Meta tags:
description=Chaco Canyon, Its World, and Ours;

Headings (most frequently used words):

the, virgin, soil, widowed, land, chaco, of, gambler, house, canyon, its, world, and, ours, guest, post, becoming, white, clay, return, light, mapping, arctic, sky, madison, buffalo, jump, another, solstice, further, thoughts, on, africa, eclipse, dating, la, cieneguilla, petroglyph, site, curious, african, counterpoint, high, count, hegemony, archives, categories, pages, archaeologists, blogroll, chacoan, sites, departments, institutes, journals, modern, pueblos, museums, newspapers, organizations, people, publishers, resources, meta,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (1028), and (352), that (166), this (127), was (111), for (102), but (86), with (83), which (68), were (61), from (57), not (49), have (48), some (45), there (45), are (45), #africa (42), very (41), his (39), most (36), these (35), dobyns (35), they (34), other (33), new (32), had (32), their (31), well (31), history (30), its (30), about (29), one (29), into (29), trade (28), more (28), plains (28), research (27), been (27), archaeological (26), may (26), also (26), population (26), apache (26), pueblo (23), out (23), who (23), period (22), december (22), many (22), would (22), jicarilla (22), people (21), world (21), spanish (21), americas (21), native (21), few (21), chaco (20), university (20), much (20), contact (20), populations (20), time (20), two (20), both (20), european (20), june (19), them (19), disease (19), african (19), now (18), arizona (18), solstice (18), american (18), book (18), century (18), important (18), just (18), part (17), only (17), still (17), slave (17), like (16), archaeology (16), northern (16), point (16), interesting (16), apachean (16), land (15), today (15), post (15), 2014 (15), depopulation (15), than (15), did (15), though (15), led (15), those (15), early (15), years (15), small (15), eiselt (15), site (14), blog (14), petroglyphs (14), museum (14), what (14), probably (14), all (14), course (14), any (14), while (14), especially (14), over (14), groups (14), society (13), past (13), anthropology (13), 2012 (13), however (13), paper (13), article (13), used (13), same (13), own (13), even (13), how (13), when (13), has (13), here (13), first (13), white (13), interest (13), you (13), colonies (13), athabascan (13), mexico (12), high (12), cultural (12), far (12), reading (12), rio (12), 2009 (12), february (12), april (12), 2010 (12), 2011 (12), 2013 (12), 2015 (12), 2016 (12), 2017 (12), 2018 (12), quite (12), between (12), within (12), group (12), known (12), parts (12), then (12), winter (12), buffalo (12), bison (12), ancestors (12), get (11), comments (11), southwest (11), south (11), times (11), national (11), sites (11), alaska (11), west (11), january (11), march (11), october (11), europeans (11), southern (11), went (11), area (11), way (11), generally (11), british (11), slaves (11), house (10), project (10), historical (10), navajo (10), modern (10), july (10), august (10), september (10), november (10), posted (10), large (10), including (10), whole (10), among (10), chapter (10), teofilo (10), societies (10), seems (10), grande (10), style (10), sky (10), dene (10), use (9), journal (9), park (9), study (9), clear (9), subsequent (9), colonial (9), region (9), before (9), epidemic (9), concept (9), ways (9), particular (9), several (9), can (9), likely (9), story (9), sense (9), colonization (9), main (9), interested (9), where (9), across (9), rock (8), center (8), studies (8), indigenous (8), north (8), virgin (8), soil (8), environment (8), ideas (8), during (8), estimates (8), coming (8), various (8), political (8), further (8), cook (8), earlier (8), itself (8), hemisphere (8), work (8), fact (8), tradition (8), old (8), long (8), cieneguilla (8), themselves (8), territory (8), rather (8), yahdii (8), system (8), migration (8), enclave (8), sign (7), gambler (7), free (7), canyon (7), field (7), culture (7), wide (7), western (7), hunting (7), widowed (7), series (7), archaeoastronomy (7), east (7), continued (7), demographic (7), published (7), specific (7), regions (7), demography (7), made (7), again (7), does (7), seem (7), direct (7), ratio (7), detailed (7), didn (7), through (7), recently (7), major (7), scholars (7), numbers (7), could (7), after (7), end (7), being (7), ended (7), say (7), traditional (7), focus (7), centuries (7), different (7), often (7), common (7), due (7), don (7), lot (7), astronomical (7), escarpment (7), trail (7), basic (7), portuguese (7), europe (7), diseases (7), lived (7), pathogens (7), children (7), constellation (7), named (7), ollero (7), vecino (7), sun (6), colorado (6), utah (6), press (6), art (6), state (6), taos (6), eastern (6), indeed (6), kin (6), elsewhere (6), 2024 (6), 2025 (6), perhaps (6), largely (6), associated (6), cases (6), total (6), estimate (6), significant (6), took (6), variety (6), mostly (6), form (6), prehistoric (6), nineteenth (6), current (6), analysis (6), areas (6), oral (6), issue (6), throughout (6), later (6), epidemics (6), exchange (6), along (6), back (6), introduced (6), around (6), social (6), close (6), really (6), highly (6), scholarship (6), human (6), others (6), previous (6), understanding (6), complicated (6), ones (6), background (6), place (6), clearly (6), complex (6), curtin (6), coast (6), vast (6), something (6), recent (6), evidence (6), happy (6), thought (6), top (6), take (6), came (6), eclipse (6), knowledge (6), presence (6), think (6), written (6), madison (6), note (6), term (6), languages (6), record (6), wordpress (5), com (5), name (5), comment (5), account (5), traditions (5), down (5), association (5), america (5), albuquerque (5), santa (5), independent (5), natural (5), san (5), list (5), older (5), posts (5), methodology (5), count (5), mooney (5), difference (5), data (5), smith (5), interior (5), larger (5), points (5), particularly (5), disciplines (5), berkeley (5), year (5), central (5), come (5), relatively (5), doesn (5), beyond (5), provide (5), single (5), second (5), attention (5), infection (5), majority (5), widely (5), influential (5), developed (5), declines (5), turn (5), question (5), impact (5), obvious (5), mixed (5), extensive (5), key (5), followed (5), states (5), saw (5), figures (5), trying (5), slavery (5), pretty (5), see (5), doing (5), type (5), little (5), mentioned (5), goes (5), either (5), case (5), instead (5), kind (5), another (5), experience (5), river (5), off (5), wave (5), entirely (5), countries (5), peoples (5), immunity (5), transatlantic (5), dutch (5), relationship (5), caribbean (5), jump (5), montana (5), cliff (5), summer (5), athabascans (5), cannon (5), describes (5), blackfoot (5), she (5), moiety (5), ancestral (5), started (4), collapse (4), view (4), home (4), archaeologists (4), indian (4), zuni (4), del (4), pueblos (4), anthropological (4), school (4), edge (4), monument (4), stone (4), middle (4), connections (4), building (4), great (4), 2023 (4), fairly (4), noted (4), topic (4), available (4), accounts (4), notes (4), coastal (4), overall (4), implications (4), precontact (4), documented (4), suggests (4), dynamics (4), additional (4), low (4), influence (4), crosby (4), decades (4), general (4), argument (4), plausible (4), possible (4), began (4), interpretive (4), cause (4), called (4), limited (4), academic (4), present (4), figure (4), next (4), although (4), colonialism (4), settler (4), why (4), hard (4), lower (4), able (4), unlike (4), since (4), information (4), lost (4), found (4), fascinating (4), anchorage (4), alignments (4), petroglyph (4), look (4), alignment (4), result (4), panels (4), find (4), horizon (4), date (4), boulder (4), fields (4), relative (4), direction (4), occurred (4), turned (4), includes (4), miles (4), fifteenth (4), reason (4), eclipses (4), americans (4), path (4), idea (4), enough (4), component (4), picture (4), under (4), third (4), powers (4), establish (4), french (4), islands (4), need (4), toward (4), enclaves (4), newcomers (4), black (4), permanent (4), forts (4), good (4), brazil (4), endemic (4), once (4), makes (4), settlement (4), active (4), jumps (4), three (4), check (4), family (4), speaking (4), forest (4), division (4), gwich (4), historic (4), camps (4), enclavement (4), clay (4), review (4), reader (3), log (3), create (3), plateau (3), anasazi (3), paul (3), digging (3), council (3), springs (3), hopi (3), news (3), daily (3), smithsonian (3), heritage (3), pottery (3), antiquity (3), cedars (3), aztec (3), religion (3), follow (3), tours (3), papers (3), valley (3), casa (3), near (3), consequences (3), books (3), 2019 (3), 2020 (3), 2022 (3), event (3), focused (3), expanded (3), role (3), hegemony (3), number (3), skeptical (3), carried (3), legacy (3), worked (3), tribes (3), higher (3), hemispheric (3), petersen (3), takes (3), methods (3), regard (3), catastrophic (3), kroeber (3), andes (3), contemporary (3), response (3), terms (3), counters (3), following (3), set (3), necessarily (3), considered (3), positive (3), concentrated (3), certain (3), historian (3), smallpox (3), accompanied (3), spread (3), empire (3), example (3), discussed (3), fit (3), awareness (3), 1960s (3), going (3), days (3), hundred (3), similar (3), regional (3), publications (3), typically (3), combination (3), innovative (3), quantitative (3), eventually (3), california (3), range (3), flaws (3), making (3), ultimately (3), emphasize (3), aboriginal (3), magnitude (3), face (3), extended (3), vector (3), natives (3), counter (3), importance (3), detail (3), peru (3), scholarly (3), era (3), least (3), questions (3), side (3), debate (3), intellectual (3), approach (3), defined (3), managed (3), continent (3), scale (3), places (3), rest (3), interests (3), fall (3), bit (3), atlantic (3), economic (3), somewhat (3), less (3), extent (3), effects (3), abolitionists (3), ever (3), starting (3), massive (3), accurate (3), looking (3), said (3), briefly (3), topics (3), sources (3), working (3), continuing (3), became (3), might (3), trait (3), classic (3), pattern (3), sunrise (3), hills (3), solar (3), must (3), images (3), actually (3), trails (3), left (3), continues (3), turns (3), right (3), easier (3), visited (3), finally (3), got (3), semi (3), wasn (3), entrance (3), anniversary (3), articles (3), soon (3), preserved (3), totality (3), having (3), involved (3), paths (3), happen (3), dating (3), epidemiology (3), environments (3), asia (3), importantly (3), conquest (3), tropical (3), control (3), immense (3), benefited (3), canada (3), yet (3), such (3), projects (3), neither (3), believed (3), visiting (3), traders (3), seventeenth (3), initially (3), sugar (3), basin (3), introduction (3), allowed (3), devastating (3), women (3), encounters (3), will (3), phase (3), bozeman (3), recommend (3), ridge (3), day (3), exit (3), agricultural (3), ago (3), artifacts (3), town (3), body (3), language (3), stars (3), elders (3), night (3), newgrange (3), light (3), ireland (3), trip (3), inside (3), based (3), identity (3), corn (3), seasonal (3), nor (3), dwell (3), tribe (3), describing (3), essential (3), live (3), structures (3), linguistic (3), arrived (3), split (3), kiowa (3), dismal (3), shifting (3), changes (3), neighbors (3), therefore (3), boreal (3), phenomenon (3), surrounded (3), resident (3), guest (3), website (2), write (2), manage (2), report (2), content (2), subscribed (2), subscribe (2), already (2), meta (2), travels (2), professional (2), alliance (2), observer (2), country (2), denver (2), republic (2), institution (2), juan (2), science (2), fort (2), salmon (2), ruins (2), lowry (2), guadalupe (2), escalante (2), chimney (2), casamero (2), bluff (2), pages (2), per (2), mile (2), legal (2), four (2), corners (2), remote (2), stephen (2), david (2), disclaimer (2), virtual (2), touring (2), agriculture (2), subsistence (2), introducing (2), aftermath (2), physical (2), linguistics (2), geology (2), ethnohistory (2), ethnography (2), reference (2), mesa (2), puerco (2), origins (2), fauna (2), wood (2), shell (2), ground (2), bone (2), material (2), lessons (2), protection (2), management (2), alto (2), downtown (2), mounds (2), built (2), 2026 (2), archives (2), bring (2), forcefully (2), ironically (2), publication (2), 1983 (2), him (2), reached (2), breaking (2), become (2), anthropologists (2), included (2), 1976 (2), below (2), implies (2), million (2), handbook (2), indians (2), notable (2), william (2), widespread (2), noting (2), loss (2), wake (2), certainly (2), giving (2), differences (2), position (2), explain (2), himself (2), convincing (2), mild (2), criticism (2), considerable (2), underlying (2), ratios (2), opposed (2), should (2), census (2), seen (2), rapidly (2), fire (2), medical (2), wrote (2), too (2), numerous (2), looked (2), 1970s (2), reach (2), encountered (2), conclusions (2), dramatic (2), groundbreaking (2), contributed (2), increasing (2), increasingly (2), counts (2), pioneering (2), obscure (2), audience (2), sent (2), thinking (2), techniques (2), mid (2), starts (2), defining (2), given (2), looks (2), tool (2), derive (2), reasonable (2), using (2), 000 (2), avoid (2), make (2), continue (2), factors (2), processes (2), mortality (2), non (2), maintain (2), constant (2), reported (2), caused (2), inevitably (2), consists (2), addition (2), factor (2), ignored (2), researchers (2), partial (2), cited (2), aspects (2), 1966 (2), born (2), against (2), cornell (2), records (2), develop (2), behind (2), enormously (2), heart (2), personally (2), simple (2), stood (2), flaw (2), context (2), potential (2), parallel (2), beginning (2), investigated (2), henry (2), subject (2), circles (2), leave (2), comparisons (2), divided (2), overwhelmingly (2), situation (2), maintaining (2), dominated (2), significantly (2), ancestry (2), suggest (2), impacts (2), existence (2), tended (2), increased (2), exact (2), shifted (2), literature (2), read (2), exaggerated (2), formed (2), evaluate (2), rigorous (2), whatever (2), sort (2), americanists (2), leading (2), forming (2), crucial (2), huge (2), short (2), periods (2), enormous (2), source (2), concluded (2), otherwise (2), decline (2), text (2), discuss (2), share (2), struck (2), curious (2), worth (2), visit (2), because (2), influx (2), developmental (2), coalition (2), call (2), thoughts (2), stylistic (2), intriguing (2), residents (2), usually (2), verde (2), equinox (2), elaborate (2), anything (2), station (2), clustering (2), mountains (2), occasion (2), pointed (2), cover (2), distinction (2), concentration (2), front (2), late (2), jornada (2), similarly (2), commonly (2), directions (2), locations (2), leads (2), boulders (2), isn (2), entire (2), leaving (2), finding (2), actual (2), aspect (2), cool (2), stuff (2), conceptual (2), couldn (2), 1965 (2), learned (2), basically (2), passed (2), ethnic (2), kingdoms (2), names (2), maps (2), 1968 (2), visible (2), connected (2), racial (2), sure (2), rise (2), assumption (2), progressive (2), nation (2), real (2), begins (2), true (2), antipodes (2), happened (2), failed (2), efforts (2), examples (2), colonized (2), 100 (2), destiny (2), decided (2), primitive (2), worlds (2), conquer (2), remaining (2), pacific (2), mainland (2), helped (2), intended (2), multiple (2), gotten (2), oriented (2), progress (2), lesser (2), obviously (2), initial (2), process (2), death (2), rates (2), slightly (2), colony (2), populated (2), intercept (2), illegal (2), despite (2), personal (2), gold (2), established (2), maintained (2), until (2), shortly (2), cape (2), hope (2), hands (2), cuba (2), internal (2), labor (2), grown (2), productive (2), quickly (2), previously (2), answer (2), details (2), allow (2), replace (2), developing (2), famously (2), above (2), childhood (2), lack (2), appear (2), adults (2), devastated (2), traced (2), cortes (2), epidemiological (2), survived (2), outbreaks (2), explorers (2), unlikely (2), anyone (2), sixteenth (2), mean (2), lots (2), sometimes (2), dig (2), everywhere (2), spectacular (2), collapses (2), almost (2), difficult (2), isolated (2), millennia (2), identifying (2), replaced (2), brief (2), deep (2), comparison (2), want (2), meat (2), restaurant (2), shouldn (2), loops (2), viewpoint (2), serious (2), hiking (2), boots (2), rim (2), steep (2), fine (2), follows (2), drive (2), logan (2), consisting (2), herds (2), horses (2), nearby (2), currently (2), figured (2), astronomy (2), branch (2), theme (2), authors (2), cross (2), apparently (2), loanword (2), ancient (2), dark (2), dena (2), ina (2), darkness (2), possibility (2), relationships (2), trust (2), herbert (2), described (2), arctic (2), conceived (2), big (2), dipper (2), gradually (2), york (2), mention (2), famous (2), chamber (2), myself (2), northeastern (2), lipan (2), goods (2), settlements (2), recapitulated (2), identify (2), principal (2), produced (2), each (2), bands (2), comprised (2), sedentary (2), section (2), divisions (2), uplands (2), llanero (2), farming (2), hunted (2), members (2), intermarriage (2), marriage (2), matrilineal (2), matrilocal (2), mother (2), folklore (2), reflect (2), landscape (2), her (2), sees (2), practice (2), meaning (2), element (2), familiar (2), residence (2), comanche (2), replacement (2), entered (2), indirect (2), revolt (2), products (2), readers (2), interactions (2), frequently (2), uses (2), instance (2), former (2), living (2), distinct (2), moved (2), southward (2), delightfully (2), kinship (2), chi (2), critical (2), connects (2), prompted (2), existed (2), culturally (2), sociological (2), refers (2), rendered (2), invisible (2), author (2), themes (2), becoming (2), longtime (2), fellow (2), aki (2), ivan (2), ours (2), design, email, loading, bar, subscriptions, privacy, join, 153, subscribers, wpthemes, xfn, valid, xhtml, crossroads, sipapu, evaluating, models, stratigraphy, page, archive, archnet, adventure, aluaki, resources, sar, altamira, publishers, smokeythepig, patrick, rené, moonspiral, joeguy, ambs, amsam, statewide, institute, conservancy, organizations, mexican, salt, lake, tribune, pagosa, moab, gallup, farmington, durango, herald, deseret, cortez, star, newspapers, poeh, maxwell, harvard, peabody, haak, collection, shiwi, wan, museums, zia, ysleta, sur, tesuque, santo, domingo, clara, ana, sandia, ildefonso, felipe, pojoaque, picuris, nambe, laguna, jemez, isleta, cochiti, acoma, kiva, palacio, journals, sri, foundation, advanced, office, laboratory, tree, ring, crow, institutes, washington, virginia, delaware, lewis, college, binghamton, departments, yucca, twin, angels, dittert, chelly, chacoan, urban, digs, voice, young, elk, theoretical, structural, archaeo, saving, antiquities, everyone, publishing, powered, osteons, portable, collecting, issues, square, ohio, savagery, memories, looting, matters, towns, jfleck, inkstain, jaunting, jen, illicit, property, genealogy, hikes, energy, digitally, collide, scape, calixtlahuaca, blackwater, locality, archaeopop, archaeolog, archaeoblog, anthroslug, put, upon, net, stories, alunsalt, wilderness, blogroll, wolky, toll, tom, windes, plog, lekson, ruth, van, dyke, reed, patricia, crown, nancy, akins, keith, kintigh, kathy, durand, john, kantner, joan, mathien, jill, neitzel, dean, saitta, wilcox, stuart, chip, wills, charles, riggs, catherine, cameron, ben, nelson, barbara, mills, andrew, duff, uncategorized, faq, gathering, tracing, ambiguous, fuel, foreshadow, atlatls, bows, 