Meta tags:

Headings (most frequently used words):

article, the, first, pages, wednesday, january, 2013, doi, primary, sources, translate, presidents, search, this, blog, notables,

Text of the page (most frequently used words):
the (314), and (69), party (58), first (51), one (48), for (45), #article (45), 000 (42), house (40), than (38), more (37), representatives (36), that (33), congress (32), shall (31), this (30), republican (30), districts (30), representative (29), less (28), would (28), democratic (23), after (23), john (22), representation (22), per (20), every (20), thousand (19), citizens (18), which (18), persons (17), was (16), not (16), congressional (16), 200 (16), number (15), committee (15), nor (15), states (14), constitution (14), hundred (14), amendment (14), there (14), james (13), people (13), george (12), william (12), with (12), population (12), their (12), cap (12), last (12), thomas (11), senate (11), version (11), its (10), electoral (10), rights (9), united (9), over (9), but (9), 1789 (9), line (9), until (9), amount (9), amendments (9), samuel (8), madison (8), president (8), between (8), members (8), apportionment (8), lobbyists (8), size (8), word (8), intended (8), reps (8), smaller (8), proportion (8), today (7), bill (7), have (7), capping (7), district (7), conference (7), required (7), clause (7), regulated (7), proposed (7), washington (6), adams (6), act (6), read (6), language (6), thirty (6), vision (6), principle (6), constitutional (6), gerrymandering (6), college (6), structure (6), fifty (6), lee (5), political (5), both (5), under (5), jefferson (5), whig (5), presidents (5), hancock (5), new (5), census (5), two (5), also (5), government (5), influence (5), founders (5), constituents (5), while (5), larger (5), ensure (5), effectively (5), second (5), passed (5), forty (5), enumeration (5), september (5), other (4), francis (4), david (4), make (4), out (4), time (4), richard (4), benjamin (4), henry (4), war (4), without (4), research (4), notes (4), permanent (4), 1929 (4), nation (4), must (4), restore (4), person (4), vote (4), principles (4), are (4), accountability (4), most (4), had (4), correction (4), each (4), equitable (4), final (4), change (4), could (4), floor (4), 100 (4), million (4), upper (4), rep (4), place (4), introduced (4), ratification (4), original (4), were (4), however (4), formula (4), power (4), nearly (4), votes (4), 2013 (3), klos (3), all (3), randolph (3), robert (3), notables (3), roosevelt (3), monroe (3), atchison (3), never (3), march (3), 1849 (3), because (3), taylor (3), law (3), andrew (3), visit (3), wilson (3), franklin (3), harrison (3), arthur (3), federalist (3), 1787 (3), huntington (3), continental (3), four (3), fort (3), declaration (3), address (3), articles (3), charles (3), oliver (3), share (3), large (3), historical (3), expand (3), democracy (3), history (3), remain (3), promise (3), can (3), voices (3), american (3), republic (3), balance (3), citizen (3), only (3), yet (3), average (3), direct (3), often (3), significantly (3), drafting (3), made (3), capped (3), including (3), them (3), created (3), recommendation (3), impossible (3), instead (3), limit (3), from (3), critical (3), sought (3), these (3), added (3), subsequent (3), increase (3), initial (3), rather (3), maintain (3), versions (3), textual (3), twelve (3), included (3), proposals (3), designed (3), among (3), during (3), failed (3), run (3), creating (3), receive (3), small (3), has (3), bigger (3), stan (2), alexander (2), edward (2), van (2), woman (2), suffrage (2), ross (2), livingston (2), jay (2), america (2), scientists (2), who (2), zachary (2), therefore (2), became (2), presidential (2), quincy (2), jackson (2), hospitality (2), presidency (2), donald (2), trump (2), joseph (2), bush (2), carter (2), johnson (2), grover (2), cleveland (2), abraham (2), mckean (2), elected (2), office (2), 1777 (2), peyton (2), middleton (2), world (2), papers (2), battle (2), historic (2), virginia (2), compact (2), taxation (2), independence (2), primary (2), sources (2), stone (2), printed (2), january (2), 1776 (2), carolina (2), carroll (2), morris (2), lewis (2), stephen (2), roger (2), sherman (2), home (2), chatgpt (2), historian (2), where (2), org (2), when (2), write (2), times (2), june (2), vital (2), year (2), long (2), reflects (2), does (2), replacing (2), system (2), partisan (2), reduce (2), civic (2), understood (2), meaningful (2), diluting (2), individual (2), engagement (2), concerns (2), increasing (2), impact (2), dependence (2), foster (2), process (2), legislative (2), misplacement (2), consequential (2), been (2), might (2), thousands (2), closer (2), accountable (2), ensuring (2), far (2), yes (2), sizes (2), coherent (2), followed (2), contradiction (2), let (2), reads (2), changing (2), range (2), amend (2), striking (2), inserting (2), reconcile (2), proposing (2), subtle (2), implies (2), sixty (2), allow (2), minimum (2), least (2), intent (2), ambiguity (2), text (2), mathematical (2), leaving (2), state (2), standard (2), resolution (2), replaced (2), following (2), said (2), clarify (2), proportional (2), grew (2), proper (2), ellsworth (2), report (2), bicameral (2), aimed (2), maintaining (2), growth (2), much (2), close (2), revised (2), ultimately (2), reflected (2), remained (2), federal (2), why (2), ratified (2), grassroots (2), ordinary (2), lobbyist (2), fairer (2), elections (2), example (2), idaho (2), california (2), bringing (2), directly (2), donors (2), electorate (2), reinstating (2), proposal (2), vast (2), serve (2), residents (2), disparities (2), early (2), adhered (2), intimate (2), 750 (2), consequences (2), practice (2), abandoned (2), decennial (2), 435 (2), certain (2), kept (2), within (2), unratified (2), copyright, 1999, reserved, picture, window, theme, powered, blogger, istoric, himalaya, mountains, egyptian, mummy, andy, warhol, sitting, bull, haym, salomon, rockefeller, edmund, peirpoint, wolfgang, mozart, clement, moore, mason, ferdinand, magellan, macdonald, vladimir, lenin, hamilton, alva, edison, walter, disney, gottlieb, daimler, clemens, champlain, carver, alphonse, capone, aaron, burr, boone, daniel, napoleon, bonaparte, karl, benz, graham, bell, ludwig, beethoven, benedict, arnold, audubon, martha, sojourner, truth, betsy, eleanor, elizabeth, dolley, sarah, julia, ward, howe, clara, barton, catherine, great, susan, anthony, abigail, search, blog, confederate, acting, claimed, day, assertion, claim, refused, sworn, sunday, vice, term, ended, date, pro, tempore, succession, organized, 1791, went, existence, schism, sake, expediency, incorrectly, refer, utilized, name, stanley, please, biden, barack, obama, clinton, ronald, reagan, earl, gerald, ford, nixon, lyndon, kennedy, dwight, eisenhower, harry, truman, herbert, hoover, calvin, coolidge, warren, harding, woodrow, taft, theodore, mckinley, chester, garfield, rutherford, hayes, ulysses, grant, davis, lincoln, buchanan, pierce, millard, fillmore, polk, tyler, martin, buren, cyrus, griffin, clair, nathaniel, gorham, chairman, ramsay, mifflin, elias, boudinot, hanson, declined, johnston, laurens, republics, translate, 1812, vietnam, underground, railroad, stamp, jumonville, glen, pitt, necessity, duquesne, civil, movement, yorktown, orleans, events, assembled, nations, charter, treaty, paris, 176, mayflower, thanksgiving, proclamations, northwest, ordinance, doctrine, gettysburg, emancipation, proclamation, coin, confederation, association, wet, ink, transfer, 1820, mary, katherine, goddard, timothy, matlack, engrossed, aug, dunlap, july, walton, lyman, hall, button, gwinnett, georgia, rutledge, lynch, heyward, south, penn, hooper, hewes, north, wythe, nelson, lightfoot, braxton, paca, chase, carrollton, maryland, caesar, rodney, delaware, smith, rush, morton, clymer, pennsylvania, witherspoon, stockton, hopkinson, hart, clark, jersey, philip, floyd, york, hopkins, ellery, rhode, island, wolcott, williams, connecticut, treat, paine, elbridge, gerry, massachusetts, whipple, thornton, matthew, bartlett, josiah, hampshire, thomson, secretary, commander, chief, doi, subscribe, posts, atom, pinterest, facebook, blogthis, email, comments, posted, https, com, model, 2024, open, edited, bureau, data, 1790, 2020, sabato, larry, journal, ideas, spring, 2008, fang, gone, 2014, analysis, chang, alisa, literally, npr, nov, rosiak, luke, 2012, brookings, institution, statistics, ansolabehere, maxwell, palmer, statistical, gerrymander, 1911, reapportionment, speech, references, see, honor, framers, reaffirm, enduring, now, revisit, overlooked, doing, create, expansive, genuinely, faithfully, strengthens, foundations, generations, come, call, renew, crucially, transformation, require, retains, full, authority, enact, thereby, rigid, ceiling, imposed, evolving, founding, ideals, reinforce, eliminate, money, lobbying, politics, strengthen, driven, governance, reviving, core, presents, opportunity, imperative, requires, proximity, officials, asserted, connected, 760, undermining, reclaiming, forgotten, cost, frequently, overstated, involve, higher, expenditures, broader, likely, unelected, intermediaries, such, staffers, turn, responsive, transparent, justifying, investment, skeptics, argue, unwieldy, precedent, global, comparisons, challenge, assumption, kingdom, commons, 