Meta tags:
description=2 posts published by Seth Long during April 2013;

Headings (most frequently used words):

posts, menu, month, april, 2013, robo, graders, building, chinese, room, top, pages, recent, archives, categories, econ, politics, linguistics, rhetoric, writing, sci, tech,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (53), and (41), that (23), #writing (20), for (20), are (18), 2013 (13), there (10), will (10), students (8), this (7), april (7), 2014 (7), software (7), expectations (7), get (6), with (6), parameters (6), machine (6), these (6), can (6), wordpress (5), com (5), language (5), humanities (5), technology (5), its (5), written (5), way (5), essay (5), grading (5), those (5), about (5), not (5), grade (5), like (4), have (4), now (4), other (4), stephen (4), 2012 (4), march (4), 2015 (4), posts (4), more (4), than (4), their (4), however (4), how (4), point (4), teaching (4), use (4), program (4), courses (4), who (4), has (4), all (4), but (4), they (4), student (4), academic (4), expected (4), fiction (4), log (3), rhetoric (3), linguistics (3), science (3), october (3), february (3), may (3), 2016 (3), video (3), good (3), what (3), our (3), chinese (3), out (3), institutions (3), time (3), say (3), from (3), question (3), state (3), why (3), need (3), major (3), market (3), exigence (3), designed (3), well (3), own (3), across (3), possible (3), discipline (3), sciences (3), defined (3), king (3), site (2), content (2), sign (2), subscribed (2), subscribe (2), technaverbascripta (2), already (2), free (2), blog (2), research (2), translation (2), world (2), digital (2), library (2), attention (2), semiotics (2), literature (2), september (2), november (2), december (2), january (2), july (2), readability (2), formulas (2), top (2), pages (2), posted (2), example (2), social (2), minutes (2), speaker (2), words (2), into (2), response (2), suggests (2), was (2), really (2), best (2), figure (2), both (2), isn (2), seth (2), long (2), uses (2), ever (2), rather (2), professor (2), should (2), esl (2), single (2), could (2), feedback (2), your (2), always (2), certain (2), sentence (2), grammar (2), talk (2), overlook (2), errors (2), instead (2), higher (2), order (2), concerns (2), whether (2), just (2), fill (2), don (2), because (2), only (2), many (2), taking (2), any (2), university (2), colleges (2), online (2), years (2), edx (2), you (2), few (2), reality (2), readers (2), some (2), academia (2), course (2), elite (2), campuses (2), undergraduate (2), announced (2), continue (2), graded (2), mainstay (2), boutique (2), kind (2), algorithms (2), one (2), programs (2), department (2), whatever (2), score (2), never (2), each (2), differences (2), disciplines (2), write (2), texts (2), most (2), templates (2), talking (2), poetry (2), highly (2), follow (2), might (2), communication (2), ensure (2), subjective (2), authors (2), reasons (2), novel (2), novels (2), poems (2), qua (2), started, design, collapse, bar, manage, subscriptions, view, reader, report, privacy, account, join, subscribers, create, website, phylogenetic, networks, orbiting, frog, ian, bogost, genetic, literacy, project, gene, expression, dienekes, contagions, ars, technica, sci, tech, silvae, rhetoricae, planned, obsolescence, page, tectonics, journal, jeff, rice, derek, mueller, collin, gifford, brooke, clay, spinuzzi, ancient, scripts, allison, hitt, alex, reid, replicated, typo, omniglot, linguischtick, geoffrey, sampson, found, zero, hedge, super, economy, steven, landsburg, spengler, ross, wolfe, overcoming, bias, graphic, detail, dissent, magazine, code, culture, econ, politics, ramsay, scott, weingart, sapping, nodus, labs, mining, flowing, data, british, uncategorized, maps, futurism, edm, categories, june, august, 2017, archives, attempt, quantifying, changes, genre, medium, cont, cosine, similarity, idf, boolean, relinquishing, control, distant, reading, autosomes, recent, search, comment, ways, computer, scientists, include, researchers, natural, processing, category, operating, squarely, realm, humanistic, been, spiritual, epistemological, theoretical, nature, computers, getting, hang, humanists, ignore, successes, peril, tomes, manifestos, unto, around, six, demonstration, begins, translated, almost, instantaneously, auditory, output, sounds, somewhat, similar, actual, voice, obviously, speakers, audience, demo, successful, chomsky, statistical, learning, via, using, big, corpora, machines, works, structurally, shows, phonetically, acoustically, steve, hsu, fan, building, room, comments, guess, final, valid, even, won, demand, condemn, wholesale, mean, every, college, lecturer, adapt, advantage, masse, quicker, times, perhaps, detailed, responses, instructor, provide, especially, she, half, dozen, anyone, tried, learn, second, knows, waiting, week, two, teacher, drag, german, wished, quick, turn, phrase, construction, lest, something, wrong, awkward, imprinted, developing, mechanics, formatting, unless, remedial, english, aspects, tend, downplayed, know, rarely, participial, clauses, accusative, case, focusing, secondary, source, put, quoted, requirement, think, thing, class, meeting, bring, level, issues, without, away, off, head, teachers, professors, value, stop, infiltrating, here, available, vast, majority, undergraduates, smaller, universities, trying, graduate, through, fulfills, exigencies, mentioned, above, allows, cut, costs, while, simultaneously, making, easier, door, employing, ten, adjuncts, associates, papers, tenure, track, lectures, uploads, essays, clicks, inevitable, another, robot, publishing, firms, wherever, want, void, less, money, pay, full, faculty, teach, affairs, ivy, league, flagships, masses, population, yale, ago, generous, alumnus, his, plans, fund, increase, mit, body, whopping, such, imagine, human, grown, local, stickers, whole, foods, experiences, future, 