268, palynology, paleoclimatology, ethnobotany, dendrochronology, 178, archaeoacoustics, totah, slope, blue, red, sanders, chambers, allentown, carhart, village, kivas, cibola, skunk, newcomb, chuska, pintado, klizhin, bineola, halo, outliers, weather, hydrology, flora, textiles, ornaments, chipped, tools, basketry, 182, salvage, preservation, resource, 115, wijiji, una, vida, peñasco, blanco, nahasbas, hungo, pavi, chiquita, suburban, tsin, kletzin, arroyo, bonito, kletso, chetro, ketl, rinconada, roads, landscaping, irrigation, architecture, murals, categories, 2008, 2021, quibbles, minor, timucuan, florida, served, vehicle, promote, revised, thinned, historians, geographers, holdouts, directly, douglas, ubelaker, editing, updated, responsible, updates, original, version, submitted, approximately, double, interim, discipline, strikingly, absent, surprisingly, reasons, demographer, astonishing, display, saying, quiet, loud, aim, interpretations, prehistory, slim, estimating, parameters, admits, losses, agree, credence, clarification, maintains, positing, analogizes, mound, builder, legends, midwestern, pontifical, perambulation, attempts, refute, accusation, opponents, liberal, capitalism, invests, stock, market, admires, companies, substance, polemical, tone, foreshadows, reactions, criticisms, 1975, andeanist, 1970, geographer, denevan, truly, average, conceals, variation, determining, markedly, combining, reduces, merely, separately, refine, dissenting, voices, eclipsed, disappear, caught, sorts, innumerable, wilbur, jacobs, whom, treatment, vantage, geography, heyday, refined, arguments, overview, bolstered, alfred, documenting, conquistadors, andean, ahead, inca, killing, emperor, fatally, weakening, concrete, expand, 1972, outlining, specifics, columbian, plight, tumult, strong, advocate, rights, claim, implicitly, successful, lose, mood, conclusion, striking, colleague, woodrow, borah, totally, expansion, brought, flagship, garnered, occasional, reservations, bold, seemingly, tendencies, sciences, comparing, concerned, hit, nadir, grow, justify, endpoints, generalizability, derived, amazon, piman, speakers, sonora, derives, satisfaction, sound, conservative, employ, minimum, considers, alternative, nadirs, comes, aggregate, 043, 112, 553, 750, estimated, 400, showing, underestimation, attempted, devise, sounder, basis, assumptions, leaps, lead, methodological, career, demonstrated, operation, ecology, showed, resistant, biological, tribal, immediate, decimation, californians, missionized, outward, agent, intrusive, carriers, necessary, fundamental, trends, interpretation, ignores, tremendous, underestimates, size, populace, thorough, methodologies, pre, convincingly, demonstrates, underestimated, disregarding, observers, relying, overly, extrapolations, estimation, extrapolation, circle, affecting, cites, exception, discusses, malaria, 1830s, oregon, specifically, emphasizes, underappreciated, relation, monograph, 1963, foundational, emerging, aforementioned, reviewed, approaches, raised, mainly, providing, support, claims, federal, government, 1950s, getting, 1960, hired, vicos, mission, noticed, severe, theory, exercise, applied, hubris, painful, reckoning, enduring, contributions, test, qualitative, strongest, critics, concede, closer, capturing, reality, predecessors, greatest, unsurprising, modernist, excessive, confidence, answers, oversimplification, undercurrent, institutions, emerge, prominence, 1980s, afterward, acolytes, questioned, empirical, incorporated, better, public, popularized, unprecedented, fervor, falling, intense, activism, dispute, ascendant, revolutionizing, tragedies, inexorably, inequities, sherburne, dominant, equivalent, undoubtedly, controversial, decidedly, unquestionable, exaggeration, handedly, launched, limelight, pursue, spur, backlash, convenience, recognition, bracketed, drew, subfield, overreach, threw, welcome, lurks, survive, fewer, persist, independence, mirror, image, contrasting, situations, colored, empires, revival, patterns, exactly, puzzle, reorientation, exporting, level, entities, complexity, supply, affected, raiding, trading, tiny, portion, consensus, stir, opposition, accepted, baseline, controversy, pushback, age, wisconsin, 1969, revolutionary, tried, compile, philip, africanists, mind, quantify, concern, persistent, narrative, fostered, negative, counterarguments, forth, backdrop, advent, pacification, justified, eliminating, sudan, warfare, mahdist, uprising, 1890s, absence

Text of the page (random words):