650, continues, operate, efficiently, democracies, high, member, ratios, demonstrate, effectiveness, inherently, tied, chamber, transparency, public, rethinking, scale, single, stands, errors, recommended, properly, implemented, comprise, representing, reflection, error, may, technical, glitches, correctly, contain, granular, authorize, fewer, unconstitutional, say, functioned, workable, limitation, future, then, set, exactly, what, changed, using, worked, conclusion, inoperable, exceeds, meet, requirements, you, look, logical, problem, previous, contradicts, due, misstatement, wrong, altered, yields, mathematically, consistent, acceptable, legislate, depending, lower, logic, flows, meaning, mean, analytical, focus, matters, leave, post, restrictive, sets, theoretically, ratio, meets, bound, 250, examine, finalized, emphasis, relevant, how, evolves, across, three, breakdown, into, rendering, inconsistent, practical, implementation, infeasible, conflicting, thresholds, erroneous, unworkable, consequently, ceased, efforts, short, fifths, approval, adoption, mistakenly, directed, result, form, recommendations, reviewed, chambers, drafted, deviated, precise, regarding, specifically, advised, amending, provision, limits, divergence, seemingly, minor, resolve, progression, committees, opinion, houses, agree, accordingly, recommend, reconsidered, purpose, rejected, revisions, senator, formally, before, crucial, stated, differences, known, convened, composed, several, prominent, statesmen, vining, paterson, mandate, harmonize, divergent, establish, apportioning, path, structured, allowed, keep, citizenry, deliberated, passing, forward, different, framework, generous, permitting, exceeded, adjustments, gradually, establishing, response, overwhelming, input, seventeen, august, journey, complex, politically, charged, ratifying, conventions, distinct, submitted, various, reflecting, broad, priorities, once, repetitive, suggestions, consolidated, unique, many, seeking, either, protect, liberties, recalibrate, crowded, agenda, widespread, raised, debates, regulate, populations, achieve, making, become, wasn, empower, movements, allowing, relying, infrastructure, funding, reinvigorate, participation, diverse, dynamic, revitalizing, cracking, packing, manipulative, practices, rendered, moot, eliminating, distribution, 780, disparity, shrink, dramatically, popular, engage, reducing, candidates, campaigns, reaching, multimillion, dollar, budgets, enhanced, through, systemic, issues, case, amerndment, inhabitants, powerful, earth, largely, olds, vacuum, usually, filled, fueled, very, bills, passes, unable, adequately, spend, fundraising, legislating, according, gridlock, current, equating, 450, receives, 727, imbalance, undermines, easier, damaging, parties, manipulate, boundaries, entrench, expense, fair, same, fixed, skews, amplifying, distort, contrast, congresses, 1790s, served, roughly, fostering, trust, contains, cry, envisioned, makes, connections, drowned, interests, diluted, oversized, five, decades, expanding, 1830, averaged, just, shifts, 1840s, beyond, saw, 1920, reapportion, itself, froze, unchanged, century, despite, tripled, seems, necessary, secure, benefits, free, consultation, discussion, hand, ought, order, avoid, confusion, intemperance, multitude, dangers, overcentralized, principal, architect, argued, preserve, gulf, they, meant, profound, diminished, increased, rampant, distorted, reinvigorating, back, unlike, companion, becoming, years, eventually, culminating, newly, minted, foundational, guarantee, central, truly, building, will, return, reins, website, examines, remains, site, discusses, adherence, censuses, eventual, abandonment, leading, explores, highlighting, evolution, challenges, effective, checks, balances, articlethefirst, net, wednesday, big, enough, build, a1hr, pages,

Text of the page (random words):
n response to this overwhelming input the house of representatives introduced and passed seventeen articles on august 24 1789 included among them was article the first which sought to ensure smaller and more equitable congressional districts by capping their population size the house version read after the first enumeration required by the first article of the constitution there shall be one representative for every thirty thousand until the number shall amount to one hundred after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall be not less than one hundred representatives nor less than one representative for every forty thousand persons until the number of representatives shall amount to 200 after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall not be less than two hundred