmaking (2), jump (2), game (2), arrow (2), diet (2), crops (2), outline (2), dogs (2), cats (2), paleoanthropology (2), fossils (2), roles (2), gathering (2), denisovans (2), rudolfensis (2), sediba (2), garhi (2), anamensis (2), africanus (2), afarensis (2), kadabba (2), sahelanthropus (2), orrorin (2), nakalipithecus (2), australopithecines (2), gorilla (2), revolutionary (2), vajda (2), edward (2), pinker (2), instinct (2), six (2), year (2), macneilage (2), toronto (2), belknap (2), 28651524 (2), 509092 (2), trans (2), 484 (2), 164 (2), 1990 (2), explanations (2), logical (2), hillert (2), dieter (2), circuits (2), 1976 (2), steklis (2), horst (2), harnad (2), stevan (2), 2025 (2), vol (2), gooding (2), created (2), millions (2), mimicked (2), told (2), stories (2), francis (2), benjamins (2), 237 (2), greatest (2), 1076 (2), jerome (2), dessalles (2), publishers (2), encyclopedia (2), princeton (2), 954587 (2), everaert (2), inference (2), william (2), sussex (2), 359 (2), meena (2), ram (2), lakhan (2), publications (2), scotland (2), accounts (2), remarkable (2), turner (2), dediu (2), 0012 (2), quentin (2), 349 (2), 332 (2), wray (2), verbal (2), 171 (2), 172 (2), thesis (2), suzuki (2), face (2), jhevol (2), 005 (2), 209 (2), 195 (2), domestic (2), rspb (2), phonetic (2), observations (2), vocalizing (2), 218 (2), henshilwood (2), south (2), 295 (2), ethiopia (2), 021 (2), networks (2), 158 (2), 162 (2), 3758 (2), s13423 (2), 016 (2), psychonomic (2), bulletin (2), supralaryngeal (2), ajpa (2), 1142 (2), 152 (2), 1800 (2), cartmill (2), 2013ploso (2), kebara (2), arensburg (2), schepartz (2), tillier (2), vandermeersch (2), rak (2), 646 (2), 2223235 (2), 2066 (2), 41103 (2), 431525 (2), 621 (2), 240 (2), 0003 (2), 010 (2), action (2), barham (2), 579 (2), 225509049 (2), 1573 (2), s10816 (2), 020 (2), 09480 (2), 535 (2), semiotics (2), cataldo (2), migliano (2), vinicius (2), 207 (2), berkeley (2), s1364 (2), 6613 (2), 258 (2), aronoff (2), 631 (2), cub (2), arnold (2), kate (2), 303 (2), 441 (2), seyfarth (2), cheney (2), dorothy (2), 3472 (2), scott (2), pages (2), stuart (2), roger (2), kanzi (2), 141 (2), future (2), schlenker (2), karim (2), hockett (2), 1111 (2), successor (2), tetsuro (2), 315 (2), influence (2), 156 (2), 153 (2), rising (2), selected (2), 314 (2), karen (2), 1166068 (2), tbilisi (2), hauser (2), 5598 (2), 298 (2), 1569 (2), 363 (2), anthropological (2), 3914 (2), lakoff (2), 1979 (2), maynard (2), harper (2), genesis (2), mahwah (2), erlbaum (2), wilson (2), relevance (2), 342 (2), srpx2 (2), elder (2), 0027 (2), 8424 (2), heffner (2), 1984 (2), lobe (2), macaques (2), 6474192 (2), 99817 (2), 1932 (2), 6203 (2), mapping (2), esposito (2), bandl (2), lexicon (2), hickok (2), gregory (2), kayser (2), petkov (2), logothetis (2), nikos (2), 011 (2), warren (2), aphasia (2), integration (2), lesion (2), region (2), 367 (2), hierarchical (2), 2400 (2), identification (2), poliva (2), oren (2), fnins (2), frontiers (2), neuroanatomically (2), f1000research (2), kaye (2), falk (2), whence (2), motherese (2), andrea (2), impossible (2), flow (2), 1973 (2), shadowing (2), warrington (2), 463 (2), vowel (2), fast (2), 1044 (2), 593 (2), 435 (2), larsson (2), s10071 (2), generated (2), locomotion (2), 015 (2), mcneill (2), 138 (2), kenny (2), 109 (2), 6th (2), evolang6 (2), italy (2), 170 (2), 163 (2), rizzolatti (2), 173 (2), pika (2), critical (2), waal (2), premack (2), 393 (2), 131 (2), bottleneck (2), vyshedskiy (2), andrey (2), e38546 (2), leap (2), levinson (2), pbio (2), half (2), merge (2), reports (2), labor (2), 191 (2), lévi (2), strauss (2), ferdinand (2), looking (2), port (2), antoine (2), compositionality (2), uomini (2), transcranial (2), doppler (2), reality (2), willfuhr (2), illusions (2), heidelberg (2), verlag (2), beliefs (2), chapter (2), religious (2), sociology (2), 230 (2), hunter (2), 1080861 (2), deacon (2), terrence (2), steels (2), luc (2), prerequisite (2), enfield (2), 329 (2), 236 (2), super (2), 114 (2), faber (2), status (2), 1971 (2), 120 (2), 1964 (2), byrne (2), whiten (2), clarendon (2), 852175 (2), expertise (2), intellect (2), always (2), piece (2), 55165312 (2), 156852711x562335 (2), 124 (2), weiss (2), shah (2), paget (2), 1930 (2), paul (2), lecture (2), lectures (2), reprinted (2), harris (2), bristol (2), thoemmes (2), 1871 (2), johanna (2), nichols (2), dispersal (2), 127 (2), diversification (2), karl (2), 338 (2), 224 (2), 168 (2), 12141 (2), lineage (2), pan (2), christiansen (2), morten (2), speculation (2), essay (2), introduced (2), separate (2), sub (2), 1990s (2), neurolinguistics (2), scholarly (2), influential (2), 1866 (2), banned (2), reaching (2), gottfried (2), herder (2), tried (2), deaf (2), attempted (2), experiment (2), care (2), determine (2), says (2), prevented (2), start (2), explaining (2), she (2), woman (2), survived (2), born (2), renaissance (2), divine (2), paper (2), gave (2), addition (2), 221 (2), survey (2), 500 (2), best (2), western (2), formant (2), sole (2), extreme (2), observed (2), puberty (2), increase (2), length (2), frequencies (2), threat (2), itself (2), respect (2), remain (2), shown (2), hyoidal (2), permanent (2), association (2), possessed (2), normal (2), mammalian (2), swallowing (2), costs (2), increasing (2), risk (2), choking (2), benefit (2), extremely (2), roughly (2), pressures (2), improved (2), terminology (2), organ (2), emit (2), loud (2), please (2), improve (2), whether (2), behavioural (2), growing (2), purposes (2), claim (2), implies (2), 204 (2), evaluate (2), showing (2), quite (2), kit (2), presence (2), following (2), extensively (2), describes (2), aesthetic (2), reached (2), technological (2), controls (2), believe (2), sophisticated (2), parts (2), becomes (2), though (2), posited (2), beginning (2), commands (2), suggestions (2), redirects (2), humming (2), prominently (2), vital (2), sitting (2), previously (2), incapable (2), creating (2), establishing (2), transmitting (2), cranial (2), unclear (2), ratios (2), speculative (2), prior (2), claims (2), suggestive (2), juvenile (2), measures (2), opposed (2), modulation (2), captivity (2), recorded (2), grapes (2), pointed (2), members (2), predictable (2), recognizing (2)
Text of the page (random words):
ees having learned to use rudimentary signing to communicate with their human trainers proved able to respond correctly to complex questions and requests yet they failed to ask even the simplest questions themselves 163 conversely human children are able to ask their first questions using only question intonation at the babbling period of their development long before they start using syntactic structures although babies from different cultures acquire native languages from their social environment most languages of the world use similar rising question intonation for yes no questions 164 165 166 this fact is a strong evidence of the universality of question intonation in general according to some authors like whom sentence intonation pitch is pivotal in spoken grammar and is the basic information used by children to learn the grammar of whatever language 13 cognitive development and language edit language users have high level reference or deixis the ability to refer to things or states of being that are not in the immediate realm of the speaker this ability is often related to theory of mind or an awareness of the other as a being like the self with individual wants and intentions according to chomsky hauser and fitch 2002 there are six main aspects of this high level reference system theory of mind capacity to acquire non linguistic conceptual representations such as the object kind distinction referential vocal signals imitation as a rational intentional system voluntary control over signal production as evidence of intentional communication number representation 160 theory of mind edit main article theory of mind simon baron cohen 1999 argues that theory of mind must have preceded language use based on evidence of use of the following characteristics as much as 40 000 years ago intentional communication repairing failed communication teaching intentional persuasion intentional deception building shared plans and goals intentional sharing of focus or topic and pretending moreover baron cohen argues that many primates show some but not all of these abilities citation needed call and tomasello s research on chimpanzees supports this in that individual chimps seem to understand that other chimps have awareness knowledge and intention but do not seem to understand false beliefs many primates show some tendencies toward a theory of mind but not a full one as humans have 167 ultimately there is some consensus within the field that a theory of mind is necessary for language use thus the development of a full theory of mind in humans was a necessary precursor to full language use 168 number representation edit in one particular study rats and pigeons were required to press a button a certain number of times to get food the animals showed very accurate distinction for numbers less than four but as the numbers increased the error rate increased 160 in another the primatologist tetsuro matsuzawa attempted to teach chimpanzees arabic numerals 169 the difference between primates and humans in this regard was very large as it took the chimps thousands of trials to learn 1 9 with each number requiring a similar amount of training time yet after learning the meaning of 1 2 and 3 and sometimes 4 children after the age of 5 5 to 6 easily comprehend the value of greater integers by using a successor function i e 2 is 1 greater than 1 3 is 1 greater than 2 4 is 1 greater than 3 once 4 is reached it seems most children suddenly understand that the value of any integer n is 1 greater than the previous integer 170 put simply other primates learn the meaning of numbers one by one similar to their approach to other referential symbols while children first learn an arbitrary list of symbols 1 2 3 4 and then later learn their precise meanings 171 these results can be seen as evidence for the application of the open ended generative property of language in human numeral cognition 160 linguistic structures edit lexical phonological principle edit hockett 1966 details a list of features regarded as essential to describing human language 172 in the domain of the lexical phonological principle two features of this list are most important productivity users can create and understand completely novel messages new messages are freely coined by blending analogizing from or transforming old ones either new or old