Meta tags:
Headings (most frequently used words):
august, 2012, the, and, friday, thursday, it, on, erosion, wednesday, tuesday, monday, sunday, saturday, to, debt, why, heilbroner, bernstein, for, new, arthurian, economics, 25, in, just, things, year, of, when, again, how, what, libertarian, dilemma, but, have, with, accumulation, google, translate, blog, archive, links, labels, 31, 30, 29, 28, 27, 26, 24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, paul, krugman, faces, technology, changes, everything, funny, sad, way, celebrate, fed, don, they, move, actual, projected, line, left, enough, make, better, now, pictures, adjusting, this, deficit, last, inflation, echoes, ancients, remember, name, edward, demarco, curse, jackson, pollock, ain, useless, as, fire, hose, against, tsunami, flatland, delong, history, economic, thought, de, rosion, simple, ada, ida, calculating, real, problem, is, not, dual, mandate, finance, grows, large, circumvents, weakens, policy, prioritizing, beating, dead, horse, can, resist, doubting, lars, anthony, migchels, matters, we, pay, money, cochrane, vat, log, scale, anatole, kaletsky, about, quantitative, easing, people, that, fits, pattern, jw, past, years, you, know, look, at, m2, divided, by, m1, instead, hate, disagree, somebody, would, liked, agree,
Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (882), and (290), debt (176), that (170), for (103), inflation (88), but (73), graph (72), money (71), you (66), this (66), not (66), from (56), year (53), gdp (50), with (49), when (42), real (42), more (40), what (40), #august (40), line (39), arthurian (37), are (35), have (35), #economic (35), comments (34), then (34), rates (34), posted (33), economy (33), 2012 (33), can (32), growth (32), just (32), was (31), than (31), years (30), about (29), interest (29), price (29), look (28), all (27), one (27), two (26), rate (26), cochrane (26), erosion (26), tax (25), would (24), there (24), way (24), they (24), does (23), financial (23), don (23), because (23), red (23), blue (23), policy (23), krugman (23), think (22), now (22), sumner (22), same (21), other (21), why (21), only (21), fred (20), how (20), sector (20), cost (20), want (20), like (20), out (20), again (20), see (20), figure (20), problem (20), spending (20), ratio (19), savings (19), great (19), used (19), new (19), could (19), has (19), deficit (19), fed (18), much (18), get (18), people (18), adjustment (18), here (17), even (17), time (16), should (16), say (16), data (16), level (16), know (16), which (16), some (16), back (16), may (16), federal (15), right (15), finance (15), good (15), use (15), were (15), well (14), reduce (14), let (14), costs (14), divided (14), amount (14), credit (14), after (14), been (14), post (14), circulating (13), shows (13), doesn (13), things (13), them (13), economics (13), wrong (13), nominal (13), bernstein (13), monetary (12), our (12), income (12), first (12), too (12), non (12), start (12), before (12), lower (12), fedfunds (12), above (12), thing (12), january (12), adjust (12), heilbroner (12), def (12), production (11), large (11), part (11), little (11), page (11), did (11), government (11), less (11), higher (11), also (11), numbers (11), says (11), every (11), thought (11), pay (11), prices (11), consumption (11), cmdebt (11), end (10), since (10), those (10), very (10), had (10), during (10), excessive (10), where (10), between (10), important (10), value (10), taxes (10), relative (10), down (10), long (10), june (10), their (10), lines (10), household (10), december (10), old (10), adjusted (10), set (9), last (9), read (9), component (9), still (9), history (9), work (9), number (9), any (9), its (9), base (9), wants (9), labels (9), must (9), becomes (9), incremental (9), 2005 (9), february (9), march (9), april (9), july (9), september (9), october (9), november (9), will (8), better (8), crisis (8), world (8), high (8), depression (8), point (8), rises (8), matters (8), financialization (8), source (8), proxy (8), series (8), move (8), his (8), begins (8), into (8), changes (8), private (8), both (8), friedman (8), spend (8), something (8), most (8), christensen (8), curve (8), surges (8), next (8), reduction (8), gunnar (7), today (7), factors (7), take (7), golden (7), these (7), roaring (7), 20s (7), below (7), off (7), instead (7), bad (7), over (7), who (7), 100 (7), times (7), 1982 (7), actual (7), few (7), run (7), increase (7), euro (7), zone (7), target (7), productive (7), aggregate (7), total (7), accumulation (7), figured (7), reserve (6), particular (6), based (6), find (6), simply (6), yes (6), age (6), components (6), small (6), bit (6), gives (6), values (6), view (6), gold (6), law (6), dollar (6), click (6), note (6), using (6), average (6), market (6), show (6), each (6), rise (6), maybe (6), short (6), milton (6), looking (6), else (6), keynes (6), suppose (6), enough (6), need (6), dilemma (6), economists (6), revenue (6), matter (6), 1984 (6), second (6), paid (6), always (6), simple (6), adjusting (6), effect (6), borrowing (6), everything (6), technology (6), louis (5), graphs (5), bank (5), posts (5), zarlenga (5), believe (5), system (5), least (5), smith (5), looked (5), five (5), recent (5), found (5), deposits (5), rising (5), result (5), increased (5), low (5), soon (5), available (5), supply (5), book (5), payment (5), three (5), decline (5), grows (5), put (5), thursday (5), size (5), goes (5), far (5), anyway (5), calc (5), actually (5), looks (5), obviously (5), many (5), risk (5), equal (5), friday (5), pdf (5), didn (5), left (5), fits (5), demand (5), exactly (5), four (5), half (5), whether (5), difference (5), while (5), code (5), around (5), said (5), libertarian (5), deflator (5), boost (5), nunes (5), cause (5), toynbee (5), congress (5), current (5), calculation (5), addition (5), cannot (5), deficits (5), paul (5), help (5), google (5), mill (5), your (5), plan (5), planned (5), phillips (5), edward (5), watkins (5), horse (4), make (4), excerpt (4), seems (4), gang8 (4), assets (4), useful (4), land (4), capital (4), following (4), portion (4), already (4), picks (4), 1970s (4), early (4), write (4), plus (4), united (4), japan (4), control (4), went (4), according (4), issue (4), somebody (4), liked (4), 1990 (4), remember (4), funds (4), mason (4), writes (4), pretty (4), rest (4), along (4), lot (4), increases (4), term (4), fall (4), math (4), presented (4), different (4), away (4), past (4), full (4), state (4), england (4), started (4), interesting (4), either (4), saturday (4), words (4), created (4), 000 (4), john (4), sunday (4), cpi (4), probably (4), similar (4), almost (4), effects (4), scale (4), monday (4), eye (4), dan (4), vat (4), analysis (4), limit (4), tuesday (4), annual (4), percent (4), wednesday (4), civilization (4), lars (4), solution (4), clear (4), blog (4), 1964 (4), output (4), recession (4), scott (4), mind (4), productivity (4), title (4), investment (4), dual (4), mandate (4), add (4), wojnilower (4), gets (4), relation (4), delong (4), student (4), sometimes (4), sale (4), everybody (4), nest (4), egg (4), duy (4), unemployment (4), dimensional (4), demarco (4), report (4), her (4), appear (3), research (3), org (3), him (3), thinking (3), profit (3), link (3), 2011 (3), war (3), fine (3), focus (3), poorly (3), circ (3), 1990s (3), share (3), 1980s (3), falls (3), comparable (3), consists (3), states (3), indicator (3), results (3), trade (3), such (3), public (3), allow (3), makes (3), hate (3), disagree (3), runs (3), until (3), seen (3), per (3), means (3), factor (3), greater (3), slack (3), comes (3), true (3), open (3), dates (3), version (3), really (3), zero (3), shown (3), bottom (3), evaluation (3), circumvents (3), mine (3), textbook (3), stable (3), case (3), central (3), 2007 (3), lowered (3), points (3), period (3), local (3), ten (3), 1983 (3), pattern (3), kaletsky (3), deleverage (3), free (3), sound (3), doing (3), 2009 (3), general (3), added (3), trillion (3), family (3), britain (3), recessions (3), simplistic (3), easing (3), significant (3), change (3), log (3), gap (3), 1921 (3), longer (3), middle (3), wrote (3), wall (3), street (3), journal (3), distortions (3), raise (3), keep (3), raising (3), top (3), moving (3), backs (3), anthony (3), migchels (3), misinterprets (3), meter (3), kilo (3), easier (3), trend (3), fix (3), currently (3), standard (3), calls (3), targeting (3), path (3), ecb (3), policies (3), care (3), sad (3), idea (3), might (3), surge (3), another (3), separate (3), yet (3), 1965 (3), within (3), called (3), received (3), made (3), incorrect (3), percentage (3), lowering (3), prioritizing (3), arnold (3), 2010 (3), never (3), job (3), creation (3), pence (3), order (3), itself (3), employment (3), divide (3), multiply (3), goods (3), call (3), big (3), optimism (3), future (3), 1960s (3), third (3), presents (3), reduced (3), perhaps (3), incomes (3), calculating (3), face (3), raw (3), ida (3), built (3), laffer (3), casual (3), life (3), without (3), intending (3), purchase (3), talk (3), agents (3), action (3), circle (3), tim (3), saying (3), flatland (3), reducing (3), principal (3), useless (3), fire (3), hose (3), against (3), tsunami (3), recovery (3), encouraging (3), homeowners (3), china (3), combined (3), rome (3), ceos (3), links (3), roman (3), economist (3), gross (3), echoes (3), thayer (3), concept (3), arithmetic (3), smaller (3), funny (3), projected (3), patently (3), unremunerative (3), abandoned (3), timeline (3), 2016 (2), http (2), lead (2), older (2), newer (2), tomasson (2), american (2), institute (2), favor (2), structure (2), society (2), occurred (2), everyone (2), story (2), invented (2), come (2), questions (2), adam (2), labor (2), return (2), remarks (2), worldbank (2), asserts (2), ideal (2), normal (2), comparison (2), recently (2), george (2), loans (2), lose (2), through (2), success (2), fell (2), finally (2), midst (2), starts (2), ends (2), 1970 (2), subtracting (2), roughly (2), hence (2), rather (2), though (2), agree (2), reason (2), definition (2), commodity (2), backed (2), example (2), sense (2), bankers (2), supported (2), flat (2), mid (2), takes (2), macroeconomic (2), miracle (2), relatively (2), trouble (2), assuming (2), reliance (2), outcome (2), duplicate (2), guess (2), hidden (2), purple (2), apart (2), together (2), compare (2), 1987 (2), financialized (2), farther (2), markets (2), download (2), office (2), later (2), various (2), aaa (2), baa (2), begin (2), paint (2), picture (2), vertical (2), changed (2), definitely (2), closer (2), swing (2), striking (2), evaluate (2), weakens (2), thomas (2), collected (2), single (2), economies (2), hand (2), premia (2), default (2), independent (2), practice (2), yeah (2), bonds (2), rose (2), going (2), spread (2), argued (2), international (2), giving (2), solves (2), deflation (2), main (2), paying (2), bond (2), accounts (2), british (2), households (2), cash (2), helicopters (2), notes (2), unfortunately (2), modern (2), forgotten (2), slumps (2), anatole (2), quantitative (2), quantity (2), fairly (2), hard (2), gradual (2), separation (2), 1950s (2), peak (2), straight (2), prior (2), broaden (2), dramatically (2), simplify (2), efficient (2), lowers (2), sure (2), analyses (2), cycle (2), repayment (2), wanted (2), context (2), consistent (2), fill (2), horizontal (2), printing (2), mean (2), establish (2), carry (2), facts (2), thinks (2), however (2), comment (2), professor (2), course (2), tell (2), views (2), study (2), calling (2), university (2), doubting (2), quoted (2), resist (2), day (2), pushed (2), denominator (2), clearly (2), moments (2), grew (2), faster (2), isn (2), beating (2), dead (2), stop (2), someone (2), importance (2), topic (2), talking (2), gonna (2), parts (2), hands (2), identified (2), fixing (2), trying (2), grow (2), encourage (2), limiting (2), outside (2), ineffective (2), month (2), forget (2), jobs (2), happens (2), consider (2), often (2), answer (2), included (2), balance (2), technique (2), pull (2), stepping (2), separately (2), method (2), stuff (2), dramatic (2), beholder (2), 2000 (2), anything (2), remissions (2), arise (2), relaxed (2), policymakers (2), erode (2), significantly (2), burden (2), creating (2), yesterday (2), differences (2), nose (2), chin (2), eyes (2), cross (2), described (2), docs (2), spreadsheet (2), ada (2), ways (2), late (2), formula (2), location (2), reading (2), upon (2), error (2), correctly (2), premisses (2), incrementally (2), opposed (2), possibilities (2), rosion (2), took (2), arthur (2), nice (2), pages (2), except (2), bigger (2), correction (2), digit (2), rules (2), hurts (2), observed (2), produced (2), services (2), ruled (2), nobody (2), produces (2), raised (2), knows (2), 1829 (2), question (2), theory (2), excess (2), activity (2), joe (2), gagnon (2), initial (2), reaction (2), aggressive (2), taken (2), embrace (2), slides (2), living (2), argument (2), obvious (2), objective (2), willing (2), fiscal (2), specifics (2), conventional (2), weapon (2), induces (2), supposedly (2), try (2), stimulus (2), western (2), jackson (2), pollock (2), ain (2), became (2), others (2), mortgages (2), done (2), excuse (2), delaying (2), preventing (2), stance (2), regulator (2), mark (2), name (2), curse (2), emporium (2), imperial (2), revenues (2), corporations (2), evidence (2), she (2), estates (2), villas (2), owned (2), search (2), major (2), written (2), domestic (2), ancients (2), reviews (2), minimize (2), woke (2), morning (2), governments (2), account (2), reduces (2), adding (2), 110 (2), accumulated (2), pictures (2), celebrate (2), couldn (2), deliberately (2), faces (2), 2018 (2), loops (2), jerry (2), historical (2), banking (2), expectations (2), push (2), 2013 (2), dave (2), ross (2), image (2), translate (2), html (2), blogger (2), charts (2), venn (2), rights, reserved, courtesy, stlouisfed, fred2, water, drink, stay, thirsty, friends, subscribe, atom, home, wikipedia, arguing, sort, event, cave, men, exasperating, functions, design, coming, stupid, concerns, answers, easy, ask, liabilities, expand, include, distinguish, examine, expanded, figures, stat, nations, leading, decades, philip, breakdown, create, revise, sentence, essential, reached, began, thereafter, tries, succeeds, simpler, 1959, 1915, currency, kind, checks, lending, philipji, com, france, 152, kingdom, 171, netherlands, 226, 236, benchmark, guide, treasury, lbl, mqmy, selected, countries, published, 736, emerge, barter, individuals, tribes, religious, worship, sacrifice, mainstream, scholars, keith, hart, developed, distinction, believed, determines, controlled, traded, silver, artifact, whose, derived, legal, tender, laws, argues, proper, nature, lost, science, sharply, 90s, rocket, hiccups, breaks, tighter, gauge, indicates, depends, providing, follows, deregulation, play, role, competition, tried, selection, came, date, match, tb3ms, beyond, drop, eliminate, reorganize, columns, convenience, selecting, cell, ranges, figuring, averages, excel, monthly, comfortable, working, differ, corporate, 1934, mslb20, 1953q1, gs10, 1953q4, mortg, 1971q4, blank, copied, pasted, bar, thickness, several, bars, colors, windows, snipping, tool, got, expectation, holds, moved, sticky, near, 1946, downswing, immediately, responsive, reaches, 1940s, skills, contradict, competes, gage, philippon, versus, wow, ugly, macro, models, including, fond, feature, existence, waved, premium, expected, probability, borrower, depend, reasonably, whole, speaking, reasonable, hold, notice, heavy, black, wire, competitor, 1929, 28pp, norbert, wiley, aside, flows, news, farmer, 1920s, congruence, weber, excellent, helps, freeing, overhang, restore, vigorous, wildly, irresponsible, boe, traders, directing, fairer, effective, propping, financed, windfall, 500, man, woman, child, 375, billion, worth, head, distributed, sums, easily, transform, conditions, receiving, windfalls, decided, extra, save, debts, distributing, response, intractable, liquidity, traps, maynard, proposed, dropping, bills, suggested, burying, pound, chests, unemployed, workers, dig, misleading, assumptions, self, stabilizing, insights, students, deep, electronic, ditchdiggers, computer, imagination, courage, banks, reuters, parallel, wwii, veer, landed, outer, space, twice, wide, widening, pick, intact, sat, squarely, atop, accelerating, 1945, invariant, dropped, served, mostly, visual, mathematical, coincidences, staniford, catches, paragraphs, opening, apparently, mitchell, highlighting, behavior, damage, opposes, grounds, politicians, sky, strking, atrocious, limited, sounds, consistently, downhill, assume, individual, national, taxpayers, union, compound, pessimistic, generate, disincentive, fractions, compounds, drastic, reductions, wave, running, key, entire, currencies, provide, interests, compares, devalue, myself, impressed, clarity, strikes, convenient, obtuseness, hug, respect, preferences, stabilize, interprets, stability, forever, enforce, contracts, myths, okay, upset, evil, section, likes, regime, endorse, implemented, targeter, tight, pre, conclude, failed, keeping, depressed, afraid, massive, chicago, professors, continue, disregard, units, artfully, devaluing, give, shopkeepers, fooling, once, guessed, terrible, inconsistencies, yep, taxing, refer, foolishly, ending, starting, flattened, 1969, 1975, 1981, brief, cases, drove, moderate, ran, briefly, ever, slightly, 1998, glaring, highs, 1991, necessarily, slowed, improved, impression, slower, differently, confusing, sectors, stats, among, highest, chapter, writers, seem, inputs, process, whatsoever, macroeconomics, boring, insist, inconsequential, meaningless, place, anxiety, ennui, gentlemen, wages, listen, derivative, commodities, person, woj, factually, survival, societies, compatible, statement, civilizations, die, suicide, cnn, annalyn, censky, keeps, stimulate, blossom, hokum, hogwash, focused, cut, saving, borrow, business, sorts, fiddle, 1800s, busies, eventually, circulates, insufficient, support, hell, tasked, outlines, goals, maximize, critics, sick, tired, juggling, act, promoting, staving, proven, led, cheap, dangerous, consequences, house, bill, introduced, seeks, goal, focusing, leave, republicans, reviewing, article, typical, converts, basket, 125, includes, relevant, remaining, harp, works, measure, considered, sees, lies, heart, continuing, 1952, reflects, peoples, prospects, observe, felt, 60s, bright, anymore, indebtedness, reports, followed, ages, severe, asks, joshua, responds, chop, attribute, describe, lays, scenario, explaining, troubles, contrast, glance, misses, detail, luck, neatly, missed, ruckus, days, possibly, overlooked, numerator, cancel, related, microbes, allan, meltzer, compared, increasing, necessary, cover, previous, actions, drag, yours, truly, downloaded, quarterly, neck, indications, hair, conversion, learn, ability, despite, 