representatives nor less than one representative for every fifty thousand persons this language was designed to gradually expand the house of representatives in proportion to population growth while establishing a minimum standard of representation effectively capping district sizes at 50 000 citizens u s senate adjustments between september 4 and 9 1789 the senate deliberated and revised the house s proposals ultimately passing twelve amendments to forward to the states while their version also included article the first its language reflected a significantly different mathematical framework the senate s version introduced a more generous cap on district size permitting one representative for every 60 000 persons after the house exceeded 200 members the revised text read after the first enumeration required by the first article of the constitution there shall be one representative for every thirty thousand until the number shall amount to one hundred to which number one representative shall be added for every subsequent increase of forty thousand until the representatives shall amount to two hundred to which one representative shall be added for every subsequent increase of sixty thousand persons this formula while maintaining a structured growth in house representation allowed for much larger districts than the house version diluting the amendment s original intent to keep representation close to the citizenry the house senate conference committee and the path to article the first to reconcile the differences between the house and senate versions of the proposed constitutional amendments a bicameral conference committee known as the house senate conference committee hr s cc was convened this committee was composed of several prominent statesmen including james madison roger sherman john vining oliver ellsworth charles carroll and william paterson their mandate was to harmonize the divergent versions of the amendments including article the first which aimed to establish a formula for apportioning representatives and effectively cap the population of congressional districts the recommendation on article the first on september 24 1789 the conference committee rejected the senate s version of article the first and proposed revisions to the house version instead senator oliver ellsworth formally read the committee s report before the senate which included a crucial textual amendment to clarify the intended apportionment structure the report stated hr s cc amendment to the first article the committees were also of opinion that it would be proper for both houses to agree to amend the first article by striking out the word less in the last line but one and inserting in its place the word more and accordingly recommend that the said article be reconsidered for that purpose this seemingly minor textual correction was intended to resolve ambiguity in the population formula and ensure a coherent progression in congressional representation as the nation s population grew with the hr s cc change article the first would read after the first enumeration required by the first article of the constitution there shall be one representative for every thirty thousand until the number shall amount to one hundred after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall be not less than one hundred representatives nor more than one representative for every forty thousand persons until the number of representatives shall amount to 200 after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall not be less than two hundred representatives nor less than one representative for every fifty thousand persons the divergence the recommendations of the house senate conference committee hr s cc were reviewed by both chambers of congress however when the u s house introduced the twelve proposed amendments to the constitution it drafted a resolution that deviated from the committee s precise language regarding article the first specifically the committee had advised amending the article by replacing the word less with more in the last line but one a change intended to clarify the provision s proportional limits instead the house resolution mistakenly directed that the word less be replaced with more in the last place of the said first article as a result article the first was passed in the following form after the first enumeration required by the first article of the constitution there shall be one representative for every thirty thousand until the number shall amount to one hundred after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall be not less than one hundred representatives nor less than one representative for every forty thousand persons