es ended up falling on the high counter side of the demographic debate with its obvious political implications during a period of intense political awareness activism and dispute there was a clear sense that the high counter position was ascendant and revolutionizing the whole world s understanding of the tragedies of the past and how they led inexorably to the inequities of the present as i ve noted before though this is an oversimplification a parallel tradition of low counts continued as an undercurrent to the high count hegemony mostly focused in certain disciplines and institutions this current would emerge into higher prominence in the 1980s and afterward as the work of dobyns and his acolytes started to be questioned by a wide variety of detailed empirical studies of particular regions ironically this turn in the scholarship would come as the earlier high count research was just beginning to be incorporated into more popularized accounts which made it better known among the general public this chapter of the story is in some sense the heart of it in some ways it s a story of scholarly hubris particularly on the part of dobyns personally that eventually led to a painful reckoning but again that is too simple the high counters of this era made enduring contributions to understanding of this issue even if not all of their specific conclusions have stood the test of time in a qualitative sense at least even their strongest critics would mostly concede that they were closer to capturing the historical reality than most of their predecessors their greatest flaw perhaps unsurprising in the context of the mid century modernist context in which they worked may have been an excessive confidence in the potential for academic research to provide specific detailed answers to complicated historical questions dobyns was born and raised in arizona and his early anthropological work focused mainly on the tribes there including providing support to their land claims cases against the federal government in the 1950s after getting his ph d from cornell university in 1960 he was hired by cornell and went to peru to work on the vicos project an innovative and groundbreaking exercise in applied anthropology both in arizona and peru dobyns also did research in the colonial and mission archives and developed an interest in historical demography he noticed very severe population declines in the records of both areas and began to develop a theory for what was behind them that would end up being enormously influential in anthropology and beyond dobyns published some early work on the population dynamics of southern arizona but his first widely influential publication was a 1963 article on the history of epidemics in peru this article was foundational to the emerging interest in disease history and is still widely cited today his most important early work however was the aforementioned 1966 current anthropology article in which he reviewed previous approaches to the issue of precontact population and introduced a new methodology and estimate of his own the majority of this article consists of a thorough and detailed analysis of all the methodologies that had been used to estimate pre contact native american populations dobyns convincingly demonstrates that the various techniques used by the low counter school of mooney and kroeber likely underestimated numbers by disregarding the accounts of contemporary observers and relying overly on extrapolations from later ethnography he is more positive about the innovative estimation and extrapolation methods of cook and others in his circle at berkeley in addition he forcefully points out the importance of disease in affecting population numbers a factor largely ignored by the previous researchers he cites with the partial exception of cook in fact dobyns discusses in detail cook s monograph on the malaria epidemic of the 1830s in oregon and california a very important study still widely cited today dobyns specifically emphasizes two important but underappreciated aspects of disease in relation to demography cook s analysis of this california epidemic demonstrated the operation of two very important processes in the human ecology of aboriginal american populations first he showed the magnitude of mortality which a single epidemic can cause in a non resistant population second he called attention to the biological fact that epidemic infection is not limited to tribal populations in immediate face to face contact with europeans the decimation of native californians was not limited to missionized indians but extended outward as far as disease agent and vector could spread infection from intrusive white carriers to aboriginal populations it is necessary to maintain constant awareness of these two processes or fundamental trends among natives of the new world any interpretation of reported native populations during the early years of contact with europeans which ignores the tremendous mortality caused by epidemics inevitably underestimates the size of the aboriginal populace dobyns would continue to emphasize these factors throughout his career dobyns s analysis of past work is