1950, eroded, applied, entirely, stopped, identical, multiplied, convert, 993, gdpdef, absolutely, resulting, absurd, certainly, ignored, seemingly, accurate, deeply, flawed, ignores, pretends, marcus, builds, plausible, explain, laid, being, superstructure, erected, logical, consistency, lack, clearness, generality, happened, equals, earlier, forehead, expressed, erodes, visualize, suggests, visible, brad, leaving, secretarial, summary, reminds, quote, choose, hugely, physics, nick, rowe, texts, 900, hundred, seven, shot, precisely, coordinated, produce, message, hari, seldon, treat, hurt, saves, safe, plenty, recurs, serious, choice, able, decent, options, dammit, intrinsically, insignificant, exerts, distinct, influence, own, sensible, active, metaphysical, necessity, malthus, complained, ricardo, doctrine, seemed, fit, theoretical, resolution, definitively, resolved, stuart, leverage, booms, decreases, quotes, peterson, considering, relying, accepting, shudderingly, hey, arrows, arrow, discussions, ought, flatlanders, somewhere, dragged, feet, resisted, majority, committee, projects, assign, weight, accept, modestly, guest, benjamin, cole, accepted, usual, substitute, cuts, chatter, generalities, alternatives, diversionary, tactic, loss, needed, stick, wander, accurately, refinancing, frees, spent, improves, supposed, improve, become, forgiveness, writedowns, badly, historinhas, nor, inventive, clever, 5do, random, regulating, deregulating, inflating, deflating, list, tanked, sudden, deleveraging, rage, fast, possible, prevent, needs, arena, moral, hazard, allowing, damned, holier, thou, son, bitch, record, moralistic, prick, heroic, horrific, overseeing, fannie, mae, freddie, mac, blocked, obama, administration, companies, forgive, mortgage, owed, stressed, million, helped, writedown, incorrectly, helping, joseph, stiglitz, zandi, michael, wood, wealthy, romans, escaping, decadent, declining, haven, stash, exceeds, executive, ceo, eating, organism, concentrate, governing, aristocracy, expense, mass, population, concrete, survives, accretion, power, landowner, latin, lady, valerii, christian, church, recorded, disposal, charity, 404, melania, freed, 8000, slaves, sixty, farms, hamlets, vicinity, landholdings, elsewhere, italy, sicily, africa, spain, rentals, archaeology, fourth, centuries, southern, domesday, roots, cited, wealthiest, stashed, offshore, havens, estimate, london, justice, network, former, chief, mckinsey, range, product, hours, adjusts, robert, peter, authors, san, josé, department, techniques, agenda, driven, arguments, bed, meanwhile, happy, heilbron, equation, dividing, index, corrections, conceptual, innovation, deducting, agencies, net, budgets, usually, surplus, offsets, false, alarms, measuring, cheat, making, nine, bringing, accumulate, noted, significance, minds, check, rigorously, previously, intuitively, ruminate, latest, subtract, shrink, shrinking, dollars, themselves, owe, shoulda, rectangle, pile, cbo, velocity, 1869, astounded, density, 1930s, 3036, nber, macrohistory, fat, pita, adams, advertisement, school, desperately, advertise, deny, couple, personal, favorites, fax, machine, microwave, oven, phones, everywhere, bothered, phone, under, survive, trumps, abridgement, somervell, 255, 256, feasible, profitable, stage, encounter, social, obstacles, yield, diminishing, returns, abandonment, roads, europe, technologies, credits, photo, jeff, zelevansky, getty, images, mpra, 40696, forbes, copyright, shipman, zoho, withering, shoots, waste, fraud, abuse
Text of the page (random words):
osted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 7 comments labels erosion of debt tuesday august 14 2012 the problem is not the dual mandate reviewing an old article from cnn money republicans to fed forget about jobs by annalyn censky 3 december 2010 for more than 30 years the fed has been tasked with a so called dual mandate which outlines two important goals keep prices stable and maximize u s employment but some critics are sick and tired of the fed prioritizing job creation at the risk of rising prices they say the juggling act of promoting economic growth while staving off inflation has proven ineffective and has led to a policy of too much cheap money with dangerous consequences for the economy a house bill introduced last month by pence seeks to scale the dual mandate back to a single goal of focusing only on prices and leave job creation policy up to congress you know congress never keeps its hands off job creation policy they re always spending more to stimulate the