elements are freely assigned new semantic loads by circumstances and context this says that in every language new idioms constantly come into existence duality of patterning a large number of meaningful elements are made up of a conveniently small number of independently meaningless yet message differentiating elements the sound system of a language is composed of a finite set of simple phonological items under the specific phonotactic rules of a given language these items can be recombined and concatenated giving rise to morphology and the open ended lexicon a key feature of language is that a simple finite set of phonological items gives rise to an infinite lexical system wherein rules determine the form of each item and meaning is inextricably linked with form phonological syntax then is a simple combination of pre existing phonological units related to this is another essential feature of human language lexical syntax wherein pre existing units are combined giving rise to semantically novel or distinct lexical items this paragraph needs citation s certain elements of the lexical phonological principle are known to exist outside of humans while all or nearly all have been documented in some form in the natural world very few coexist within the same species bird song singing nonhuman apes and the songs of whales all display phonological syntax combining units of sound into larger structures apparently devoid of enhanced or novel meaning certain other primate species do have simple phonological systems with units referring to entities in the world however in contrast to human systems the units in these primates systems normally occur in isolation betraying a lack of lexical syntax philippe schlenker et al wrote a paper in 2014 giving evidence to suggest that campbell s monkeys also display lexical syntax combining two calls a predator alarm call with a boom the combination of which denotes a lessened threat of danger however it is still unclear whether this is a lexical or a morphological phenomenon 173 pidgins and creoles edit main articles creole language and pidgin pidgins are significantly simplified languages with only rudimentary grammar and a restricted vocabulary in their early stage pidgins mainly consist of nouns verbs and adjectives with few or no articles prepositions conjunctions or auxiliary verbs often the grammar has no fixed word order and the words have no inflection 174 if contact is maintained between the groups speaking the pidgin for long periods of time the pidgins may become more complex over many generations if the children of one generation adopt the pidgin as their native language it develops into a creole language which becomes fixed and acquires a more complex grammar with fixed phonology syntax morphology and syntactic embedding the syntax and morphology of such languages may often have local innovations not obviously derived from any of the parent languages studies of creole languages around the world have suggested that they display remarkable similarities in grammar citation needed and are developed uniformly from pidgins in a single generation these similarities are apparent even when creoles do not have any common language origins in addition creoles are similar despite being developed in isolation from each other syntactic similarities include subject verb object word order even when creoles are derived from languages with a different word order they often develop the svo word order creoles tend to have similar usage patterns for definite and indefinite articles and similar movement rules for phrase structures even when the parent languages do not 174 evolutionary timeline edit hominin timeline this box view talk edit 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 miocene pliocene pleistocene hominini nakalipithecus samburupithecus ouranopithecus ou turkae ou macedoniensis chororapithecus oreopithecus sivapithecus sahelanthropus graecopithecus orrorin o praegens o tugenensis ardipithecus ar kadabba ar ramidus australopithecus au africanus au afarensis au anamensis h habilis h rudolfensis au garhi h erectus h antecessor h ergaster au sediba h heidelbergensis homo sapiens neanderthals denisovans earlier apes gorilla split chimpanzee split earliest bipedal earliest sign of ardipithecus earliest sign of australopithecus earliest stone tools earliest sign of homo dispersal beyond africa earliest fire cooking earliest rock art earliest clothes modern humans h o m i n i d s p a r a n t h r o p u s million years ago primate communication edit field primatologists can give useful insights into great ape communication in the wild 30 one notable finding is that nonhuman primates including the other great apes produce calls that are graded as opposed to categorically differentiated with listeners striving to evaluate subtle gradations in signallers emotional and bodily states nonhuman apes seemingly find it extremely difficult to produce vocalisations in the absence of the corresponding emotional states 44 in captivity nonhuman apes have been taught rudimentary forms of sign language or have been persuaded to use lexigrams symbols that do not graphically resemble the corresponding words on computer keyboards some nonhuman apes such as kanzi have been able to learn and use hundreds of lexigrams 175 176 the