250, hasn, changed, since, 1978, certainly, fair, useful, definition, surface, markers, checked, clearly, size, fits, ones, ets, problematic, too, general, means, day, company, start, offering, tailor, made, psychology, history, curriculum, bet, against, enterprise, very, discourse, community, aren, anywhere, near, incommensurable, exist, supra, hard, soft, matter, standard, members, communicate, conform, believe, popular, handbooks, writers, hundred, work, when, context, formulaic, patterns, standardized, rhetorical, moves, description, sound, fingernails, chalkboard, look, standards, necessary, purpose, lower, division, requirements, enculturate, various, modes, psychologists, historians, literary, critics, optimize, clearest, ideas, product, cannot, dependent, ultimately, individual, myriad, people, enjoy, ness, based, style, form, otherwise, remain, forever, impossible, quantitatively, doing, anyway, publishers, replace, front, line, agents, robots, differentiate, bad, ill, vague, successfully, mines, profs, anxious, algorithmic, scoring, ask, mechanized, five, paragraph, paper, review, genres, text, quite, easy, check, were, followed, met, marc, bousquet, founded, harvard, probably, prestigious, implement, assessment, robo, graders, month, wilkommen, published, elsewhere, home, skip, menu,

Text of the page (random words):
april 2013 menu skip to content home posts published elsewhere wilkommen month april 2013 april 10 2013 by seth long robo graders edx founded by harvard and probably the most prestigious online course program has announced that it will implement its own assessment software to grade student writing marc bousquet s essay successfully mines the reasons why humanities profs are anxious about algorithmic scoring the reality is across many disciplines the writing we ask our students to do is already mechanized the five paragraph essay the research paper the literature review these are all written genres with well defined parameters and expectations and if you have parameters and expectations for a text it s quite easy to write algorithms to check whether the parameters were followed and the expectations met the only way to ensure that a written product cannot be machine graded is to ensure that it has ill defined parameters and vague or subjective expectations for example the expectations for fiction and poetry are highly subjective dependent ultimately on individual authors and the myriad reasons why people enjoy those authors it might be possible to machine grade a stephen king novel on its stephen king ness based on the expected style and form of a stephen king novel but otherwise it will remain forever impossible to quantitatively score novels qua novels or poems qua poems and there s no market for doing that anyway publishers will never replace their front line readers and agents with robots who can differentiate good fiction from bad fiction however when we talk about student writing in an academic context we re not talking about fiction or poetry we re talking about texts that are highly formulaic and designed to follow certain patterns templates and standardized rhetorical moves this description might sound like fingernails on a chalkboard to some but look in the academic world written standards and expectations are necessary to optimize for the clearest possible communication of ideas the purpose of lower division writing requirements is to enculturate students into the various modes of written communication they are expected to follow as psychologists historians literary critics or whatever each discourse community each discipline has its own way of writing but the differences aren t anywhere near incommensurable the major differences exist across the supra disciplines hard sciences soft sciences social sciences humanities no matter the discipline however there is a standard way that members of that discipline are expected to write and communicate in other words texts in academia will always need to conform to well defined parameters and expectations don t believe it one of the most popular handbooks for student writers they say i say is a hundred pages of templates and they work so what s my point my point is that it s very possible to machine grade academic writing in a fair and useful way because academic writing by definition will have surface markers that can be checked with algorithms clearly the one size fits all software programs like the ones ets uses are problematic and too general well all that means is that any day now a company will start offering essay grading software tailor made for your own university s writing program or psychology department or history department or writing across the curriculum program or whatever software designed to score the kind of writing expected in those programs never bet against technology and free enterprise and that s another major point there s not a market for robot readers at publishing firms but there certainly is a market for software that can grade student writing and wherever there s a need or a want or some other exigence technology will fill the void the exigence in academia is that there are more students than ever and less money to pay for full time faculty to teach these students of course this state of affairs isn t an exigence for the ivy league major state flagships or other elite institutions these campuses are not designed for the masses the undergraduate population at yale hasn t