until the number of representatives shall amount to 200 after which the proportion shall be so regulated by congress that there shall not be less than two hundred representatives nor more than one representative for every fifty thousand persons this subtle yet critical misplacement introduced ambiguity into the final text of article the first rendering its mathematical structure inconsistent and its practical implementation infeasible the conflicting thresholds for apportionment created by the erroneous language effectively made the amendment unworkable consequently the states ceased their ratification efforts leaving article the first one state short of the four fifths approval required for adoption under the original constitutional standard would changing the word less to more in the second to last line rather than in the last line as was passed by congress cap congressional districts at 1 representative for every 50 000 citizens textual breakdown and intent let s re examine the structure of article the first as finalized with an emphasis on the relevant clause and how it evolves across the three versions house version initial the final clause reads nor less than one representative for every fifty thousand persons this implies that congress must maintain at least one representative per 50 000 persons so for 250 000 people there must be at least 5 representatives there is no upper bound congress could theoretically allow a smaller ratio e g 1 per 30 000 or 1 per 40 000 as long as it meets the 1 50 000 minimum so this does not cap representation rather it sets a floor senate version initial to which one representative shall be added for every subsequent increase of sixty thousand persons this implies a cap 1 representative per 60 000 persons after 200 it s a more restrictive version than the house conference committee recommendation the committee sought to reconcile these by proposing a subtle but critical change amend the first article by striking out the word less in the last line but one and inserting in its place the word more this would make the critical clause read nor more than one representative for every forty thousand persons and leave the last clause post 200 reps as nor less than one representative for every fifty thousand persons analytical focus less vs more where it matters the committee s intended correction in the second to last line would mean clause meaning after correction nor more than one rep per 40 000 a cap on districts no district can have more than 40 000 persons after 100 reps nor less than one rep per 50 000 a floor on districts no district can be smaller than 50 000 after 200 reps the logic flows from 100 to 200 reps no more than 1 per 40 000 upper limit after 200 reps no less than 1 per 50 000 lower limit this yields a mathematically consistent range of acceptable representation congress could legislate representation between 1 per 40 000 and 1 per 50 000 depending on population size the final version passed by congress due to the house s misstatement changing last line but one to last place the wrong clause was altered so instead of nor more than one rep per 40 000 an upper cap committee version it reads nor more than one rep per 50 000 an upper cap that contradicts the previous not less than 200 representatives clause let s look at the logical problem contradiction created not less than 200 representatives floor of 200 reps nor more than 1 per 50 000 if the u s population is over 10 million you d be required to have more than 200 representatives so after population exceeds 10 million it s impossible to meet both requirements this contradiction made the amendment inoperable conclusion would using more in the second to last line have worked yes that is exactly what the conference committee intended if congress had followed the committee s recommendation and changed less to more in the second to last line the amendment would have set a cap of 1 representative per 40 000 after 100 reps then a floor of 1 representative per 50 000 after 200 reps created a coherent structure for future apportionment functioned as a workable limitation on congressional district sizes including effectively capping them at no larger than 50 000 persons therefore yes it would have effectively capped congressional districts at 1 representative per 50 000 people because after 200 representatives congress could not authorize districts with fewer representatives per person i e larger districts it would be unconstitutional to have say 1 representative per 60 000 people under that language this drafting error may be one of the most consequential technical glitches in american constitutional history had the intended