highly convincing in showing the flaws that led to past underestimation of population numbers and this accounts in part for the influence this paper has had on subsequent scholarship he went beyond this however and also attempted to devise a new methodology which would avoid those flaws and provide a sounder basis for making estimates here he starts to make some assumptions and interpretive leaps that would ultimately lead him into some methodological flaws of his own dobyns starts by defining a depopulation ratio comparing the population of a given group at two times in its history the two times he is particularly concerned with are the group s precontact population or as close to it as is possible to get and the time when it hit its nadir of population and began to grow again as most native populations eventually did he doesn t really justify his use of these two endpoints or the generalizability of a ratio derived from them he looks at several well documented cases including central mexico the andes california the amazon and the piman speakers of southern arizona and northern sonora and derives to his satisfaction a ratio of 20 1 as a sound if perhaps conservative tool to employ as a hemispheric minimum he considers 25 1 an alternative ratio to derive a reasonable range using these two ratios and available data on population nadirs he comes up with an aggregate hemispheric estimate of 90 043 000 to 112 553 750 for the whole western hemisphere at contact kroeber had estimated 8 400 000 a hundred million people this conclusion was striking and contributed to the influence of dobyns on further research he notes in the paper that cook s berkeley colleague woodrow borah had recently come to a very similar estimate so he was not totally on his own and in some ways his estimate was a plausible expansion of the increasingly high counts that were coming out of berkeley in the wake of cook s pioneering research much of that research was in relatively obscure regional publications however and it was dobyns who brought it to one of the flagship publications of american anthropology and garnered a large audience as it typically does for its major paper current anthropology sent the paper around to a wide variety of other scholars and published their comments which were mostly very positive with occasional reservations on particular points the combination of bold thinking with seemingly innovative quantitative techniques fit well with certain tendencies within the social sciences at mid century they also fit with an increasing political awareness of the plight of modern native people along with the general political tumult of the 1960s dobyns himself was a strong advocate for native rights going back to his land claim days and his concept that precontact native populations were large and implicitly successful only to lose 95 or more of their people to disease introduced by europeans fit well with the political mood of the times the following year dobyns s conclusions were bolstered by a paper by the historian alfred crosby documenting the smallpox epidemic that accompanied the spanish conquistadors into central mexico and per dobyns s earlier andean epidemic research probably continued to spread ahead of them into the inca empire killing the emperor and fatally weakening the empire itself this was a concrete example of the dynamics of disease that dobyns had discussed in general terms with very clear and dramatic consequences for the course of world history crosby would later go on to expand his argument in his groundbreaking 1972 book the columbian exchange and a 1976 paper outlining the specifics of how virgin soil epidemics contributed to depopulation in the americas dobyns s and crosby s ideas rapidly caught fire in all sorts of disciplines and led to innumerable studies of specific areas in the coming decades the historian wilbur jacobs whom we encountered before through his oral history of the berkeley medical school and its treatment of s f cook wrote an important overview of the implications for the history of contact other studies too numerous to list looked at the issue from the vantage points of geography anthropology and many other disciplines throughout the heyday of 1970s the high count school of dobyns and crosby expanded its reach and refined its estimates and arguments there were some dissenting voices even at this time however the low counters may have seen their influence eclipsed but they didn t disappear and as i ve noted before they were particularly concentrated in certain disciplines in direct response to dobyns s article the andeanist c t smith published his own in current anthropology in 1970 following up on some mild criticism by the geographer william denevan in his comments on dobyns smith notes that the depopulation ratio of 20 1 if truly an average of well documented cases probably conceals