economy or spending less to let the private sector blossom it s all hokum and hogwash anyway pence is focused on the wrong thing he has not identified the problem he has identified a problem but if you re not fixing the problem then you are just trying to fix results and that ll never work the problem is excessive debt here s what congress does to grow the economy they cut taxes assuming that people will spend more as a result they encourage saving so that we may borrow more and spend it they encourage spending by means of the business tax code to grow the economy congress does all sorts of things to cause spending to increase here s what the fed does they fiddle with interest rates and the quantity of money in order to control inflation they limit the amount of money that is in the economy think of it like in the 1800s when we used gold for money the fed is limiting the amount of gold we have to spend while congress busies itself doing things to make us spend more more spending less money so we use credit so our financial costs increase so eventually the money that circulates outside the financial sector becomes insufficient to support both the productive sector and the financial sector that s when you get a crisis so what the hell is pence talking about posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 0 comments monday august 13 2012 when finance grows large it circumvents and weakens policy note well the title of this post it is not just a point of view it is a view about the survival of societies it is a view compatible with arnold toynbee s statement that civilizations die by suicide posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 0 comments sunday august 12 2012 prioritizing in a comment on scott sumner s debt surges don t cause recessions sumner wrote woj you said as the aggregate amount of debt and interest rises the percentage of income used to pay interest costs or pay down debt also rises lowering the amount available for consumption investment this is simply factually wrong every debt payment is money received by someone else let s put it a little differently then let s stop confusing the financial sector with the productive sector let s look at them like two different sectors of the economy you know the same way the stats are presented all the time as the aggregate amount of debt and interest rises the percentage of productive sector income used to pay interest costs and pay down debt also rises lowering the amount available for consumption and investment in the productive sector it does not matter that every debt payment is money received by someone else it would not matter even if every debt payment was received by the same person who made the payment what matters is that the money is moving out of the productive sector and into finance that is the problem among economists mind you productivity is said to be of the highest importance i go back again and again to adam smith and his factors of production though i do not think he called them that smith looked at the component parts of the price of commodities he thought the topic important enough not only to write about but to use in the title of the chapter where he wrote it modern economists or textbook writers at least seem to think the factors of production are all about the inputs to the production process that is incorrect or if not incorrect it is of no importance whatsoever to macroeconomics why economics seems boring economists insist on talking about inconsequential and meaningless things in place of math anxiety there is economics ennui the issue is the component parts of price the issue gentlemen is cost as the aggregate amount of debt and interest increases the cost of finance rises in the productive sector as smith put it the interest of money is always a derivative revenue which if it is not paid from the profit which is made by the use of the money must be paid from some other source of revenue the cost of finance if not paid out of profit comes out of wages now who ya gonna listen to sumner or smith posted by the arthurian at 12 00 pm 3 comments labels factors beating the dead horse again we looked at household debt the other day relative to gdp that s krugman s graph used by sumner and nunes and me sumner foolishly said it shows one debt surge ending in 1964 and another starting in 1984 i say that between 1964 and 1984 the great inflation pushed the denominator up and flattened the curve let us look at that let s us separate out cmdebt and gdp as two separate lines and compare their growth rates graph 2 growth rates of household debt blue and gdp red click for fred source page at the very start the red line is high but the blue line didn t even start