change been made correctly the u s house of representatives today might contain thousands of members ensuring far more granular representation of the population final reflection the misplacement of a single word in article the first stands as one of the most consequential drafting errors in american constitutional history had the recommended correction been properly implemented the united states house of representatives might today comprise thousands of members each representing no more than 50 000 citizens a structure that would ensure closer more equitable and more accountable representation rethinking the scale of representation skeptics often argue that a significantly larger house would be unwieldy yet both historical precedent and global comparisons challenge this assumption the united kingdom s house of commons with over 650 members continues to operate efficiently other democracies with high member to citizen ratios demonstrate that legislative effectiveness is not inherently tied to a chamber s size but to its structure transparency and public accountability concerns over cost are also frequently overstated while increasing the number of representatives would involve higher direct expenditures the broader impact would likely reduce dependence on unelected intermediaries such as lobbyists and staffers in turn this would foster a more direct responsive and transparent democratic process more than justifying the investment reclaiming a forgotten vision the founders understood that meaningful representation requires proximity between the people and their elected officials as james madison asserted representation must remain vital and connected to the people yet today congressional districts average over 760 000 constituents diluting individual voices and undermining democratic engagement reviving the core principles of article the first presents not only an opportunity but a civic imperative capping districts at 50 000 citizens would strengthen citizen driven governance reduce the influence of money and lobbying in politics restore balance to the electoral college eliminate partisan gerrymandering reinforce the constitutional promise of one person one vote crucially this transformation does not require a constitutional amendment congress retains full authority to enact a new apportionment law thereby replacing the rigid ceiling imposed by the 1929 permanent apportionment act with a system that reflects the nation s evolving population and founding ideals a call to renew the republic to honor the vision of the framers of the u s constitution and the bill of rights is to reaffirm the enduring principle that government must remain of the people by the people for the people now is the time to revisit and restore the long overlooked promise of article the first by doing so we can create a more expansive and genuinely representative house one that faithfully reflects the voices of its citizens and strengthens the foundations of american democracy for generations to come references also see research notes madison s speech in the first congress june 8 1789 article the first 1789 house of representatives historian the 1911 house reapportionment ansolabehere stephen and maxwell palmer a two hundred year statistical history of the gerrymander brookings institution vital statistics on congress rosiak luke the washington times june 6 2012 chang alisa when lobbyists literally write the bill npr nov 11 2013 thirty thousand org analysis of article the first fang lee where have all the lobbyists gone the nation march 10 17 2014 sabato larry expand the house of representatives democracy journal of ideas spring 2008 u s census bureau historical census data 1790 2020 house of representatives historian the permanent apportionment act of 1929 madison federalist papers no 10 visit research notes for more or less edited open ai 2024 chatgpt large language model https chatgpt com posted by stan klos at 10 32 am 3 comments email this blogthis share to x share to facebook share to pinterest home subscribe to posts atom doi declaration of independence commander in chief george washington president john hancock secretary charles thomson new hampshire josiah bartlett matthew thornton william whipple massachusetts john adams samuel adams elbridge gerry john hancock robert treat paine connecticut samuel huntington roger sherman william williams oliver wolcott rhode island william ellery stephen hopkins new york william floyd francis lewis philip livingston lewis morris new jersey abraham clark john hart francis hopkinson richard stockton john witherspoon pennsylvania george clymer benjamin franklin robert morris john morton george ross benjamin...