considerable variation in the underlying data set with regard to the colonial andes one of dobyns s most important cases for determining the ratio smith points out that the coastal regions dobyns used in his analysis have markedly higher depopulation ratios than the interior regions in the same data combining them reduces the depopulation ratio to 4 1 smith is not necessarily opposed to dobyns s ideas however and he merely suggests that the dynamics of coastal and interior populations in this region should be considered separately he also does a detailed analysis of additional colonial census data to further refine the depopulation estimates and dobyns s comments on his paper are largely positive one notable discipline that was strikingly absent from the study of this demographic topic is perhaps surprisingly demography the reasons for this were made clear in a 1975 paper again in current anthropology by the demographer william petersen in an astonishing display of saying the quiet part loud petersen took aim at a wide variety of demographic interpretations widespread in the study of prehistory this mostly takes the form of noting the very slim data available for various methods of estimating prehistoric population parameters with regard to catastrophic population loss in the wake of contact he admits that there certainly have been losses and does seem to agree with dobyns in giving historical accounts more credence than kroeber did though he also notes smith s clarification about the differences between coastal and interior populations in the andes overall he maintains a skeptical position and notes the contemporary political implications of positing much larger precontact populations which he also analogizes to the nineteenth century mound builder legends to explain the mounds of the midwestern us in his response to what he terms petersen s pontifical perambulation dobyns attempts to refute his accusation that high counters are political opponents of modern liberal capitalism by noting that he himself invests in the stock market and admires some companies this is not very convincing in substance but the polemical tone foreshadows dobyns s reactions to subsequent criticisms archaeologists and physical anthropologists also continued to be skeptical about the ideas coming largely from historians and geographers many of these holdouts were associated with the smithsonian institution and carried on the legacy of mooney in some cases quite directly douglas ubelaker who worked on the editing of the smithsonian s updated handbook of north american indians was in part responsible for updates to mooney s demographic estimates included in the original version of the handbook in an interim report published in 1976 he noted that the estimates for specific tribes and regions submitted by that point were higher than mooney s but well below dobyns s the total estimate approximately double s mooney s total which implies a hemispheric total of about 16 million a significant difference indeed these quibbles were fairly minor during this period however the event that started to bring them out more forcefully was perhaps ironically dobyns s publication in 1983 of his book their number become thinned which focused on the timucuan people of northern florida but served also a vehicle for him to promote his revised and expanded methodology for population estimates and the role of disease in depopulation by this point the high count hegemony had reached its breaking point posted in series virgin soil widowed land 2 comments older posts archives june 2026 1 december 2025 1 june 2025 1 february 2025 1 december 2024 1 may 2024 1 april 2024 1 december 2023 1 june 2023 1 december 2022 1 june 2022 1 december 2021 1 december 2020 1 october 2020 1 june 2020 1 december 2019 1 june 2019 1 january 2019 2 december 2018 1 november 2018 1 october 2018 1 september 2018 1 august 2018 1 july 2018 1 june 2018 1 may 2018 1 april 2018 1 march 2018 1 february 2018 1 january 2018 1 december 2017 1 november 2017 1 october 2017 1 september 2017 1 august 2017 1 july 2017 1 june 2017 1 may 2017 1 april 2017 1 march 2017 1 february 2017 1 january 2017 1 december 2016 1 november 2016 1 october 2016 1 september 2016 1 august 2016 1 july 2016 1 june 2016 1 may 2016 1 april 2016 1 march 2016 1 february 2016 1 january 2016 1 december 2015 1 november 2015 1 october 2015 1 september 2015 1 august 2015 1 july 2015 1 june 2015 1 may 2015 1 april 2015 1 march 2015 1 february 2015 1 january 2015 1 december 2014 2 november 2014 1 october 2014 1 september 2014 1 august 2014 1 july 2014 1 june 2014 1 may 2014 1 april 2014 1 march 2014 1 february 2014 2 january 2014 1 december 2013 2 november 2013 1 october 2013 1 september 2013 1 august 2013 2 july 2013 2 june 2013 1 may 2013 1 april 2013 2 march 2013 1 february 2013 1 january 2013 2 december 2012 2 november 2012 2 october 2012 1 ...