yet and at the end the red line is higher than the blue but the blue line is down because of the crisis other than that there are only four times that the red line is clearly above the blue line around 1965 and 1969 and again around 1975 and 1981 that s it for those four brief moments gdp grew faster than household debt all four of those moments are within the period called the great inflation in all four cases gdp grew faster than household debt because inflation drove prices up so the dollar value of gdp went up it was not so much that output increased but the rising price of output pushed the red line above the blue at all other times with inflation more moderate gdp growth ran lower than the growth of household debt oh oh oh there is something else after the 1990 recession the red line rose briefly above the blue and again ever so slightly maybe around 1998 but you know what those two glaring highs of gdp growth both fall within sumner s second golden age 1991 2007 so again it isn t necessarily that debt growth slowed but that actual improved real growth gives the impression of slower debt growth posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 3 comments saturday august 11 2012 how can i resist two from cochrane i quoted him here tax consumption not savings and i quoted him here most economic analyses don t look at the long run growth effects of tax distortions yep like taxing consumption but not savings i refer you to my recent remarks on savings posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 3 comments friday august 10 2012 doubting lars in a look at cochrane s inconsistencies lars christensen writes cochrane seems to be very upset about the calls for easier monetary policy in the euro zone here is cochrane as you might have guessed i think it s a terrible idea hence cochrane thinks easier monetary policy is very evil however in the in the comment section cochrane states the following i like a price level target i view money as a set of units for value and i don t think the government artfully devaluing the meter and kilo to give shopkeepers a boost is a good idea any more than fooling with inflation to do so even if it does work at least once anyway note that cochrane says he likes a price level targeting regime fine with me then why not endorse price level targeting for the euro zone professor cochrane the graph below shows the euro zone gdp deflator and a 2 trend path for prices the 2 path is of course what the ecb would be targeting if it implemented a price level target as supported by cochrane now have a look at the graph again and tell me what the ecb should do now if it was a price level targeter the graph is very clear monetary policy is far too tight in the euro zone and as a result the actual price level is far below the pre crisis 2 path level if professor cochrane was consistent in his views then he would obviously conclude that the ecb s failed monetary policies are keeping the euro zone price level depressed but i am afraid he did not even care to study the numbers cochrane should obviously be calling for massive monetary easing in the euro zone milton friedman would do so i can only again say how sad it is that the university of chicago professors continue to disregard the economics of milton friedman the excerpt is a bit long but i wanted to provide context for the bit of it that interests me lars christensen misinterprets cochrane and then says cochrane is not consistent cochrane compares the price level to the meter and the kilo and says it is wrong to devalue any of them cochrane does not say 2 inflation is okay cochrane wants prices as stable as the meter and the kilo myself i m impressed by cochrane s clarity but christensen doesn t see it strikes me as convenient obtuseness on christensen s part christensen wants easier money if i have it right there is a gap between the euro zone deflator and the 2 trend line and christensen wants to fill that gap with money that s a simplistic solution cochrane doesn t want the deflator to hug the 2 line he wants it horizontal i respect that cochrane has clear preferences in myths and facts about the gold standard he said the fed currently interprets price stability to mean 2 inflation forever a cpi standard could enforce 2 inflation but why not establish a price level target instead the cpi could be the same 30 years from now as it is today and long term contracts could carry no inflation risk the cpi could be the same 30 years from now as it is today cochrane says you know what that is it s a horizontal deflator it s not a 2 line christensen misinterprets yes if we don t fill the graph with money like christensen wants if we stabilize prices at zero inflation then