changed since 1978 a few years ago a generous alumnus announced his plans to fund an increase in mit s undergraduate body by a whopping 250 students such institutions will continue to be what they are boutique experiences for the future elite i imagine that human graded writing will continue to be a mainstay at these boutique campuses kind of like grown local stickers are a mainstay of whole foods for the vast majority of undergraduates those at smaller state colleges online universities or those trying to graduate in 4 years by taking courses through edx machine grading will be an inevitable reality why it fulfills both exigencies i mentioned above it allows colleges to cut costs while simultaneously making it easier to get more students in and out of the door instead of employing ten adjuncts or teaching associates to grade papers you just need a single tenure track professor who posts lectures and uploads essays with a few clicks so the question for teachers of writing the question for any professors who value writing in their courses is not how can we stop machine grading from infiltrating the university it s here it s available rather the question should be how can we best use it off the top of my head grammar mechanics and formatting unless we re teaching esl writing or remedial english these aspects tend to get downplayed i know i rarely talk about participial clauses or the accusative case i overlook errors all the time focusing instead on higher order concerns say whether or not a secondary source was really put to use or just quoted to fill a requirement however i don t think it s a good thing that we overlook these errors we do so because there are only so many minutes in a class or a meeting with essay grading software we can bring sentence level issues to students attention without taking time away from higher order concerns quicker response times for esl students and perhaps more detailed responses than a single instructor could provide especially if she s teaching half a dozen courses anyone who has tried to learn a second language knows that waiting a week or two for teacher feedback on your writing is a drag in my german courses i always wished i could get quick feedback on a certain turn of phrase or sentence construction lest something wrong or awkward get imprinted in my developing grammar so i guess my final point is that there are valid uses for essay grading software even for those of us teaching at institutions that won t ever demand its use en masse rather than condemn it wholesale we and by we i mean every college program professor and lecturer should figure out how to adapt to it and use it to our advantage posted in technology writing and semiotics 3 comments april 2 2013 by seth long building a chinese room chomsky isn t a fan of statistical machine learning however this video via steve hsu suggests that using really big corpora is the best way to get machines to figure out how language works both structurally and as the video shows phonetically and acoustically around six minutes in the demonstration begins the speaker s words are translated almost instantaneously into chinese and the auditory output sounds somewhat similar to the speaker s actual voice there are obviously chinese speakers in the audience and their response suggests that the demo was successful this video is a good example of the ways that computer scientists and i include researchers in natural language processing in that category are operating squarely in the realm of the humanities what s more humanistic than language translation there have been tomes and manifestos written unto its spiritual social epistemological and theoretical nature and now computers are getting the hang of it we humanists ignore their successes at our peril posted in linguistics science technology 1 comment search top posts pages readability formulas recent posts a distant reading of my autosomes relinquishing control readability formulas cosine similarity parameters tf idf or boolean an attempt at quantifying changes to genre medium cont d archives april 2017 may 2016 march 2016 january 2016 september 2015 august 2015 march 2015 february 2015 october 2014 july 2014 june 2014 may 2014 april 2014 march 2014 february 2014 december 2013 november 2013 october 2013 july 2013 may 2013 april 2013 march 2013 february 2013 january 2013 december 2012 november 2012 october 2012 september 2012 categories edm futurism linguistics literature maps rhetoric rhetoric of science science technology uncategorized writing and semiotics d h british library dh blog digital humanities now flowing data mining humanities nodus labs sapping attention scott weingart stephen ramsay world digital library econ politics code and culture dissent magazine graphic detail overcoming bias ross wolfe spengler steven landsburg super economy zero hedge linguistics found in translation geoffrey sampson language log linguischtick omniglot replicated typo rhetoric writing alex reid allison hitt ancient scripts clay spinuzzi collin gifford brooke derek mueller jeff rice journal of writing research page tectonics planned obsolescence silvae rhetoricae sci tech ars technica contagions dienekes gene expression genetic literacy project ian bogost orbiting frog phylogenetic networks create a free website or blog at wordpress com subscribe subscribed technaverbascripta wordpress com join 49 other subscribers sign me up already have a wordpress com account log in now privacy technaverbascripta wordpress com subscribe subscribed sign up log in report this content view site in reader manage subscriptions collapse this bar design a site like this with wordpress com get started