broca s and wernicke s areas in the primate brain are responsible for controlling the muscles of the face tongue mouth and larynx as well as recognizing sounds primates are known to make vocal calls and these calls are generated by circuits in the brainstem and limbic system 177 in the wild the communication of vervet monkeys has been the most extensively studied 174 they are known to make up to ten different vocalizations many of these are used to warn other members of the group about approaching predators they include a leopard call a snake call and an eagle call 178 each call triggers a different defensive strategy in the monkeys who hear the call and scientists were able to elicit predictable responses from the monkeys using loudspeakers and prerecorded sounds other vocalisations may be used for identification if an infant monkey calls its mother turns toward it but other vervet mothers turn instead toward that infant s mother to see what she will do 179 180 similarly researchers have demonstrated that chimpanzees in captivity use different words in reference to different foods they recorded vocalisations that chimps made in reference for example to grapes and then other chimps pointed at pictures of grapes when they heard the recorded sound 181 182 ardipithecus ramidus edit a study published in homo journal of comparative human biology in 2017 claims that ardipithecus ramidus a hominin dated at approximately 4 5 ma shows the first evidence of an anatomical shift in the hominin lineage suggestive of increased vocal capability 183 this study compared the skull of a ramidus with 29 chimpanzee skulls of different ages and found that in numerous features a ramidus clustered with the infant and juvenile measures as opposed to the adult measures such affinity with the shape dimensions of infant and juvenile chimpanzee skull architecture it was argued may have resulted in greater vocal capability this assertion was based on the notion that the chimpanzee vocal tract ratios that prevent speech are a result of growth factors associated with puberty growth factors absent in a ramidus ontogeny a ramidus was also found to have a degree of cervical lordosis more conducive to vocal modulation when compared with chimpanzees as well as cranial base architecture suggestive of increased vocal capability what was significant in this study according to the authors 183 was the observation that the changes in skull architecture that correlate with reduced aggression are the same changes necessary for the evolution of early hominin vocal ability in integrating data on anatomical correlates of primate mating and social systems with studies of skull and vocal tract architecture that facilitate speech production the authors argue that paleoanthropologists prior to their study have failed to understand the important relationship between early hominin social evolution and the evolution of our species capacities for language while the skull of a ramidus according to the authors lacks the anatomical impediments to speech evident in chimpanzees it is unclear what the vocal capabilities of this early hominin were while they suggest a ramidus based on similar vocal tract ratios may have had vocal capabilities equivalent to a modern human infant or very young child they concede this is a debatable and speculative hypothesis however they do claim that changes in skull architecture through processes of social selection were a necessary prerequisite for language evolution as they write we propose that as a result of paedomorphic morphogenesis of the cranial base and craniofacial morphology ar ramidus would have not been limited in terms of the mechanical components of speech production as chimpanzees and bonobos are it is possible that ar ramidus had vocal capability approximating that of chimpanzees and bonobos with its idiosyncratic skull morphology not resulting in any significant advances in speech capability in this sense the anatomical features analysed in this essay would have been exapted in later more voluble species of hominin however given the selective advantages of pro social vocal synchrony we suggest the species would have developed significantly more complex vocal abilities than chimpanzees and bonobos 183 early homo edit anatomically some scholars believe that features of bipedalism developed in the australopithecines around 3 5 million years ago around this time these structural developments within the skull led to a more prominently l shaped vocal tract 184 page needed in order to generate the sounds modern homo sapiens are capable of making such as vowels it is vital that early homo populations must have a specifically shaped voice track and a lower sitting larynx 185 opposing research previously suggested that neanderthals were physically incapable of creating the full range of vocals seen in modern humans due to the differences in larynx placement establishing distinct larynx positions through fossil remains of homo sapiens and neanderthals would support this theory however modern research has revealed that the hyoid bone was indistinguishable in the two populations though research has shown a lower sitting larynx is important to producing speech another theory states it may not be as important as once thought 186 cataldo migliano and vinicius...
|