we have to do something else we have to do something other than printing more money to fix the economy that s what this blog is about posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 0 comments thursday august 9 2012 anthony migchels it matters what we pay for the money anthony migchels at real currencies it matters not what we use as money it matters not what backs the money it matters what we pay for the money exactly i think maybe at some point on the long wave or at some point on the cycle of civilization it does matter what backs the money or maybe even just when the economy is running really well it matters what backs the money but now now the trouble is the excessive reliance on credit and it is a problem because of the cost of it cost and repayment so what we pay for the money is most definitely the key thing today today and during the entire great financialization posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 0 comments wednesday august 8 2012 the libertarian dilemma again from cochrane s january post i m almost as pessimistic as dan sure raising tax rates can generate more revenue for a few years but most economic analyses don t look at the long run growth effects of tax distortions the full disincentive effects don t show up for years if taxes just lower growth a few fractions of a percent that soon compounds to drastic reductions in income and tax revenue raising tax rates lowers growth over the long term sounds right right well here s u s economic growth since the end of world war ii graph 1 a 21 year moving compound annual growth rate growth has been consistently downhill so we can assume this has something to do with tax rates going up graph 2 top and bottom individual income tax rates source national taxpayers union hard to say posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 2 comments tuesday august 7 2012 cochrane the vat a libertarian dilemma from january an efficient tax code can also raise a lot more revenue dan opposes the vat and similar consumption taxes on that grounds yes it looks good to start but politicians will soon raise the rate to the sky and spend the results it s a strking dilemma should we keep an atrocious tax system to limit the size of government is there no way to get an efficient tax system and a limited government catches the eye no no my eye is on the prior paragraphs the opening of cochrane s post dan mitchell wrote an interesting op ed in the wall street journal highlighting a great libertarian dilemma is a consumption tax vat or similar a good thing every bit of economic analysis says yes economists hate distortions taxes that lead to bad economic behavior our tax system is full of them broaden the base lower the rate tax consumption not savings dramatically simplify the code and you can get the same revenue with much less economic damage dan and cochrane both apparently think it would be good to broaden the base lower the rate tax consumption not savings dramatically simplify the tax code tax consumption not savings no read more posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 2 comments monday august 6 2012 on a log scale the quantity of base money and the cpi run fairly parallel from wwii to 1982 then veer apart graph 1 prices and base money you could have just now landed from outer space and you could still see that there was a significant change a significant policy change probably around 1982 as staniford said it s hard to read changes in small growth rates on a log graph still i think i see a gradual separation of the red and blue lines before 1982 in particular the gap in the 1970s is twice as wide as in the 1950s and there is even more of a widening after 2007 if you could pick up the blue line intact and move it until its little 1921 peak sat squarely atop the 1921 peak of the red line you would see a similar gradual but accelerating separation of the lines from 1921 to 1945 now base money and the rate of inflation graph 2 base money and the inflation rate there is pretty much a straight line increase from 1970 to 1990 on the blue line if not longer and right in the middle of that invariant increase inflation dropped away it s almost like before 1982 the blue line served as a bottom for the red line and then after 1982 not this one is mostly just all visual effects and mathematical coincidences i think posted by the arthurian at 4 00 am 0 comments sunday august 5 2012 anatole kaletsky how about quantitative easing for the people excellent at reuters kaletsky writes giving away free money may sound too good to be true or wildly irresponsible but it is exactly what the fed and the boe have been doing for bond traders and bankers since 2009 directing q...
|
